Portrait of Martin Luther by Lucas Cranach the Elder, 1528.
IX / XI
1517–1650

The Reformation

In 1517 Martin Luther, a friar and professor at Wittenberg who had long been terrified of God’s judgement, protests against the way indulgences are being sold. An indulgence is the Church’s release from punishment still owed for sins already forgiven, and preachers were selling them for donations as if a soul could be bought out of purgatory.

The protest becomes a split over who has authority in the Church, how a sinner is put right with God, and what the sacraments are.

Others break away too, each in their own way: Zwingli and Calvin in Switzerland, the Anabaptists, who baptise only adult believers, and Henry VIII, who makes himself head of the Church in England. Knox carries Calvin’s reform to Scotland, and English Separatists gather churches of their own.

Calls for Catholic reform had begun before Luther. The Council of Trent, from 1545, answers the reformers on doctrine and fixes the abuses that gave them their case, with seminaries to train priests.

Both sides also kill for their faith, and the wars of religion only end, in exhaustion, in 1648.

The world: Age of exploration · wars of religion
Martin Luther, painted by his friend Lucas Cranach in 1528.
31 October 1517 · Wittenberg
“They preach man who say that so soon as the penny jingles into the money-box, the soul flies out of purgatory. … Every truly repentant Christian has a right to full remission of penalty and guilt, even without letters of pardon. … The true treasure of the Church is the Most Holy Gospel of the glory and the grace of God. ”
Disputation on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences (the Ninety-five Theses) · Theses 27, 36 and 62
The bronze theses door of the Castle Church, Wittenberg.
The 1858 bronze doors of the Castle Church, Wittenberg, cast with the text of the theses.
1517Historical

Luther's Ninety-five Theses

In 1517 an indulgence was being preached in Germany for the rebuilding of St Peter's in Rome. By a secret deal, half the money repaid Archbishop Albert of Mainz's bankers, who had lent him the fees for being bishop of three places at once.

The preachers told people that a soul flew out of purgatory when the coin rang, which is not what the Church teaches an indulgence is.

On 31 October Martin Luther, a friar, professor and pastor at Wittenberg, sent the archbishop 95 theses for debate. They were printed and spread across Germany within weeks.

Within four years an argument about indulgences had become an argument about the authority of popes and councils, how a sinner is saved, and the sacraments, and Western Christianity split.

What the Church says

The Church still teaches indulgences: ‘a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven’ (CCC 1471). In 1563 the Council of Trent abolished all profit-making from them.

The Church excommunicated Luther in 1521. Leo X's bull of 1520 also condemned his statement ‘That heretics be burned is against the will of the Spirit’.

The Church no longer stands behind that condemnation: since 1965 it teaches that no one may be forced in religion (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

In 1999 the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation declared a shared understanding of the basic truths of justification. In 2016 at Lund, Pope Francis and Lutheran leaders together lamented that they ‘have wounded the visible unity of the Church’.

1517

Real but imperfect communion

By 1500 many Catholics agreed the Western Church needed reform. Indulgences, grants from the Church that cancel the punishment still due for sins already forgiven, were being preached for money. Printing could now spread an argument across Germany in weeks.

In 1517 one such campaign near Wittenberg, in Saxony, was paying off Archbishop Albert of Mainz, who had borrowed to buy his post. Martin Luther, a friar who taught the Bible at the university, wrote to the archbishop and published 95 theses for debate.

The quarrel soon turned to a deeper question: how is a sinner made right with God? Luther came to read St Paul as saying it is God’s gift, received by faith. “All at once I felt that I had been born again,” he wrote.

What we still share
  • The creeds, and the Bible as “the sole rule and standard” by which teaching is judged (*Formula of Concord*, a Lutheran statement of faith of 1577).
  • Baptism, which the Catholic Church recognises when “duly administered as Our Lord instituted it” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • Christ really present in the Lord’s Supper: “the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed” to those who receive it (*Augsburg Confession* X).
  • Confession to a pastor: “Private Absolution ought to be retained in the churches” (*Augsburg Confession* XI).
How they describe it

Lutherans see their church as the catholic Church reformed, not a new one. The *Augsburg Confession* insists that it teaches nothing contrary to the ancient Church, and only corrects abuses that had crept in.

