Part XVII · Chapter 37
Vatican I

Didn't the Catholic Church just vote the pope infallible in 1870, over its best historians' objections, with the dissenters gone and an army at the gates?

10 scenes · about 26 min read

The short answer

Partly, yes. On 18 July 1870 the voted 533 to 2 that the is infallible, kept from error, under strict conditions. Most of the who opposed it had already gone home.

About a fifth of the bishops opposed it, mostly because they thought defining it then was unwise, not false. Leading Catholic historians in Germany said the early Church's history told against it. Two months later Italian troops took Rome.

What was defined is narrow. Four conditions must all be met. The pope speaks as shepherd and teacher of all Christians. He uses his full authority as 's successor. The matter is faith or morals. And he defines it as a teaching for the whole Church. He can't add new .

Pius XII's definition of Mary's in 1950 met all four. A pope's teaching letter, a sermon or an interview defines nothing, so it isn't covered.

The power has clearly been used twice, in 1854 and 1950, and both times the pope first asked every bishop.

The still reject it as unknown in the first thousand years. The narrowness of the definition doesn't answer that objection.

Follow the trail

Ten scenes, from the pope's list of condemned ideas in 1864 to the German bishops' answer to Bismarck in 1875.

8 December 1864Historical2 min read

A pope who had lost most of his country

Pius IX, the Syllabus of Errors

By 1864 Pope Pius IX had lost most of his lands to the new kingdom of Italy. That December, in Rome, he announced a and published the Syllabus, a list of eighty ideas he condemned.

Black-and-white photograph of an elderly Pius IX seated in a white cassock and cape.
Pius IX, photographed by Adolphe Braun on 13 May 1875 for his eighty-third birthday.
IWhat was going on

For more than a thousand years the pope had ruled a band of central Italy, the Papal States. Popes saw it as their guarantee that no king could lean on them.

Pius IX was elected in 1846 as the liberal candidate, and he began by making reforms. Then came the revolutions of 1848. On 15 November his chief minister, Rossi, was stabbed to death on his way to open parliament.

Nine days later the pope fled Rome in disguise. Revolutionaries declared a republic in Rome. French troops ended it, and Pius came back in April 1850, no longer a political liberal.

A French garrison stayed on to protect him.

IIWhat was at stake

In 1859 and 1860 the kingdom of Piedmont, in north-west Italy, was leading the drive to unite Italy. It took every papal province except Rome and the land around it.

In Piedmont itself the same government had shut monasteries, seized church property and expelled religious orders. It jailed or banished bishops who resisted. To Pius IX, liberalism meant the movement that had done all this.

To its supporters, liberalism meant a free press, elected parliaments, state schools and an Italy run by Italians. Should the Catholic Church make peace with the new states on their terms? Or should it say where it thought they were wrong?

IIIWhat happened

On 6 December 1864 Pius told the cardinals in Rome that he meant to call a general council. That is a meeting of the world's bishops whose decisions bind the whole Church.

Two days later he sent all bishops a letter, Quanta Cura, and with it the Syllabus. It listed eighty statements his earlier letters had already condemned. They were on pantheism, rationalism, socialism, freemasonry and religious liberalism.

The list gave only bare headlines, each pointing back to an older document. The last one condemned the idea that a pope should come to terms with modern civilisation.

IVWhat came of it

Critics across Europe read the Syllabus as the Catholic Church turning its back on the modern world. Supporters saw it as a stand against governments that were taking over the Church's schools and property.

Governments were indeed tightening their hold. Baden, a German state, tore up its agreement with the Church in 1860.

A council called by the author of the Syllabus looked, to many statesmen, like a threat.

VRead the source
The Roman Pontiff can, and ought to, reconcile himself, and come to terms with progress, liberalism and modern civilization.
The Syllabus of Errors · Syllabus of Errors (8 December 1864), section X, proposition 80 (condemned)

Why it matters

The council was called by a pope who had been driven out of Rome once and expected to lose it again. Its mood came from a Church that felt under siege.

That explains the tone, but it doesn't make the Syllabus the last word. In 1965 the taught that every person has a right to religious freedom, which the state must respect.

8 December 1869Historical2 min read

Seven hundred bishops in St Peter's

The council opens

On 8 December 1869 Pope Pius IX opened the First Vatican Council in St Peter's, Rome. Bishops came from far beyond Europe. Papal infallibility, the pope being kept from error, was not on the official agenda.

Engraving of the council in session in St Peter's: bishops in mitres fill tiered benches on both sides, the pope enthroned at the far end.
The council in session in St Peter's, engraved by Karl Benzinger for a book on Pius IX, 1873.
IWhat was going on

The last council of all the world's bishops, at Trent in northern Italy, had ended in 1563. No bishop alive had ever been to one.

Pius asked the cardinals in Rome first. Of twenty-one written replies, only one said a council was not needed, and five thought the timing wrong.

Bishops were consulted under a pledge of silence, and theologians came to Rome to draft texts. On 29 June 1868 Pius summoned the council by a bull, a formal papal letter named after its seal. It was called Aeterni Patris.

IIWhat was at stake

The drafts dealt with faith and reason, the Church, and church law. Bishops sent wish lists too. Those of Quebec and Halifax, in Canada, asked for church law to be reformed and gathered into one code.

Outside, a fight had already started over papal infallibility. That is the belief that, under strict conditions, the pope cannot err when he defines what the Church believes.

In February 1869 Civiltà Cattolica, a journal run by Jesuit priests in Rome, printed letters saying most French Catholics wanted it defined. Ignaz von Döllinger, a leading German church historian, answered with anonymous newspaper articles against it.

IIIWhat happened

On 8 December about seven hundred bishops met in St Peter's. Of some 1,050 entitled to come, about 774 took part at some point.

The Orthodox bishops, of the Eastern Churches not in with Rome, were invited and did not come.

Within weeks the bishops split. On Christmas Day Archbishop Dechamps of Mechlin, in Belgium, proposed a definition. A petition for it gathered about 500 signatures. The minority's petitions against it gathered 136.

IVWhat came of it

Governments moved too. On 10 February 1870 Austria warned it would forbid any decree that clashed with its laws.

France demanded an envoy at the council, and Austria, Bavaria, Britain, Spain and Portugal backed it.

Pius IX favoured a definition. On 6 March a chapter on papal infallibility was added to the draft on the Church.

