Crusaders bound for Egypt and Jerusalem storm Constantinople, the greatest Christian city of the East, and loot it for three days. For the Greek East, it made the split with the West feel permanent.
Historical evidence✓ Quotes checked
In brief
In 1202 the Fourth Crusade, meant for Egypt and Jerusalem, could not pay Venice for its ships. To clear the debt it attacked Zara, a Catholic city, and Pope Innocent III excommunicated the army.
Then a Byzantine prince, Alexios, promised money, soldiers and church union if the crusaders put his deposed father back on the throne of Constantinople.
They did, in 1203, but the money never came. On 12 April 1204 they stormed the city and looted it for three days: killing civilians, stripping churches, carrying off relics, and setting up a Latin empire that lasted until 1261.
Innocent condemned the sack, and for the Greek people it turned the split with the West into lasting hatred. John Paul II expressed Catholic regret in 2001 and 2004.
Where we are
The situation
Since 1095 Western Christians had been going east on crusades, armed pilgrimages to win and hold Jerusalem. In 1187 Saladin had taken Jerusalem back. Innocent III, from 1198, made recovering it the first aim of his reign.
The new crusade's leaders, mostly French knights, decided to strike at Egypt, the main Muslim power. In 1201, without consulting the pope, they signed a contract with Venice, a rich sea republic, for ships to carry 33,500 men, at 85,000 silver marks.
Venice and Constantinople were trade rivals. In 1171 the emperor had arrested Venice's merchants across his empire and seized their goods.
In 1182 a mob in Constantinople massacred the city's other Latin merchants, mostly Genoese and Pisans. Those memories still fed anger at the Greeks in the West. The Byzantines, for their part, had seen crusading armies march through their land since 1096.
Constantinople was the largest city in Christendom, but its rulers were divided. In 1195 Emperor Isaac II was overthrown and blinded by his own brother, Alexios III. Isaac's son, also called Alexios, escaped to the West to look for help.
▸Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
01
A contract the crusaders could not pay
The Catholic Encyclopedia's account of the money: Venice promised ships and food, the crusaders could not pay, and Venice named its price.
“The Venetians had pledged themselves to transport the entire Christian army and to furnish the fleet with provisions for nine months, for 85,000 marks. When the crusaders were unable to pay the sum, the Venetians proposed to bear the financial expenses themselves on condition that the crusaders would first assist them in the conquest of the city of Zara .”
Twenty-two years before the sack, a Byzantine mob massacred the Latin merchants of Constantinople. Greek violence against Latins is part of the background.
“Although precise numbers are unavailable, most Genoese and Pisans, which are estimated at less than 3,900 individuals, were either wiped out or forced to flee.”
A legate who left the Holy Land for Constantinople
Innocent III's letter to his legate Peter Capuano begins not with the sack but with desertion: the legate had sailed to Greece instead of tending the crusade's true object.
“It was your duty to attend to the business of your legation and to give careful consideration, not to the capture of the Empire of Constantinople, but rather to the defense of what is left of the Holy Land and, with the Lord's leave, the restoration of what has been lost.”
By May 1202 only about 12,000 crusaders had reached Venice, not 33,500. They couldn't pay. Venice had built the fleet and would not let them sail without the money.
So the question was whether an army sworn to fight for Jerusalem would let debt and promises turn it against fellow Christians. Many crusaders saw the danger, and some went home rather than take part.
Innocent III saw it too. He told the crusaders not to attack Christians. But his letter may have reached them too late, and his own legate, or envoy, of Capua, went along with the change of plan to keep the crusade from collapsing.
▸Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
01
Crusaders released from their vows
The legate had absolved the crusaders who stayed to hold Constantinople from their pilgrimage vows, which in the pope's eyes turned a diverted crusade into an abandoned one.
“you have absolved from their pilgrimage vows and their crusading obligations all the Crusaders who have remained to defend Constantinople from last March to the present. It is impossible not to be moved against you, for you neither should nor could give any such absolution.”
Venice offered a deal: help it take Zara, a Catholic port under the crusading King of Hungary, and the debt could wait. The crusaders took it in November 1202. Innocent excommunicated them, cutting them off from the , but in 1203 lifted it for all but the Venetians.
Then the young Alexios made his offer. If they put his father back on the throne, he would pay 200,000 silver marks, send 10,000 soldiers, and bring the Greek Church under the pope. Most leaders accepted; some, like Simon de Montfort, left in protest.
In July 1203 the crusaders attacked Constantinople. Alexios III fled, and the young man became co-emperor as Alexios IV. He could not pay what he had promised, and in February 1204 a Byzantine noble, Alexios Doukas, overthrew him and had him strangled.
The crusaders and Venetians agreed in advance how to share out the empire, and on 12 April 1204 they stormed the city. For three days soldiers killed civilians, raped women, including nuns, stripped churches and broke up the altar of Hagia Sophia.
