Part IX · Chapter 24
What was wrong in the medieval Church

Church posts for sale, priests living with partners, absent bishops, indulgences for money, three men claiming to be pope. How much of it is true?

9 scenes · about 27 min read

The short answer

Most of it is true. Church posts were bought and sold. Priests lived with partners, and drew income from dioceses they never lived in. Indulgences, releases from punishment owed for , were tied to money for the new St 's.

From 1378 to 1417 rival divided the Church, and saints took opposite sides.

Almost all of that record comes from Catholics. Church councils condemned buying church posts, called simony, in 1215, 1418 and 1514. The was still fighting the same abuses in 1563.

Each new ban admits that the last one failed.

In 1537 a pope's own advisers said the rot began with earlier popes. They blamed a teaching that the pope owns every church post, so he can never be guilty of simony.

But the documents give no numbers: not one says how many priests or bishops were corrupt.

They are laws and complaints, written to stop what was going wrong. Historians who have read the parish records, such as Eamon Duffy on England, found ordinary parish religion far livelier than the complaints suggest.

Follow the trail

Nine documents from the 1090s to the 1560s, every one written by Catholics about their own Church.

c. 1094-1101Historical2 min read

A bishop looks back on a Church for sale

Bruno, bishop of Segni in Italy

Around 1094, Bruno, bishop of Segni in Italy, looked back on the Church of the early 1000s. In a sermon he described it as sold to the highest bidder, with priests openly taking wives.

IWhat was going on

In the 1000s a bishop wasn't only a pastor. He was also a great landowner and often a royal official, so kings and nobles cared a lot about who got the job.

They usually picked bishops themselves, and expected loyalty and money in return. Church posts came with land and income, and they were often bought.

Buying a church post is called simony. The name comes from Simon the magician, in chapter 8 of Acts, a book of the . He offered the , Jesus's first followers, money for their power.

IIWhat was at stake

The Western, Latin-speaking Church required its priests to stay unmarried, but in many places the rule was ignored. Priests married or lived with partners, and their sons often inherited their churches.

If church posts could be bought and handed down in families, who was the Church really serving? Reformers called the whole system a sickness.

IIIWhat happened

In 1049 another Bruno, bishop of Toul, became Pope Leo IX. He travelled across Europe holding councils, meetings of bishops. He removed bishops who had bought their posts and pressed priests to keep their vow not to marry.

His work began what is called the Gregorian reform, named after Gregory VII, one of the popes after him. It led to a long struggle with emperors over who appoints bishops.

IVWhat came of it

About 45 years later, Bishop Bruno of Segni preached a sermon on Leo's feast day, the day the Church remembers him. He described the Church before Leo as utterly corrupt.

He also raised the hard question his own words invited. If almost every priest had bought his post, or been ordained by someone who had, had the priesthood itself failed? He promised a long answer rather than a denial.

VRead the source
The whole world was placed in wickedness, sanctity had failed, justice had perished, and truth lay buried. Iniquity was king, avarice was lord, Simon magus held the Church, bishops and priests were given over to pleasure and fornication.
A Pamphlet on Simoniacs (Libellus de symoniacis) · Libellus de symoniacis, Part I, sermon on Leo IX (trans. W. L. North)

Why it matters

A sermon praising a reformer paints the time before him as dark as it can. So its opening lines are a preacher's exaggeration, not a measurement.

But the problem was real enough for popes, councils and saints to fight it for a century. Much of the record against it comes from the Catholic Church's own reformers.

1215Historical2 min read

A council admits ordinations had a price

The Fourth Lateran Council, under Pope Innocent III

In 1215 the largest of the Middle Ages met in Rome. It admitted that in many places there were fixed fees for making someone a priest or a bishop.

IWhat was going on

Innocent III, pope from 1198 to 1216, led the Catholic Church at the height of its power in Europe. In 1213 he called a council, a gathering of bishops from across the Church.

It was to meet in November 1215 at the Lateran, the pope's cathedral in Rome. He invited all bishops and abbots, the heads of monasteries. In each region only one or two bishops were allowed to stay at home.

He named its aims himself: to root out vices, plant virtues and reform morals.

IIWhat was at stake

A century of reform had not ended simony, the buying and selling of church posts. Making someone a priest, called ordination, is a spiritual act, and so is making a bishop. No one may sell them.

But clergy had to live. Fees and gifts had grown into fixed charges, and some defended them as an old custom.

IIIWhat happened

The council issued 71 canons, or church laws, on everything from confession to church taxes.

Canon 63 said the council knew for certain what was happening in many places. Money was being forced out of people for consecrating bishops, blessing abbots and ordaining clergy, at fixed rates.

It condemned the custom outright. Both the one who paid and the one who took the money shared the guilt of Simon the magician. He was the man in the Bible who tried to buy the apostles' power.

IVWhat came of it

Another admitted that some parish priests were left only a sixteenth of their church's tithes, the tenth of produce owed to the Church. Patrons, who had the right to name the priest, and even bishops kept the rest.

As a result, few such priests had more than a little learning. The same complaints were repeated at later councils for 300 years.

VRead the source
We have learned with certainty that in many places and by many persons exactions and base extortions are made for the consecration of bishops, the blessing of abbots, and the ordination of clerics, and that a tax is fixed as to how much this one or that one is to receive and how much this one or that one is to pay; and what is worse, some endeavor to defend such baseness and depravity by an appeal to a custom of long standing.
Canons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) · Canon 63, On simony (trans. H. J. Schroeder, 1937)

Why it matters

This isn't a critic speaking. It is the Church's own highest council, stating what it knew.

The Catholic Church still teaches that buying or selling spiritual things is a sin. The law was clear. The failure was in keeping it.

1215Historical2 min read

A council bans priests' sons from their fathers' posts

The Fourth Lateran Council

In 1215 the Fourth Lateran Council, meeting in Rome, barred the sons of cathedral priests from taking their fathers' places in the same church. It wouldn't have needed the rule if those priests weren't having sons.

IWhat was going on

Canons were the priests who served a cathedral or a large church. The same word is also used for a church law.

Canons sang the church's daily prayers, managed its lands and lived on its income. The Latin Church, the Western Church under the pope, required them to stay unmarried.

The council's own law on clergy chastity shows the rule was often broken.

IIWhat was at stake

When a canon had a son, the son was often placed in his father's post. The church's lands and income then passed down a family like private property.

That turned a church into a family business, and it made the rule against priests marrying look like it meant nothing.

IIIWhat happened

The council's law on it, Canon 31, called this the worst of corruptions, grown up in many churches. It forbade making the sons of canons, especially those born outside marriage, canons in the churches where their fathers served.

Such appointments were declared invalid, and those who made them were to be suspended from their duties.

The printed English quoted below has lost a word to a scanning error: it should read "that has grown up".

IVWhat came of it

Another law, Canon 14, ordered clergy who broke celibacy, their vow to live unmarried and chaste, to be punished. Anyone who protected them for money was to share the penalty.

It added that clergy in regions where custom let them stay married were to be punished more severely if they sinned, because they could live in marriage lawfully.

VRead the source
To destroy that worst of corruptions that grown up in many churches, we strictly forbid that the sons of canons, especially the illegitimate ones be made canons in the same secular churches in which their fathers have been appointed.
Canons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) · Canon 31 (trans. H. J. Schroeder, 1937)

Why it matters

The council wouldn't make rules about canons' sons born outside marriage unless canons were having them and placing them. A law like this shows the problem it was written to stop.

The Latin Church still requires its priests to be unmarried. , which are in union with the pope but keep Eastern ways, ordain married men. Either way, a church post is not a family inheritance.

c. 1340-1353Historical2 min read

A Catholic poet on the popes' court in France

Petrarch, Italian poet

For most of the 1300s the popes lived at Avignon, in southern France. Petrarch, a famous Italian poet and a Catholic, wrote the best-known complaint against their court.

IWhat was going on

In 1303 Pope Boniface VIII was seized and mistreated by agents of King Philip IV of France. The two had fought for years over the king's power to tax the clergy. Boniface died soon after.

Under French pressure the cardinals, the senior clergy who elect a pope, chose a French archbishop as Clement V in 1305. In 1309 he moved the papal court to Avignon, where it stayed for 67 years.