VRead the source
There were in the entire world approximately one thousand and fifty prelates entitled to take part in the council, and of these no less than seven hundred and seventy-four appeared during the course of the proceedings.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', section on procedure

Why it matters

None of the drafts prepared in advance dealt with infallibility. It came onto the agenda because it was being fought over in public, and a large majority wanted it settled.

So the council wasn't simply called to make the pope infallible. But the pope who called it wanted the definition, and the majority knew it.

28 January 1870Historical2 min read

A private letter that did not stay private

John Henry Newman, to Bishop Ullathorne in Rome

In January 1870 John Henry Newman, England's best-known convert to the Catholic Church, wrote privately to his bishop at the council. He believed the doctrine himself. But he feared that defining it then would hurt people.

IWhat was going on

John Henry Newman had been a leading Anglican priest at Oxford. Anglicans belong to the Church of England and its sister churches. He became a Catholic in 1845, and in 1870 he was a priest in Birmingham.

His bishop, William Ullathorne, was in Rome for the council. By January a petition from the majority for the definition was going round the bishops. Newman wrote to Ullathorne on 28 January.

IIWhat was at stake

Newman wasn't asking whether the doctrine was true. He was asking whether it was wise to define it then.

Councils had defined doctrine when a crisis forced them. The first great council, at Nicaea, did so over whether Jesus is God. Here Newman saw no crisis.

He worried about Catholics already struggling with history. One example was Pope Honorius, whom a council condemned in 681.

IIIWhat happened

He wrote that he expected no trial of faith for himself. But he suffered with the many people who were suffering. He dreaded having to defend decisions that might be hard to square with historical facts.

He called the push for a definition the work of a faction, and asked why the faithful could not be left in peace. The letter was meant for one reader, but its words reached the press.

IVWhat came of it

When the council defined the dogma, Newman accepted it. A dogma is a teaching the Catholic Church declares to be revealed by God, binding on all Catholics.

In 1875 he defended it in his Letter to the Duke of Norfolk. It answered the British statesman Gladstone, who said Catholics could no longer be loyal citizens. Newman stressed how rarely such definitions happen, and that conscience comes first.

VRead the source
What have we done to be treated as the faithful never were treated before? When has definition of doctrine de Fide been a luxury of devotion, and not a stern painful necessity? Why should an aggressive insolent faction be allowed to “make the heart of the just to mourn, whom the Lord hath not made sorrowful”?
The Vatican Council: The Story Told from Inside in Bishop Ullathorne's Letters, vol. I · Butler, The Vatican Council (1930), vol. I, pp. 212-213, Newman to Ullathorne, 28 January 1870

Why it matters

Newman shows what most of the minority feared. They did not think the doctrine false; they thought defining it then would do harm.

A Catholic can hold a doctrine and still argue about timing. Newman was made a cardinal in 1879 and declared a saint in 2019. In 2025 Pope Leo XIV named him a Doctor of the Church, a title for the saints whose teaching it holds up for everyone.

24 April 1870Revealed2 min read

The council's first teaching: faith and reason

Dei Filius, the third public session

On 24 April 1870 the council finished its first document. It was about faith and reason, not about the pope, and all 667 bishops present voted for it.

IWhat was going on

Nineteenth-century Europe was full of confident new ideas. Some thinkers held that only matter exists. Others held that reason alone settles every question, and open atheism was spreading.

The council's own text describes the mood. People who rejected God and had fallen into pantheism, materialism and atheism, it says, and some Catholics were being carried along. Pantheism is the belief that everything is God.

IIWhat was at stake

Can a thinking person believe? If science and faith seem to clash, which one wins?

Some said religion is only feeling and has nothing to do with reason. Others said reason can judge everything, God's revelation included. Either way, faith ends up with nothing to say about the real world.

IIIWhat happened

The draft came to the floor on 18 March 1870. The bishops debated it until 19 April and worked through more than three hundred proposed changes.

On 24 April Dei Filius, Latin for '', passed unanimously. It taught that human reason can know God with certainty from the things he made.

Faith and reason can never truly conflict, because the same God gives both.

IVWhat came of it

When they seem to clash, the text says, either the faith has been misunderstood or a bad idea is being passed off as reason.

It also restated the list of books in the Bible as the had given it. It remains the Catholic Church's basic statement on faith and reason.

built on it in his 1998 letter Fides et Ratio, Faith and Reason.

VRead the source
Even though faith is above reason, there can never be any real disagreement between faith and reason, since it is the same God who reveals the mysteries and infuses faith, and who has endowed the human mind with the light of reason.
Pastor Aeternus, First Dogmatic Constitution on the Church of Christ · Session 3 (24 April 1870), Dogmatic Constitution on the Catholic Faith (Dei Filius), chapter 4, Tanner translation

Why it matters

The council that defined papal infallibility first defended the rights of reason. Catholics are not asked to switch off their minds.

It also makes a claim anyone can test: that honest science and true faith will not, in the end, contradict each other.

11 July 1870Historical2 min read

A bishop explains what the definition doesn't mean

Bishop Vinzenz Gasser of Brixen, for the drafting committee

On 11 July 1870, before the final vote, Bishop Vinzenz Gasser spoke for nearly four hours. On behalf of the drafting committee, he explained what the definition meant and what it did not.

Lithograph of Bishop Vinzenz Gasser standing in choir dress, a pectoral cross on a chain.
Vinzenz Gasser, bishop of Brixen, in a lithograph by Josef Kriehuber, 1856.
IWhat was going on

The draft on the pope reached the floor in May. From 13 May the bishops debated it as a whole, in sixty-four mostly long speeches.

On 3 June, at the request of 150 bishops, the president closed that debate. About forty bishops who had asked to speak never did.

The chapter-by-chapter debate ran from 6 June to 13 July, with about a hundred speakers.

Gasser was prince-bishop of Brixen, in the Tyrol, in the Alps. He spoke for the Deputation on Faith, the committee in charge of the text.

IIWhat was at stake

The minority wanted conditions written in. The pope must consult the bishops, they said, or a definition needs the Church's agreement.

An old French view, called Gallicanism, held exactly that: a pope's ruling on faith stays open until the Church consents. The majority wanted that view closed for good.

IIIWhat happened

On 11 July Gasser gave the longest speech of the council. It fills twenty-seven columns in the printed record.

