Anabaptists killed by both sides
Christians who rebaptised adults were drowned by Protestant Zurich and burned by Catholic Austria.
Some Reformation Christians read the Bible and concluded that baptism was only for believing adults, that the church should be a free gathering, and that Christians shouldn't swear oaths or bear arms. Because they baptised adults again, they were called Anabaptists, ‘rebaptisers’. Rulers fresh from the Peasants' War saw them as rebels.
Protestant Zurich drowned Felix Manz in January 1527. In May a Catholic court at Rottenburg had Michael Sattler, a former Benedictine prior who wrote their articles of faith, tortured and burned, and the women with him drowned. Both sides killed the movement's first generation.
It survived as the Mennonites, Hutterites and Amish, and in 2010 Lutherans asked their forgiveness.
The situation
By the mid-1520s Luther in Wittenberg and Zwingli in Zurich had broken with Rome. Some of their own followers went further. Reading the same , they concluded that belongs to believers old enough to ask for it.
On 21 January 1525, in Zurich, a small group met at Felix Manz's house and baptised each other as adults. Since they'd been baptised as babies, their enemies called them Anabaptists, ‘rebaptisers’. They said their first baptism hadn't counted.
They also held that the church should be a free gathering of believers, not everyone born in a town, and that Christians shouldn't swear oaths or take up the sword. In February 1527 a few dozen met at Schleitheim on the Swiss border and wrote down seven articles.
Europe was already frightened. In 1524–25 the Peasants' War had swept southern and central Germany, with monasteries burned, until the princes crushed it. Thomas Müntzer, a preacher who rejected infant baptism in theory, had led one rebel army, and was executed.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
What they actually agreed on
The Schleitheim articles are short and concrete: baptism, the ban, the breaking of bread, separation, pastors, the sword, the oath. Article I defines the whole quarrel in two sentences.
“Baptism shall be given to all those who have learned repentance and amendment of life, and who believe truly that their sins are taken away by Christ, and to all those who walk in the resurrection of Jesus Christ, and wish to be buried with Him in death, so that they may be resurrected with Him and to all those who with this significance request it (baptism) of us and demand it for themselves. This excludes all infant baptism, the highest and chief abomination of the Pope.”
The Schleitheim Confession · Schleitheim Confession, Article I - 02
21 January 1525
The Baptist historian William Estep retells the first rebaptisms from the Hutterite chronicle, which seems to rest on an eyewitness.
“After his baptism at the hands of Grebel, Blaurock proceeded to baptize all the others present.”
The Anabaptist Story, chapter 1: The Birth of Anabaptism · Estep, The Anabaptist Story, ch. 1
What was at stake
Every government in Europe, Catholic or , assumed one church for one society. Infant baptism was the door into both: it made you a Christian and a member of your community at the same time.
So refusing to baptise babies, refusing oaths and refusing to serve as magistrates looked to rulers like refusing the state itself. To them it wasn't only false belief; it was sedition, stirring people against lawful rule.
Old law was close to hand. Roman emperors had made rebaptism a crime, and in 529 Justinian made it punishable by death. In 1529 the Diet of Speyer, the empire's assembly, applied that law to Anabaptists, with Catholic and Protestant princes alike.
The Anabaptists saw it the other way round. To them a church that baptised everyone at birth and leaned on the sword had fallen away from the . The Schleitheim articles didn't deny rulers their sword; they refused to carry it themselves.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
The 1529 Diet of Speyer
The joint Catholic-Mennonite report explains the old imperial law that both sides invoked against rebaptism.
“In 529, the emperor Justinian I, in reproducing the Theodosian edict in his revision of Roman law, specified the penalty as capital punishment. … On the basis of this ancient imperial law against the Donatists, the Diet of Speyer in 1529 proclaimed the death penalty for all acts of “rebaptism.””
Called Together to be Peacemakers: Report of the International Dialogue between the Catholic Church and Mennonite World Conference, 1998-2003 · Called Together to be Peacemakers (2003), §40 - 02
The sword is for magistrates, not for Christians
The Schleitheim articles grant that God ordains the sword for rulers, while refusing it to believers.
“We are agreed as follows concerning the sword: The sword is ordained of God outside the perfection of Christ.”