What it cost
  • The Edict of Worms outlaws Luther and his followers (1521)Suffered by Protestants
  • The first Lutheran martyrs burned in Brussels (1523)Suffered by Protestants
  • Luther tells the princes to strike down the peasants (1525)
  • The peasants crushed (1525)
  • Monasteries and church lands taken over (1520s–1555)Suffered by Catholics
  • The Emperor’s war on the Lutheran princes (1546–47)Suffered by Protestants
  • The ruler’s religion turned against Lutherans: Inner Austria (1579–80)Suffered by Protestants
  • Lutheran rulers persecute the Anabaptists (1520s–1530s)Between Protestants
1520s

Real but imperfect communion

Zurich in the 1520s was a self-governing Swiss city run by its council. Its preacher, Huldrych Zwingli, a priest and scholar, began preaching straight through Matthew’s Gospel in the main church in 1519.

In January 1523 the council held a public debate before about six hundred people. Zwingli’s first thesis: “All who say that the gospel is nothing without the approbation of the Church, err and cast reproach upon God.” The council, not the bishop, ruled for him.

Within two years Zurich had stripped its churches of pictures, relics, crucifixes and altars and replaced the Mass with a plain communion service at tables. To the reformers this was obedience to the commandment against images; to Catholics, it was the destruction of holy things.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the creeds and the Bible.
  • Baptism, which the Catholic Church recognises (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • A high place for preaching: “the preaching of the holy gospel” is the first key of the kingdom (*Heidelberg Catechism* 83, 1563).
How they describe it

Reformed Christians hold that they brought worship and church order back to what the Bible teaches, clearing away additions of the Middle Ages.

What it cost
  • Zurich strips its churches and ends the Mass (1524–25)Suffered by Catholics
  • War between the cantons; Zwingli killed at Kappel (1531)Suffered by Protestants
  • Geneva bans the Mass and the nuns leave (1535–36)Suffered by Catholics
  • Geneva burns Michael Servetus (1553)
  • France’s wars of religion: Wassy and the Michelade (1562–67)
  • The iconoclastic fury in the Netherlands (1566)Suffered by Catholics
  • Alba’s Council of Troubles (1567–73)Suffered by Protestants
  • The martyrs of Gorkum (1572)Suffered by Catholics
  • The St Bartholomew’s Day massacre (1572)Suffered by Protestants
  • Dragonnades and the end of the Edict of Nantes (1681–1685)Suffered by Protestants
1525

Real but imperfect communion

In the 1520s church and society were one. Every baby was baptised into both, and the ruler kept order in both.

In Zurich a circle of young men read the Greek New Testament with the city’s reformer, Zwingli, among them Conrad Grebel and Felix Manz.

They came to want more than Zwingli did: a church of adults who chose to join, with no help from the state and no force. In 1524 Grebel wrote: “One should also not protect the gospel and its adherents with the sword, nor themselves.”

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the Bible, and following Jesus in daily life.
  • Baptism “in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Mennonite Confession, article 11), which the Catholic Church recognises when properly given (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22; Ecumenical Directory 93).
  • A concern for peace. Mennonites and Catholics wrote together *Called Together to be Peacemakers* (2003).
How they describe it

Anabaptists see themselves as a return to the free church of the New Testament. It is a church people join by choice and that does not use the sword, as the Church was before it became bound up with the Roman state.

What it cost
  • Felix Manz drowned by Protestant Zurich, 1527Between Protestants
  • Zurich keeps Anabaptism a capital crime, 1530 to 1614Between Protestants
  • Burned by Catholic authorities in the Netherlands, 1544Suffered by Protestants
  • Radical Anabaptists seize Münster, 1534Suffered by Catholics
  • Siege, torture and the cages of St Lambert's, 1534 to 1536Suffered by Protestants
  • Oude Klooster and Menno's turn to non-violence, 1535 to 1539
1534

Real but imperfect communion

Henry VIII married Catherine of Aragon, his elder brother’s widow, in 1509, with the pope’s permission to set aside the church rule against such a match. Only one of their children, Mary, survived, and no woman had yet reigned in England in her own right.

From about 1527 Henry asked Pope Clement VII to annul the marriage, to rule it had never been valid, so he could marry Anne Boleyn. Historians still argue whether he wanted a son more than he wanted Anne.

