The pope deposes Elizabeth
Pius V declares Elizabeth deprived of the crown and absolves her subjects from obedience, turning English Catholics into suspected traitors.
Elizabeth I had been queen for eleven years. Her laws made her head of the Church of England and fined anyone who stayed away from the parish church, but at first Catholics were only lightly punished.
Then Mary, Queen of Scots, a Catholic claimant to the English throne, fled to England, and in 1569 the Catholic earls of the north rose in her name. The rising failed, and about 600 of its supporters were executed.
On 25 February 1570 Pope Pius V issued a bull, a formal papal letter, declaring Elizabeth a heretic, removing her ‘pretended title’ to the crown, and forbidding her subjects to obey her. He could not enforce it, but it made every English Catholic a possible traitor in the state's eyes, and Parliament answered with treason laws. The Church has since given up any claim to depose rulers.
The situation
became queen in 1558, after her Catholic sister Mary. In 1559 her Parliament made her Supreme Governor of the Church of England and required clergy and officials to swear that no foreign had any authority in England.
Every Catholic bishop but one refused, and all who refused were removed. Most spent the rest of their lives in prison or under guard, and a few escaped abroad. Anyone who stayed away from the parish church paid a fine for each absence. Even so, for her first decade Catholics were only lightly punished.
Then, in 1568, Mary, Queen of Scots, fled to England after losing her throne, and Elizabeth held her prisoner. Mary was Catholic, and many Catholics saw her as Elizabeth's rightful heir, or as her replacement.
In November 1569 the Catholic earls of the north rose to free her and restore the old religion. They had , the Catholic service, sung in Durham Cathedral. The rising collapsed by December, and about 600 of its supporters were executed.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The oath that came first
Elizabeth's 1559 Supremacy Act required officeholders and clergy to swear that no foreign prelate had any authority in England. Refusal cost a man his office.
“…that no foreign prince, person, prelate, state or potentate, has, or ought to have, any jurisdiction, power, superiority, preeminence, or authority ecclesiastical or spiritual, within this realm; and therefore I do utterly renounce and forsake all foreign jurisdictions, powers, superiorities, and authorities, and do promise that from henceforth I shall bear faith and true allegiance to the queen's highness.”
Elizabeth's Supremacy Act, Restoring Ancient Jurisdiction · 1 Elizabeth c. 1 (1559), the oath - 02
And the fine for staying away from church
The Act of Uniformity of the same year made attendance at the parish church compulsory, with a fine for every absence, collected by the churchwardens for the parish poor.
“…upon pain of punishment by the censures of the Church, and also upon pain that every person so offending shall forfeit for every such offence twelve pence, to be levied by the churchwardens of the parish where such offence shall be done, to the use of the poor of the same parish.”
Elizabeth's Act of Uniformity · 1 Elizabeth c. 2 (1559) - 03
The rising and its reprisals
After the earls fled, the government took its revenge on their followers in the north.
“Altogether, 600 supporters of Mary were executed, while many others fled into exile.”
Wikipedia, 'Rising of the North' · Wikipedia, 'Rising of the North', reprisals (tertiary; retrieved 2026-10-08)
What was at stake
Rome had to decide what a Catholic in England owed a queen who had broken with the and outlawed the Mass.
Pope Pius V believed that had given the pope authority over all Christian rulers. Medieval popes had acted on it: in 1076 Gregory VII had released the German king Henry IV's subjects from their oaths of loyalty.
To depose a ruler was to declare that they were no longer the lawful ruler, so their subjects no longer owed them obedience. Pius decided to settle the English question by deposing the queen.
He meant to support the northern rising. But news travelled so slowly that he acted two months after the rising had collapsed, without yet knowing it had even begun.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
A bull that arrived too late
Pollen, in the Catholic Encyclopedia, on the timing.
“So slowly did posts travel in those days that the pope, two months after the collapse of the rising, but not having yet heard of its commencement, excommunicated Elizabeth (25 Feb., 1570) in order to pave the way for the appeal to arms.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Mary Queen of Scots', by J. H. Pollen
The event
On 25 February 1570 Pius V issued a bull, a formal papal letter named for its lead seal, called Regnans in Excelsis, Latin for ‘Reigning on High’.
It declared Elizabeth a heretic, one who holds beliefs the Church judges false, and deprived her of her ‘pretended title’ to the crown. It also excommunicated her: a church penalty cutting her off from the , not a physical one.
It released her subjects from their oaths of loyalty and commanded them not to obey her laws. Anyone who did obey was to be excommunicated as well.
Pius consulted no Catholic ruler first. Philip II of Spain and the Emperor Maximilian II both disagreed, and Philip judged it would only harden the treatment of English Catholics.