The Schleitheim Confession · Schleitheim Confession, Article VI
The event
Zurich's , Protestant and led by Zwingli's allies, had made rebaptism punishable by drowning. On 5 January 1527 it drowned Felix Manz in the river Limmat, the first Swiss put to death by Zwingli's city.
In May 1527 the Catholic imperial court at Rottenburg tried Michael Sattler, a former Benedictine prior, the deputy head of a monastery, who had drafted the Schleitheim articles.
It sentenced him to have his tongue cut out and his body torn with red-hot tongs, and then to be burned. His companions were beheaded. The women were drowned, and a few days later so was his wife.
The killing spread. By one modern estimate, about 5,000 people were executed for their faith in the 1500s, and 2,000 to 2,500 of them were Anabaptists, most in Catholic lands, others in Protestant ones.
In 1534–35 a different, violent wing seized the city of Münster in Westphalia. It forced rebaptism on everyone, declared property held in common and brought in polygamy.
The city's Catholic , helped by the Lutheran prince Philip of Hesse, besieged and retook it, and its leaders were tortured and executed.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Felix Manz, 5 January 1527
A Mennonite sketch of the first Swiss Anabaptist executed by a Protestant government.
“He was the first Swiss Anabaptist to be martyred at the hands of the Protestant followers of Zwingli.”
Felix Manz · Felix Manz (anabaptists.org) - 02
The women were drowned, including Sattler's wife
The Martyrs Mirror records the fate of the whole group in one line, and dates it.
“His fellow brethren were executed with the sword, and the sisters drowned. His wife, also, after being subjected to many entreaties, admonitions and threats, under which she remained very steadfast, was drowned a few days afterwards. Done the 21st day of May, A. D. 1527.”
The Bloody Theatre or Martyrs Mirror: the trial and execution of Michael Sattler · Martyrs Mirror, Rottenburg, 21 May 1527 - 03
How many died
The joint Catholic-Mennonite report gives a recent estimate, and says most of the Anabaptist dead were in Catholic territories.
“According to recent estimations, approximately 5,000 persons were executed for their religious beliefs in the course of the sixteenth century. Of these, between 2,000 and 2,500 were Anabaptist and Mennonite men and women, the majority of them in Catholic territories, who were convicted of heresy.”
Called Together to be Peacemakers: Report of the International Dialogue between the Catholic Church and Mennonite World Conference, 1998-2003 · Called Together to be Peacemakers (2003), §46
The outcome
Münster fixed the fear for generations. To rulers, Anabaptist came to mean rebel, and peaceful groups were suspected of only waiting for their chance.
The peaceful wing survived. Under Menno Simons, a former Catholic priest, it became the Mennonites; others became the Hutterites, and later the Amish. Baptists later took up their rejection of infant baptism.
Mennonites faced restrictions in some countries for centuries, often for refusing military service. On 22 July 2010, at Stuttgart, the Lutheran World Federation asked forgiveness ‘from God and from our Mennonite sisters and brothers’. Mennonite World Conference granted it.
Catholics and Mennonites held their first international dialogue from 1998 to 2003. Each side asked the other's forgiveness: Catholics for committed against Mennonites, Mennonites for hostile images of Catholics.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Stuttgart, 22 July 2010
The Lutheran World Federation's assembly adopted a statement of repentance, printed in the Mennonite World Conference's own report.
“we ask for forgiveness—from God and from our Mennonite sisters and brothers—for the harm that our forbears in the 16th century committed to Anabaptists”
Lutherans and Anabaptists reconcile in service of repentance and forgiveness · Courier 2010/3-4, Action on the Legacy of Lutheran Persecution of Anabaptists - 02
Münster made Anabaptist mean rebel
The Catholic-Mennonite report describes how the Münster rising hardened both Catholic and Protestant fear.
“As a result, the term “Anabaptist,” employed in both Catholic and Protestant polemics, came to connote rebellion and anarchy.”
Called Together to be Peacemakers: Report of the International Dialogue between the Catholic Church and Mennonite World Conference, 1998-2003 · Called Together to be Peacemakers (2003), §39
For the trail
No side's hands were clean. In 1527 the men doing the killing were Catholic judges and Protestant councillors. The people dying held a reading of Scripture that millions of Christians, Baptists among them, now take for granted.