IIWhat was at stake

Rome held the tomb of Peter, the leader of Jesus's apostles, and the pope is Rome's bishop. A pope living far away, among French officials, looked to many like a pope in the king's pocket.

The court at Avignon also grew large and rich, collecting fees and taxes from across Europe. Was the papacy serving the Church, or itself?

IIIWhat happened

Petrarch, the most famous Italian poet of his day, lived near Avignon for years. In a letter he called it the Babylon of the West, after the Bible's city of exile and corruption.

He compared the poor fishermen of Galilee, Jesus's first followers, with their successors loaded with gold and dressed in purple, living in fortified palaces.

IVWhat came of it

In 1376 Pope Gregory XI left Avignon for Rome, arriving in January 1377. Catherine of Siena, an Italian holy woman now honoured as a saint, was among those who had pressed him to go back.

He died the next year. The election that followed split the Church.

VRead the source
Here reign the successors of the poor fishermen of Galilee; they have strangely forgotten their origin. I am astounded, as I recall their predecessors, to see these men loaded with gold and clad in purple, boasting of the spoils of princes and nations; to see luxurious palaces and heights crowned with fortifications, instead of a boat turned downward for shelter.
Letter Criticizing the Avignon Papacy · Letter criticising the Avignon papacy, in J. H. Robinson, Readings in European History (1904), p. 502

Why it matters

Petrarch's letter is literature, not a witness statement. It names no one and gives no incident. It reaches us in a free translation made for a 1904 book of readings.

What it does show is that a devout Catholic could write this about the pope's court and be widely read.

1378-1417Historical2 min read

Two popes at once, and saints on both sides

The Western Church

In 1378 the cardinals elected a pope in Rome, then turned against him and elected a rival who settled at Avignon. Western Europe was divided for nearly 40 years, and even future saints took opposite sides.

IWhat was going on

When Pope Gregory XI died in Rome in 1378, the cardinals, the senior clergy who elect a pope, chose an Italian, Urban VI. Within months, most of the same cardinals turned against him, saying they had voted out of fear of the Roman mob.

The chapter Bad popes, antipopes and scandals tells the whole story of the split. What matters here is what it did to ordinary Christians.

IIWhat was at stake

On 20 September thirteen cardinals met at Fondi, in Italy, and elected Robert of Geneva. He took the name Clement VII and settled at Avignon, in southern France.

Now there were two popes, each with cardinals and kingdoms behind him. How could an ordinary Christian know which one was real?

IIIWhat happened

Europe split, largely along political lines. Most Italian and German states, England and Flanders backed the pope in Rome. France and its allies backed Avignon.

Saints were divided too. Catherine of Siena backed Urban; Vincent Ferrer, a famous preacher, backed .

In 1409 a council at Pisa tried to end it. It deposed both popes, declaring them removed, and elected a third. That made three.

IVWhat came of it

The split lasted until 1417, when the Council of Constance elected Martin V.

In 1904 the Vatican's yearbook printed a corrected list of popes. It dropped ten names, and no longer counted the Avignon and Pisa popes in the line of Peter.

Today the Catholic Church counts the Roman line as the true one, though no formal teaching of the Church has ever settled it.

This account comes from a Catholic encyclopedia of 1912, not from writers of 1378.

VRead the source
Everywhere the faithful faced the anxious problem: where is the true pope? The saints themselves were divided: St Catherine of Siena, St. Catherine of Sweden, Bl. Peter of Aragon, Bl. Ursulina of Parma, Philippe d'Alencon, and Gerard de Groote were in the camp of Urban; St. Vincent Ferrer, Bl. Peter of Luxemburg, and St. Colette belonged to the party of Clement.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism', section 1

Why it matters

The schism, or split, was fed by politics and pride, not by a dispute about faith. Holy people were sincerely on both sides.

Catholics hold that 's promise to his Church held through it. But the damage to trust in the papacy was deep, and it prepared the ground for the Reformation, the break of the 1500s that produced the Protestant churches.

1415Historical2 min read

A council puts a rival pope on trial

The Council of Constance

In 1415 the Council of Constance, in southern Germany, removed John XXIII, one of three rival claimants to be pope. It called him a notorious simoniac, a man who bought and sold church posts.

IWhat was going on

Christians then owed obedience to three different popes: Gregory XII of the Roman line, Benedict XIII of the Avignon line, and John XXIII of the Pisa line. The council, opened at Constance in 1414, had first to end the split.

The chapter Bad popes, antipopes and scandals tells how it did. What matters here is the charge it brought.

IIWhat was at stake

Who can judge a pope? Normally no one. But with three claimants, someone had to decide.

In April 1415 the council declared that it held its power directly from Christ. Everyone, even a pope, had to obey it on matters of faith, ending the split, and reform.

IIIWhat happened

John XXIII fled the city in March 1415, was brought back and tried. On 29 May the council deposed him, removing him from office. Its sentence called him a notorious simoniac and a destroyer of the goods of the Church.

On 4 July Gregory XII formally called the council himself, and then resigned.

IVWhat came of it

In 1417 the council removed Benedict XIII, and on 11 November it elected Martin V. The split was over.

The same council condemned Jan Hus, a Czech reformer, who had come under the emperor's promise of safe passage. He was burned as a heretic, someone judged to teach against the faith, in July 1415.

In 1999 expressed deep regret for his cruel death.

VRead the source
that the said lord pope John has been and is a notorious simoniac, a notorious destroyer of the goods and rights not only of the Roman church but also of other churches and of many pious places, and an evil administrator and dispenser of the church's spiritualities and temporalities
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Session 12 (29 May 1415), sentence of deposition (Tanner)

Why it matters

Three cautions go with the sentence quoted below. This John XXIII is now counted an antipope, a false claimant, not a pope. The text is a prosecution, a list of charges. And the authority of the council's sessions before 4 July is disputed.

What can't be disputed is this: the bishops of the Western Church were willing to write these words about a man half of Europe had obeyed.

c. 1517Historical2 min read

A friar preaches an indulgence for St Peter's

Johann Tetzel, a Dominican friar

In 1517 a Dominican friar, Johann Tetzel, preached an indulgence in Germany. The money was for the new St Peter's in Rome. His preaching provoked Martin Luther's Ninety-five Theses.

IWhat was going on

An indulgence is a release, granted by the Catholic Church, from punishment still owed for sins that have already been forgiven. It required real sorrow for sin and confession.

Giving alms, gifts to the poor or to a good cause, had long been one of the good works an indulgence could be attached to. That made it easy to turn into a fundraiser.

IIWhat was at stake

Pope Leo X needed money to rebuild St Peter's Basilica, the great church over Peter's tomb in Rome. In 1515 he put Albrecht, archbishop of Mainz and Magdeburg, in charge of the indulgence in one part of Germany.

Albrecht held several bishops' posts at once. He had borrowed heavily from the Fugger bank to pay Rome. A banker's agent held one of the keys to the money chest.

IIIWhat happened

Tetzel's surviving sermon promises complete remission of all sins to those who confess and put alms in the chest, as their confessor advises.

It doesn't contain the famous rhyme about the coin in the chest and the soul springing from purgatory. Purgatory is the cleansing Catholics believe some souls go through after death.

That line is attributed to Tetzel, but it isn't found in anything he is known to have written.

On gifts for the souls of the dead, though, Tetzel did go wrong. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1912 grants that he taught a full indulgence for the dead could be gained by a gift of money alone, without sorrow for sin from the giver, and calls that against Church teaching.

IVWhat came of it

On 31 October 1517 Martin Luther, a friar and professor at Wittenberg, wrote to Albrecht. He protested against the false impression the preaching gave, and sent his Ninety-five Theses, points for debate on indulgences.

Within a few years the argument over indulgences had grown into an argument over faith, grace and the authority of the pope.

VRead the source
You should know that all who confess and in penance put alms into the coffer according to the counsel of the confessor, will obtain complete remission of all their sins. If they visit, after confession and after the Jubilee, the Cross and the altar every day they will receive that indulgence which would be theirs upon visiting in St Peter's the seven altars, where complete indulgence is offered.
Sermon on Indulgences · Sermon on Indulgences, closing section, trans. in Hillerbrand, The Reformation (1964), pp. 41-43

Why it matters

The Catholic Church still grants indulgences, but no longer in exchange for money. In 1563 the Council of Trent, its great reforming council, ordered all evil gains connected with them abolished.

