From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/crusades
← No religion, or not sureThe Crusades were wars that called from 1095 to help Christians in the East and win back Jerusalem. The threat was real, but crusaders massacred Jews and Muslims and looted a Christian city, and the Catholic Church has asked forgiveness.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
For many people, the Crusades are the clearest case of Christians killing in Jesus's name. For many Muslims and Jews, the word still names a wound.
That's true, so it comes first.
In 1096 crusaders in Germany killed at least 800 Jews in Worms and 1,100 in Mainz.9
In 1099 they took Jerusalem, the city where Jesus was executed and, Christians believe, rose from the dead. They killed thousands of its Muslims and Jews.2,10 Their own writers boasted that they waded in blood up to their ankles.2
Historians' estimates of the dead run from about 3,000 to 40,000. Some Muslims and Jews were spared if they left the city.10
And in 1204 crusaders attacked Constantinople, today's Istanbul, then the greatest Christian city of the East.3 For three days they looted it, killed civilians, and stripped and defiled its churches.7 They turned on fellow Christians.
Why they went
So how did it start? Not out of nowhere. In 1071 Turkish armies crushed the army of the Christian empire ruled from Constantinople, and spread across what's now Turkey. Pilgrims to Jerusalem faced tolls, kidnapping and attacks.8
In 1095 that Christian empire asked the pope for soldiers.8 Pope Urban II called on the knights of Western Europe to free the churches of the East.1
He sold it as an armed pilgrimage with a reward in , life with God after death: accounts of his speech say anyone who died on the way would have all their forgiven.8
That's how those accounts put it. The Council of Clermont, the church meeting where Urban spoke, wrote it more narrowly. Anyone who went out of devotion alone, not for money or fame, could count the journey instead of all their penance.11
Penance is what someone who has confessed their sins is given to do, to help put things right.
But the bigger promise is what many crusaders seem to have heard: fight, and your sins are wiped away.
And the Catholic Church teaches that no deed can buy forgiveness. Forgiveness comes first, free, from .13
Think of it like this
Imagine a gang is taking over your cousin's neighbourhood. They're beating up anyone who walks home late, and the police can't stop them. One night he calls you and asks for help.
You gather some friends and go. That phone call explains why you went. It's a real reason, and nobody would blame you for answering it.
Now suppose that on the way, some of your group stop and beat up a family on another street, people who had nothing to do with the gang. Then, in another part of town, they kill whoever they find, whether they had anything to do with the gang or not.
And when you finally reach your cousin, some of your group turn on him. They break into his home, hurt his family and wreck the place. Does the phone call excuse any of that? Of course it doesn't. The call for help explains why you went. It doesn't excuse a single one of those acts.
So look at the Crusades the same way. The gang was the Turkish armies. The Jews killed in Germany were the family on another street. Jerusalem in 1099 was the part of town where they killed whoever they found. And Constantinople, a century later, was your cousin's own home.
Did the popes want this?
Church leaders didn't call for the attacks on Jews, and some tried to stop them. In 1096 German hid Jews in their own homes. Crusaders broke in anyway.9
Pope Innocent III had told the crusaders of 1204 not to attack Christians.7 Afterwards he wrote that their swords were now dripping with Christian blood, and that they have spared neither age nor sex: they had killed young and old, men and women.3 Yet he went on to accept the new Western rulers of the city.3
And popes did call these wars, and did promise spiritual rewards to those who fought. The violence grew out of a movement the Catholic Church itself started.
But didn't they start it?
Some people answer that Muslims started it. Muslim armies had conquered Christian lands, Jerusalem included, in the 600s.8 And the Turks' advance after 1071 was recent and real.8
But by then Jerusalem had been under Muslim rule for over 400 years. To the people living there, the crusaders were foreign invaders. And the Jews killed in Germany had nothing to do with any of it.
Explaining why the Crusades began isn't the same as excusing what crusaders did.
How did Muslims see it?