He said the pope is not infallible as a private person. He is kept from error only when he defines for the whole Church as its teacher. The gift comes by God's help, not by new revelation.

Popes do consult the Church in practice, he said. Pius IX did so before defining the Immaculate Conception, the teaching that Mary was free from sin from the moment she was conceived. But such consultation could not be made a legal rule.

IVWhat came of it

His speech became the drafting committee's official explanation of the text.

In 1964 the Second Vatican Council, the next meeting of all the world's bishops, cited it. It did so in Lumen Gentium, its teaching on the Church, when it set out what infallibility means.

VRead the source
In no sense is it absolute, because absolute infallibility belongs to God alone. The Pope's is restricted by limitations and conditions, as set forth in the definition.
The Vatican Council: The Story Told from Inside in Bishop Ullathorne's Letters, vol. II · Butler, The Vatican Council (1930), vol. II, pp. 136-137, Butler's English summary of Gasser's relatio of 11 July 1870 (Mansi 52, 1204ff)

Why it matters

The popular idea is that Catholics think the pope can't be wrong, or can't sin. The men who wrote the definition said the opposite.

What 1870 defined is narrow: rare, public, and tied to what the apostles handed on. Whether it should have been defined at all is a fair question. What it says is not in doubt.

17 July 1870Historical2 min read

The bishops against it go home

The minority bishops, in a letter to Pius IX

On 17 July 1870, after a trial vote, more than fifty bishops who opposed the definition wrote to Pius IX that their no votes stood. Then they left Rome rather than vote no to his face.

IWhat was going on

On 13 July 1870, 601 bishops voted on the whole text in a trial vote. Of these, 451 said yes and 88 said no. Another 62 said yes with amendments.

Most German and Austro-Hungarian bishops were in the minority, with about half of the Americans and a third of the French. No bishop from Spain, Portugal, Belgium, the Netherlands or Latin America opposed it.

IIWhat was at stake

The minority now had to choose. A public no at the final, formal session would be cast in front of the pope, whom they honoured as a father.

A yes would go against their judgement. Staying away would leave the vote to the majority.

IIIWhat happened

A group from the minority asked the pope to soften the wording, and failed. Instead, at the last moment, the council added a phrase. It said such definitions stand of themselves, not by the consent of the Church.

The phrase was aimed at the Gallican view, the old French idea that a pope's ruling waits for the Church's agreement. It hardened the minority.

On 17 July they wrote to Pius that their votes stood. Their reverence for him, they said, kept them from saying no to his face. Then they left.

IVWhat came of it

Many bishops on both sides had already gone home, because war between France and Prussia was coming. On 18 July only 535 were left.

Every minority bishop later accepted the decree, some only after months of struggle.

Bishop Hefele of Rottenburg, a leading historian of the councils, held out until April 1871. Meanwhile Rome held back permissions he had asked for so that couples in his diocese could marry.

VRead the source
For the filial piety and reverence, which very recently brought our representatives to the feet of your Holiness, do not allow us in a cause so closely concerning Your Holiness to say 'non placet' openly and in the face of the Father.
The Vatican Council: The Story Told from Inside in Bishop Ullathorne's Letters, vol. II · Butler, vol. II, pp. 158-159, letter of the minority dated 17 July 1870 (Mansi 52, 1325), in Butler's translation

Why it matters

The final 533 to 2 shows who stayed, not what every bishop thought. A fair account counts the 88 no votes of 13 July too.

Catholics believe the council's teaching is true because the Holy Spirit guards the Church, not because the process was tidy. It wasn't tidy, and both things can be said at once.

18 July 1870Historical2 min read

The final vote, 533 to 2, in a thunderstorm

The fourth public session

On 18 July 1870, in St Peter's, the council defined that the pope teaches without error under strict conditions. The vote was 533 to 2, as a thunderstorm broke overhead.

IWhat was going on

This was the fourth public session: the formal sitting where the final vote is taken with the pope present, and he confirms the result.

The text was Pastor Aeternus, Latin for 'Eternal Shepherd'. Its four chapters say that Christ gave Peter first place among the twelve apostles, and that the bishops of Rome inherit it.

They also say what power the pope holds, and when he teaches without error.

IIWhat was at stake

Chapter three gives the pope full, direct power over every church. That covers church discipline as well as faith and morals. The same chapter says this does not take away the bishops' own power in their dioceses.

Chapter four is the part people remember. It sets out when a pope speaks ex cathedra, Latin for 'from the chair'.

He must speak as teacher of all Christians, with his full authority, defining a teaching on faith or morals for the whole Church.

IIIWhat happened

The roll call was taken in St Peter's while a thunderstorm broke overhead. In all, 533 voted yes.

Two voted no: Bishop Riccio of Caiazzo in Italy and Bishop Edward Fitzgerald of Little Rock, Arkansas, in the United States. As soon as Pius confirmed the text, both went up to his throne and accepted it.

IVWhat came of it

The next day war broke out between France and Prussia.

Since 1870 a pope has clearly used this power once. In 1950 Pius XII defined that Mary was taken body and soul into heaven, a teaching called the Assumption. He wrote to every bishop first, asking whether they and their people believed it.

VRead the source
The great Session is over. The decree was voted by 533 'placets' to 2 'non placets' amidst a great storm.
The Vatican Council: The Story Told from Inside in Bishop Ullathorne's Letters, vol. II · Butler, vol. II, p. 166, Bishop Ullathorne's letter of 18 July 1870

Why it matters

This is the teaching other Christians most often name as a barrier. In 1895 the Patriarchate of Constantinople, first in honour among the Orthodox Churches, replied to Rome. It said the Church knows no one infallible on earth except Christ himself.

Catholics answer that the gift protects the Church's faith, not the pope's person. It is meant to keep the Church from losing what the apostles taught.

20 September 1870Historical2 min read

Italian troops take Rome

Italian troops enter Rome

On 20 September 1870, two months after the vote, Italian troops broke into Rome. The council was suspended and never met again.

Sepia photograph of the walls of Rome beside the Porta Pia, with a gap broken in the wall to the right of the gate.
The breach beside the Porta Pia, photographed in 1870. The printed caption reads 'Breccia a Porta Pia, eseguita dalle truppe italiane il 20 settembre 1870': breach at Porta Pia, made by the Italian troops on 20 September 1870.
IWhat was going on

Since 1849 French troops had guarded Rome for the pope. When France went to war with Prussia, the leading German state, it pulled them out, starting on 20 July 1870.