A holy practice was being sold in all but name, and it helped split Western Christianity.

9 March 1537Historical2 min read

The pope's own advisers blame the papacy

Contarini, Carafa, Sadoleto, Pole and five others, for Pope Paul III

In 1537 Pope Paul III asked nine senior churchmen to report on what was wrong with the Church. Their report blamed the papacy first.

IWhat was going on

By 1537 the Reformation, the Protestant break with Rome, had been spreading for 20 years. Lutheran princes ruled much of Germany, and in 1534 England had broken with Rome.

Paul III, pope from 1534, appointed nine churchmen to report on abuses. Gasparo Contarini led them, and they included Gian Pietro Carafa, Jacopo Sadoleto and Reginald Pole.

Four of them were cardinals, the pope's most senior clergy, by the time they signed it.

IIWhat was at stake

Was the trouble just a few bad men? Or was something wrong in the way the Church was run?

A report that blamed the papacy itself would be dangerous to write. It would be read by the pope, and possibly by the Church's enemies.

IIIWhat happened

On 9 March 1537 they read their report to the pope. It is known by its Latin title, Consilium de emendanda ecclesia, 'advice on reforming the Church'.

It traced the trouble to earlier popes, who gathered teachers to tell them what they wanted to hear. Those teachers gave them a bad idea: the pope owns every church post, so he can't be guilty of simony, the sin of selling one.

The report called that idea a Trojan horse, the gift that smuggled the enemy in. Through it, the report said, so many abuses had entered the Church.

They went on to list careless ordinations, bishops living away from their dioceses, and church posts bought and sold.

IVWhat came of it

Paul III accepted the recommendations but didn't act on them at once. The report was confidential, but it was printed without permission in 1538. Luther published a German version with mocking notes in the margins.

In 1545 Paul III opened the Council of Trent, the Catholic Church's great reforming council. Carafa later became Pope Paul IV.

VRead the source
Thence it came about, besides the fact that flattery follows all dominion as the shadow does the body and that truth’s access to the ears of princes has always been most difficult, that teachers at once appeared who taught that the pope is the lord of all benefices and that therefore, since a lord may sell by right what is his own, it necessarily follows that the pope cannot be guilty of simony. Thus the will of the pope, of whatever kind it may be, is the rule governing his activities and deeds: whence it may be shown without doubt that whatever is pleasing is also permitted. From this source as from a Trojan horse so many abuses and such grave diseases have rushed in upon the Church of God
Consilium de emendanda ecclesia (1537), trans. John C. Olin · Consilium de emendanda ecclesia, opening section; Olin trans., Catholic Reform (1990), pp. 65-79, as reprinted on capdox.capuchin.org.au

Why it matters

This is a pope's own commission saying the rot started at the top. Catholics don't have to wait for critics to admit it.

The English quoted below is John Olin's translation, from his 1990 book Catholic Reform.

16 July 1562Historical2 min read

A council scraps the travelling pardoners

The Council of Trent

In 1562 the Council of Trent dealt with the pardoners, travelling collectors who offered indulgences for gifts of money. It didn't try to reform them. It abolished their job altogether.

IWhat was going on

Quaestors of alms, often called pardoners, were licensed to travel and collect money for good causes. In return they offered indulgences, releases from punishment still owed for sins already forgiven.

The Lateran council of 1215 had tried to regulate them, and so had later councils at Lyon and Vienne, in France. None of it worked.

IIWhat was at stake

The Reformers, the leaders of the Protestant break, said indulgences were a racket. The Council of Trent, the Catholic Church's reforming council, had been meeting on and off since 1545. It held that indulgences themselves were good.

So it had to show it could separate the practice from the abuse. Could the Church clean up the trade without denying what it taught?

IIIWhat happened

On 16 July 1562 the council said all earlier remedies had become useless. The abuse grew worse every day, and there was no hope of improvement.

It ordered the name and use of quaestors of alms abolished everywhere.

Bishops were to announce indulgences themselves and collect the alms, taking nothing for it. That way everyone could see these gifts were given not for gain but for godliness.

IVWhat came of it

The next year the council ordered all evil gains from indulgences abolished. It also required bishops to live in their dioceses, and to set up seminaries, colleges to train priests.

In 1967 Pope Paul VI simplified indulgences further and dropped the old counting in days and years.

VRead the source
Whereas many remedies, heretofore applied by divers councils in their day, as well by that of Lateran, and of Lyons, as by that of Vienne, against the wicked abuses of questors of alms, have become in later times useless; yea, rather the depravity of such is, to the great scandal and complaint of all the faithful, found daily so to increase the more, as that there seems to be no longer any hope left of their amendment; (the Synod) ordains that, in all parts of Christendom soever, their name and use be henceforth utterly abolished
Council of Trent, Session XXI (16 July 1562): Decree on Communion under Both Species and Decree on Reformation · Session XXI (16 July 1562), Decree on Reformation, chapter IX (trans. Waterworth, 1848)

Why it matters

This came 45 years after Luther's Ninety-five Theses. The Catholic reform was real, and it was late.

The Catholic Church now teaches that the wrongs of its members were real sins. In 2000 John Paul II led a Day of Pardon, asking forgiveness for the sins of Christians through the centuries.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic reading starts by admitting the facts, because the facts come from Catholic records.

Most of the witnesses on this page are Catholic. Three church councils, meetings of bishops, are among them: Lateran IV, Constance and Lateran V. So are Pope Adrian VI, the pope's commission of 1537 and the Council of Trent.

The charges they bring are heavier and more detailed than most of what outsiders said.

Two exceptions belong with that, and both are noted where the documents appear. wrote the letter of 31 October 1517. Adrian VI's confession is given in the English of a historian of the 1800s.

Catholics say this is still what a living body does: it names its own disease.

Catholics then draw a line. It matters to them, and to others it can look like special pleading.

The charges are about behaviour, appointments and money. They aren't charges about defined teaching of the faith.

Bruno of Segni, an Italian bishop, faced the hardest form of the objection in the 1090s. If nearly every priest had bought his post, had the priesthood itself failed? Was anyone still truly ?

The Catholic answer turns on the , the rites such as through which Catholics believe God acts. They don't depend on the holiness of the man who gives them.

The law followed that answer. In 1418 Pope Martin V barred men ordained through simony, the buying of church posts, from acting as priests. He didn't declare that they weren't priests.

Catholics also point to what the same Church did next. The commission of 1537 was appointed by a pope and wrote for a pope. It told him the fault began with the popes before him.

The Council of Trent, the Catholic Church's great reforming council, abolished the pardoners outright in 1562.

In 1563 it made a bishop's absence from his diocese a mortal sin, a grave sin that breaks a person's friendship with God. It held cardinals to the same rule.

It also set a scale of penalties for clergy living with partners, reaching up to bishops.

The Church that was diagnosed and the Church that wrote the cure were the same Church.

But the rule on bishops living in their dioceses shows the cure wasn't clean. Trent had already made a law on it once, under Paul III in 1547.

The 1563 law exists because the earlier one had been, in the council's own words, 'wrested to a meaning alien from the mind of the sacred and holy Synod, as if by virtue of that decree it were lawful to be absent during five continuous months'.

In other words, bishops had read the first law as permission to stay away five months at a time. Sixteen years separate the two.

Trent also chose not to settle whether God's own law requires a bishop to live in his diocese. So what it produced was church discipline, not .

The weakest point in that account is the timing. Adrian VI's confession is from 1522 or 1523. The commission reported in 1537. The pardoners were abolished in 1562, and the decree on clergy living with partners came in 1563.

All of it came after Luther, and most of it after much of Germany, Scandinavia and England had broken away.

With the documents in hand, a Catholic can say the reform came from inside. It is much harder to say that it came in time.

To be fair, some reform had begun before Luther. In Spain in the 1490s, Francisco Jiménez de Cisneros, archbishop of Toledo, reformed the clergy and the religious orders. But reform hadn't reached Rome.

A reader who concludes that, at the top, the cure came only when not curing had become too costly is reading the dates correctly.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Lutheran readers

Lutherans, the churches that follow Martin Luther, generally say the abuses were the symptoms, not the disease.