What did Muslims at the time make of all this? Not what you might expect. They didn't call these wars crusades. Their writers called the invaders Franks, a name for Western Europeans, and spoke of the wars of the Franks.11
The Christian idea of a crusade was foreign to them. Muslim writers often thought the crusaders had simply come out of greed.11
And most didn't treat it as the story of their age. The crusades turn up as chapters inside bigger histories of rulers and cities, mentioned now and then, often without much detail.11
A few saw the danger early. Around 1105 a scholar in Damascus called on Muslims to unite against the Franks in jihad, holy war.12 Decades later Nur al-Din, the Muslim ruler of Syria, made winning back Jerusalem the main aim of his war, and Saladin took the city in 1187.12
Muslim observers could be as shocked as anyone. The Muslim scholar Ibn al-Athir, like the pope himself, was horrified by what crusaders did to Christian Constantinople in 1204.12
The picture of the crusades as one long clash between Islam and the West mostly came much later. In the 1800s, Arabic-speaking Christians in Syria began translating French histories, and the wars of the Franks became the wars of the Cross.11
Historians have long said the wider Muslim world took little interest in the crusades until the mid-1800s. The historian Carole Hillenbrand suggests they seemed a side issue next to the fall of the caliphate, the old Muslim empire, to the Mongols.11
Newer research adds a caveat. Writings in praise of Jerusalem kept the memory of the Frankish invasion alive, and by the late 1400s they told it as one story centred on Jerusalem and Saladin.11
Today some Muslim thinkers, and some right-wing groups in the West, read the present through the crusades.11 None of this shrinks what was done to the Muslims and Jews killed in 1099. It only means the idea of one unbroken clash is mostly modern.
What the Catholic Church says now
Today the Catholic Church teaches that war is allowed only as a last-resort defence, under strict conditions. The says civilians, wounded soldiers and prisoners must be treated humanely.4
By that standard, what crusaders did in Germany, in Jerusalem and in Constantinople was gravely wrong.
And popes have said so. In 2000, at the Day of Pardon, asked forgiveness for the violence some have used in the service of the truth.5
To be honest, that prayer was general: it didn't name the Crusades. In the same breath he asked pardon for the distrustful and hostile attitudes sometimes taken towards the followers of other religions.5
A year later he went to Athens, where the memory of 1204 still hurts. The Christians there share most of their faith with Catholics. The two Churches split in the Middle Ages, mainly over the pope's role, and each believes the other left. He named the sack directly:
It is tragic that the assailants, who had set out to secure free access for Christians to the Holy Land, turned against their own brothers in the faith. The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret.
Latin Christians means Western Christians, whose Church worshipped in Latin. In other words, Catholics.
In the same speech he asked forgiveness for every time Catholics had sinned by action or omission against Orthodox Christians. He asked for an honest remembering that heals, so old wounds stop poisoning the present.6
Fairness to the people of the past matters too. Not every crusader was a murderer. Many went at great cost, believing they were helping others.
Not they started it, then, and not we were monsters either. The , Jesus's message, asks the same of anyone: tell the truth about what happened, and ask forgiveness for the wrong done in Christ's name.
Sources13
- 1Urban II, Letter of Instruction to the Crusaders (December 1095), Fordham Medieval SourcebookUrban says he urged the princes of the West to free the churches of the East.
- 2The Fall of Jerusalem, 1099: contemporary accounts, Fordham Medieval SourcebookCrusader chroniclers' own descriptions of the killing in Jerusalem.
- 3Innocent III, Letter to his legate Peter Capuano (12 July 1205), Fordham Medieval SourcebookThe pope condemns the sack of Constantinople; the editor notes he later accepted the new Latin order there.
- 4Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2307–2317 (avoiding war)Strict conditions for war; non-combatants and prisoners must be treated humanely.
- 5John Paul II, Homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000)The pope asks pardon for violence used in the service of the truth.
- 6John Paul II, Address to Archbishop Christodoulos of Athens (4 May 2001)The pope expresses deep regret for the sack of Constantinople in 1204.
- 7Wikipedia, Fourth CrusadeInnocent III forbade the crusaders to attack Christians; the sack of 1204.
- 8Wikipedia, First CrusadeManzikert (1071), Alexios's appeal at Piacenza (1095), Clermont, pilgrims' hardships and Urban's promises.
- 9Wikipedia, Rhineland massacresThe killing of Jews at Worms and Mainz in 1096; bishops who tried to protect them; Bernard's letters.
- 10Wikipedia, Siege of Jerusalem (1099)The massacre after the city fell; the range of estimates (Kostick, Ibn al-Athir); residents spared if they left.
- 11Wikipedia, Historiography of the Crusades (Arabic and Muslim historiography)Crusade an alien idea to medieval Muslims, who often saw the crusaders as driven by greed; little Muslim interest until the mid-1800s (Hillenbrand: marginal next to the collapse of the Caliphate); the Merits of Jerusalem writings kept the memory alive; 'wars of the Franks' became 'wars of the Cross' in the 1800s; modern uses on both sides.
- 12Wikipedia, CrusadesAl-Sulami's call to jihad (c. 1105); Nur al-Din makes Jerusalem the aim of jihad; Saladin takes Jerusalem (1187); Ibn al-Athir shocked by the sack of 1204.
- 13Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2006–2011No one can merit the first grace of forgiveness; it is God's free gift.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.