On 2 September the French emperor, Napoleon III, surrendered at Sedan. Nothing now stood between Italy and Rome.

Most bishops had gone home on leave until 11 November. Barely a hundred stayed, debating a minor decree. Their last meeting was on 1 September.

IIWhat was at stake

Italy wanted Rome as its capital. Pius IX held that the city was the Catholic Church's guarantee of freedom from any government.

King Victor Emmanuel II of Italy offered a peaceful entry, presented as protecting the pope. Pius refused to hand over the city.

IIIWhat happened

On 11 September Italian troops under General Raffaele Cadorna crossed into the pope's territory. On 20 September they broke through the walls beside the Porta Pia, one of the city's gates.

Pius had ordered his small army to resist only long enough to show that Rome was taken by force, not handed over. Then a white flag went up. The district around the Vatican was left to him.

IVWhat came of it

A vote in Rome on 2 October approved joining Italy. On 20 October Pius suspended the council with no date to return.

In May 1871 Italy passed the Law of Guarantees. It offered him a sovereign's honours and a yearly payment. He refused it, and popes stayed inside the Vatican as self-declared prisoners.

The Lateran Pacts, agreements between the papacy and Italy, finally settled the question on 11 February 1929. They created the Vatican City State.

VRead the source
On 8 Sept. the Piedmontese troops entered the States of the Church at several points; on Tuesday, 20 Sept., a little before eight o'clock in the morning, the enemy entered Rome through the Porta Pia. The pope was a prisoner in the Vatican.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', section on the council after the fourth session

Why it matters

The bishops didn't vote under the guns: the vote came two months before the troops arrived. But they knew Rome was likely to fall, and that fear hung over the whole council.

The council was cut short with most of its work undone, including its teaching on the bishops. That gap was only filled at the Second Vatican Council, nearly a century later.

28 March 1871Historical2 min read

A great historian refuses to accept it

Ignaz von Döllinger, to the Archbishop of Munich

In March 1871 Ignaz von Döllinger, Germany's best-known Catholic church historian, publicly refused to accept the council's decrees. In April the Archbishop of Munich excommunicated him.

Painted portrait of Ignaz von Döllinger, an elderly man in black clerical dress holding a book.
Ignaz von Döllinger, painted by Franz von Lenbach in 1874, three years after his excommunication.
IWhat was going on

Ignaz von Döllinger, born in 1799, was a priest and professor of church history in Munich. He was admired across Europe.

In 1869 he wrote anonymous articles against papal infallibility, the belief that the pope can't err when he defines the faith. They were later published as a book under the name Janus.

During the council he wrote letters to a newspaper in Augsburg under the name Quirinus. He used reports sent from Rome by his former students.

IIWhat was at stake

His case was history. Popes had made mistakes, and a council had condemned Pope Honorius in 681. The early Church, he argued, never treated Rome as a judge that could not err.

Underneath was a deeper question. If historians find a doctrine missing from the early record, can a council still define it?

IIIWhat happened

Archbishop von Scherr of Munich asked him to accept the decrees. On 28 March 1871 Döllinger refused in a public declaration. He said the decrees had no basis in Scripture or tradition, and that they clashed with the modern state.

On 18 April the archbishop declared him excommunicated: cut off from the until he reconciled. It is a church penalty, not a physical punishment.

IVWhat came of it

Döllinger accepted that the penalty bound him and stopped acting as a priest. He never joined another church, and he died in Munich in 1890.

Some of his followers formed the Old Catholic churches. Their first German bishop, Joseph Reinkens, was consecrated in 1873.

In 1889 they rejected the Vatican decrees in the Declaration of Utrecht, made in the Netherlands, while still granting Rome a first place of honour.

VRead the source

Why it matters

The objection from history is serious, and Catholics made it first.

Catholics answer that the definition is narrower than what Döllinger wrote against. They add that Honorius defined nothing ex cathedra, 'from the chair', as teacher of the whole Church.

They also say doctrine can grow like a seed into a plant without changing what it is. Readers can weigh both cases on the same evidence.

1875Historical2 min read

German bishops answer Bismarck

The bishops of Germany, endorsed by Pius IX

Germany's chancellor, Otto von Bismarck, claimed the council had made the pope an absolute monarch. In 1875 the German bishops said in a joint statement that it had not, and Pius IX agreed with them.

IWhat was going on

Germany was united under Prussia in January 1871, after it defeated France. Its chancellor, the head of government, was Otto von Bismarck. He governed with the Liberals.

He also saw Catholics who looked to Rome as a danger to the new empire. With the Liberals behind him he started the Kulturkampf, German for 'culture struggle'. New laws put the training and appointment of priests under the state.

Bishops and priests who refused lost property, went to prison or were exiled.

IIWhat was at stake

Bismarck used the council as his reason. He held that it had made the pope an absolute monarch and the bishops mere delegates.

If that were true, every German Catholic answered to a foreign ruler. The bishops had to show what the council had actually said.

IIIWhat happened

Early in 1875 the bishops of Germany issued a joint declaration. The pope, they wrote, is bound by God's law and cannot change the way Christ set up the Church.

The bishops, too, exist because God set them up, with rights and duties the pope cannot take away. They are not mere tools of the pope.

That same year Pius IX wrote that their reading was the true sense of the council.

IVWhat came of it

The Kulturkampf eased after 1878, when Bismarck needed the votes of the Catholic Centre Party and opened talks with Rome.

In 1998 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office for doctrine, cited the bishops' declaration. It said the pope's power has limits set by God's law.

VRead the source
it is in virtue of the same divine institution upon which the papacy rests that the episcopate also exists. It, too, has its rights and duties, because of the ordinance of God himself, and the Pope has neither the right nor the power to change them
Vatican II is back in the news, which begs a question: What was Vatican I? · EWTN News (Carl Bunderson, 2022), quoting the German bishops' joint declaration of January-February 1875

Why it matters

This is the Catholic Church's own answer to the fear that 1870 made the pope a dictator. Primacy, the first place of Peter's successor, is meant to serve the bishops' unity, not replace them.

Orthodox and Protestant Christians still ask whether the text of 1870 bears that reading. The Second Vatican Council tried to answer by setting out the bishops' shared authority with the pope.