Luther's Ninety-five Theses of 1517 give the reason.

'Every truly repentant Christian has a right to full remission of penalty and guilt, even without letters of pardon', and 'The true treasure of the Church is the Most Holy of the glory and the of God'.

On that reading, the trade in grew out of an earlier teaching. It was about merit earned by good works, and satisfaction, making up for sin. It also held that the Church had a store of merit, a treasury, at the pope's disposal.

So abolishing the pardoners in 1562 stopped the trade, but left the teaching that made the trade thinkable.

Lutherans sharpen the point with the Church's own report. The commission of 1537 traced the rot to the claim that the pope owns every church post, and so can't commit simony, the sin of selling one.

Rome later gave up the selling. It didn't give up the claim about papal power that, the commission said, the selling came from.

Reformed readers

Reformed Christians, the Protestant family that includes the Presbyterians, tend to ask what was wrong with the system, more than with people's behaviour.

The Belgic Confession of 1561, one of their statements of faith, sets the rule they read a chapter like this by.

It says: 'nor may we put custom, nor the majority, nor age, nor the passage of times or persons, nor councils, decrees, or official decisions above the truth of God, for truth is above everything else'.

On that reading, councils condemning the same abuses for three and a half centuries is not proof of a Church correcting itself, as Catholics take it. It shows how little the machinery of councils and popes can guarantee on its own.

Reformed readers add a further point. The system could produce rival claimants to be pope, and sell the posts that carry the preaching.

It could also pay for a great church out of people's fear of , the cleansing after death that Catholics teach. A system like that had failed in its offices, whatever faith remained in its people.

Anglican readers

The Church of England gave its formal answer in 1562, while the Council of Trent was still meeting.

Its Articles of Religion are its official statement of belief. Article XXI is about general councils, councils of the whole Church.

It says: 'when they be gathered together, (forasmuch as they be an assembly of men, whereof all be not governed with the Spirit and Word of God,) they may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God'.

That Article is about councils deciding doctrine, not church discipline.

Even so, an Anglican reader will see the record as the same judgement in practice. Councils made laws against the same abuses in 1215, 1418, 1514 and 1562, each admitting that the last attempt had failed.

The same Articles go further on pardons, meaning indulgences. Article XXII calls the Roman teaching on them 'a fond thing vainly invented', where fond means foolish.

Eastern Orthodox readers

The in America, one of the Eastern Orthodox Churches, describes the Western crisis from outside it, in its own history of the period.

'The West in the early decades of the 15th century was in turmoil over the relationship between the Papacy and Church councils. Some held that the Papacy was supreme.

Others held that the authority of the Church councils supersedes that of the Pope of Rome. ... This council, the 16th in the listing of ecumenical councils of the Roman Church, also asserted that even the Pope is to be subject to the dictates of an ecumenical council'.

The phrase to notice is 'of the Roman Church'.

Rome counts Constance among the ecumenical councils, the councils of the whole Church, but the East doesn't. On this reading, the rival popes and the cure of putting a council over the pope are both Western.

Both grew out of how the West had developed the pope's office.

For the Orthodox, the answer to a bishop who goes wrong, even the bishop of Rome, is a council of bishops whose decision the whole Church then receives. Neither a pope above the councils nor a council above the pope is how they see the Church.

What these documents cannot show

The documents above have a limit, and it matters.

Reform laws, satire and reports from the pope's court are evidence for the prosecution. They record what reformers wanted stopped, in reformers' language. They say nothing about everything that was working.

Nothing quoted on this page is a bishop's inspection report, a parish account, a will or a churchwardens' book. Those are the sources that would show what ordinary religion looked like.

Historians who have read them, such as Eamon Duffy on England, found parish religion on the eve of the Reformation far livelier than the complaints suggest.

One historian did make a comparison: Philip Schaff, who wrote as a Protestant, and whose English of Adrian VI is used above.

He wrote that 'the church was more than once in a far worse condition, during the papal in the fourteenth, and especially in the tenth and eleventh centuries; and yet she was reformed by Pope Hildebrand and his successors without a split'.

Hildebrand is Pope Gregory VII, the reformer of the late 1000s. Schaff goes straight on to blame the split of the 1500s on Rome's resistance to reform. So the comparison is his, not a verdict in Rome's favour.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself6
The Church's own paperwork on itself10 steps

Ten passages. Eight are church law from councils, or the report of a commission a pope set up. The ninth is the letter Luther sent with his Theses on 31 October 1517.

The tenth is a pope's own confession. It survives here in the English of a Protestant historian of the 1800s, and its step says so.

Read in order, they make a point no outside critic has to add. The same abuses are condemned in almost the same words across three and a half centuries. That is also the record of the condemnations not working.

  1. Pluralism banned, with a door left open

    1215

    In 1215 the Fourth Lateran Council renewed an older ban on one man holding several benefices, church posts that came with an income. In the same law it admitted the old ban had produced 'little or no fruit'.

    Then it kept back a power to make exceptions. That power is how one man could later hold two great bishoprics at once.

    Luther's letter of 1517 shows it. He writes to one man as archbishop of both Mainz and Magdeburg.

    “Only in the case of eminent and learned persons who are to be honored with major benefices, can the Apostolic See, if need be, grant a dispensation.”
    HistoricalCanons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215)Canon 29, on multiple benefices (trans. Schroeder)The evidence ↓
  2. Concubinage, and the superiors who were paid to permit it

    1215

    The council's Canon 14 punishes clergy who broke their vow to live unmarried and chaste. Then it punishes the senior clergy who protected them for money.

    A council doesn't outlaw being paid to look away unless someone was being paid to look away.

    The same law admits that in some regions clergy had never given up marriage at all.

    “Prelates who dare support such in their iniquities, especially in view of money or other temporal advantages, shall be subject to a like punishment.”
    HistoricalCanons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215)Canon 14, on clerical incontinence (trans. Schroeder)The evidence ↓
  3. Indulgences capped, three centuries before Tetzel

    1215

    An indulgence is a release from punishment still owed for sins already forgiven. The abuse Luther protested against in 1517 is already described in church law in 1215.

    The same law, Canon 62, makes alms collectors carry genuine letters, because some were passing themselves off as something they weren't.

    Notice what the law doesn't do. It doesn't condemn indulgences. It condemns handing out too many, too generously.

    “Since, through indiscreet and superfluous indulgences which some prelates of churches do not hesitate to grant, contempt is brought on the keys of the Church, and the penitential discipline is weakened, we decree that on the occasion of the dedication of a church an indulgence of not more than one year be granted”
    HistoricalCanons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215)Canon 62, final section (trans. Schroeder)The evidence ↓
  4. A council claims authority over the pope

    6 April 1415

    The decree known as Haec sancta, from its first Latin words, is the most argued-over thing left behind by the years of rival popes.

    In it the Council of Constance declares that a general council, a council of the whole Church, gets its power directly from Christ. Everyone must obey it, even a pope, in matters of faith, ending the split, and reform.

    This sitting of the council came before Gregory XII formally called the council in July 1415. Whether the sessions before Martin V's election count as acts of the whole Church is disputed.

    The common Catholic view is that these early sessions don't count. Catholics read the First Vatican Council's later teaching on the pope's authority as settling the question the other way. Among Catholics the decree is still disputed.

    “First it declares that, legitimately assembled in the holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the catholic church militant, it has power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it in those matters which pertain to the faith, the eradication of the said schism and the general reform of the said church of God in head and members.”
    HistoricalCouncil of Constance (1414–1418), decreesSession 5 (6 April 1415), decree Haec sancta (Tanner)The evidence ↓
  5. A pope states that the law has failed

    21 March 1418

    Martin V, elected in 1417 to end the years of rival popes, made a law against simony, the buying and selling of church posts, with the council's approval.

    The first sentence is the admission, and a pope makes it, not a critic. The penalties that follow are aimed at popes and cardinals, naming those ranks outright.

    This sitting came after Martin V's election, so no one disputes its authority.

    “Many constitutions have been issued in the past against the evil of simony, but they have not been able to eradicate the disease.”
    HistoricalCouncil of Constance (1414–1418), decreesSession 43 (21 March 1418), decree On simoniacs (Tanner)The evidence ↓
  6. Three years before the Theses, a pope describes a breakdown

    5 May 1514

    Pope Leo X opened the Fifth Lateran Council's reform decree with a warning. Discipline, he said, was decaying through almost every rank of the faithful. Left uncorrected, it would end in collapse.