Clement was then in the power of Catherine’s nephew, Emperor Charles V, and in 1529 he called the case to Rome.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the creeds and the Bible.
  • Baptism, which the Catholic Church recognises (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • A special closeness: Vatican II said that among the communities that came out of the Reformation, “the Anglican Communion occupies a special place” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 13).
  • Bishops, priests and deacons, the three orders kept in the Anglican rite of ordination.
How they describe it

Anglicans see their church as both catholic and reformed: the Church planted in England in the 500s, reformed in the 1500s, which kept its bishops and its ancient creeds.

What it cost
  • Fisher and More, 1535Suffered by Catholics
  • The London Carthusians, 1535–40Suffered by Catholics
  • The Pilgrimage of Grace crushed, 1536–37Suffered by Catholics
  • Monks, nuns and servants turned out, 1536–40Suffered by Catholics
  • Shrines, relics and libraries destroyed, 1538Suffered by Catholics
  • The abbots of Glastonbury, Reading and Colchester, 1539Suffered by Catholics
  • Reformers burned under the Six Articles, 1539–46Suffered by Protestants
  • The Western Rising, 1549Suffered by Catholics
  • Radicals burned by a Protestant government, 1550
  • Mary and Elizabeth reverse each other, 1555–1603
A sixteenth-century drawing of the drowning of Felix Manz in the Limmat at Zurich, 1527.
The drowning of Felix Manz at Zurich, 5 January 1527, from Heinrich Thomann’s chronicle.
1527Historical

Anabaptists killed by both sides

Some Reformation Christians read the Bible and concluded that baptism was only for believing adults, that the church should be a free gathering, and that Christians shouldn't swear oaths or bear arms. Because they baptised adults again, they were called Anabaptists, ‘rebaptisers’. Rulers fresh from the Peasants' War saw them as rebels.

Protestant Zurich drowned Felix Manz in January 1527. In May a Catholic court at Rottenburg had Michael Sattler, a former Benedictine prior who wrote their articles of faith, tortured and burned, and the women with him drowned. Both sides killed the movement's first generation.

It survived as the Mennonites, Hutterites and Amish, and in 2010 Lutherans asked their forgiveness.

“In the case of the Governor of his Imperial Majesty versus Michael Sattler, judgment is passed, that Michael Sattler shall be delivered to the executioner, who shall lead him to the place of execution, and cut out his tongue; then throw him upon a wagon, and there tear his body twice with red hot tongs; and after he has been brought without the gate, he …”
The Bloody Theatre or Martyrs Mirror: the trial and execution of Michael Sattler · Martyrs Mirror, the sentence at Rottenburg, 1527
What the Church says

Killing people for their faith is against the Church's own teaching: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). Vatican II admitted ways of acting ‘hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel’ (DH 12).

In 2000 John Paul II asked God's forgiveness ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’. In 2001 Cardinal Kasper told Mennonites: ‘I surely regret those instances when this took place in Catholic societies.’

The Church still holds that baptism given to infants is true baptism and ‘cannot be repeated’ (CCC 1272). It counts baptised Mennonites as brothers and sisters in Christ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).

Hans Holbein’s portrait of King Henry VIII.
Henry VIII, painted by Hans Holbein the Younger around 1537.
1527–35Historical

Henry VIII breaks with Rome

Henry VIII had been married to Catherine of Aragon since 1509. Only a daughter, Mary, survived, and Henry feared that without a son England could fall back into civil war over the throne.

From 1527 he asked Pope Clement VII to annul the marriage, that is, to declare it had never been valid, so that he could marry Anne Boleyn. Clement, whose Rome had just been sacked by the troops of Catherine's nephew, the Emperor Charles V, would not.

So Henry broke with Rome. In 1533 his own Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, annulled the marriage, and in November 1534 Parliament declared the king ‘the only supreme head in earth of the church of England’. Denying it became treason.

In 1535 three Carthusian priors were hanged at Tyburn, and Bishop John Fisher and Sir Thomas More were beheaded.

“the king our sovereign lord, his heirs and successors, kings of this realm, shall be taken, accepted, and reputed the only supreme head in earth of the church of England, called Anglicana Ecclesia”
Act of Supremacy (1534), 26 Henry VIII c. 1 · Act of Supremacy, 26 Henry VIII c. 1 (November 1534)
What the Church says

The Church honours John Fisher and Thomas More as saints and martyrs, canonised together in 1935; in 2000 John Paul II named More patron of statesmen and politicians. The Carthusian priors hanged in 1535 were canonised in 1970 among the Forty Martyrs of England and Wales.