To be fair, a pope approving a reading in 1875 shows how Rome chose to read the text. It doesn't, on its own, settle what the words of 1870 mean.

The test is the text itself. Chapter 3 gives the pope 'full power' to 'tend, rule and govern the universal church', with a jurisdiction that is 'episcopal and immediate' over every church.

In the same chapter it says this 'by no means detracts' from the bishops' own power. Whether those two claims sit together is the real question, and readers can weigh it.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church reads 1870 as the settling of an old argument, not the invention of a new power.

Since 1682 a French school of thought, called Gallicanism, had held that a pope's teaching on faith stays open until the Church consents to it. The council closed that door.

The point was finality: a way for an argument about the faith to reach an end.

The definition protects rather than creates. Pastor Aeternus, the council's text on the pope, says so itself. The was not promised so that popes could make known new doctrine, but so that they could guard what the handed on.

Bishop Gasser, speaking for the committee that drafted the text, said the same on 11 July, as his scene above tells.

The , its official summary of teaching, puts the boundary in one line. Infallibility 'extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself': as far as what God has revealed, and no further.

Nor did the council turn bishops into the pope's local managers. Pastor Aeternus says papal power 'by no means detracts' from the bishops' own power over their flocks.

When Bismarck, Germany's chancellor, claimed otherwise, the German bishops replied that bishops 'are not mere tools of the Pope'. Pius IX endorsed their reading.

Newman, England's best-known convert, accepted the definition. He still wrote that he would drink a toast 'to Conscience first, and to the Pope afterwards'.

He meant the pope's commands about conduct. Conscience, he explained, 'cannot come into direct collision with the Church's or the Pope's infallibility'.

In practice the power has been used the way the minority hoped. Before 1854 Pius IX asked every bishop what his people believed about Mary's , her being free from from the moment she was conceived.

Before 1950 Pius XII asked every bishop two things. Could the Assumption, Mary being taken body and soul into , be defined? And did they want it?

Both times the pope spoke for an agreement he had first checked. Gasser had refused to make such checking a legal condition: 'such a case cannot be set up as the rule'. The Church's consent to a true definition, he said, 'can never be withheld'.

The council's own evidence reaches back into the first thousand years. Pastor Aeternus quotes a statement of faith published by the Fourth Council of Constantinople in 869 and 870. It says: 'in the apostolic see the catholic religion has always been preserved unblemished'.

The apostolic see means Rome. The words come from Pope Hormisdas's formula of 517, which that council's bishops signed.

The Orthodox recognise seven councils of the whole Church, the last in 787, so they do not count this one. The Catholic claim is that 1870 named a role Rome had long played. Whether that growth was faithful is exactly what the Orthodox deny.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Eastern Orthodox

Pope Leo XIII invited the Orthodox to reunion. In 1895 the Patriarchate of Constantinople, first in honour among the Orthodox Churches, answered in an encyclical, a formal letter.

It says the early Church's great teachers and councils of the first nine centuries show 'the Bishop of Rome was never considered as the supreme authority and infallible head of the Church'.

In Orthodox teaching every bishop heads his own church, subject to the councils of the whole Church. A history published by the Orthodox Church in America says that in 1870 the was laid down 'for the first time in history'.

On this reading a Western council, with no Orthodox bishop present, defined a power the undivided Church never knew.

Old Catholic

The Old Catholic churches grew from the protest of Döllinger and others against the council. Their bishops met at Utrecht, in the Netherlands, on 24 September 1889.

They rejected 'the Vatican decrees, promulgated July 18, 1870' on and on the pope's power over the whole Church. They said these contradicted the faith of the ancient Church.

They did not reject Rome's first place altogether. The same article acknowledges 'the historic ' that councils and early teachers gave the bishop of Rome, as first among equals.

Their position is the 1870 minority's argument carried through to separation.

Protestant

Philip Schaff, an American church historian, wrote in 1877. He called papal infallibility 'the direct antipode of the Protestant principle of the absolute supremacy and infallibility of the Holy Scriptures': its exact opposite.

He argued that 'The makes no provision and has no promise for an œcumenical Council', a council of the whole Church, let alone for an infallible pope. He wrote that 'Christ needs no vicar', no stand-in on earth.

For him the dogma 'was not dreamed of for more than a thousand years'. On this reading only Scripture is the rule that cannot err, and every church office stays answerable to it.

Anglican

In 2005 Anglican and Catholic theologians, meeting as an official joint commission, issued an agreed statement on Mary.

In it, Anglicans question whether the two teachings about Mary that popes defined, in 1854 and 1950, must be believed as part of the faith. Their reason is that 'the Bishop of Rome defined these doctrines “independent of a Council”'.

The same paragraph records the Catholic reply. It points to the faith of believers, the Church's worship and the bishops' support.

For Anglicans, 'it would be the consent of an ecumenical council', a council of the whole Church, that most securely shows a teaching belongs to the faith.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself7
The texts behind the definition, and the texts against it12 steps

Twelve documents, in date order. They show the view the council closed, the evidence the minority pressed, the words the bishops voted on, and the answers from outside.

  1. The Gallican article the council set out to end

    1682

    In 1682 the French clergy adopted four articles limiting the pope's power. The fourth said a pope's judgement on faith stays open until the Church consents to it.

    For a long time it was required teaching in French universities and in seminaries, where priests are trained.

    The council's phrase 'not by the consent of the church' was written against this article.

    “Although the pope have the chief part in questions of faith , and his decrees apply to all the Churches, and to each Church in particular, yet his judgment is not irreformable, at least pending the consent of the Church .”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Gallicanism'Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Gallicanism', the Declaration of 1682, article 4The evidence ↓
  2. Catholic catechisms that denied it

    before 1870

    Philip Schaff, an American Protestant historian, pointed to Catholic teaching books that said the opposite before 1870.

    He cites a German catechism, a question-and-answer summary of the faith, saying that papal infallibility is no article of faith. He also cites Keenan's Controversial Catechism, which called it a Protestant invention in editions before 1871.

    Before 1870 the doctrine was widely held but not defined. Catholics such as the French Gallicans could deny it and remain in the Church.

    “popular Catechisms of the Roman Church, extensively used till 1870, expressly denied the doctrine, which is now set up as an article of faith necessary to eternal salvation.”
  3. Before defining, Pius IX asks the bishops

    1849

    Pius IX wanted to define the Immaculate Conception, the teaching that Mary was free from sin from the moment she was conceived. In 1849 he wrote from Gaeta, where he had fled from Rome, to every Catholic bishop.