It also shows that fear of disorder, not only disagreement about , drove the killing. Rulers who couldn't imagine society without one church saw people who left it as enemies of the peace.
And the Anabaptists' conviction that faith can't be forced is one the Catholic Church now teaches too, since 1965.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Rome's own verdict on such methods, 473 years later
On the first Sunday of Lent in 2000, in St Peter's, the Church prayed this about itself.
“Lord, God of all men and women, in certain periods of history Christians have at times given in to intolerance and have not been faithful to the great commandment of love, sullying in this way the face of the Church, your Spouse. Have mercy on your sinful children and accept our resolve to seek and promote truth in the gentleness of charity, in the firm knowledge that truth can prevail only in virtue of truth itself.”
Universal Prayer: Confession of Sins and Asking for Forgiveness · Universal Prayer, II: Confession of sins committed in the service of truth
What the Church says
Killing people for their faith is against the Church's own teaching: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). Vatican II admitted ways of acting ‘hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel’ (DH 12).
In 2000 John Paul II asked God's forgiveness ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’. In 2001 Cardinal Kasper told Mennonites: ‘I surely regret those instances when this took place in Catholic societies.’
The Church still holds that baptism given to infants is true baptism and ‘cannot be repeated’ (CCC 1272). It counts baptised Mennonites as brothers and sisters in Christ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).
Think of it like this
Two neighbours who agree on nothing join forces against a third for building his house differently.
Catholic and Protestant rulers disagreed about almost everything, and agreed on this: people who rebaptised adults were pulling apart the only order either could imagine, one church for one society, entered at birth.
“In the case of the Governor of his Imperial Majesty versus Michael Sattler, judgment is passed, that Michael Sattler shall be delivered to the executioner, who shall lead him to the place of execution, and cut out his tongue; then throw him upon a wagon, and there tear his body twice with red hot tongs; and after he has been brought without the gate, he shall be pinched five times in the same manner.”
The same record adds: 'His fellow brethren were executed with the sword, and the sisters drowned. His wife, also, after being subjected to many entreaties, admonitions and threats, under which she remained very steadfast, was drowned a few days afterwards.'
Where people disagree
Rebels or ? Most Catholics and Protestants of the 1500s saw rebels. Mennonite historians stress that the founders at Schleitheim renounced the sword, and that the Münster rising was a different movement that they rejected.
Historians now stress how varied the radicals were. Even the Mennonite delegates in the 2003 dialogue grant that it was hard for people at the time to tell the peaceful from those who took up the sword.
How much did the Reformers' own teaching drive the killing? Lutherans in 2010 regretted especially that ‘Lutheran reformers theologically supported this persecution’. On the Catholic side, Leo X had in 1520 condemned Luther's own statement ‘That heretics be burned is against the will of the Spirit’.
Authorities then pointed to Roman law against rebaptism, older than any of them. The Catholic Church now rejects that reasoning outright: no one may be forced in matters of religion.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
The Mennonite delegation on their own history
In the 2003 report the Mennonite side grants that the movement had violent currents and that contemporaries found it hard to tell them apart.
“We believe that it was initially difficult for contemporaries to distinguish between the Anabaptists we claim as our spiritual forebears—those committed to Biblical pacifism, ready to suffer martyrdom for the cause of Christ—and those who took the sword”
Called Together to be Peacemakers: Report of the International Dialogue between the Catholic Church and Mennonite World Conference, 1998-2003 · Called Together to be Peacemakers (2003), §203 - 02
Cardinal Kasper, 2001
Quoted in the Catholic delegation's statement of repentance.
“Especially, in the sixteenth century, the Anabaptists were among those who suffered greatly in this regard. I surely regret those instances when this took place in Catholic societies.”
Called Together to be Peacemakers: Report of the International Dialogue between the Catholic Church and Mennonite World Conference, 1998-2003 · Called Together to be Peacemakers (2003), §202
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Thieleman J. van Braght · 1660; events of 1527 · anabaptists.org
- Swiss Brethren, drafted by Michael Sattler · 1527-02-24 · anabaptists.org (Rod and Staff Publishers edition, 1985)
- John Paul II and the Roman Curia · 2000-03-12 · Holy See