From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/muslims-same-god
← Another faithDo Muslims and Christians worship the same God?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minThe Catholic Church says yes: Muslims and Christians both worship the one God who made and earth, the God of , who will judge us all. But they disagree deeply about who he is. Christians believe God is Father, Son and , and that Jesus is God made man.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 841
- Vatican II
- Lumen Gentium, 16Nostra Aetate, 3
People answer this in two ways, and both have a point. Some say yes. Some Christians say no: the God they worship has a Son, and the God of the Qur'an, the Muslim holy book, doesn't.
Many Muslims would say no too. The Qur'an says God is far above having a son.1 Muslims hold that God is one and can't be divided.2
The word isn't the problem. Allah is simply Arabic for God, and Arabic-speaking Christians used it before Islam began, and still do.3
The real question is whether two people who describe someone very differently are still talking about the same person.
The Catholic answer: yes
The Catholic Church teaches that Muslims worship the one God together with Christians, even though they don't believe in the : the Christian belief that the one God is Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
In 1964 the put it like this:
But the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator. In the first place amongst these there are the Muslims, who, professing to hold the faith of Abraham, along with us adore the one and merciful God, who on the last day will judge mankind.
Abraham is the ancient believer who trusted God completely. Jews, Christians and Muslims all look back to him as a father of faith.6,10 The repeats the 's words.5
The plan of is God's plan to rescue every person and bring them home to him. Catholics believe whoever is saved is saved through Jesus, even without knowing his name.4
A year later the council added that the Church regards with esteem the Muslims, who worship the one, living, merciful God who made heaven and earth.6
Why say the same God, with differences this big? Because there's only one God, and Muslims aren't pointing at some other god. They point to the one God who made heaven and earth, called Abraham, and will judge the world. Christians point to him too.
In 1985 spoke to young Muslims in Casablanca, Morocco. He told them: We believe in the same God, the one God, the living God.7
Think of it like this
Imagine two neighbours talking about the old man at the end of your street. Both have known him for years. Both have sat at his table. Each is sure she knows him best.
One says: he has a son working overseas, and his whole face changes when the son calls. The other shakes her head. No, she says, he has no son. You've misunderstood him.
That isn't a small slip. It's a big disagreement about who this man is and what matters most to him. One of them is wrong about something important, and they can talk it through.
But they're both talking about the same man. That's how the Catholic Church sees Christians and Muslims: one God, described in ways that clash on something that matters hugely.
What they share
A lot. Both believe in one merciful God who made everything and will judge the world. Both pray, give to the poor and fast.6
And here's what surprises many Christians: Muslims honour Jesus as a prophet and Mary as his virgin mother.6 The Qur'an calls him the , and most Muslims believe God took him up to heaven, and that he will come back at the end of time.1,11
Where they really differ
The differences are not small, and pretending they are disrespects both faiths.
Christians believe in one God in three persons. The Qur'an rejects that.1
For Muslims, God's oneness, tawhid, is the heart of the faith. A short chapter of the Qur'an says it: He is Allah, One and Indivisible.2
To a Muslim, saying God has a son doesn't honour him. It takes away from his greatness and his oneness.1
Christians believe Jesus is God the Son, who became a man. That's why they pray to him. They believe he died on a cross and rose again. The Qur'an says they neither killed nor him.8
In Casablanca John Paul II named that too: Loyalty demands also that we should recognize and respect our differences.7
The most basic one, he said, is who Jesus is, and what he did. He called it a mystery on which he was sure God would one day enlighten us.7
Same God doesn't mean same faith.
Why some Christians say no
Some Christians say no for a serious reason: a God without the Son isn't the God of the .
Their key verse is in John's first letter, in the : No one who denies the Son has the Father, but whoever confesses the Son has the Father as well.12
Catholics take it seriously. John wrote it about people who had left the church and denied that Jesus is the .12
To have the Father, for John, is to know him and belong to him fully. And the verse doesn't say they're praying to another god.
Catholics agree that leaving out the Son leaves out the heart of who God is. But they'd say it's still the same God being described.
Christians already say something like this about Jews. Jews don't believe in Jesus either, and Christians still say they truly worship the God of Abraham. So believing differently about Jesus doesn't, on its own, mean worshipping a different God.
Those who say no answer that Jews are different, because the Jewish scriptures are the first part of the Christian Bible. It's a fair point, and it's why Christians still argue about this.
Living it out
In 2019 Francis and the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar, a leading Muslim scholar, signed the Document on Human Fraternity together in Abu Dhabi.9
It speaks In the name of God who has created all human beings equal in rights, duties and dignity.9
One line says the variety of religions is willed by God in His wisdom.9 Some Catholics worried: does that mean God wants many religions?
Two months later Francis explained: God allowed this. Some religions are born from culture, he said, but they always look to heaven. What God wants, he said, is for us to live as brothers and sisters.10
A careful yes, then. Same God, worshipped by both, and understood very differently on the biggest question of all: who Jesus is.
Catholics and Muslims can say that to each other honestly, and stay friends.
Sources12
- 1The Qur'an 4:171 (The Clear Quran, tr. Mustafa Khattab, on quran.com)"Do not say, Trinity"; God is "far above having a son"; Jesus is the Messiah, son of Mary.
- 2The Qur'an 112, Al-Ikhlas (on quran.com)"He is Allah, One and Indivisible": the heart of Muslim belief about God.
- 3Wikipedia, AllahArabic-speaking Christians and Jews also call God Allah; it is the word for God in Indonesian Bibles.
- 4Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (21 November 1964), 16Muslims "along with us adore the one and merciful God".
- 5Catechism of the Catholic Church, 841The Church's relationship with the Muslims.
- 6Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (28 October 1965), 3The Church regards Muslims with esteem: what they believe and how they worship.
- 7John Paul II, Address to young Muslims in Casablanca (19 August 1985)"We believe in the same God", and the honest naming of differences about Jesus.
- 8The Qur'an 4:157 (The Clear Quran, tr. Mustafa Khattab, on quran.com)"They neither killed nor crucified him; it was only made to appear so."
- 9Pope Francis and Ahmad al-Tayyeb, Document on Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together (Abu Dhabi, 4 February 2019)A joint Catholic and Muslim declaration on dignity, freedom of belief and peace.
- 10Pope Francis, General Audience (3 April 2019)Why are there many religions? "God allowed this" (voluntas permissiva); what God wants is fraternity.
- 11Wikipedia, Islamic views on Jesus' deathMost Muslims hold that Jesus was not crucified but raised bodily to heaven, to remain until his Second Coming.
- 121 John 2 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Verse 23 quoted; verses 19 and 22 give its context: people who left the community and denied that Jesus is the Christ.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.