    He asked what their people believed, and what they thought of a definition. He defined it in 1854.

    This is the pattern the minority wanted written into the definition. It is also what happened both times the power has clearly been used.

    “on February 2, 1849,[27] we sent an Encyclical Letter from Gaeta to all our venerable brethren, the bishops of the Catholic world, that they should offer prayers to God and then tell us in writing what the piety an devotion of their faithful was in regard to the Immaculate Conception of the Mother of God.”
    HistoricalIneffabilis Deus, Apostolic Constitution defining the Immaculate ConceptionIneffabilis Deus (8 December 1854), paragraph on the consultation of 1849The evidence ↓
  4. Hefele's case from Chalcedon

    May 1870

    Bishop Hefele of Rottenburg wrote a standard history of the councils.

    In the general debate he pointed to a letter Pope Leo I wrote to Flavian, bishop of Constantinople, on how Christ is both God and man. He argued it was as solemn as any papal teaching could be.

    Yet the Council of Chalcedon in 451 examined that letter before accepting it. On his reading, the bishops judged the pope.

    The Archbishop of Saragossa replied that Leo had told his envoys to allow no change, and none was made. Hefele also pressed the case of Pope Honorius, told in the chapter on bad popes.

    “at the Council all the bishops were called on to declare on oath if it was conformable to the Creeds of Nicaea and Constantinople; therefore they were called on to judge of its orthodoxy”
    HistoricalThe Vatican Council: The Story Told from Inside in Bishop Ullathorne's Letters, vol. IIButler, vol. II, pp. 46-47, summarising Hefele's speech in the general debate (Mansi 52)The evidence ↓
  5. Gasser on the consent of the Church

    11 July 1870

    Gasser, speaking for the drafting committee, answered the minority's central worry. The pope is never cut off from the Church's agreement, he said.

    The definition only refuses to make that agreement a legal condition, before or after. The reason is that the Church's agreement to a true definition cannot fail.

    The Second Vatican Council would repeat the point and cite his speech for it.

    “we do not in the least separate the Pope from the consent of the Church, provided that consent be not put as a condition, be it antecedent or consequent consent. We cannot separate the Pope from the consent of the Church because this consent can never be withheld.”
    InferenceThe Vatican Council: The Story Told from Inside in Bishop Ullathorne's Letters, vol. IIButler, vol. II, p. 137, summary of Gasser's relatio of 11 July 1870The evidence ↓
  6. Five words added at the last moment

    16 July 1870

    Two days before the final vote, the council adopted an amendment that some bishops of the majority had asked for. Schaff says Spanish bishops proposed it.

    The clause 'not by the consent of the Church' was added to the end of the definition. Butler, a Catholic historian, judged that it made the text harder for the minority to accept.

    The majority's aim was to shut out the Gallican article of 1682.

    “The Council, following the lead of the deputation de Fide, instead of conciliating added at the last moment the clause 'non autem ex consensu ecclesiae', making the definition still more unacceptable to the Minority.”
  7. Chapter 3: obedience in government too

    18 July 1870

    The chapter on the pope's first place, his primacy, goes further than faith and morals. It binds clergy and faithful to the pope's authority in church discipline and government, across the whole Church.

    The Old Catholics at Utrecht rejected this 'universal episcopate' alongside infallibility. By that phrase they meant the pope acting as bishop over every church.

    “Both clergy and faithful, of whatever rite and dignity, both singly and collectively, are bound to submit to this power by the duty of hierarchical subordination and true obedience, and this not only in matters concerning faith and morals, but also in those which regard the discipline and government of the church throughout the world.”
  8. Chapter 4: no new doctrine

    18 July 1870

    Before it defines anything, chapter 4 limits what a pope may do.

    It says popes have defined doctrine by calling councils, by consulting the churches and through synods, which are church meetings. They always drew on Scripture and the tradition of the apostles.

    The gift exists to guard what was handed down, not to add to it.

    “For the holy Spirit was promised to the successors of Peter not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new doctrine, but that, by his assistance, they might religiously guard and faithfully expound the revelation or deposit of faith transmitted by the apostles.”
  9. Chapter 4: the definition and its four conditions

    18 July 1870

    Read the conditions before the conclusion. The pope must speak as shepherd and teacher of all Christians. He must use his supreme authority as successor of the apostle Peter.

    The matter must be faith or morals. He must define it as a teaching to be held by the whole Church.

    Only then does the protection apply.

    “we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals. Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.”
  10. Constantinople answers Leo XIII

    1895

    Pope Leo XIII invited the Orthodox to reunion, and in 1895 the Patriarchate of Constantinople replied.

    It wrote that the early Church's great teachers and councils of the first nine centuries never treated the bishop of Rome as the infallible head of the Church. It listed popes it held had erred, Honorius among them.

    It called 1870 a widening of the gulf between the Churches.

    “The orthodox Eastern and catholic Church of Christ, with the exception of the Son and Word of God, who was ineffably made man, knows no one infallible upon earth.”
  11. Before 1950, Pius XII asks every bishop

    1 May 1946

    In 1950 Pius XII defined the Assumption: Mary was taken body and soul into heaven. He did it in the full form of 1870, by his 'own authority'.

    Four years earlier he wrote to every bishop with two questions. The answer, he reported, was almost unanimous.

    The pope spoke alone, but only after checking that he spoke for the Church.

    “Do you, venerable brethren, in your outstanding wisdom and prudence, judge that the bodily Assumption of the Blessed Virgin can be proposed and defined as a dogma of faith? Do you, with your clergy and people, desire it?”
    HistoricalMunificentissimus Deus, Apostolic Constitution defining the AssumptionMunificentissimus Deus (1 November 1950), paragraph 11The evidence ↓
  12. Vatican II repeats Gasser

    21 November 1964

    Lumen Gentium is the Second Vatican Council's teaching on the Church. Its section 25 restates the 1870 definition, including the phrase 'of themselves, and not from the consent of the Church'.

    It adds the explanation Gasser had given the bishops, with a footnote citing his speech.

    It also places the pope's teaching inside the college of bishops, all the bishops together as one body. With him, that body teaches without error at a council of the whole Church.

