← Sources
What the site rests on

What are your sources?

Read it as an illustrated story · 6 min

1,166 documents, each linked to the original, and 1,160 of them fetched and checked against the original page. They're sorted into five tiers by how much weight they can carry. Catholic teaching has to rest on official texts, history starts with first-hand sources, and the lower tiers aren't meant to carry a claim alone.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Vatican II
Lumen Gentium

It's the first thing to ask of any site that makes claims about God and history. So here's the whole answer, with the numbers.

The chapters, the River (the timeline of Christian history on this site) and these questions rest on 1,166 documents.1 Every one of them links to the original, so you can open it and read it for yourself.1

Of those, 1,160 were fetched and checked against the original page.1 The other 6 are marked as still waiting, so you know which ones they are.1

Not every source weighs the same

A council's ruling and a blog post aren't the same kind of thing.

Treating them the same would mislead you.

So the sources are sorted into five tiers, from A to E, by how much weight each one can carry.1 Most sit in the top two: 669 of the 1,166 are official texts or first-hand history. Only 5 are in the bottom tier.1

Think of it like this

Think of a rumour going round that your child's school is closing next year.

The strongest source is the school's own letter, signed by the principal. If you want to know what the school has decided, that's where you look. Next is a parent who was actually in the room at the meeting.

Then there's the local newspaper, whose reporter talked to several people and checked the dates. Then the parents' Facebook group, full of people who care, a few of whom have done their homework. And last, the forwarded WhatsApp message with no name on it.

None of them is useless. The WhatsApp message might be what made you start asking. But you wouldn't pull your child out of school because of it.

That's how the five tiers work: each source is trusted for what it can actually show.

The five tiers

Tier A is official texts. That's the and the Catholic Church's own documents: its councils (meetings of the world's ), , the (its summary of what it believes) and the Vatican's offices.1

One example is Lumen Gentium, the 's teaching on the Church, from 1964.2

Tier A also holds other churches' own founding and official texts, in their own words.1 One is the Lausanne Covenant. It came out of a gathering of Christians from more than 150 countries in 1974, and it set out what it means to be evangelical.3

Tier B is first-hand history. These are the Church Fathers, the Christian writers of the first centuries after the , along with old letters and chronicles, Reformation writings and eyewitnesses.1

Here you'll find two early church leaders: , writing around AD 96, and , writing around AD 107 to 110.1 You'll also find , a Christian in Rome who described Sunday worship to the emperor around AD 155.4

Writings from the Reformation, the break with Rome in the 1500s, are here too, like 's Ninety-five Theses of 1517. So are eyewitnesses, like a Greek historian who watched the crusaders sack Constantinople, today's Istanbul, in 1204.1

Tier C is scholarship, reference and news. These set the story in context and, where needed, push back on it.1 To be honest, it's a mixed tier, and its three kinds don't weigh the same.

Modern scholarship, like books from university presses and articles in academic journals, carries the most weight.

About half the tier is older reference work, like the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica, written over a century ago. It's useful for names and dates, but it can be out of date.

And news reports, from places like Time and Christianity Today, are there for recent events.1 It also means critics. The case that the Shroud of Turin, a cloth some believe wrapped Jesus's body, is a medieval painting is given by skeptics, in their own words.1

Tier D is Catholic explanation. That's Catholic encyclopedias, shrine websites and devotional sites.1 They're useful for finding the arguments Catholics make, but they're never enough on their own.1

Tier E is popular material. These are leads only.1 There are just 5, among them three Wikipedia articles and an old translation saved from a website that no longer exists.1

The rule that keeps it honest

One rule ties the tiers together. Catholic teaching has to rest on tier A, and history starts at tier B. The lower tiers can help find things, but they're not meant to carry a claim alone.1

Why split it that way? Because what the Catholic Church teaches and what actually happened are different questions. The answer on why the site quotes the Catholic Church's own documents explains why they're the right source for the first, and not enough for the second.

Where to see them all

The saints' lives and the histories of each country and diocese (the area a bishop looks after) work a little differently. They cite their own pages in notes right beside the text, so those aren't repeated in the main list.1

The saved copies of every page stay in the project's own files, because they belong to the sites they came from.1 That's why the site links you to the original instead.

You can see all 1,166, tier by tier, at the end of the method page, under Every source.1 How each quote is checked against them has its own answer, How was this researched?

Every title in that list opens the original. You never have to take anyone's word for it.

Sources4
  1. 1The Trail, How we know (the method page), chapter V: Every source1,166 documents, 1,160 checked against the original page; the five tiers, what each is for and how many each holds; the rule that teaching rests on tier A and history starts at tier B; saints' lives and histories cite their own pages; saved copies kept in the project's files.
  2. 2Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (21 November 1964)A tier A example: the Council's teaching on the Church.
  3. 3The Lausanne Covenant (1974), Lausanne MovementA tier A example from another tradition: written at the First Lausanne Congress in 1974 by participants from more than 150 nations; it defined what it means to be evangelical.
  4. 4Justin Martyr, The First Apology (c. AD 155), chapters 65–67A tier B example: addressed to the Emperor Antoninus Pius; describes Christian Sunday worship.
Quotes not yet checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.