The Church holds that the authority they died for, the pope's authority over the whole Church, was given by Christ (Lumen Gentium 22).

It also teaches that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That judges every burning in this story, the Catholic ones included.

A painting of the ruins of Glastonbury Abbey.
The ruins of Glastonbury Abbey, dissolved in 1539, its last abbot hanged on the Tor above the town.
1536–40Historical

Henry VIII dissolves the monasteries

In 1535 England's monasteries, convents and friaries still fed many of the poor and held a large share of the land, and Henry VIII, newly head of the Church, needed money. Thomas Cromwell, the king's deputy in church matters, sent inspectors whose reports accused many monks and nuns of immorality.

In 1536 Parliament gave the king every house worth less than £200 a year, saying that ‘manifest sin’ was rife in the small houses while in the great ones religion was ‘right well kept’. Within four years the great houses were gone too.

The north rose in 1536 to save the abbeys, in the Pilgrimage of Grace, and was put down with executions of leaders, abbots and monks. Shrines such as Thomas Becket's at Canterbury were stripped.

In 1539 the abbots of Glastonbury, Reading and Colchester were executed. By one Catholic historian's count about 8,000 monks, friars and nuns lost their homes; the land went to the Crown, and much of it was sold on to courtiers and gentry.

“considering also that divers and great solemn monasteries of this realm, wherein (thanks be to God) religion is right well kept and observed, be destitute of such full numbers of religious persons, as they ought and may keep”
Act for the Dissolution of the Lesser Monasteries (1536), 27 Henry VIII c. 28 · Act for the Dissolution of the Lesser Monasteries, 27 Henry VIII c. 28, preamble (Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (1896), No. LXI, p. 258)
What the Church says

The Church honours as martyrs the abbots executed in 1539 for resisting, Richard Whiting of Glastonbury and the abbots of Reading and Colchester, and beatified them, declaring them blessed, in the 1890s.

It holds that consecrated life, the vows of poverty, chastity and obedience lived in community, belongs to the life and holiness of the Church (Lumen Gentium 44). Mary briefly restored a few houses in the 1550s.

Most religious communities came back only around 1800, when monks and nuns fleeing the French Revolution settled in England.

Pasquale Cati, The Council of Trent, 1588, Santa Maria in Trastevere.
The Council of Trent, painted by Pasquale Cati in 1588.
1545–63Historical

Council of Trent

By 1545 much of Germany, Scandinavia and England had left the Catholic Church, and a council had been put off for 25 years by wars between the emperor and the king of France, papal hesitation and Protestant refusal. Pope Paul III finally opened one at Trent, in the Alps, and it met on and off for 18 years.

It answered the Protestant positions on Scripture and tradition, how we are saved, the seven sacraments, the Mass, purgatory and the saints. It also fixed the abuses that had provoked them: bishops had to live in their dioceses, seminaries were founded to train priests, and profiteering from indulgences was abolished.

“The use of Indulgences, for the Christian people most salutary, and approved of by the authority of sacred Councils, is to be retained in the Church … all evil gains for the obtaining thereof, whence a most prolific cause of abuses amongst the Christian people has been derived, be wholly abolished.”
Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent · Session XXV, Decree concerning Indulgences
What the Church says

The Church counts Trent as the 19th ecumenical council, and its doctrinal decrees remain Catholic teaching.

In 1999 the Joint Declaration stated that Trent's condemnations on justification do not apply to Lutheran teaching as the declaration presents it, while they remain ‘salutary warnings’ for both sides.

Channels that rejoined

Five unions with Rome, and one Church that holds it never left

1553 to 1646
1553from the Church of the East channel

The election of John Sulaqa

The Church of the East is the ancient Church of Iraq and Persia. From 1450 its patriarch's office passed inside one family, from uncle to nephew. In 1552 a group of its bishops broke with that and elected a monk, Yuhannan Sulaqa, instead.

Read the full footprint→
no union actno act of union

The Church with no act of union

From the 1400s Albanian Christians fleeing the Ottoman conquest settled in southern Italy and Sicily, keeping their Byzantine liturgy. They never signed any act of union with Rome.

Read the full footprint→
1595–96from the Eastern Orthodox channel

The Union of Brest

By the late 1500s the Orthodox of Ukraine and Belarus, then called Ruthenians, lived under Catholic Poland, and their Church was losing ground to both Protestants and Polish Catholicism. Some of their bishops saw union with Rome as a way to keep their own tradition.

