← Another faith
Other religions

Didn't the Church blame the Jews for killing Jesus?

Read it as an illustrated story · 9 min

For centuries, yes. Christian preachers blamed the Jews, and anti-Jewish teaching ran through Catholic lessons and prayers. The harm was terrible. In 1965 the Catholic Church rejected that blame: Jesus's death can't be pinned on all the Jews of his day, or on any Jew today. Catholic teaching says all sinners share the blame, Christians most of all.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Catechism
597–598

Yes, for a very long time, and that has to come first.

From the 100s on, Christians accused the Jews as a people of killing God.1

They leaned above all on one verse. At Jesus's trial, Matthew's , one of the four books about his life, says the crowd shouted His blood be upon us and upon our children.2 Preachers read it as a curse on every Jewish generation.

That charge fed centuries of contempt. It was used to justify killing Jews during the Crusades, the medieval wars to bring Jerusalem back under Christian rule from its Muslim rulers.1,11

It was used to justify throwing Jews out of England, France, Spain and Portugal. It fed the torture carried out by the Inquisition, the church courts of Spain and Portugal.1

It was even in the prayers. Until 1959, the Catholic Good Friday service, held on the day Christians remember Jesus's death, called the Jews perfidis: faithless, a word many heard as treacherous. That year the had the word taken out.3

What the Gospels say

Now look at what the Gospels actually say. Some leaders in Jerusalem did push for Jesus's death, and a crowd that day shouted for it. But the Roman governor, , sentenced him, and Roman soldiers carried it out.2

So what about the crowd's cry in Matthew? The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, calls it the outcry of a manipulated crowd: one stirred up by others. And it says blame can't be stretched to other Jews of different times and places.5

On the cross, Jesus forgave the people who put him there, as people who didn't know what they were doing. Later , the leader of his closest followers, said the same to a crowd in Jerusalem, about them and their leaders.5

And here's what the blame always ignored: nearly everyone on Jesus's side of the story was Jewish too. Jesus, his mother, his (his closest followers) and most of the first believers.4

Think of it like this

Imagine a man wrongly executed long ago, in a small country under foreign rule. A few local officials pushed for it. A foreign governor signed the order. A crowd outside shouted along.

Now imagine what happens next. For 1,900 years, the descendants of that crowd are blamed for it. They're spat at in the street. They're driven from town to town, in every country they move to.

Nobody alive today stood in that crowd. Most people in that city weren't in it either, and plenty of them loved the man. And yet the blame keeps getting passed down, generation after generation, like a debt nobody signed for.

Nobody would call that justice. Guilt belongs to the people who did the wrong, never to a whole nation or its children.

How the Catholic Church changed

The push for change came from Jules Isaac, a Jewish historian who survived the Holocaust, the Nazis' mass murder of Europe's Jews. He showed how much anti-Jewish teaching ran through Catholic lessons and prayers. In 1960 he met the Pope to ask for change.1

Why then? Because of the Holocaust. Isaac argued that Christian hatred of Jews had helped prepare the way for it.12

Pope John XXIII listened. After their meeting on 13 June 1960, he had a statement on the Jews prepared for the , the great church meeting he had called.12

Even then it was a fight. The text went through five drafts. Some cardinals in Rome distrusted it. Bishops from the Middle East feared it would look like taking the side of the new state of Israel, and put Christians in Arab countries at risk.12

So it grew into a statement about other religions too. That's why the same 1965 document also speaks of Muslims, Hindus and Buddhists.12

In 1965 the gave its answer:

True, the Jewish authorities and those who followed their lead pressed for the death of Christ; still, what happened in His passion cannot be charged against all the Jews, without distinction, then alive, nor against the Jews of today.
Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (1965), 4

The same paragraph says Jews must not be presented as rejected or accursed by God, as if this followed from the Holy Scriptures. It says the Catholic Church decries hatred, persecutions, displays of anti-Semitism, directed against Jews at any time and by anyone.4

Some words were softened on the way. An earlier draft used the word deicide, killing God, and the final text doesn't. Another said the Church condemns hatred of Jews; the final text says decries.12

Some American Jewish groups saw dropping deicide as a defeat. Still, in the final vote the passed the document by 2,221 votes to 88.12

So who is to blame? The Catechism turns the old charge around. Every sinner shares the blame, it says, and Christians most of all: a responsibility with which they have all too often burdened the Jews alone.5

That idea wasn't new. An official Catholic teaching book from 1566 already said sinners were to blame.1,5 The honest problem is that it didn't stop centuries of sermons that said the opposite.

