From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/labels
← About this siteWhat do the labels like source-verified and revealed mean?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minEvery claim the site's chapters rest on carries three labels. One says what kind of claim it is, one says how sure anyone can be, and one says how far it's been checked, not whether it's true. They're The Trail's own labels, separate from the Catholic Church's levels of teaching.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 67
Not every claim is the same kind of thing. A ruling by the world's and a vision at a shrine are very different. Writing them with the same certainty would mislead you.1
So every claim on The Trail carries three labels, and each one answers a different question. You'll find them at the foot of each chapter, in a folded section called Check it yourself.1
One real example
Around AD 107 a bishop named , on his way to be executed in Rome, wrote a letter. In it he warned about people who stayed away from the .1
The claim built on that letter carries three labels: Historical, Strong historical evidence and Source verified.1
Historical, because it's an old letter, not a Church teaching. Strong historical evidence, because it's an early letter that most scholars accept as his. Source verified, because its quoted words were found, word for word, in a saved copy of the page.1
And the labels keep it modest. The letter shows what one bishop believed around AD 107. It doesn't prove a Church teaching on its own.1 And the method page says what's still open: scholars still debate exactly when Ignatius's letters were written.1
You can see this very claim, with its three labels as they look on the page, in chapter IV of the method page, One claim, start to finish. It also shows the line of the saved page that its quote was matched against.1
Three labels, three questions
What kind of claim is it? There are four kinds. Revealed means the Catholic Church teaches it as part of what God has revealed, like Jesus rising from the dead.1 It doesn't mean The Trail has proved it.
Historical rests on things like old letters, manuscripts or archaeology. Inference is a conclusion drawn from the and Church tradition together. Devotional covers reported visions, (objects linked to a saint), the Shroud of Turin and later miracle reports. Catholic faith doesn't depend on any of them.1
How sure can anyone be? Seven steps, from settled Church teaching down to a claim still being investigated.1
From the top: Established Catholic teaching, like Mary being taken into . Strong historical evidence, like Ignatius's letter.
Probable historical reconstruction, like how Rome's noble families controlled the in the 900s. Disputed, like whether the record of bad popes fits the Catholic claim.
Then Devotional tradition, Private revelation, like the Fatima visions, and Extraordinary claim under investigation.1
Disputed, for example, means serious scholars, or serious Christians, disagree, and the site gives both sides. The last step, for miracles and unexplained events, is held to the strictest standard on the site.1
How far has it been checked? Source verified means every quoted word was found in a saved copy of the source page.1
Think of it like this
Picture a news app that puts three small tags on every story, each answering a different question.
The first tag says what kind of piece it is: News, Opinion or Analysis. The second says how solid it is: Confirmed, or Developing while the facts are still coming in. The third says what's been checked: Quotes verified, meaning an editor made sure everyone quoted really said those words.
None of them can stand in for another. An opinion piece can have perfectly real quotes and still be one person's view. A breaking story can be real news and still not be confirmed.
The Trail's labels work the same way. The kind of claim is the first tag, how sure anyone can be is the second, and Source verified is the third. A claim can be well checked and still uncertain.
Checked isn't the same as right
There's a catch with Source verified.
It doesn't mean the claim is right. A quote can be perfect and the conclusion drawn from it still wrong.
Three more readings are planned: one for Catholic teaching, one for the history, and one by someone from another tradition. After that come a plain-language edit and a review by a priest, theologian or historian.1
To be honest, none of those has happened yet. So no claim is Approved, and no AI is allowed to mark one approved.1
Why keep the kinds apart?
Mix them up, and a well-loved religious story starts to sound like a dated historical record.
Take three examples. Catholics believe Mary, Jesus's mother, was taken body and soul into heaven at the end of her life. That's defined Catholic teaching.1
The visions of Mary reported at Fatima, in Portugal, are among the best known. The Church allows devotion to them, but no Catholic has to believe them. And the Shroud of Turin, a cloth some believe was Jesus's burial cloth, still has its origin argued over.1
Each one is written with the certainty it has, and no more.
Not the Church's own scale
One thing to keep straight. These labels are The Trail's own. The Catholic Church has its own levels, for how firmly Catholics are asked to hold what it teaches.2
The site's labels only line up with them roughly.
Revealed matches the Church's top level: what it teaches as revealed by God, like Mary being taken into heaven, defined in 1950.1,2
Private revelation matches its bottom one: visions like Fatima, which no Catholic has to believe, even ones the Church allows devotion to.1,4
Established Catholic teaching is rougher. It covers anything the Catholic Church teaches with authority, from what's settled for good to its everyday teaching.1,2
That's a real blur, and the label alone won't tell you which. So each claim's own words have to say it, by naming the , pope or document it comes from.
Strong historical evidence and Disputed aren't Church levels at all. They're about history: how well the documents support what happened. Nor is Disputed the same as the Church's open questions, which popes generally leave theologians free to argue out.3
So you only need to hold one scale here: the site's three labels. The Church's own levels have their own answer, “What's the difference between a and a devotion?”
And the labels are a guide to weight, not a verdict. A Revealed claim isn't proved by the site, and a Disputed one isn't false.
Each label is there for the same reason: being exact about how sure a claim is. They tell you what kind of claim it is, how sure anyone can be, and how far it's been checked.
Sources4
- 1The Trail, How we know (the method page), chapters I, II and IVThe four evidence labels, the seven confidence steps and the review statuses; the 'Check it yourself' lists; chapter IV, 'One claim, start to finish', the Ignatius claim with its three labels and its saved page; the five levels of Church teaching and how the site's labels map onto them.
- 2Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio Fidei (29 June 1998), with canons 750 and 752The levels of Catholic teaching and the assent each asks for.
- 3Pius XII, Humani Generis (12 August 1950), 19Popes generally leave theologians free on disputed matters, though many once open no longer admit of discussion.
- 4Catechism of the Catholic Church, 67Private revelations don't belong to the deposit of faith.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.