Read the full footprint→
1599from the Church of the East channel

The Synod of Diamper

The St Thomas Christians of south India trace their faith to the apostle Thomas. For centuries they received their bishops from the Church of the East, and from the 1550s from its Chaldean patriarch, who was in communion with Rome.

Read the full footprint→
1611from the Eastern Orthodox channel

The union at Marča

Croatia's Byzantine-rite Catholics today trace their Church back to Orthodox refugees. Around 1600 Serbs fleeing Ottoman lands settled on the Habsburg military frontier in Croatia, a belt of forts facing the Ottoman Empire. They were Orthodox.

Read the full footprint→
1646from the Eastern Orthodox channel

The Union of Uzhhorod

Transcarpathia, on the south-western side of the Carpathian mountains, was ruled partly by Catholic Hungary and partly by the Protestant princes of Transylvania. Its Rusyn people were Orthodox.

Read the full footprint→
Woodcut from Foxe’s Book of Martyrs of the burning of Latimer and Ridley at Oxford, 1555.
The burning of Latimer and Ridley at Oxford, 1555, as Foxe’s Book of Martyrs printed it.
1555–58Historical

Mary I burns the reformers

Mary Tudor, Henry VIII's daughter by Catherine of Aragon, had seen her mother set aside and herself declared illegitimate. She became queen of England in 1553 and set out to undo the Protestant reformation of her father and brother.

Parliament revived the old laws against heresy, and England was reconciled to Rome in 1554.

Between 1555 and 1558 about 280 to 290 Protestants were burned, most of them ordinary people, along with bishops Latimer and Ridley at Oxford and Archbishop Cranmer, author of the Book of Common Prayer. It failed.

Foxe's Book of Martyrs made the victims national heroes, and Mary's sister Elizabeth reversed everything. Catholics, in turn, were executed under Henry before her and Elizabeth after her.

“A lighted fagot was now laid at Dr. Ridley's feet, which caused Mr. Latimer to say, "Be of good cheer, Ridley; and play the man. We shall this day, by God's grace, light up such a candle in England, as, I trust, will never be put out."”
Foxe's Book of Martyrs (abridged edition) · Foxe's Book of Martyrs, the burning of Latimer and Ridley, Oxford, October 1555
What the Church says

Killing people for their faith is against the Church's own teaching. The Second Vatican Council declared in 1965 that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

It admitted that ‘there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it’ (Dignitatis Humanae 12). In 2000 John Paul II asked pardon ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.

This was a correction, not a continuity. In Mary's day church law handed convicted heretics to the state for punishment, and in 1520 Leo X had condemned the statement ‘That heretics be burned is against the will of the Spirit’.

An engraving of John Knox leaning out of a high pulpit, preaching with raised arm to seated Scottish lords and ladies, while bishops in mitres watch from the left.
John Knox preaching to the Protestant lords on 10 June 1559, in George Thomas Doo's engraving of David Wilkie's 1832 painting. Fourteen months later Scotland's Parliament broke with Rome.
1560Historical

Scotland's Parliament breaks with Rome

In the 1550s Scotland was a Catholic kingdom allied to France against England. Its queen, Mary, lived in France, and her French mother, Mary of Guise, ruled as regent.

Church courts had burned Protestant preachers, among them George Wishart in 1546, and Protestant conspirators had murdered Cardinal Beaton, partly in revenge. Protestant nobles, calling themselves the Lords of the Congregation, bound themselves together in 1557.

In May 1559 the preacher John Knox came home from exile. After his sermon at Perth a crowd wrecked the town's churches and friaries, and the quarrel became a war, which the Protestants won with English help.

The regent died in June 1560, and in August a Parliament met without any summons from the queen. On 17 August it ratified a Confession of Faith drawn up by Knox and other ministers. On 24 August it passed three acts.

The pope was to have ‘no jurisdiction nor authority within this realm’; the old laws protecting the Church were repealed; and anyone who said or heard Mass faced the loss of all goods, then banishment, then death. Mary never ratified the acts. They were re-enacted in 1567, after she was forced to abdicate.

