From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/sack-of-constantinople
← OrthodoxHas Rome ever apologised for the sack of Constantinople in 1204?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minYes. In 2001 told the of Greece that the sack fills Catholics with deep regret, and asked God's forgiveness for Catholic against them. In 2004 the Ecumenical Patriarch, Bartholomew, publicly accepted the apology.
For many Orthodox, 1204 hurts more than 1054. In 1054, church leaders cut each other off. In 1204, Western crusaders sacked Constantinople, today's Istanbul: they looted and wrecked the city. The split became a wound in ordinary families.
So it's fair to ask if Rome has ever owned it.
What the crusaders did
The story is worse than most people know.
In 1202 Western crusaders set out to win back Jerusalem, on ships built by Venice. They couldn't pay for the ships. So, to clear the debt, they attacked Zara, a Catholic city on the Adriatic coast, today's Zadar in Croatia. Innocent III cut them off for it.1
Then a Greek prince made them an offer. Put his deposed father back on the throne in Constantinople, the great Christian capital of the East, and he'd pay. He even promised to put the Greek Church under the pope.1
The pope warned them not to attack Christians, but didn't clearly forbid the plan. When the deal fell apart, he ordered them again not to attack. The clergy travelling with the army kept his letter quiet.1
Many crusaders refused and went home. The rest stormed Constantinople in April 1204 and looted it for three days.1,2
They killed civilians and stripped and defiled churches, among them Hagia Sophia, the city's great church.1,2
Western Catholics, known then as Latins, ruled the city for 57 years and put in their own patriarch, the city's top .2 An Orthodox history calls it the final sealing of the between East and West.2
Innocent III was furious. He listed the crusaders' crimes: killing, rape, looting churches. How could the Greeks ever come back to Rome now, he asked, when they hated the Latins more than dogs, and with good reason?3
But his anger didn't last. In the end he accepted the new Latin rule in Constantinople.3
The apology, by name
John Paul II called it a purification of memory: looking honestly at the past, naming your own side's wrongs and asking forgiveness.4 In Athens, on 4 May 2001, he did exactly that:
For the occasions past and present, when sons and daughters of the Catholic Church have sinned by action or omission against their Orthodox brothers and sisters, may the Lord grant us the forgiveness we beg of him.
He called the sack disastrous. He said it was tragic that the attackers turned against their own brothers in the faith.4
And he said plainly that the attackers were Latin Christians, and that this fills Catholics with deep regret.4 He didn't blame a few bad soldiers, or Venice alone.
On 29 June 2004, with Patriarch Bartholomew beside him in Rome, he spoke of April 1204 again.5
That November he gave back to Constantinople the , the remains, of two of its greatest bishops, St Gregory the Theologian and St John Chrysostom. Both had been away for centuries.6
If you're Orthodox, you know that second name. It's on the Divine Liturgy most Orthodox churches celebrate Sunday after Sunday.7
How the Orthodox took it
Not everyone in Greece welcomed the Pope. CNN reported that hundreds of conservative Orthodox protested, with banners calling him the anti-Christ.8 Other reports noted that no Greek Orthodox clergy met him at the airport.9
According to CNN, Greek Church leaders said the protesters came from fringe groups with no official relation with the church of Greece.8
Archbishop Christodoulos of Athens, head of Greece's Orthodox Church, opened their meeting with a long list of grievances going back 1,000 years. The Washington Post quoted him saying no one had yet asked pardon for the crusaders.9
The Pope answered with the apology quoted above. The American magazine U.S. News & World Report wrote that it visibly softened Christodoulos. In private, the magazine said, the two prayed the Lord's Prayer together, and at the end Christodoulos called the visit the beginning of a new era.9
To be fair, it wasn't a complete surprise: the Vatican had told Greece's Orthodox leaders in advance that an apology was coming.9 Nobody seems to have surveyed what ordinary Greeks made of it. Some protested in the streets, and their archbishop ended the visit speaking of a new era.
In 2004 Bartholomew, the Ecumenical Patriarch, accepted the apology with gratitude and respect, 800 years on. But he didn't soften it: It is a fact that a crime was committed here in the city 800 years ago.10
Of the relics, he said their return atones for an anomaly and an ecclesiastical injustice.6 In other words, giving them back put right a wrong done to his Church.