On 24 May a Catholic gentleman, John Felton, fixed a copy to the gates of the Bishop of London's palace. He was racked and, in August, executed.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The theory behind it, stated in the first line
The bull opens by stating the principle that makes the deposition thinkable: one ruler on earth over all peoples and kingdoms.
“He that reigneth on high, to whom is given all power in heaven and earth, has committed one holy Catholic and apostolic Church, outside of which there is no salvation, to one alone upon earth, namely to Peter, the first of the apostles, and to Peter's successor, the pope of Rome, to be by him governed in fullness of power. Him alone He has made ruler over all peoples and kingdoms.”
Regnans in Excelsis, excommunicating Elizabeth I · Regnans in Excelsis, preamble - 02
Catholic rulers disagreed
Spain and the Empire, the great Catholic powers, did not want the bull.
“Pius did not consult any Catholic rulers. Both Philip II of Spain and the Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian II disagreed with his approach.”
Wikipedia, 'Regnans in Excelsis' · Wikipedia, 'Regnans in Excelsis', content (tertiary; retrieved 2026-10-08) - 03
The man who posted it
John Felton was beatified as a martyr; the Catholic Encyclopedia records his act.
“affixed a copy of the Bull of St. Pius V excommunicating the queen to the gates of the Bishop of London's palace near St. Paul's.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Blessed John Felton'
The outcome
The bull could not be enforced, and no Catholic army came. But it made every English Catholic a possible traitor in the government's eyes: the pope had told them their queen was no queen.
Parliament answered in 1571. It became high treason to bring in or use a papal bull, and the laws against Catholics grew harsher for the rest of the reign.
Plots followed. The Ridolfi plot of 1571 aimed to put Mary, Queen of Scots on the throne, and the bull's publication in England gave it its impetus.
In 1580, it was said, Gregory XIII explained that Catholics could obey the queen in civil matters for now, until a chance came to overthrow her. In 1588 Sixtus V renewed the excommunication to support the Spanish Armada. Most English Catholics stayed loyal to their queen.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Gregory XIII's explanation, 1580
How widely it reached English Catholics is unknown.
“explaining that Catholics should obey the queen outwardly in all civil matters, until such time as a suitable opportunity presented itself for her overthrow.”
Wikipedia, 'Regnans in Excelsis' · Wikipedia, 'Regnans in Excelsis', suspension from 1580 to 1584 (tertiary; retrieved 2026-10-08)
For the trail
Without the bull, the persecution that followed could be read as simple victimhood. English Catholics were persecuted under laws their own pope had given the government a reason to pass.
That does not make the persecution just. Most of the priests and lay people executed later had no part in any plot. But it explains why the government saw them as a danger.
It also shows how far the Church's own thinking has moved. It no longer claims any power to depose rulers, and it teaches that faith can't be forced on anyone.
What the Church says
The Church no longer claims any power to depose rulers or release subjects from obedience. The Second Vatican Council taught that ‘the Church and the political community in their own fields are autonomous and independent from each other’ (Gaudium et Spes 76).
It also teaches that religious freedom is a civil right: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).
Think of it like this
A referee from another country declares your team's captain illegitimate, and every fan in the stadium is suddenly suspected of planning a pitch invasion.
The bull was addressed to consciences, but it landed as politics. A Catholic farmer in Yorkshire who wanted nothing but Mass had been told by the highest authority he recognised that his queen was no queen and her laws were not binding. From Westminster, every such farmer now looked like a man holding a foreign warrant.
“And moreover (we declare) her to be deprived of her pretended title to the aforesaid crown and of all lordship, dignity and privilege whatsoever. And also (declare) the nobles, subjects and people of the said realm and all others who have in any way sworn oaths to her, to be forever absolved from such an oath and from any duty arising from lordship, fealty and obedience … We charge and command all and singular the nobles, subjects, peoples and others afore said that they do not dare obey her orders, mandates and laws.”
Where people disagree
Catholic historians point out that Pius acted on a claim of papal authority over Christian rulers that was centuries old, though already contested. They add that most English Catholics never acted on the bull.
Anglican and secular historians reply that the bull's effect on real people was catastrophic, whatever its theory. It handed Elizabeth's ministers a reason to treat Catholic worship as treason.
The timing cuts against the gentler reading. The Catholic Encyclopedia says Pius issued it ‘to pave the way for the appeal to arms’: it was meant to support a rising, not only to pass judgment on a soul.
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Pope Pius V · 1570-02-25 · papalencyclicals.net
- Parliament of England · 1559 · Hanover Historical Texts Project, from Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (Macmillan, 1896), 442–58
- Parliament of England · 1559 · Hanover Historical Texts Project, from Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (Macmillan, 1896), 458–67