“the three estates, understanding that the jurisdiction and authority of the bishop of Rome, called the pope, used within this realm in times past, has not only been contumelious to the eternal God, but also very hurtful and prejudicial to our sovereign's authority and commonwealth of this realm; therefore have statute and ordained that the bishop of Rome …”
Concerning the abolishing of the pope and his usurped authority (A1567/12/1, re-enacting the act of 24 August 1560) · Act of 24 August 1560, as re-enacted in December 1567 (RPS A1567/12/1)
What the Church says

The Church does not blame today's Presbyterians for the break of 1560. Those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’, and the Church embraces them ‘as brothers, with respect and affection’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). Dialogue with them began in 1970.

It honours St John Ogilvie as a martyr. Canonising him in 1976, Paul VI hoped his memory would soothe, not reopen, the wounds of religious violence.

The Church now teaches that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That judges the Mass Act, and the burnings of Hamilton, Wishart and Myln under laws the Church then upheld.

1560

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Reformed channel

Sixteenth-century Scotland was a small kingdom allied with Catholic France against England. Its bishops burned Protestant preachers: Patrick Hamilton in 1528, George Wishart in 1546. Months after Wishart’s death, a band of men murdered Cardinal Beaton in his castle at St Andrews.

John Knox, a Catholic priest turned Protestant, had guarded Wishart with a two-handed sword. He joined the killers in the castle and became their preacher. When French ships took it in 1547, he spent at least nineteen months chained in the galleys.

In exile at Geneva, where Calvin led the church, Knox found what he thought a truly reformed church. He came home in 1559.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the creeds and the Bible.
  • Baptism, which the Catholic Church recognises (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22). By baptism, the Scots Confession says, “we are engrafted in Christ Jesus”.
  • One Church, “catholic, that is, universal” (Scots Confession 16).
  • Sacraments that are not “naked and bare signs” but real meetings with Christ (Scots Confession 21).
How they describe it

Presbyterians see their church as part of the one catholic Church, reformed by the Word of God, with Christ as its only head, and governed by elders meeting in councils rather than by bishops.

What it cost
  • Hamilton, Wishart and Myln burned at St Andrews (1528–58)Suffered by Protestants
  • Cardinal Beaton murdered in his castle (1546)Suffered by Catholics
  • Perth: altars smashed and friaries sacked (May 1559)Suffered by Catholics
  • The Mass outlawed (1560)Suffered by Catholics
  • St John Ogilvie hanged at Glasgow (1615)Suffered by Catholics
  • No quarter after Philiphaugh (1645) and at Dunaverty (1647)Suffered by Catholics
  • The Killing Time: Presbyterians hunted by an Episcopalian government (1660s–1688)Between Protestants
  • The pope called Antichrist; a campaign against Irish Catholics (1647–2002)Suffered by Catholics
El Greco’s portrait of Pope Pius V.
Pius V, painted by El Greco.
1570Historical

The pope deposes Elizabeth

Elizabeth I had been queen for eleven years. Her laws made her head of the Church of England and fined anyone who stayed away from the parish church, but at first Catholics were only lightly punished.

Then Mary, Queen of Scots, a Catholic claimant to the English throne, fled to England, and in 1569 the Catholic earls of the north rose in her name. The rising failed, and about 600 of its supporters were executed.

On 25 February 1570 Pope Pius V issued a bull, a formal papal letter, declaring Elizabeth a heretic, removing her ‘pretended title’ to the crown, and forbidding her subjects to obey her. He could not enforce it, but it made every English Catholic a possible traitor in the state's eyes, and Parliament answered with treason laws. The Church has since given up any claim to depose rulers.

“And moreover (we declare) her to be deprived of her pretended title to the aforesaid crown and of all lordship, dignity and privilege whatsoever. And also (declare) the nobles, subjects and people of the said realm and all others who have in any way sworn oaths to her, to be forever absolved from such an oath and from any duty arising from lordship, fealty …”
Regnans in Excelsis, excommunicating Elizabeth I · Regnans in Excelsis, 25 February 1570, sections 4–5
What the Church says

The Church no longer claims any power to depose rulers or release subjects from obedience. The Second Vatican Council taught that ‘the Church and the political community in their own fields are autonomous and independent from each other’ (Gaudium et Spes 76).

It also teaches that religious freedom is a civil right: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

Engraved portrait of Edmund Campion, Jesuit, executed at Tyburn in 1581.
Edmund Campion, executed at Tyburn on 1 December 1581.
1581–1603Historical

The penal laws and the priests

After the pope declared Elizabeth deposed in 1570, England treated Catholicism as a security threat, and with Spain hostile and Mary, Queen of Scots, in the background, the plots were real. Englishmen trained as priests abroad, at Douai and Rome, and from 1574 slipped home under false names to say Mass in hiding.