    “To these definitions the assent of the Church can never be wanting, on account of the activity of that same Holy Spirit, by which the whole flock of Christ is preserved and progresses in unity of faith.”
Every claim this chapter leans on11 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The First Vatican Council was announced in 1864, two days before Pius IX published the Syllabus of Errors, and met while the Papal States were being lost. By the end of 1860 the pope held only Rome and its surroundings. The council was summoned by the bull Aeterni Patris of 29 June 1868 and opened on 8 December 1869; about 1,050 prelates were entitled to attend and 774 came at some point.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Pope Pius IX', section 'Intrigues against the Papal States (1858-1878)'
    “After defeating the papal army at Castelfidardo on 18 September, and at Ancona on 30 September, he deprived the pope of all his possessions with the exception of Rome and the immediate vicinity.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', section 'Previous to the official convocation'
    “On 6 December, 1864, two days before the publication of the Syllabus, Pius IX announced, at a session of the Congregation of Rites, his intention to call a general council .”
  • Syllabus of Errors, proposition 80 (condemned)
    “The Roman Pontiff can, and ought to, reconcile himself, and come to terms with progress, liberalism and modern civilization.”
  • Editorial introduction (Tanner) on the papalencyclicals.net page
    “This council was summoned by Pope Pius IX by the bull Aeterni Patris of 29 June 1868. The first session was held in St Peter’s basilica on 8 December 1869 in the presence and under the presidency of the pope.”
  • Editorial introduction (Tanner)
    “Very large numbers attended this council, including, for the first time, bishops from outside Europe and its neighbouring lands. Bishops from the eastern Orthodox churches were also invited, but did not come.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', on attendance
    “There were in the entire world approximately one thousand and fifty prelates entitled to take part in the council, and of these no less than seven hundred and seventy-four appeared during the course of the proceedings.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', on the preparatory drafts
    “Not a single one of the numerous drafts drawn up by the preparatory commission bore on papal infallibility .”
Other readings
  • Philip Schaff (1877) read the council as convoked 'to proclaim his own infallibility'; the Catholic Encyclopedia answers that none of the preparatory drafts touched infallibility and that the question was brought in by petitions during the council.
Limits
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia articles are Catholic reference works of about 1910 and take the papal side of the Roman Question.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia's 'Pope Pius IX' article dates Aeterni Patris to 1869; its 'Vatican Council' article and Tanner's introduction give 29 June 1868, which is followed here.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

About a fifth of the council opposed defining papal infallibility. Most argued that a definition was inopportune rather than that the doctrine was false; a few, such as Bishop Hefele of Rottenburg, argued from history that it was untenable, citing Chalcedon's examination of Leo's letter and the case of Honorius. Newman, outside the council, wrote in January 1870 that a definition would needlessly burden the faithful.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Philip Schaff (1877) held that the minority 'broke down by its own act of cowardice' in leaving Rome instead of voting no; Catholic historians such as Butler present the departure as a courteous refusal to vote against the pope to his face.
  • Schaff notes that the address of the German bishops argued from 'the contradiction of history and tradition', so the minority's objection was not everywhere only one of timing.
Limits
  • Hefele's speech is known here through Butler's English summary, not through the Latin text in Mansi.
  • Newman's letter is quoted from the text Butler printed; Schaff prints a slightly different text taken from the Standard of 7 April 1870.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

On 24 April 1870 the council unanimously adopted Dei Filius, the Dogmatic Constitution on the Catholic Faith. It teaches that God can be known with certainty from created things by the natural power of human reason, and that there can never be any real disagreement between faith and reason, because the same God gives both.

Rests on
  • Session 3 (24 April 1870), Dei Filius, chapter 2
    “The same holy mother church holds and teaches that God, the source and end of all things, can be known with certainty from the consideration of created things, by the natural power of human reason”
  • Session 3, Dei Filius, chapter 4
    “Even though faith is above reason, there can never be any real disagreement between faith and reason, since it is the same God who reveals the mysteries and infuses faith, and who has endowed the human mind with the light of reason.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', section 'Completion of the First Constitution'
    “On 24 April, the first Constitution, "De fide catholica", was unanimously adopted in the third public session by the 667 fathers present, and was formally confirmed and promulgated by the pope .”
Other readings
  • The same chapter 4 forbids Catholics to defend as scientific conclusions opinions known to be contrary to the doctrine of faith; critics read this as subordinating reason to Church authority, while Catholics read it as a claim that truth cannot contradict truth.
Limits
  • The English is Tanner's translation as printed on papalencyclicals.net; the Latin text is authoritative.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04InferenceEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

On 11 July 1870 Bishop Vinzenz Gasser of Brixen, speaking for the drafting committee, explained the definition in a speech of nearly four hours. He said papal infallibility is personal only in the sense that it belongs to the pope as a public person teaching the whole Church, that it is in no sense absolute, and that the pope is not separated from the Church's consent, which is simply not made a legal condition.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The minority accepted most of this explanation but wanted it written into the definition itself (for example, 'using the counsel and seeking the help of the universal Church'); the committee refused on the ground that such a condition was vague.
  • Gasser also said that consulting the bishops before a definition, as for the Immaculate Conception, is sometimes wise but 'cannot be set up as the rule'; the minority wanted exactly that rule.
Limits
  • Butler says he gives 'a somewhat full analysis' of the speech: the words are his English summary and translation of the Latin in Mansi 52, 1204ff, not a complete translation. James T. O'Connor's full translation (The Gift of Infallibility, 1986) could not be read.
  • A relatio explains the mind of the drafting committee; it is not itself part of the defined text.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