Knights and clergy alike carried off , the bones of saints and objects linked to , to churches across the West. The leaders then crowned Baldwin, Count of Flanders, emperor in Hagia Sophia, and made a Venetian cleric, Thomas Morosini, patriarch, the senior of the city.
▸Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
01
Alexios's promises
The treaty that turned the crusade towards Constantinople, as the Catholic Encyclopedia summarises it.
“They had concluded with Alexius, the Byzantine pretender, a treaty whereby he promised to have the Greeks return to the Roman communion, give the crusaders 200,000 marks, and participate in the Holy War.”
Innocent's description of what the crusaders did is as blunt as any Greek chronicle.
“whose swords, which they were supposed to use against the pagans, are now dripping with Christian blood ... They have even ripped silver plates from the altars and have hacked them to pieces among themselves. They violated the holy places and have carried off crosses and relics.”
'An example of perdition and the works of darkness'
The sentence that names the consequence for reunion: the Greek Church now sees in the Latins only perdition, and 'with reason' detests them.
“How, indeed, is the Greek church to be brought back into ecclesiastical union and to a devotion for the Apostolic See when she has been beset with so many afflictions and persecutions that she sees in the Latins only an example of perdition and the works of darkness, so that she now, and with reason, detests the Latins more than dogs?”
Innocent's first reaction was fury. He wrote to his legate that the Greek Church now saw in the Latins ‘only an example of perdition and the works of darkness’. Unable to undo it, he then accepted the new order and tried to bring the Greek Church under Rome.
The Byzantines regrouped at Nicaea, across the water in Asia Minor. In 1261 Michael VIII Palaiologos took Constantinople back. The Latin empire had lasted 57 years.
The empire never fully recovered. It survived, weaker, until the Ottoman Turks took the city in 1453.
For the Greek people, distrust of the Latins now turned into hatred of the whole Latin West. Leaders later signed reunions at Lyon in 1274 and Florence in 1439. Both were rejected at home, and the memory of 1204 was one reason.
On 4 May 2001, in Athens, named the sack and said Catholics regret it deeply. On 29 June 2004, welcoming Patriarch Bartholomew I to Rome, he shared the ‘indignation and sorrow’ Innocent III had felt eight centuries earlier.
▸Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
01
Anger, then acceptance
The sourcebook's headnote records what followed the letter: the pope could change nothing, and in time recognised the Latin regime in Constantinople.
“Despite these bitter words, there was little that the Pope could do to alter what had happened and so, as his initial anger subsided, Innocent first recognized and then embraced the new order in Constantinople.”
Speaking in Athens in 2001, John Paul II named the sack as one of the memories that still wound, and said its authors being Latin Christians 'fills Catholics with deep regret'.
“I am thinking of the disastrous sack of the imperial city of Constantinople, which was for so long the bastion of Christianity in the East. It is tragic that the assailants, who had set out to secure free access for Christians to the Holy Land, turned against their own brothers in the faith. The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret.”
Welcoming Patriarch Bartholomew I to Rome, John Paul II named April 1204 directly and made Innocent III's anger his own.
“An army that had set out to recover the Holy Land for Christendom marched on Constantinople, took it and sacked it, pouring out the blood of our own brothers and sisters in the faith. Eight centuries later, how can we fail to share the same indignation and sorrow that Pope Innocent III expressed as soon as he heard the news of what had happened?”
Constantinople was retaken in 1261, but the Orthodox history draws the line from 1204 to the fall of the city in 1453.
“Even though the Byzantine Empire lasted for almost another 200 years, she never fully recovered from the devastation of the Fourth Crusade and the 57 years of Latin rule in her capital city.”
Many Catholics date the East–West split to 1054. Many Christians date it to 1204. Before the sack it was a quarrel between church leaders. After it, it was a wound in the memory of a whole people.
It's also a case of a holy aim going wrong step by step. The crusade was preached for Jerusalem. Debt, trade rivalry, ambition and a promise of money pulled it to Zara and then to the greatest Christian city in the world.
And it explains why Catholic–Orthodox talks today begin with memory as well as . In Athens in 2001 John Paul II asked for a ‘purification of memory’ on both sides, starting with Catholic against the Orthodox.
▸Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
01
Purification of memory
The same address asks forgiveness for Catholic sins 'by action or omission' against the Orthodox. Understanding why the East never rejoined starts with the memory of 1204.
“Clearly there is a need for a liberating process of purification of memory . For the occasions past and present, when sons and daughters of the Catholic Church have sinned by action or omission against their Orthodox brothers and sisters, may the Lord grant us the forgiveness we beg of him.”
In Athens on 4 May 2001 John Paul II said: ‘It is tragic that the assailants, who had set out to secure free access for Christians to the Holy Land, turned against their own brothers in the faith. The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret.’
In the same address he asked God's forgiveness for the times Catholics ‘have sinned by action or omission against their Orthodox brothers and sisters’. In 2004 he told Patriarch Bartholomew I that Catholics share Innocent III's ‘indignation and sorrow’.