Why say sorry for the dead?
Nobody alive sacked Constantinople. So why apologise? Because Catholics believe their Church is one family across time. You inherit its saints, and you also inherit its debts.
Think of it like this
Imagine a cousin who comes to stay with your family. One night he robs the house, sells Grandma's jewellery, the pieces she was saving for her granddaughters, and moves into the main bedroom. He keeps the house for years.
Generations pass. Everyone who was there has died. But his great-grandchildren still come to every family wedding and every holiday dinner. They sit at the same table as the great-grandchildren of the family he robbed.
They didn't do it. Nobody blames them for it. But if they never once mentioned it, never once said that was wrong, you'd notice. So would everyone else at the table.
An apology from people who didn't do the harm isn't about guilt. It's about refusing to pretend it didn't happen.
Wrongs on both sides
The wrongs didn't all run one way. In 1182 a mob in Constantinople attacked the Latin quarter, killing Latin residents. How many died isn't known: estimates run from hundreds to many thousands.11
In 1215 a Western complained that Greeks re-baptised Latins and washed altars Latin priests had used. That council met while Latins still ruled Constantinople, and it ordered the Greeks to fall in line with Rome.2,12
Each side had learned to treat the other with contempt.
None of this makes 1204 smaller. It shows why both Churches need healing, not just one.
In 1993 the official Catholic-Orthodox commission agreed that suspicion would fade if both Churches would condemn violence wherever communities of one Church use it against communities of a Sister Church.13 Sister Churches is an old Eastern name for Churches that are family to each other.
So yes, Rome has apologised, publicly and by name, and the Ecumenical Patriarch accepted.4,10 An apology doesn't undo 1204. But the Catholic Church no longer tells the story as if it happened to someone else's family.
Sources13
- 1Wikipedia, Fourth CrusadeZara, the deal with Alexios, Innocent's orders and the suppressed letter, the three-day sack; the 1205 date of Innocent's letter.
- 2Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. III: The Fourth CrusadeAn Orthodox account: the sack, the Latin patriarch, 57 years of Latin rule.
- 3Innocent III, Letter to his legate on the conquest of Constantinople (12 July 1205; Fordham Medieval Sourcebook, tr. Brundage)The pope's rebuke listing the crusaders' crimes; the editor notes he later accepted the new order.
- 4John Paul II, Address to Archbishop Christodoulos of Athens (4 May 2001)Names the sack of Constantinople, expresses deep regret and asks forgiveness.
- 5John Paul II, Address to Patriarch Bartholomew I (29 June 2004)Recalls April 1204 and shares Innocent III's indignation and sorrow.
- 6John Paul II, Letter to Bartholomew I on the return of relics, with the Patriarch's reply (27 November 2004)Relics of Sts Gregory and John Chrysostom returned; Bartholomew calls it an act of atonement.
- 7Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. II: The Divine LiturgyThe Liturgy of St John Chrysostom is the one the Orthodox Church celebrates; St Basil's is used only ten times a year.
- 8CNN, Papal visit sparks Greek protests (4 May 2001)Hundreds of conservative Orthodox protest; Church of Greece leaders call them fringe groups.
- 9Andrew Walsh, The Pope Among the Orthodox, Religion in the News (Trinity College), Summer 2001How the press reported Athens 2001: no clergy at the airport, Christodoulos's grievances, the apology, the Lord's Prayer together, the advance notice; Ukraine and the Lviv parishes.
- 10In Communion (Orthodox Peace Fellowship), News, issue 33 (2004): Patriarch accepts Pope's apologyBartholomew's words accepting the apology at the 800th-anniversary liturgy, April 2004.
- 11Wikipedia, Massacre of the Latins (1182)The 1182 killing of Genoese and Pisan residents of Constantinople; death toll unknown, likely in the hundreds.
- 12Fourth Lateran Council (1215), canon 4Complains that Greeks washed altars after Latin use and rebaptised Latins.
- 13Catholic-Orthodox Joint Commission, Balamand Document (1993), 27Both Churches to condemn violence by one against the other.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.