On 13 July 1870, 601 fathers voted on the constitution on the Church: 451 placet, 88 non placet, 62 placet iuxta modum. On 17 July the minority bishops signed a letter (fifty-five signatures on Butler's count from the acts, fifty-six on Schaff's) saying their votes stood and that they would not vote non placet in the pope's presence, and left Rome. On 18 July the constitution passed 533 to 2; the two, Bishop Riccio of Caiazzo and Bishop Edward Fitzgerald of Little Rock, accepted it at once.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Schaff counts fifty-six signatures on the minority's letter; Butler, working from Mansi, counts fifty-five, with six more bishops sending separate letters (sixty-one in all).
Limits
  • The newadvent.org transcription of the Catholic Encyclopedia article 'Vatican Council' gives 435 present and 433 placet on 18 July. Butler (from Mansi and Ullathorne's same-day letter) and Schaff both give 535 present and 533 placet; the newadvent figures appear to be a slip.
  • Schaff places Caiazzo 'in Sicily'; it was in the mainland Kingdom of Naples, as Butler says.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Franco-Prussian War broke out the day after the vote of 18 July 1870. The French garrison left Rome on 20 July, Italian troops entered Rome through the breach at the Porta Pia on 20 September, and on 20 October Pius IX suspended the council indefinitely with the bull Postquam Dei munere. It was never resumed and never formally closed.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Schaff (1877) read the war and the fall of Rome as 'swift retribution of criminal ambition'; Catholic writers read them as a political catastrophe unconnected with the truth of the decrees.
Limits
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia calls the Italian army 'the enemy' and takes the papal side of the Roman Question.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Ignaz von Döllinger refused to accept the decrees in a declaration of 28 March 1871 and was excommunicated in April 1871. Some of his followers formed the Old Catholic churches; Döllinger himself stood apart from them. In 1889 the Old Catholic bishops at Utrecht rejected the Vatican decrees on infallibility and universal jurisdiction while acknowledging a historic primacy of honour for Rome.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Catholic sources of the time called the Old Catholics a 'sect'; the Old Catholic churches regard themselves as the continuation of the Catholic faith of the undivided Church.
Limits
  • Döllinger's declaration is known here through Butler's English summary and Schaff's German text, not a full English translation.
  • Butler and Schaff date the excommunication 17 April 1871; the Catholic Encyclopedia says Archbishop von Scherr excommunicated him publicly on 18 April.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

Pastor Aeternus chapter 3 gives the pope ordinary and immediate jurisdiction over every church, in discipline and government as well as faith and morals, while saying this does not detract from the bishops' own power. In 1875 the German bishops, answering Bismarck, declared that the episcopate exists by the same divine institution as the papacy and that bishops are not mere tools of the pope; Pius IX endorsed their reading. Newman wrote in 1875 that conscience comes first.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Old Catholic bishops at Utrecht (1889) rejected the 'universal episcopate or ecclesiastical plenitude of power of the Roman Pope' as destroying the ancient constitution of the Church.
  • Bismarck's government read chapter 3 as making bishops papal delegates; the German bishops and Pius IX denied that reading.
Limits
  • The German bishops' declaration and Pius IX's letter are quoted from a 2022 EWTN News article; the full texts (DH 3112-3117) were not found on a reachable page. The CDF document of 1998 confirms that the declaration exists and is cited by the Holy See.
  • Newman's toast concerns obedience to papal commands, not assent to defined doctrine; he wrote it to answer Gladstone.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

Pastor Aeternus chapter 4 defines that the pope is protected from error only when he speaks ex cathedra: as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, with his supreme apostolic authority, defining a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the whole Church. The same chapter says the Spirit was not promised so that popes could make known new doctrine. The words 'and not by the consent of the church' were added on 16 July 1870 to exclude the Gallican article of 1682. Lumen Gentium 25 and the Catechism repeat the definition and its limits.

Rests on
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4, the definition
    “we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a …”
    Read the full passage
    “we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals. Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4
    “For the holy Spirit was promised to the successors of Peter not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new doctrine, but that, by his assistance, they might religiously guard and faithfully expound the revelation or deposit of faith transmitted by the apostles.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Gallicanism', Declaration of 1682, article 4
    “Although the pope have the chief part in questions of faith , and his decrees apply to all the Churches, and to each Church in particular, yet his judgment is not irreformable, at least pending the consent of the Church .”
  • Butler, vol. II, p. 157
    “The Council, following the lead of the deputation de Fide, instead of conciliating added at the last moment the clause 'non autem ex consensu ecclesiae', making the definition still more unacceptable to the Minority.”
  • Butler, vol. II, p. 146
    “they were bent on killing the Gallican ex consensu ecclesiae”
  • Lumen Gentium 25
    “To these definitions the assent of the Church can never be wanting, on account of the activity of that same Holy Spirit, by which the whole flock of Christ is preserved and progresses in unity of faith.”
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church 891
    “This infallibility extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself.”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox and Old Catholics read 'not by the consent of the church' as separating the pope from the body of bishops; Catholic teaching, following Gasser and Lumen Gentium 25, reads it as denying only that a definition needs later ratification.
  • Schaff (1877) argued that even within the definition there is 'room for controversy' over what counts as ex cathedra and how far 'faith and morals' extends.
Limits
  • The English of Pastor Aeternus is Tanner's translation; the Latin is authoritative.
  • The definition does not list which past papal documents meet its conditions.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

The Orthodox reject the definition as unknown to the first nine centuries: Constantinople's encyclical of 1895 says the Church knows no one infallible on earth except Christ. Protestants, in Philip Schaff's words, see it as the opposite of the supremacy of Scripture, and Schaff documented Catholic catechisms that denied the doctrine before 1870. Anglicans question whether a definition made without a council can bind belief.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Catholic reply is that Pastor Aeternus itself argues from first-millennium texts, including the profession of faith of the Fourth Council of Constantinople (869-870), whose words come from Pope Hormisdas's formula of 517, and that a council may define what the Church had held without defining it.
Limits
  • Schaff writes as a polemical Protestant historian; his claim about catechisms is documented in his note 348 by Overberg's German catechism and Keenan's Controversial Catechism, which were not themselves read.
  • The 1895 encyclical answers Leo XIII's invitation to reunion and is itself polemical in places.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

11HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

The Catholic Church has no official list of ex cathedra definitions. The Marian definitions of 1854 and 1950 are the clearest cases, and in both the pope first consulted the world's bishops. Bishop Fessler, secretary of the council, whose reading Pius IX praised, found only a few papal definitions in history; Manning read the definition far more widely; the theologian Dublanchy counted twelve before 1870.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Manning and others of the majority read 'define' broadly, to include dogmatic facts, censures and canonisations; Fessler and later theologians such as Choupin and Dublanchy read it strictly.
  • The Syllabus of 1864 was widely defended as ex cathedra in the 1860s and 1870s; Dublanchy (1923) reports that view as almost abandoned.
Limits
  • No saved page gives a count for the years since 1930; the statement that 1854 and 1950 are the clearest cases rests on their solemn form and on ARCIC's reading of them together with Pastor Aeternus.
  • Dublanchy's list is known here only through Butler's report of it.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next