The Day of Pardon
In St Peter's, John Paul II asks God's forgiveness for the Church's sins, including intolerance in the service of truth and the divisions between Christians.
As the year 2000 approached, Pope John Paul II wanted the Church to begin the new millennium by examining its own past. For years he had asked forgiveness for particular wrongs; now he asked the whole Church to make a ‘purification of memory’, and some Catholics were uneasy about it.
On 12 March 2000, at Mass in St Peter's, cardinals confessed seven kinds of sin committed by the Church's members, among them intolerance in the service of truth, divisions between Christians, sins against the Jewish people and against the dignity of women and minorities. After each one the pope prayed and a lamp was lit before the crucifix. No pope had done anything like it.
The situation
In 1994 began preparing the Church for the year 2000, a Jubilee, a holy year of pilgrimage and pardon. He hoped it would bring a purification of the Church's memory from ‘counter-witness and scandal’ in the past thousand years.
He had already asked forgiveness many times for particular wrongs, among them the divisions between Christians. Now he wanted the whole Church to do it together, in prayer.
Five days before the ceremony the International Theological Commission, a body of theologians that advises the Vatican, published Memory and Reconciliation. It worked out how a Church that believes itself holy can confess the faults of its members.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
The plan, from 1994
The theologians' study traces the Day of Pardon back to John Paul II's letter preparing for the Jubilee.
“…the Pope expresses the hope that the Jubilee of 2000 might be the occasion for a purification of the memory of the Church from all forms of “counter-witness and scandal” which have occurred in the course of the past millennium.”
Memory and Reconciliation: The Church and the Faults of the Past · Memory and Reconciliation, 1.3, John Paul II's Requests for Forgiveness
What was at stake
Not everyone was comfortable. The theologians' study admitted that ‘some of the faithful are disconcerted and their loyalty to the Church seems shaken’.
Can people today be held guilty for the Crusades or the Inquisition, the church courts that tried people for heresy? Is it not too easy to judge the past by today's conscience? And does confessing faults undercut the Church's claim to teach the truth?
Its answer was that no one today is personally guilty of past . But Christians are bound together across time as one body, so they can carry the weight of what was done in the Church's name, and ask God to heal it.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
The objections, raised by the Church's own theologians first
Memory and Reconciliation opens by putting the hardest questions to itself before answering them.
“Can today's conscience be assigned 'guilt' for isolated historical phenomena like the Crusades or the Inquisition? Isn't it a bit too easy to judge people of the past by the conscience of today (as the Scribes and Pharisees do according to Mt 23:29-32), almost as if moral conscience were not situated in time?”
Memory and Reconciliation: The Church and the Faults of the Past · Memory and Reconciliation, section 1 - 02
Unease inside the Church
The study did not hide that the idea troubled some Catholics.
“Nevertheless, some of the faithful are disconcerted and their loyalty to the Church seems shaken.”
Memory and Reconciliation: The Church and the Faults of the Past · Memory and Reconciliation, 1.4, The Questions Raised
The event
On 12 March 2000, the first Sunday of , John Paul II celebrated in St 's Basilica.
Seven confessions were made in turn by cardinals, the 's most senior advisers, and other senior officials of the Vatican, each followed by a prayer from the pope and a lamp lit before the crucifix.
They confessed sins in general; sins in the service of truth; sins against the unity of Christians; sins against the people of Israel; sins against love, peace and other cultures; sins against the dignity of women and minorities; and sins against human rights.
In his homily the pope asked pardon ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’, and asked Catholics to forgive the wrongs done to them in turn.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
The first confession sets the terms
The opening prayer names both kinds of member the Church has always had, without pretending the second kind is a later problem.
“Lord God, your pilgrim Church, which you ever sanctify in the blood of your Son, counts among her children in every age members whose holiness shines brightly forth and members whose disobedience to you contradicts the faith we profess and the Holy Gospel.”
Universal Prayer: Confession of Sins and Asking for Forgiveness · Universal Prayer, I: Confession of sins in general - 02
The pope's stated reason
The homily explains the term he used for the exercise, and who he understood himself to be speaking as.
“As the Successor of Peter, I asked that 'in this year of mercy the Church, strong in the holiness which she receives from her Lord, should kneel before God and implore forgiveness for the past and present sins of her sons and daughters'.”
Homily of John Paul II, Day of Pardon, 12 March 2000 · Homily of 12 March 2000
The outcome
No pope had done anything on this scale before. It did not settle the historical arguments, and it was criticised from both directions, as too much and as too vague.
It did put the Church's own record inside its public prayer.
Later popes followed the same path, each time more specifically: Benedict XVI to victims of abuse in Ireland in 2010, Francis to Pentecostals at Caserta in 2014.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Forgive, and ask forgiveness
The homily joined the request for pardon to an act of forgiveness for wrongs suffered by Christians.
“At the same time, as we confess our sins, let us forgive the sins committed by others against us. Countless times in the course of history Christians have suffered hardship, oppression and persecution because of their faith.”
Homily of John Paul II, Day of Pardon, 12 March 2000 · Homily of 12 March 2000, §4
For the trail
The persecution footprints on this River end here, with the Church asking forgiveness for them.
A body that asks forgiveness for the methods it used is making a different claim from one that says it never erred. The Church claims to carry the truth; it does not claim that the people carrying it were always good.
The prayer itself states the principle: truth can prevail only by its own power, never by force.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Truth by persuasion or not at all
The pope's prayer states the principle that the persecution footprints violate.
“…accept our resolve to seek and promote truth in the gentleness of charity, in the firm knowledge that truth can prevail only in virtue of truth itself.”
Universal Prayer: Confession of Sins and Asking for Forgiveness · Universal Prayer, II
What the Church says
This is the Church speaking about itself. It teaches that the Church is holy while its members are sinners, and so it asks forgiveness for their sins (CCC 827).
The same liturgy confessed that ‘Christians have at times given in to intolerance and have not been faithful to the great commandment of love’. In his homily John Paul II also asked Catholics to forgive the wrongs done to them: ‘Let us forgive and ask forgiveness!’
Think of it like this
A family that finally reads out the bad chapters at the reunion instead of skipping them.
Every family has a version of its own story that leaves things out. The Day of Pardon was the Church reading its own worst pages aloud, in its most public act of worship, while still claiming to carry something true. The two things are only contradictory if the claim was ever that the people carrying it were good.
“Let us pray that each one of us, looking to the Lord Jesus, meek and humble of heart, will recognize that even men of the Church, in the name of faith and morals, have sometimes used methods not in keeping with the Gospel in the solemn duty of defending the truth.”
The pope's own prayer followed: 'in certain periods of history Christians have at times given in to intolerance and have not been faithful to the great commandment of love, sullying in this way the face of the Church, your Spouse.'
Where people disagree
Critics said the confessions were addressed to God rather than to the people who were hurt, and named no one who did the harm.
Others objected that the Church itself cannot sin, only its members. The prayers were carefully worded to say exactly that.
Some historians argue that judging past ages by present standards is unfair to the people of the past. The accompanying theological study raises that problem itself.
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- John Paul II and the Roman Curia · 2000-03-12 · Holy See
- John Paul II · 2000-03-12 · Holy See
- International Theological Commission · 2000-03-07 · Holy See
- Second Vatican Council · 1965-12-07 · Holy See