Laws of 1581 and 1585 made it treason to bring anyone into the Catholic Church, and treason for a seminary priest simply to be in England. The Jesuit Edmund Campion was racked and hanged, drawn and quartered at Tyburn in 1581; in York, Margaret Clitherow was pressed to death in 1586 for hiding priests.

More than 150 Catholics died on the scaffold between 1581 and 1603. The laws were only lifted step by step, with Catholic Emancipation coming in 1829.

“My charge is, of free cost to preach the Gospel, to minister the Sacraments, to instruct the simple, to reform sinners, to confute errors—in brief, to cry alarm spiritual against foul vice and proud ignorance, wherewith many of my dear countrymen are abused.”
Challenge to the Privy Council ('Campion's Brag') · Campion's Challenge to the Privy Council ('Campion's Brag'), 1580, article iii
What the Church says

The Church honours those executed as martyrs. Forty of them were canonised in 1970 as the Forty Martyrs of England and Wales, Edmund Campion and Margaret Clitherow among them.

Killing people for their faith is against the Church's own teaching. The Second Vatican Council declared in 1965 that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

It admitted that ‘there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it’ (Dignitatis Humanae 12). In 2000 John Paul II asked pardon ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.

1581

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Anglican channel

Under Elizabeth I the Church of England kept bishops and much of the old worship. Puritans, English Protestants who wanted it purified further, mostly stayed inside and waited for the queen and Parliament to finish the work.

Robert Browne, a Cambridge graduate, would not wait. Around 1581, at Norwich, he gathered a church whose members bound themselves by a covenant, a solemn promise to God and to each other.

His 1582 book’s title said it all: *A Treatise of Reformation without Tarying for Anie*.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the Bible and faith in Christ.
  • Baptism, which the Catholic Church recognises (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • Love for the Bible: “a love and reverence of Sacred Scripture” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 21).
How they describe it

Congregationalists hold that each local church, gathered by covenant, is a complete church under Christ its only head, bound to other churches by fellowship rather than rule.

What it cost
  • Browne jailed; two men hanged for his books, 1581 to 1583Between Protestants
  • Barrow, Greenwood and Penry hanged, 1593Between Protestants
  • Anne Hutchinson banished from Massachusetts, 1637 to 1638Between Protestants
  • Massachusetts bars Jesuits and priests on pain of death, 1647Suffered by Catholics
  • Liberty for all but Catholics and bishops, 1653Suffered by Catholics
  • Four Quakers hanged at Boston, 1659 to 1661Between Protestants
  • The Great Ejection and the laws against dissenters, 1662 to 1689Between Protestants
1609

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Congregationalist channel

Baptists began among English Separatists: Puritans who gave up on the Church of England and left it, at a time when that was against the law. A congregation from Gainsborough, led by John Smyth, a former Church of England clergyman, fled to Amsterdam around 1606–08.

There they decided that baptism belongs only to believers who can confess their faith, so their baptisms as babies did not count. In 1609 Smyth baptised himself, then the others, by pouring water. Immersion became the Baptist rule only in the 1640s.

They rented their meeting place from Dutch Mennonites, the heirs of the Anabaptists, and in 1610 Smyth asked to join them. Thomas Helwys, a lawyer who had paid for the move, refused.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the Bible and faith in Christ.
  • Baptism “in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit” (*Baptist Faith and Message* VII), which the Catholic Church recognises when properly given (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22; Ecumenical Directory 93).
How they describe it

Baptists see themselves as churches of believers gathered by free choice, as in the New Testament, where faith is personal and no business of the state.

What it cost
  • Separatists driven out of England, about 1606 to 1608Between Protestants
  • Helwys asks freedom for everyone, and goes to Newgate, 1612 to about 1616Between Protestants
  • The same book names Rome the Beast, 1612
  • Banished and outlawed by Puritan Massachusetts, 1635 to 1684Between Protestants
  • John Bunyan jailed for twelve years, 1660 to 1672Between Protestants
Robert W. Weir's painting of the Pilgrims kneeling in prayer on the deck of the Speedwell, an elder holding an open Bible.
The Leiden church at prayer on the Speedwell before it sailed from Delfshaven in July 1620, painted by Robert W. Weir for the US Capitol in 1843: a congregation setting out together, its elder holding the Bible.
1620Historical

The Pilgrims sail and found Plymouth

Around 1600 some English Puritans gave up on reforming the Church of England from inside. These Separatists formed churches of their own by covenant, a solemn promise to God and to one another. One met at Scrooby in Nottinghamshire.