    Talk of decline is normal in reform laws, and it isn't a count of anything. What stands out is the date: three years before Luther's Theses.

    “When we notice, out of solicitude for our said pastoral office, that church discipline and the pattern of a sound and upright life are worsening, disappearing and going further astray from the right path throughout almost all the ranks of Christ's faithful, with a disregard for law and with exemption from punishment, as a result of the troubles of the times and the malice of human beings, it must be feared that, unless checked by a well-guided improvement, there will be a daily falling into a variety of faults under the security of sin and soon, with the appearance of public scandals, a complete breakdown.”
    HistoricalFifth Lateran Council (1512-1517), decreesSession 9 (5 May 1514), bull on reform of the curia, opening (Tanner)The evidence ↓
  7. Where the council looked first for simony

    5 May 1514

    This law names the curia, the pope's own court and offices in Rome, first. The rest of the Christian world comes second. That order is itself the evidence.

    Earlier, in its second session, the same council had renewed a law declaring a papal election void if it was bought. That law exists because the danger was real.

    “So that the stain and disease of abominable simony may be driven out for ever not only from the Roman curia but also from all christian rule, we renew the constitutions issued by our predecessors, also in sacred councils, against simoniacs of this kind, and we prescribe that they be observed unaltered.”
    HistoricalFifth Lateran Council (1512-1517), decreesSession 9 (5 May 1514), clause renewing the constitutions against simony (Tanner)The evidence ↓
  8. The indulgence that was building St Peter's

    31 October 1517

    Luther sent this letter with his Ninety-five Theses. It names the indulgence campaign and its purpose without arguing for either, because no one disputed them.

    The letter is also more careful than the story told later. Luther says he isn't accusing the preachers, whom he had not heard. He is describing what ordinary people had come to believe.

    So it is second-hand evidence of what people believed, not a record of what was preached.

    “Papal indulgences for the building of St. Peter's are circulating under your most distinguished name, and as regards them, I do not bring accusation against the outcries of the preachers, which I have not heard, so much as I grieve over the wholly false impressions which the people have conceived from them; to wit, -- the unhappy souls believe that if they have purchased letters of indulgence they are sure of their salvation; again, that so soon as they cast their contributions into the money-box, souls fly out of purgatory”
    HistoricalLetter to Albrecht, Archbishop of Mainz (on indulgences)Letter to Albrecht of Mainz, 31 October 1517, paragraph 2 (Holman trans., 1915)The evidence ↓
  9. A pope's confession, at third hand

    1522 or 1523

    Pope Adrian VI sent this to his envoy, his legate, at Nuremberg. The German princes were meeting there in an assembly called a Diet.

    It reaches us through a long chain. It began as a Latin instruction, dated to 1522 or 1523. A chronicler of the 1600s printed it.

    A Protestant historian of the 1800s translated it, under the heading of the Diets of Nuremberg, 1522 to 1524.

    The document itself isn't in doubt, because Luther reprinted it with mocking notes in the margins. But the English below hasn't been checked against the Latin.

    The same historian records the Catholic reply: later Catholic writers charged Adrian with exaggerating.

    “that for some time many abominations, abuses in ecclesiastical affairs, and violations of rights have taken place in the holy see; and that all things have been perverted into bad. From the head the corruption has passed to the limbs, from the Pope to the prelates: we have all departed; there is none that doeth good, no, not one.”
    HistoricalHistory of the Christian Church, Volume VII: Modern Christianity - The German ReformationPhilip Schaff, History of the Christian Church VII, section 69, quoting Adrian VI's instruction to Francesco ChieregatiThe evidence ↓
  10. The commission on who was being ordained

    9 March 1537

    The first abuse named in this part of the 1537 report isn't money. It is ordaining men as priests without anyone examining them.

    The words 'in this respect' mark it as first within its own section, not first in the document. The report opens instead with the point about church posts, quoted higher up this page.

    The phrase about men of the vilest stock is the snobbery of a commission of aristocratic churchmen. Read it as that, not as a neutral description.

    “The first abuse in this respect is the ordination of clerics and especially of priests in which no care is taken, no diligence employed, so that indiscriminately the most unskilled, men of the vilest stock and of evil morals, adolescents, are admitted to Holy Orders and to the priesthood”
    HistoricalConsilium de emendanda ecclesia (1537), trans. John C. OlinConsilium de emendanda ecclesia, on the first abuse, the ordination of clerics; Olin trans. (1990)The evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on8 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Simony, the buying and selling of ordination, consecration and church office, was condemned by name in Catholic conciliar legislation from the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 to the Fifth Lateran Council in 1514, and each renewal of the law states that the previous legislation had failed.

Rests on
  • Libellus de symoniacis, Part I, sermon on Leo IX (trans. W. L. North, from MGH Libelli de Lite II)
    “But what is even worse than all this - hardly anyone was found who either was not a symoniac [himself] or had not been ordained by symoniacs.”
  • Canon 63, On simony (trans. H. J. Schroeder, 1937)
    “We have learned with certainty that in many places and by many persons exactions and base extortions are made for the consecration of bishops, the blessing of abbots, and the ordination of clerics, and that a tax is fixed as to how much this one or …”
    Read the full passage
    “We have learned with certainty that in many places and by many persons exactions and base extortions are made for the consecration of bishops, the blessing of abbots, and the ordination of clerics, and that a tax is fixed as to how much this one or that one is to receive and how much this one or that one is to pay; and what is worse, some endeavor to defend such baseness and depravity by an appeal to a custom of long standing.”
  • Session 43 (21 March 1418), decree On simoniacs, issued by Martin V with the approval of the council (Tanner)
    “Many constitutions have been issued in the past against the evil of simony, but they have not been able to eradicate the disease.”
  • Session 9 (5 May 1514), clause renewing the constitutions against simony (Tanner)
    “So that the stain and disease of abominable simony may be driven out for ever not only from the Roman curia but also from all christian rule, we renew the constitutions issued by our predecessors, also in sacred councils, against simoniacs of this kind, and we prescribe that they be observed unaltered.”
  • Session 9 (5 May 1514), bull on reform of the curia, opening paragraph (Tanner)
    “When we notice, out of solicitude for our said pastoral office, that church discipline and the pattern of a sound and upright life are worsening, disappearing and going further astray from the right path throughout almost all the ranks of Christ's …”
    Read the full passage
    “When we notice, out of solicitude for our said pastoral office, that church discipline and the pattern of a sound and upright life are worsening, disappearing and going further astray from the right path throughout almost all the ranks of Christ's faithful, with a disregard for law and with exemption from punishment, as a result of the troubles of the times and the malice of human beings, it must be feared that, unless checked by a well-guided improvement, there will be a daily falling into a variety of faults under the security of sin and soon, with the appearance of public scandals, a complete breakdown.”
Other readings
  • A Catholic reading takes repeated condemnation as evidence of a conscience at work: the abuse is named, legislated against and eventually stopped, and the naming is done by the Church itself rather than by its opponents.
  • A Lutheran or Reformed reading takes the same sequence as evidence that the institution could not correct itself, since three and a half centuries of law produced further law rather than enforcement, and enforcement came only after large parts of Europe had left.
  • A caution this site records on its own account, and not on any historian's: renewal clauses are a standard formula in canonical legislation, so a council conceding that earlier legislation had failed is in part following a convention, and the concession cannot by itself be read as a measured finding about how far the law was being obeyed. No study of canonical drafting was consulted for this chapter.
Limits
  • None of these texts gives a proportion. Lateran IV says only 'many places and by many persons'.
  • Bruno of Segni is a Gregorian reform partisan writing a festal sermon in praise of Leo IX around 1094-1101 about the Church of the 1040s, roughly forty-five to fifty years after the events, and his opening is rhetoric rather than measurement.
  • The Fordham electronic text of Lateran IV carries scanning typos elsewhere in the same document, and Schroeder's 1937 translation is standard but not a critical edition.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Clerical concubinage was widespread enough that Catholic councils legislated against superiors who tolerated it, against the defence that it had become customary, and against the placing of clerics' sons in their fathers' churches, from 1215 through 1514 to 1563.