In plain terms
Think of it like this
The thing said in a family argument that can never be taken back.
A crusade sworn to fight elsewhere spent three days looting the greatest Christian city in the world, stripping its churches and carrying the relics home. Doctrinal disagreements can be negotiated for centuries. This was a wound to memory, and memory is what made every later reunion collapse when it reached ordinary people.
Read the text
“As for those who were supposed to be seeking the ends of Jesus Christ, not their own ends, whose swords, which they were supposed to use against the pagans, are now dripping with Christian blood … she sees in the Latins only an example of perdition and the works of darkness.”
Was the diversion planned? Some historians think Venice, or the crusade's commander Boniface of Montferrat, meant to go to Constantinople from the start. Others see a chain of bad choices driven by debt. The Catholic Encyclopedia says the idea ‘was not new to Boniface’.
Could the pope have stopped it? Innocent forbade attacks on Christians and excommunicated first the army, then the Venetians. But his legate went along, and after the conquest Innocent accepted it. Historians still argue how much more he could have done.
How bad was it? The Greek eyewitness Niketas Choniates describes icons trampled and the , the consecrated bread of , thrown on the ground. Innocent's own letter, written from the Latin side, describes the same. The two sides' sources agree.
Greek violence against Latins was real too, above all the massacre of 1182. It helps explain the anger; it does not excuse the sack, and no Catholic authority today says it does.
▸Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
01
Was it planned?
The Catholic Encyclopedia itself raises the question whether the turn to Constantinople was arranged in advance.
“a passage in the "Gesta Innocentii" (83, in P.L., CCXIV, CXXXII) indicates that the idea was not new to Boniface of Montferrat when, in the spring of 1202, he made it known to the pope .”
Could Rome have prevented it? The pope's own defence
Innocent says he had already acted against the legate for joining the diversion. How far papal prohibitions restrained the crusade is what historians argue about.
“We ourselves were not a little agitated and, with reason, we acted against you, since you had fallen in with this counsel and because you had deserted the Land which the Lord consecrated by his presence”
The Greek eyewitness: relics, and the Eucharist itself
Niketas Choniates was a senior official in Constantinople in 1204 and fled the city. His account is the Greek memory at its source, and it matches the pope's own description of what was done in the churches.
“How shall I begin to tell of the deeds wrought by these nefarious men! Alas, the images, which ought to have been adored, were trodden under foot! Alas, the relics of the holy martyrs were thrown into unclean places! ... the divine body and blood of Christ was spilled upon the ground or thrown about.”
The altar of the Great Church, broken up and shared out. This is the memory the 2001 apology in Athens was answering.
“Nor can the violation of the Great Church ... be listened to with equanimity. For the sacred altar, formed of all kinds of precious materials and admired by the whole world, was broken into bits and distributed among the soldiers, as was all the other sacred wealth of so great and infinite splendor.”
1204 as the seal on the schism: the Orthodox reading
Where Catholic timelines mark 1054, the Orthodox history marks 1204 as the moment the schism was finally sealed.
“The 13th century began with what is generally considered to be the final sealing of the schism between East and West, when the knights of the Fourth Crusade brutally sacked Constantinople during the first three days of Holy Week in 1204.”
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
Claims behind this footprint
What this rests on
Each claim says one thing, shows the words it rests on, and says how far it has been checked. Long passages are folded; open them to read the whole text.
Innocent III condemned the crusaders' sack of Constantinople in 1204, writing that their swords were dripping with Christian blood and that the Greek Church now saw in the Latins only an example of perdition.
“As for those who were supposed to be seeking the ends of Jesus Christ, not their own ends, whose swords, which they were supposed to use against the pagans, are now dripping with Christian blood … she sees in the Latins only an example of perdition and the works of darkness.”
Checked
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).
Go deeper
First-hand history✓ Checked against original 2026-09-22
Niketas Choniates (Byzantine historian and eyewitness) · c. 1204–1215 · Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University (translation from D. C. Munro, Translations and Reprints, 1912)
First-hand history✓ Checked against original 2026-09-22
You’ll be taken to the place on the Trail that answers it: a question already answered, a footprint on the River, a chapter, a country on the map.
Three written answers a day: each one costs a little, and the Trail is paid for by one person. The search, and the questions the Trail has already answered, are always free.
Try
Feedback
Step 1 of 3
How satisfied are you with the Trail so far?
Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied
Your rating is saved as soon as you choose it. Every question after this one is optional. Privacy notice. Only want to point something out?
ACG
Builds The Trail
Sorry to interrupt your reading.
I’m ACG, a Catholic in Singapore. I built the Trail so Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants can see that we all come from the same spring.
It’s entirely self-funded, built after my day job. Your support keeps it online each month.
And it brings me closer to a dream: to visit these churches in person, film their stories, and one day do this full time.
If it’s been worth your time, would you help keep it going? If not, thanks for reading. That means a lot too.