Harassed by the church courts, it escaped to Holland in 1607–08 and settled at Leiden under its pastor, John Robinson.

In 1620 part of the church sailed for America on the Mayflower. Storms brought them to Cape Cod, outside the land their permit covered, so on 11 November the men signed a compact to make their own laws. In December they settled at Plymouth.

By spring about half of the hundred or so passengers had died.

“We, whose names are underwritten, the Loyal Subjects of our dread Sovereign Lord King James, by the Grace of God, of Great Britain, France, and Ireland, King, Defender of the Faith, &c. Having undertaken for the Glory of God, and Advancement of the Christian Faith, and the Honour of our King and Country, a Voyage to plant the first Colony in the northern …”
Mayflower Compact (11 November 1620) · Mayflower Compact, signed at Cape Cod, 11 November 1620 (as printed in Thorpe, The Federal and State Constitutions, 1909)
What the Church says

The Catholic Church does not blame the Pilgrims’ heirs for the break their ancestors made. Those born into such communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’, and everyone truly baptised is in real, if imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).

Since 2013 the US Catholic bishops and the United Church of Christ, which tells the Pilgrims’ voyage as part of its own story, have recognised each other’s baptisms. What the Church says is still missing is ‘the sacrament of Orders’ (UR 22): bishops and priests ordained in a line from the apostles.

The Pilgrims fled laws that forced conscience, and the Church now agrees with them: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That judges the laws they fled, the Massachusetts gallows and Catholic Europe’s laws alike.

The Council admitted that the Church’s own history held ‘a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel’ (DH 12).

Gerard ter Borch’s painting of the swearing of the oath of ratification at Münster, 1648.
The oath of ratification at Münster, 15 May 1648, painted by Gerard ter Borch, who was there.
1618–48Historical

The wars of religion end in exhaustion

In 1555 the Peace of Augsburg let each ruler in the Holy Roman Empire choose Lutheran or Catholic for his land, and left Calvinists out. By 1600 both sides were armed and suspicious.

In 1618 Protestant nobles in Bohemia, afraid of losing their freedom to worship, threw two royal governors out of a castle window in Prague. A revolt became a war that drew in Denmark, Sweden, Spain and France.

For thirty years armies fought mostly across Germany and lived off the land. Historians estimate 4.5 to 8 million dead, most of them civilians. From 1631 Catholic France was paying Protestant Sweden to fight the Catholic Habsburgs.

The peace of 1648 recognised Lutherans and Calvinists beside Catholics. The pope protested, but Europe stopped trying to settle doctrine by war.

“That there shall be on the one side and the other a perpetual Oblivion, Amnesty, or Pardon of all that has been committed since the beginning of these Troubles, in what place, or what manner soever the Hostilitys have been practis'd, in such a manner, that no body, under any pretext whatsoever, shall practice any Acts of Hostility, entertain any Enmity, or …”
Treaty of Westphalia (Peace Treaty between the Holy Roman Emperor and the King of France and their respective Allies) · Treaty of Westphalia, 24 October 1648, Article II
What the Church says

Pope Innocent X declared the peace's religious clauses void in November 1648. In his view church lands and dioceses had been handed to Protestant rulers without the Church's consent.

The Church's teaching since 1965 is that faith must never be imposed by force or by the state (Dignitatis Humanae 2). In 2000 John Paul II asked forgiveness ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.

Saints of this age

14 lives, among many

Signs in this age
  • The account, first printed in 1648 and 1649, says that on 9 to 12 December 1531 the Virgin appeared four times to Juan Diego, a baptised Nahua, one of the native people of central Mexico, on Tepeyac hill, asked for a shrine, and gave roses out of season as a sign. When he opened his cloak before Bishop Zumárraga, the image of the Virgin was found on it.

    Not established: That an apparition occurred in 1531.

  • On the eve of Pentecost 1608 the Benedictines of Faverney set up a wooden altar against the iron screen of their abbey church, for the Pentecost indulgence. On it they exposed two hosts, consecrated that day, in a silver-gilt reliquary. In the night a fire burned the altar and its hangings to ash.

    Not established: That the record is neutral.