Rests on
  • Canon 14, on clerical incontinence (trans. Schroeder)
    “Prelates who dare support such in their iniquities, especially in view of money or other temporal advantages, shall be subject to a like punishment.”
  • Canon 31 (trans. Schroeder)
    “To destroy that worst of corruptions that grown up in many churches, we strictly forbid that the sons of canons, especially the illegitimate ones be made canons in the same secular churches in which their fathers have been appointed.”
  • Session 9 (5 May 1514), clause on continence and concubinage (Tanner)
    “Concubinage is not to be allowed by the tolerance of superiors, or as an evil custom of a great number of sinners, which should rather be called a corruption, or under any other excuse”
  • Session XXV (3-4 December 1563), Decree on Reformation, chapter XIV (trans. Waterworth, 1848)
    “the holy Synod forbids all clerics whatsoever to dare to keep concubines, or any other woman of whom any suspicion can exist, either in their own houses, or elsewhere, or to presume to have any intercourse with them”
Other readings
  • A Catholic reading notes that Lateran IV's canon 14 itself concedes that in some regions clerics had not renounced marriage at all, so part of what the law is suppressing is a surviving local discipline rather than simple vice.
  • The obvious reply from the other side is that mandatory clerical celibacy was the cause rather than the cure, and that the legislation documents the failure of the requirement itself. No text making that argument was retrieved for this chapter, so it is recorded here as the argument the canons invite rather than attributed to any named tradition.
Limits
  • The canons say 'many churches' and 'a great number of sinners' and give no figure. No proportion of the clergy can be derived from them.
  • Canon 31 is evidence by implication rather than by statement: it presupposes that canons had sons and that those sons were being placed, and does not say how often.
  • The Fordham text of canon 31 reads 'that grown up', a scanning error for 'that has grown up', reproduced here exactly.
  • Three hundred and forty-eight years separate Lateran IV's canon from Trent's penal scale, and Lateran V in 1514 is still legislating against superiors who permitted the practice.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Much of the record of medieval ecclesiastical corruption comes from Catholic sources condemning it, as the 1910 Catholic Encyclopedia itself says of indulgences. That makes the record real and self-accusing but also prosecutorial: the documents used in this chapter state no proportions, and none of them is parish-level evidence of what ordinary religion looked like.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Indulgences', section 'Abuses'
    “On the other hand, it should not be forgotten that the Church, while holding fast to the principle and intrinsic value of indulgences, has repeatedly condemned their misuse: in fact, it is often from the severity of her condemnation that we learn how grave the abuses were.”
  • Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church VII, §69, 'The Diets of Nürnberg, a.d. 1522-1524. Adrian VI.', quoting Adrian VI's instruction to Francesco Chieregati, 1522
    “that for some time many abominations, abuses in ecclesiastical affairs, and violations of rights have taken place in the holy see; and that all things have been perverted into bad. From the head the corruption has passed to the limbs, from the Pope to the prelates: we have all departed; there is none that doeth good, no, not one.”
  • Letter criticising the Avignon papacy, in J. H. Robinson, Readings in European History (1904), p. 502
    “Here reign the successors of the poor fishermen of Galilee; they have strangely forgotten their origin.”
  • Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church VII, §3, 'Necessity of a Reformation'
    “the church was more than once in a far worse condition, during the papal schism in the fourteenth, and especially in the tenth and eleventh centuries; and yet she was reformed by Pope Hildebrand and his successors without a split”
Other readings
  • The Catholic apologetic reading, stated openly in the 1910 encyclopedia article, is that severe and repeated condemnation is a sign of a healthy conscience rather than of a diseased body.
  • The critical reply is that condemnation repeated across three and a half centuries, each time conceding that the last attempt failed, proves the opposite of what the apologist wants it to prove.
  • The methodological reply, which this site makes on its own account and not on anyone else's, is that reform legislation describes what reformers wanted stopped and is structurally silent about ordinary practice that was working, so the same documents support a much less lurid picture than the polemical tradition built from them. No historian of late medieval religion was consulted for this chapter, and the objection is not attributed to any.
Limits
  • Every source in this chapter is legislation, polemic or a reform memorandum. None is a visitation return, a parish register, a will or a churchwardens' account.
  • No document states a proportion. Lateran IV says 'many places and by many persons' and Lateran V says 'a great number of sinners'.
  • The Adrian VI quotation is at third hand: a Latin instruction of 1522, printed by the seventeenth-century annalist Raynaldus, translated by a nineteenth-century Reformed historian. The Latin was not consulted, and the same historian records the Jesuit Pallavicino's charge that Adrian exaggerated.
  • Petrarch's letter, headed on the Sourcebook page only as a letter to a friend of 1340-1353, is polemical literature in a free 1904 translation made for a popular anthology, with no manuscript or critical edition given. It shows what was being said, not what was true.
  • The 1910 encyclopedia article is apologetic in purpose and is a reference work rather than a primary source.
  • The medieval Church was not uniquely bad by the standards of its own history. Philip Schaff, writing as a Protestant, judged conditions during the fourteenth-century papal schism, and especially in the tenth and eleventh centuries, worse, and reform then followed without a split. He goes straight on to blame the sixteenth-century split on Rome's resistance to reform, so the comparison is his, not a verdict in Rome's favour.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

04HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

Between 1378 and 1417 the Latin Church was divided between rival claimants to the papacy, with canonised saints supporting opposing claimants, and the council that ended the division formally deposed one claimant as a notorious simoniac.

Rests on
  • Session 12 (29 May 1415), sentence deposing John XXIII (Tanner)
    “that the said lord pope John has been and is a notorious simoniac, a notorious destroyer of the goods and rights not only of the Roman church but also of other churches and of many pious places, and an evil administrator and dispenser of the church's spiritualities and temporalities”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism', section 1
    “Everywhere the faithful faced the anxious problem: where is the true pope? The saints themselves were divided: St Catherine of Siena, St. Catherine of Sweden, Bl. Peter of Aragon, Bl. Ursulina of Parma, Philippe d'Alencon, and Gerard de Groote were …”
    Read the full passage
    “Everywhere the faithful faced the anxious problem: where is the true pope? The saints themselves were divided: St Catherine of Siena, St. Catherine of Sweden, Bl. Peter of Aragon, Bl. Ursulina of Parma, Philippe d'Alencon, and Gerard de Groote were in the camp of Urban; St. Vincent Ferrer, Bl. Peter of Luxemburg, and St. Colette belonged to the party of Clement.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism', section 4, on the corrected list of popes published in 1904
    “Ten names have disappeared from this list of legitimate popes, neither the popes of Avignon nor those of Pisa being ranked in the true lineage of St. Peter.”
Other readings
  • Catholic accounts stress that the division was juridical and personal rather than doctrinal: no claimant taught a different faith, and the Church's unity in belief survived a forty-year confusion about who held the office.
  • Orthodox accounts read the episode as the predictable cost of concentrating jurisdiction in a single see, since no comparable crisis can arise where authority is conciliar.
  • Reformation-era accounts read it as proof that the visible succession could not by itself guarantee the Church, since for forty years nobody could say with certainty who stood in it.
Limits
  • No document from 1378 was consulted for this chapter. The cardinals' repudiation of Urban VI and the election at Fondi were not retrieved, so the origin of the schism rests here on later testimony.
  • The Council of Constance is an interested party, sitting thirty-seven to forty years after the events it was resolving.
  • The sentence of deposition is a prosecution document drafted by the winning side; it recites charges rather than proving them.
  • The man deposed, Baldassare Cossa, is counted an antipope on the modern official list, so the council deposed a claimant rather than a pope.
  • The list of divided saints is the Catholic Encyclopedia's own compilation, made in 1912, and is not a contemporary record.
  • The third line of claimants, the popes of Pisa, is named on this page only from the same 1912 article. No document of the Pisan election was retrieved, and no year for it is stated anywhere in this chapter.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Indulgence preaching was tied to the building of the new St Peter's in 1517, and the abuse of licensed alms-collectors was old enough by then that a council had capped indulgences in 1215; Trent abolished the office of quaestor outright in 1562 and condemned the money-gathering in 1563 while affirming the doctrine.

