← Sources
What the site rests on

Why quote the Catholic Church's own documents? Isn't that biased?

Read it as an illustrated story · 4 min

For what the Catholic Church teaches, its own documents are the right source, the way a country's own law is where you check what the law says. For whether something actually happened, they're not enough, so history starts with first-hand sources and scholars, critics and other churches included.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Vatican II
Dei Verbum, 10

It's a fair worry. A Catholic site quoting Catholic documents can sound like asking a restaurant to review its own food.

But there are two different questions hiding in here, and they need different sources.

What does the Church teach?

Say your question is what do Catholics believe? Then the Catholic Church's own documents are the best source there is. Nobody can tell you what it teaches more exactly than its own documents can.

So The Trail has a rule. Catholic teaching has to rest on tier A: the , councils (meetings of the world's ), , the (the Church's summary of its beliefs) and the Vatican's offices.1

That rule also guards against the site's own author. When a page says what the Catholic Church teaches, it points you to the Catechism, a or a pope's document, so you can check it against the source, not against ACG.2

Think of it like this

Say you're driving in another country and you want to know the speed limit on its motorways.

You could ask a friend who drove there once, or read a travel blog. They might be right. But the surest answer is the country's own traffic law, because that's the thing that sets the limit. Nobody would call you biased for checking it there.

Now ask a different question. Is that limit a good idea? Do drivers actually keep to it? The law can't answer that. For that you'd look at the accident figures, ask the people who live there, and read the critics who think the limit is wrong.

The law is the best source for what the law says. It isn't the only source for whether it works.

And quoting a teaching doesn't prove it's true. The Trail labels a claim Revealed when the Catholic Church teaches it as revealed by God, and says outright that the label doesn't mean the site has proved it.1

Even the Church's own teaching says it isn't at the top of the chain. Speaking of the Church's teaching role (the pope and bishops when they teach), the wrote that this teaching office is not above the word of God, but serves it.3 Bear in mind it's the Church describing itself, so weigh it as that.

Did it really happen?

History is a different question. For that, the Catholic Church's word on its own isn't enough, and the site doesn't treat it as enough.1

History starts at tier B: the first-hand sources, like the early Christian writers, old letters and chronicles, and eyewitnesses.1 Then come scholars and reference works, used to set the story in context and, where needed, to push back on it.1

That includes critics, in their own words. The chapter on the Shroud of Turin, a cloth some believe wrapped Jesus's body, gives the skeptics' case that its image is a medieval painting.4

Sometimes the Catholic Church's own records are the strongest evidence against it.

The chapter on what went wrong in the medieval Church draws on the Church's own meetings of bishops, which kept condemning the same abuses from 1215 to 1563.5

When the Church's own records admit a failure, that isn't spin. It's evidence.

Every church in its own words

The same rule works for everyone else. Tier A also holds other churches' own founding and official texts, in their own words.1

So when a page says what Protestants believe, it quotes Protestants. Take the seven , the sacred rites like and marriage. The chapter on them gives the case made by Luther, Melanchthon and Calvin, leaders of the Reformation in the 1500s, that only two or three are true sacraments.6

Many Protestants hold Scripture as the final authority, with creeds and teachers to help. The Westminster Confession, a Presbyterian statement of faith from 1647, says every dispute about faith is settled by the speaking in Scripture.7

And when a page says how Christians see the pope, it quotes the Orthodox Church of Constantinople's own reply to Rome, from 1895.8

So the Catholic Church's documents tell you what Catholics believe, and other churches' documents tell you what they believe. Whether any of it is true is yours to judge, with every source open in front of you.

Sources8
  1. 1The Trail, How we know (the method page), chapters I and VThe tiers: Catholic teaching rests on tier A, history starts at tier B, other churches' own texts in tier A; the 'Revealed' label doesn't mean the site has proved a claim.
  2. 2ACG, About The Trail ("What people ask me")Whenever a page says what the Catholic Church teaches, it points to the Catechism, a council or a papal document, so it can be checked against the source, not against ACG.
  3. 3Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum (18 November 1965), 10The teaching office is not above the word of God, but serves it.
  4. 4The Trail, chapter: The Shroud of TurinThe skeptics' case, in their own words, that the image is a medieval painting.
  5. 5The Trail, chapter: What was wrong in the medieval ChurchAbuses taken from Catholic councils' own decrees, 1215 to 1563.
  6. 6The Trail, chapter: Seven sacramentsThe Protestant objection quoted from Luther, Melanchthon and Calvin: only two or three rites are sacraments properly so called.
  7. 7Westminster Confession of Faith (1647), 1.10 (Orthodox Presbyterian Church text)The supreme judge of all controversies of religion is the Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture.
  8. 8The Trail, chapter: Vatican IThe Orthodox reply in its own words: the 1895 encyclical of the Church of Constantinople.
Quotes not yet checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.