Saying sorry, and the critics

In 1998 the Vatican published We Remember, a reflection on the Holocaust. It said the Nazis' hatred of Jews, based on race, had its roots outside Christianity. But it admitted that hostile readings of the have circulated for too long, and asked whether old Christian prejudice made the Nazi persecution easier.6

Not everyone was satisfied. A leading American rabbi said it didn't admit how far the Church's anti-Jewish teaching had prepared the ground for deadly hatred.7

Others, including The New York Times, said it was too quick to defend Pope Pius XII, who led the Catholic Church during the Second World War.7

In 2000 prayed at the Western Wall in Jerusalem, a sacred place of Jewish prayer. He said he was deeply saddened by those who have caused these children of yours to suffer, and asked God's forgiveness.8

In 2008 an old prayer reopened the wound. Pope Benedict XVI had widened use of the older, 1962 form of the Catholic service.3

Its Good Friday prayer asked God to free the Jews from blindness. rewrote it to pray that they recognize Jesus .3

Many Jewish leaders heard the old call to convert them.3 In Germany, the Central Council of Jews suspended its dialogue with the Catholic Church for a time.13

Cardinal Walter Kasper, the Vatican's lead on relations with Jews, answered that the prayer leaves it to God alone, as a hope for the end of time. It isn't a call to missions.13

The usual Good Friday prayer, used since 1970, asks instead that Jews grow in love of God and stay faithful to his promises to them.3

Why most Jews don't accept Jesus

To be fair, Jews have their own serious reasons.

In Jewish belief, the , the king God promised, will rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem, the centre of Jewish worship destroyed long ago. He'll bring the Jewish people home and bring peace to the whole world. That hasn't happened. So Jewish teachers say he hasn't come yet.9

Christians answer that Jesus will finish that work when he comes back.

Jews also read key passages differently. Christians see Jesus in a passage of , an ancient Jewish prophet, about a servant who suffers. Jewish teachers usually see the Jewish people as a whole there.9

That's a real disagreement, and both sides can hold it with respect.

A promise never taken back

Behind the Catholic answer today are words of . Writing about his fellow Jews who didn't believe in Jesus, he insisted that the gifts and the call of God are irrevocable: God never takes them back.10

In 2015 a Vatican group used those words as the title of a reflection. It isn't formal teaching. But it's clear about Jesus:

It is the belief of the Church that Christ is the Saviour for all. There cannot be two ways of salvation, therefore, since Christ is also the Redeemer of the Jews in addition to the Gentiles.
Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, The Gifts and the Calling of God are Irrevocable (2015), 37

Gentiles are everyone who isn't Jewish. So the document doesn't say Jews can do without Jesus.

What it does say is that the Catholic Church neither conducts nor supports any specific institutional mission work directed towards Jews. So there are no organised campaigns to convert them.10

Why not? Because Jews already believe in the one God, and because of the Holocaust, which Jews call the Shoah. But Christians are still called to tell Jewish friends about Jesus, humbly and sensitively.10

The document even admits what it can't explain. Here's how it puts it:

That the Jews are participants in God's salvation is theologically unquestionable, but how that can be possible without confessing Christ explicitly, is and remains an unfathomable divine mystery.
The Gifts and the Calling of God are Irrevocable (2015), 36

Confessing Christ explicitly means openly believing in Jesus. So the document is sure Jews share in God's , and sure that salvation comes through Jesus. How both are true, only God knows.

Sorrow for the past, no blame on the Jewish people, and respect for a promise God has never taken back: that's where the Catholic Church stands today.

Sources13
  1. 1Wikipedia, Jewish deicideThe charge from Justin Martyr and Melito (2nd century), the harm it fed, the 1566 Roman Catechism and Jules Isaac (summarising Wilson, Cohick and others).
  2. 2Matthew 27 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The trial before Pilate, the crowd's cry, and the Roman soldiers.
  3. 3Wikipedia, Good Friday Prayer for the JewsJohn XXIII ordered perfidis removed from the prayer on 21 March 1959.
  4. 4Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (28 October 1965), 4The Passion cannot be charged against all Jews then or now; antisemitism condemned.
  5. 5Catechism of the Catholic Church, 597–598The Jews are not collectively responsible; all sinners are the authors of the Passion.
  6. 6Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, We Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah (16 March 1998)The Vatican on Christian anti-Judaism and the Holocaust, as an act of repentance.
  7. 7Wikipedia, We Remember: A Reflection on the ShoahReactions in 1998: Rabbi Rudin (AJC), Rabbi Klenicki (ADL), the New York Times.
  8. 8John Paul II, Prayer at the Western Wall (26 March 2000)The Pope's prayer asking forgiveness for those who made Jews suffer.
  9. 9Rabbi Shraga Simmons, Do Jews Believe in Jesus? (Aish.com, 2026 edition)A Jewish teacher sets out why Jews don't accept Jesus as Messiah.
  10. 10Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, The Gifts and the Calling of God are Irrevocable (10 December 2015)No institutional mission to Jews; God's covenant with Israel never revoked.
  11. 11Wikipedia, First CrusadeThe Crusades as religious wars of the Latin Church to return the Holy Land, ruled by Muslims since the 7th century, to Christian rule.
  12. 12Wikipedia, Nostra aetateIsaac's meeting with John XXIII on 13 June 1960; five drafts; opposition from curial conservatives and Middle Eastern bishops; "deicide" dropped and "condemns" softened; passed 2,221 to 88.
  13. 13Wikipedia (German), Karfreitagsfürbitte für die Juden2008 reaction: the Central Council of Jews in Germany suspended dialogue (Charlotte Knobloch); Cardinal Kasper's reply that the prayer leaves the Jews' coming to Christ to God alone, at the end of time, and rules out organised mission.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.