Rests on
  • Canon 62, final section, on indiscreet indulgences (trans. Schroeder)
    “Since, through indiscreet and superfluous indulgences which some prelates of churches do not hesitate to grant, contempt is brought on the keys of the Church, and the penitential discipline is weakened, we decree that on the occasion of the dedication of a church an indulgence of not more than one year be granted”
  • Sermon on Indulgences, closing section, trans. in Hillerbrand, The Reformation (1964), pp. 41-43
    “You should know that all who confess and in penance put alms into the coffer according to the counsel of the confessor, will obtain complete remission of all their sins. If they visit, after confession and after the Jubilee, the Cross and the altar …”
    Read the full passage
    “You should know that all who confess and in penance put alms into the coffer according to the counsel of the confessor, will obtain complete remission of all their sins. If they visit, after confession and after the Jubilee, the Cross and the altar every day they will receive that indulgence which would be theirs upon visiting in St Peter's the seven altars, where complete indulgence is offered.”
  • Letter to Albrecht of Mainz, 31 October 1517, paragraph 2 (Holman trans., 1915)
    “Papal indulgences for the building of St. Peter's are circulating under your most distinguished name, and as regards them, I do not bring accusation against the outcries of the preachers, which I have not heard, so much as I grieve over the wholly false impressions which the people have conceived from them”
  • Letter to Albrecht of Mainz, 31 October 1517, paragraph 5, on the Instruction to the Commissaries (Holman trans., 1915)
    “Again, it is said that contrition is not necessary in those who purchase souls [out of purgatory] or buy confessionalia.”
  • Session XXI (16 July 1562), Decree on Reformation, chapter IX (trans. Waterworth, 1848)
    “Whereas many remedies, heretofore applied by divers councils in their day, as well by that of Lateran, and of Lyons, as by that of Vienne, against the wicked abuses of questors of alms, have become in later times useless; yea, rather the depravity …”
    Read the full passage
    “Whereas many remedies, heretofore applied by divers councils in their day, as well by that of Lateran, and of Lyons, as by that of Vienne, against the wicked abuses of questors of alms, have become in later times useless; yea, rather the depravity of such is, to the great scandal and complaint of all the faithful, found daily so to increase the more, as that there seems to be no longer any hope left of their amendment”
  • Session XXV (3-4 December 1563), Decree concerning Indulgences (trans. Waterworth, 1848)
    “And being desirous that the abuses which have crept therein, and by occasion of which this honourable name of Indulgences is blasphemed by heretics, be amended and corrected, It ordains generally by this decree, that all evil gains for the obtaining …”
    Read the full passage
    “And being desirous that the abuses which have crept therein, and by occasion of which this honourable name of Indulgences is blasphemed by heretics, be amended and corrected, It ordains generally by this decree, that all evil gains for the obtaining thereof,--whence a most prolific cause of abuses amongst the Christian people has been derived,--be wholly abolished.”
  • Thesis 36 (Spaeth, Reed and Jacobs, Works of Martin Luther, vol. 1, Holman, 1915)
    “Every truly repentant Christian has a right to full remission of penalty and guilt, even without letters of pardon.”
  • Thesis 62 (Holman, 1915)
    “The true treasure of the Church is the Most Holy Gospel of the glory and the grace of God.”
Other readings
  • The Catholic reading distinguishes the doctrine from the traffic: the same decree of 1563 that abolishes the evil gains anathematises anyone who says indulgences are useless or that the Church has no power to grant them, and Pius V went further in 1567 by cancelling indulgences involving fees.
  • The Lutheran reading is that the traffic followed from the doctrine, so that removing the collectors while keeping the treasury of merit at the pope's disposal treated the symptom. The two theses of 1517 quoted in this claim are the form in which Luther put it: full remission belongs to the repentant without letters of pardon, and the treasure of the Church is the Gospel.
  • A further line of argument, often met but not evidenced here, is that the campaign of 1517 was as much a German fiscal transaction as a Roman one. The documents behind that arrangement are not among the sources used in this chapter, so it is recorded as an argument this chapter cannot support rather than as a reading it reports.
Limits
  • The rhyme about a coin in the coffer does not appear in Tetzel's surviving sermon. It is attributed to him, not attested.
  • Luther states in the same letter that he had not heard the preachers and is reporting what people believed, so his evidence is about popular belief rather than about what was preached.
  • Albert of Mainz's Instructio summaria was not retrieved, so nothing can be asserted about its actual wording; Luther himself says the Instruction went out under Albert's name 'doubtless without your knowledge and consent'.
  • No document used here evidences the financial arrangement behind the campaign, including the division of the proceeds and the banking debt often described in popular accounts.
  • The Tetzel text was reached through an Internet Archive capture, is a 1964 English translation of a Latin original, and the manuscript or first printing behind it was not verified.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The reform commission appointed by Paul III, nine churchmen headed by Gasparo Contarini, presented its report to him on 9 March 1537. It traced the abuses to a doctrine of papal power: teachers who said the pope is lord of all benefices, and therefore cannot be guilty of simony in selling them.

Rests on
  • Consilium de emendanda ecclesia, opening section; Olin trans., Catholic Reform (1990), pp. 65-79, as reprinted on capdox.capuchin.org.au
    “Thence it came about, besides the fact that flattery follows all dominion as the shadow does the body and that truth’s access to the ears of princes has always been most difficult, that teachers at once appeared who taught that the pope is the lord …”
    Read the full passage
    “Thence it came about, besides the fact that flattery follows all dominion as the shadow does the body and that truth’s access to the ears of princes has always been most difficult, that teachers at once appeared who taught that the pope is the lord of all benefices and that therefore, since a lord may sell by right what is his own, it necessarily follows that the pope cannot be guilty of simony. Thus the will of the pope, of whatever kind it may be, is the rule governing his activities and deeds: whence it may be shown without doubt that whatever is pleasing is also permitted. From this source as from a Trojan horse so many abuses and such grave diseases have rushed in upon the Church of God”
  • Consilium de emendanda ecclesia, on the first abuse, the ordination of clerics; Olin trans. (1990)
    “The first abuse in this respect is the ordination of clerics and especially of priests in which no care is taken, no diligence employed, so that indiscriminately the most unskilled, men of the vilest stock and of evil morals, adolescents, are admitted to Holy Orders and to the priesthood”
  • Ming Yin, Trans/Form/Acao 46:3 (2023), section 1, on the presentation of the report
    “On March 9, 1537, nine clerics headed by Gasparo Contarini presented their jointly drafted reform plan to Pope Paul III, which ushered in the reform of the Holy See.”
  • Opening paragraphs, independent translation by Nicholas Salazar, ed. Stuart Chessman (2017)
    “the experts who were instructing the Pontiff immediately proclaimed that he was the lord of all benefices. Therefore when, as lord, he lawfully sells that which is his own, it necessarily follows that the Pontiff cannot be charged with simony.”
  • Latin printing of 1538 (Rome, Antonio Blado), digitised by the Internet Archive
Other readings
  • The Catholic reading is that the commission attacked a juridical theory about benefices held by curial canonists, not a defined dogma, and that the correction of the theory is itself evidence of the Church's capacity to correct itself.
  • The Lutheran and Reformed reading is that the theory was the practical form of papal plenitude of power, that Rome abandoned the sale without abandoning the underlying claim, and that the commission therefore diagnosed more than it was willing to cure.
  • A third reading, recorded here as this site's own and not credited to any scholar, is that the Consilium is first of all a curial document of the reforming party, written to strengthen Contarini's hand before a council, and is therefore advocacy as well as diagnosis. No study of the Consilium beyond the 2023 article quoted above was consulted for this chapter.
Limits
  • The English is John C. Olin's translation as reprinted on the Capuchin Friars of Australia's site from his Catholic Reform (Fordham, 1990), pp. 65-79; the printed book was not seen. Ming Yin's 2023 article quotes the same translation from Olin's 1969 Catholic Reformation (pp. 185 and 188) with small differences of capitals and commas, which supports the reprint's wording.
  • The corroborating translation is an unpublished rendering by a private individual which its blog editor states he tweaked, and it settles nothing on its own. It is used only to show that two unrelated translations agree on the sense.
  • The Latin printing of 1538 is available only as unreliable optical character recognition using the long s, so no Latin wording is quoted here.
  • The Consilium is an advisory memorandum to a pope, not a magisterial act, and it describes the Roman Curia. It cannot establish how far the same abuses ran outside Rome.
  • The phrase about men of the vilest stock is the social prejudice of a commission of aristocratic churchmen and should not be read as neutral description.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Holding several benefices at once and drawing the income of a diocese without living in it were persistent abuses which the Church's own law both condemned and, by reserving a power of dispensation to the Apostolic See, made possible; Trent finally declared a bishop's absence a mortal sin in 1563.

