The penal laws and the priests
England makes it treason to be a Catholic priest. Between 1581 and 1603 more than 150 priests and laypeople are put to death.
After the pope declared Elizabeth deposed in 1570, England treated Catholicism as a security threat, and with Spain hostile and Mary, Queen of Scots, in the background, the plots were real. Englishmen trained as priests abroad, at Douai and Rome, and from 1574 slipped home under false names to say Mass in hiding.
Laws of 1581 and 1585 made it treason to bring anyone into the Catholic Church, and treason for a seminary priest simply to be in England. The Jesuit Edmund Campion was racked and hanged, drawn and quartered at Tyburn in 1581; in York, Margaret Clitherow was pressed to death in 1586 for hiding priests.
More than 150 Catholics died on the scaffold between 1581 and 1603. The laws were only lifted step by step, with Catholic Emancipation coming in 1829.
The situation
After the 's bull of 1570 declared Elizabeth deposed, her government treated Catholicism as a danger to the state. Mary, Queen of Scots, a Catholic claimant to the throne, was a prisoner in England, and Catholic Spain was the strongest power in Europe.
To keep the faith alive, William Allen founded a seminary, a college for training priests, at Douai in Spanish Flanders in 1568. From 1574 its priests slipped home in secret, travelling under false names and saying , the Catholic service, in attics.
In 1580 the Jesuits, a Catholic order of priests, sent their first men to England. Among them was , a celebrated Oxford scholar who had once accepted the new Church of England.
The threats were real. In 1571 and 1586 there were plots to kill or remove Elizabeth and put Mary on the throne, and in 1588 Spain sent the Armada, a great fleet, to invade. Some Catholic exiles, including Allen himself, knew of plots against the queen.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
He asked for a debate, not a rescue
Campion's offer was to argue his case before the Council, the universities and the lawyers. He was instead disputed with in the Tower, after torture.
“I do ask, to the glory of God, with all humility, and under your correction, three sorts of indifferent and quiet audiences: the first, before your Honours … the second, whereof I make more account, before the Doctors and Masters and chosen men of both universities … the third, before the lawyers, spiritual and temporal.”
Challenge to the Privy Council · Campion's Brag, article v - 02
Plots, and the loyal majority
A Catholic historian's own verdict, in the Catholic Encyclopedia.
“No doubt Cardinal Allen, the Jesuit Persons, and other Catholic exiles were cognizant of, and involved in, plots which had for their end the queen's overthrow”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'England (Since the Reformation)', by William Lilly
What was at stake
The government couldn't tell a priest who had come to hear confessions from an agent of a power that had ordered the queen's removal. It decided not to try.
Campion saw the charge coming. In 1580, a year before his arrest, he wrote to the Privy Council, the queen's ministers, that he was forbidden to deal in matters of state and had come only to preach and give the .
But the bull still stood. In 1580 Rome was said to have told Catholics they could obey the queen for the present, until a chance came to overthrow her. To Elizabeth's ministers, that left every priest's loyalty in doubt.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Campion's fourth article, written before his arrest
The document circulated in 1580, a year before he was caught. He anticipated the accusation and denied it in advance, in writing, to the Privy Council itself.
“I never had mind, and am strictly forbidden by our Father that sent me, to deal in any respect with matter of state or policy of this realm, as things which appertain not to my vocation, and from which I gladly restrain and sequester my thoughts.”
Challenge to the Privy Council · Campion's Brag, article iv
The event
Laws of 1581 and 1585 made it treason to bring anyone into the Catholic Church, and treason for a priest trained at the seminaries abroad simply to be in England. Staying away from the parish service now cost £20 a month.
Campion was caught on 17 July 1581 at Lyford Grange in Berkshire. He was racked in the Tower, tried on a charge of plotting that rested on paid informers, and on 1 December 1581 hanged, drawn and quartered at Tyburn, London's place of execution.
This was the traitor's death: hanged, cut down still alive, cut open and cut into four.
Lay people died too. Margaret Clitherow, a butcher's wife in York, hid priests in her home.
At her trial she refused to plead, so that her children and servants would not have to give evidence, and on 25 March 1586 she was pressed to death under a weighted door.
In four months of 1588, the Armada year, 21 priests, 11 laymen and one woman were put to death. Between 1581 and 1603, more than 150 Catholics died on the scaffold, besides those killed earlier in the reign.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
Campion's trial
His biographer in the Catholic Encyclopedia on how the case against him was built.
“The privy council, at its wits' end over so purely spiritual a ‘traitor’, hatched a plot to impeach Campion's loyalty, and called in the hirelings Eliot and Munday as accusers.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'St. Edmund Campion', by Louise Imogen Guiney - 02
Why Margaret Clitherow would not plead
Her indictment was for harbouring priests and hearing Mass.
