From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/evidence-against
← About this siteWill you show evidence against the Catholic position?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minYes. Most claims on The Trail keep what they can't show, and how others read the same evidence, right beside the case for them. The chapters name the gaps in the Catholic case, and the Catholic Church's own failures, straight from the sources.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 159
It's a fair test. If a site only shows you the evidence that helps it, you can't trust anything it shows you.
Right beside every claim
The Trail is open that it makes the Catholic case. But its author promises that the weak points get as much room as the strong ones.1
Every claim's file also holds what it can't show, and how others read the same evidence.2 The case against a claim sits right next to it.
Think of it like this
Think of a court case where only one lawyer gets to speak. The other side never sees the evidence, never questions a witness, never gets a word in.
Even if the verdict happened to be right, you'd never trust it. You'd always wonder what was left out, and who wasn't allowed to say it.
A fair trial works the other way. Both sides see everything. Each lawyer questions the other side's witnesses, and the weak spots come out in the open, where the jury can weigh them for themselves. It's slower and messier, but it's the only kind of verdict people trust.
The Trail tries to work like the fair trial: the other side gets to question every witness. Then you're the jury.
Three examples
Talk is cheap, so here are three.
Mary's end. Catholics believe Mary, Jesus's mother, was taken body and soul into , which they call the . The chapter on it admits that nothing in the describes how her life ended.3
The earliest writer it found on the question was a born in Palestine, writing in the late 370s. He listed three possibilities: she died and was buried, she was killed as a , or she was still alive. Then he said no one knows her end.3
The chapter points out why that matters: he was arguing about how Mary should be honoured, so a story of her being taken up would have helped him, and he gives none.3
But he left the door open: he wouldn't say she died, and allowed that God might have done something out of the ordinary. That's why could list him among early writers with testimonies, not yet fully developed, of the belief. The chapter gives both readings.3
The . Jesus gave his follower Simon a new name, , meaning rock, and said he would build his church on this rock. Catholics read that as making Peter himself the rock, with the popes, as bishops of Rome, carrying on his role.4
The chapter also gives the other reading. A Lutheran statement from 1537 reads the rock as the faith Peter declared when he said who Jesus was, as , one of the most important early Christian writers, had also read it.4
Then there's 1870. That year the Catholic bishops, at the , defined that the pope has full authority over the whole Church. They also defined that he is kept from error when he solemnly defines a teaching on faith or morals.4
and readers point to something harder. Some early bishops honoured as saints refused Rome's rulings. In 256, for one, and the bishops of North Africa refused a pope's ruling on .4 That's hard to square with what 1870 defined.
The medieval Church. That chapter lists church jobs bought and sold, priests living with mistresses, and three men claiming to be pope at once. It also covers money from , tied to building St Peter's Basilica in Rome.5
And its evidence comes from the Catholic Church's own meetings of bishops, which kept condemning the same abuses from 1215 to 1563.5 The Catholic Church's own records name the problems.
Where this still falls short
There's an honest limit here.
The counter-arguments are found, chosen and summarised by a Catholic project.
That's not the same as an opponent making the case in their own words.
A reading by someone from another tradition is planned, but hasn't happened yet.2 Until then, ACG especially wants to hear from Orthodox and Protestant readers who feel their tradition has been described unfairly.1
Inside the site, the nearest thing to a critics' reading list is in the chapters. There, critics are quoted in their own words, each linked to the original.
Here are three, left standing without a Catholic reply, so you can weigh them as their makers put them.
An Orthodox reply. The chapter on the First Vatican Council, the 1870 meeting, quotes the Orthodox Church of Constantinople answering the pope in 1895. The Church, it says, knows no one infallible upon earth except .6
A Protestant case. The chapter on the seven , the Church's seven sacred rites like baptism and marriage, gives the reformers' argument, in their words, that only two or three of them are true sacraments.7
A skeptic's case. The chapter on the Shroud of Turin, a cloth some believe was Jesus's burial cloth, gives the skeptics' view that its image is a medieval painting.8
Still, a quote inside a Catholic chapter isn't the whole argument. So read the strongest case against Catholicism in full, from the people who make it. Here are three places to start.
From an evangelical Protestant: Roman Catholic Theology and Practice: An Evangelical Assessment, by the theologian Gregg Allison.
From the Orthodox, on the pope: The Primacy of Peter, essays edited by John Meyendorff, an Orthodox priest and historian.
From a skeptic: How Jesus Became God, by Bart Ehrman, a New Testament scholar who isn't a believer.
The Trail can show you where its evidence is thin. It can't be its own opponent.
The failures, by name
You might expect a Catholic site to hide the hard parts. Catholic teaching says the opposite: since the same God gives both, there can never be any real discrepancy between faith and reason.9 On that view, honest evidence can't hurt the truth.
The Catholic Church has also asked forgiveness for its failures. On 12 March 2000, Pope John Paul II asked forgiveness for the divisions which have occurred among Christians: the splits that left Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants in separate churches.10
In the same breath he asked forgiveness for the violence some have used in the service of the truth.10
Four years later he applied those last words to the Inquisition, the church courts that put people on trial for their beliefs.
Writing about a meeting of historians held at the Vatican to study it, he said Catholics cannot but return with a spirit of repentance to the times they went along with intolerance and even the use of violence in the service of the truth.11
But a promise from the Church isn't proof about this site. The proof is on the pages: check whether the case against is really there.
Sources11
- 1ACG, About The Trail ("What I am trying to do" and "What people ask me")Weak points get as much room as strong ones; Orthodox and Protestant readers invited to say where they're described unfairly.
- 2The Trail, How we know (the method page), chapter I: How every claim is checkedEach claim keeps what it can't show and other readings; the reading by another tradition hasn't happened yet.
- 3The Trail, chapter: Mary's AssumptionNo New Testament account of Mary's end; Epiphanius, a bishop born in Palestine, in the late 370s: three possibilities, and no one knows her end; John Paul II's reading of the same passage.
- 4The Trail, chapter: Peter → Bishop of Rome → PopePeter named the rock; the Lutheran reading of the rock as Peter's confession, as Augustine had read it; what 1870 defined; Cyprian and the African bishops refusing Pope Stephen in 256.
- 5The Trail, chapter: What was wrong in the medieval ChurchSimony, concubinage, indulgence money and the three rival popes, from Catholic councils' own decrees (1215 to 1563).
- 6The Trail, chapter: Vatican IThe Orthodox and Protestant objections in their own words, including the 1895 encyclical of the Church of Constantinople: it knows no one infallible upon earth except the Son and Word of God.
- 7The Trail, chapter: Seven sacramentsThe Protestant objection quoted from Luther, Melanchthon's Apology of the Augsburg Confession and Calvin's Institutes: only two or three rites are sacraments properly so called.
- 8The Trail, chapter: The Shroud of TurinThe skeptics' case, from Joe Nickell of the Center for Inquiry and Walter McCrone, that the image is a medieval painting.
- 9Catechism of the Catholic Church, 159Faith and reason can never really contradict each other.
- 10John Paul II, Homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000)The Church asks forgiveness for divisions and for violence used in the service of truth.
- 11John Paul II, Letter to Cardinal Roger Etchegaray on the Proceedings of the Symposium on the Inquisition (15 June 2004)On the proceedings of the 1998 Vatican symposium on the Inquisition: repentance for the acquiescence given to intolerance and even the use of violence in the service of the truth.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.