Rests on
  • Canon 29, on multiple benefices (trans. Schroeder)
    “Only in the case of eminent and learned persons who are to be honored with major benefices, can the Apostolic See, if need be, grant a dispensation.”
  • Canon 29, on the failure of the Third Lateran ban and the remedy substituted for it (trans. Schroeder)
    “But since, on account of the boldness and avarice of some, the aforesaid statute has thus far produced little or no fruit, we, wishing to meet the situation more clearly and emphatically, declare in the present decree that whoever shall accept a …”
    Read the full passage
    “But since, on account of the boldness and avarice of some, the aforesaid statute has thus far produced little or no fruit, we, wishing to meet the situation more clearly and emphatically, declare in the present decree that whoever shall accept a benefice to which is annexed the cura animamm after having previously obtained such a benefice, shall ipso jure be deprived of this (the first one)”
  • Session XXIII (15 July 1563), Decree on Reformation, chapter I (trans. Waterworth, 1848)
    “But if any one, which it is hoped will never happen, shall be absent, contrary to the regulation of this decree, the sacred and holy Synod ordains, that, in addition to the other penalties imposed upon and renewed against non-residents, under Paul …”
    Read the full passage
    “But if any one, which it is hoped will never happen, shall be absent, contrary to the regulation of this decree, the sacred and holy Synod ordains, that, in addition to the other penalties imposed upon and renewed against non-residents, under Paul III., and the guilt of mortal sin which such an one incurs, he acquires no property in any fruits, in proportion to the time of his absence”
  • Session XXIII (15 July 1563), Decree on Reformation, chapter I, on the earlier residence decree of Session VI (1547)
    “wrested to a meaning alien from the mind of the sacred and holy Synod, as if by virtue of that decree it were lawful to be absent during five continuous months”
Other readings
  • A Catholic reading points out that the dispensation clause is a law about exceptions, and that the abuse lay in how freely the exception was granted rather than in the principle that a universal law can be dispensed.
  • A Reformation-era and modern critical reading treats the dispensing power itself as the abuse, since the same authority that forbade pluralism sold and granted the exemptions from its own prohibition.
Limits
  • The two standard translations of canon 29 disagree on a figure, Schroeder reading 'beyond a period of six months' and Tanner 'beyond three months', so no number from this canon should be quoted without checking the Latin.
  • The Fordham text of canon 29 reads 'cura animamm', a scanning error for cura animarum, reproduced here exactly.
  • No document quoted here counts pluralists or absentees. The claim is about what the law says and admits, not about scale.
  • Trent had to legislate on residence twice, in 1547 and again in 1563, because bishops had read the earlier decree as a licence to be absent for five months; and it declined to settle whether residence binds bishops by divine law, so the decree stands as discipline rather than doctrine.
  • The best-known individual case, one man holding Mainz and Magdeburg together in 1517, is evidenced here only by the address of Luther's letter, not by any papal dispensation document, which was not retrieved.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

08HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

Which line of claimants was the legitimate papal line between 1378 and 1417 has never been settled by a magisterial definition, and the Council of Constance's declaration that a general council holds power immediately from Christ and binds even a pope remains disputed among Catholics.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism', section 4, on the 1904 revision of the official list of popes
    “Ten names have disappeared from this list of legitimate popes, neither the popes of Avignon nor those of Pisa being ranked in the true lineage of St. Peter.”
  • Session 5 (6 April 1415), decree Haec sancta (Tanner)
    “First it declares that, legitimately assembled in the holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the catholic church militant, it has power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is …”
    Read the full passage
    “First it declares that, legitimately assembled in the holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the catholic church militant, it has power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it in those matters which pertain to the faith, the eradication of the said schism and the general reform of the said church of God in head and members.”
  • Editorial introduction to the council in Tanner's edition, reproduced at papalencyclicals.net, paragraph beginning "With regard to the ecumenical nature"
    “With regard to the ecumenical nature of the sessions, there is dispute about those before the election of Martin V and also about the significance and force of the approval which he gave to the matters transacted by the council.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance', on the papal approval of the council
    “In particular the famous five articles of the fifth session, establishing the supremacy of the council, never received papal confirmation”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapters 3 and 4 (1870)
  • The Orthodox Faith, Volume III, Church History, fifteenth century: the great schism in the papacy and the conciliar movement
    “The West in the early decades of the 15th century was in turmoil over the relationship between the Papacy and Church councils. Some held that the Papacy was supreme. Others held that the authority of the Church councils supersedes that of the Pope …”
    Read the full passage
    “The West in the early decades of the 15th century was in turmoil over the relationship between the Papacy and Church councils. Some held that the Papacy was supreme. Others held that the authority of the Church councils supersedes that of the Pope of Rome. ... This council, the 16th in the listing of ecumenical councils of the Roman Church, also asserted that even the Pope is to be subject to the dictates of an ecumenical council”
  • Article XXI, Of the Authority of General Councils (1562)
    “And when they be gathered together, (forasmuch as they be an assembly of men, whereof all be not governed with the Spirit and Word of God,) they may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God. Wherefore things ordained by them …”
    Read the full passage
    “And when they be gathered together, (forasmuch as they be an assembly of men, whereof all be not governed with the Spirit and Word of God,) they may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God. Wherefore things ordained by them as necessary to salvation have neither strength nor authority, unless it may be declared that they be taken out of holy Scripture.”
  • Article 7, The Sufficiency of Scripture
    “nor may we put custom, nor the majority, nor age, nor the passage of times or persons, nor councils, decrees, or official decisions above the truth of God, for truth is above everything else.”
Other readings
  • The common Catholic position is that Haec sancta belongs to the sessions before Gregory XII convoked the council on 4 July 1415, that those sessions are not ecumenical acts, and that Martin V's later approval did not extend to them; Vatican I's definition of papal primacy is read as settling the question in the other direction.
  • A conciliarist reading holds that Haec sancta was the legal basis on which the schism was actually ended, so that the council which produced the pope everyone accepts also produced the decree most Catholics now decline to accept. The introduction to Tanner's edition goes part of the way: it says the decrees were made to heal the schism, "and this could only be done by the authority of a council".
  • Orthodox readers cite the conciliar principle as closer to the Church's ancient practice than the definition of 1870, while declining to treat Constance itself as ecumenical. The Orthodox catechetical history quoted in this claim shows the distinction being drawn in exactly those terms, numbering Constance sixteenth 'in the listing of ecumenical councils of the Roman Church'.
  • The Gerarchia Cattolica of 1904 is an annual directory rather than a doctrinal act, so its revised list records a considered judgment and not a definition.
  • The Anglican and Reformed confessions quoted here answer the prior question rather than this one. Article XXI of 1562 holds that general councils are assemblies of men and may err, and Belgic Article 7 of 1561 holds that no council or decree stands above the truth of God. Neither text mentions Constance or the schism, and neither is evidence about 1378 to 1417; they are cited to show what the two traditions formally hold about conciliar authority, which is the ground on which they read this chapter.
Limits
  • The author of the 1912 encyclopedia article graded the case for the Roman line as "a very strong presumption" rather than "proof positive", and wrote that the time was at hand for a decision "if not definitive, at least better informed and more just".
  • This chapter did not retrieve the primary documents of 1378, so the underlying question is described here from later sources only.
  • The editorial headnote on the page that carries Haec sancta, calling it a decree contradicting Vatican I, belongs to the website's editor and not to the translator or the council, and is not relied on here.
  • Pastor Aeternus is cited by locator only; no quotation from it is reproduced in this claim.
  • The internal ellipsis in the Orthodox Church in America extract omits two paragraphs on the Council of Pisa and the calling of Constance.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

Questions people ask next