“she refused to plead, since the only witnesses against her would be her own little children and servants, whom she could not bear to involve in the guilt of her death.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'St. Margaret Clitherow', by Bede Camm - 03
A priest's crime was being a priest
Pollen's list of the martyrs notes what changed with the law of 1585, known as 27 Elizabeth.
“From this time onwards almost all the priests suffered under law of 27 Elizabeth, merely for their priestly character.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'English Confessors and Martyrs (1534-1729)', by J. H. Pollen - 04
More than 150 on the scaffold
The Catholic Encyclopedia's summary of what the laws meant for priests.
“For seminary priests it was high treason to be in England at all after 1585. Under this statute, over 150 Catholics died on the scaffold between 1581 and 1603”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Penal Laws' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Penal Laws'
The outcome
Catholicism in England became a hunted minority faith, kept alive in a few gentry houses. Under James I, 28 more Catholics were executed, and more died in 1679, in the panic over the Popish Plot, a Catholic conspiracy invented by an informer, Titus Oates.
Most English Catholics stayed loyal. When the Armada was expected, the Catholic Encyclopedia notes, they came forward in every county to serve under the queen's commanders.
The penal laws, the laws against Catholics, were eased slowly over two centuries. In 1829 the Catholic Emancipation Act let Catholics sit in Parliament and hold the higher offices of state, and in 1850 Rome restored a full set of English .
In 1970 Paul VI canonised, or declared saints, the Forty Martyrs of England and Wales. Edmund Campion and Margaret Clitherow are among them.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Loyal when the Armada came
The same historian on the great body of English Catholics.
“When the Armada was expected they repaired in every county to the standard of the Lord Lieutenant”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'England (Since the Reformation)', by William Lilly - 02
Emancipation, 1829
The Roman Catholic Relief Act received royal assent on 13 April 1829.
“removed the sacramental tests that barred Roman Catholics in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland from Parliament and from higher offices of the judiciary and state.”
Wikipedia, 'Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829' · Wikipedia, 'Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829', opening section (tertiary; retrieved 2026-10-08)
For the trail
These deaths are the other half of the story of the Marian burnings. Protestants were burned under Mary; Catholics were hanged, drawn and quartered under Elizabeth. Christians in England did both to each other.
The government called them traitors, and some exiles did plot. But most who died were priests who said Mass and lay people who sheltered them. They died for being Catholic in a country that had made that a crime.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Both directions, in the same prayer
In 2000 the Church asked forgiveness for the divisions in which Christians 'have mutually condemned one another and fought against one another'. The phrasing is deliberately reciprocal.
“Merciful Father, on the night before his Passion your Son prayed for the unity of those who believe in him: in disobedience to his will, however, believers have opposed one another, becoming divided, and have mutually condemned one another and fought against one another.”
Universal Prayer: Confession of Sins and Asking for Forgiveness · Universal Prayer, III: Confession of sins which have harmed the unity of the Body of Christ
What the Church says
The Church honours those executed as martyrs. Forty of them were canonised in 1970 as the Forty Martyrs of England and Wales, Edmund Campion and Margaret Clitherow among them.
Killing people for their faith is against the Church's own teaching. The Second Vatican Council declared in 1965 that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).
It admitted that ‘there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it’ (Dignitatis Humanae 12). In 2000 John Paul II asked pardon ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.
Think of it like this
A visitor who swears he carries only letters from home, sent by the people who have just declared your queen no queen.
Both governments had a reason that sounded solid from the inside. Rome saw priests going to feed the starving; London saw couriers from the power that had declared the queen deposed. Once the pope had put the queen's crown in play, no priest could prove he was only carrying the Gospel, and no magistrate had to believe him.
“My charge is, of free cost to preach the Gospel, to minister the Sacraments, to instruct the simple, to reform sinners, to confute errors—in brief, to cry alarm spiritual against foul vice and proud ignorance, wherewith many of my dear countrymen are abused.”
The next article is the one the government did not believe: 'I never had mind, and am strictly forbidden by our Father that sent me, to deal in any respect with matter of state or policy of this realm.'
Where people disagree
Elizabeth's government always insisted it executed traitors, not believers. It pointed to the bull of 1570, the northern rising, the plots of 1571 and 1586, and the Armada.
Catholic historians answer that after 1585 almost all the priests suffered ‘merely for their priestly character’, under a law that made being a priest the crime. Campion had denied any political aim in writing before he was arrested.
The Catholic Encyclopedia itself admits that Cardinal Allen and the Jesuit Robert Persons were involved in plots against the queen. The question historians argue over is whether that justified killing the many who were not.
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Edmund Campion · 1580 · Catholic Information Network (cin.org)
- Pope Pius V · 1570-02-25 · papalencyclicals.net
- John Paul II and the Roman Curia · 2000-03-12 · Holy See