The RiverThe ReformationUnion
1595–96

Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church

The Union of Brest

In 1595–96 most Orthodox bishops of Ukraine and Belarus entered full communion with Rome, keeping their Eastern liturgy. Two refused, and the Church split in two.

Byzantine tradition · a channel rejoining the main stream from the Eastern Orthodox

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

By the late 1500s the Orthodox of Ukraine and Belarus, then called Ruthenians, lived under Catholic Poland, and their Church was losing ground to both Protestants and Polish Catholicism. Some of their bishops saw union with Rome as a way to keep their own tradition.

Two of them went to Rome in 1595 with conditions: they would keep their Eastern liturgy, their calendar, and the creed without the Western ‘and the Son’. Rome agreed, and the union was proclaimed at Brest in October 1596. The metropolitan and five other bishops accepted it.

The two who refused were removed from office and excommunicated: a church penalty that cuts someone off from the sacraments until they reconcile, not a physical punishment.

Bitter conflict followed between those for and against the union, and in 1623 Archbishop Josaphat Kuntsevych was killed in it.

The Church that came from Brest, the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, was abolished by the tsar in his lands in 1839 and by the Soviet state in 1946. It came back above ground in 1989 and is now the largest Eastern Catholic Church.

Where we are

The situation

In the late 1500s the Christians of today's Ukraine and Belarus, then called Ruthenians, lived in Poland-Lithuania, a Catholic kingdom. Their Church was led by the metropolitan of Kyiv, its senior , under the patriarch of Constantinople.

It was losing ground on two sides at once. Protestantism was spreading fast in Ruthenian lands, and Latin Polish Catholicism was expanding.

Their bishops had less standing than the Catholic ones. And when the patriarch of Constantinople came through in 1589 to put things in order, some of the bishops resented his interference.

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    Why the Jesuits wanted it

    The motive is not hidden in a hostile source. A Catholic encyclopaedia of the Christian East states it: the union was worked for as a counter to Protestant expansion, and Orthodox bishops came to favour it for reasons of their own standing.

    “By this time Protestantism was expanding rapidly in Ukrainian lands, and the Jesuits had begun to work for a local union between Catholics and Orthodox as a way of reducing Protestant influence. Soon many Orthodox also began to view such a union favourably as a way of improving the situation of the Ukrainian clergy and preserving their Byzantine traditions at a time when Latin Polish Catholicism was expanding.”
    Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church'
The problem

What was at stake

Here a union meant part of an Eastern Church entering with Rome, sharing one faith and the with the , while keeping its own . Every party wanted one for its own reasons.

The Jesuits, a Catholic religious order, worked for it as a way of reducing influence.

Some Orthodox bishops hoped it would raise their clergy's standing and protect their Byzantine traditions. The Polish side promised them the same privileges as Latin bishops, including seats in the Senate.

None of that is shameful on its own. But it meant the union was never only about faith.

What happened

The event

Two bishops, Hipatiy Pociej and Cyril Terlecki, took their synod's conditions to Rome. Rome agreed: the Ruthenians would keep their liturgy and their calendar, and the Creed would be said without the Western ‘and the Son’.

But the ceremony in Rome, on 23 December 1595, still spoke the language of error and return. Pociej read, in Latin, a formula renouncing the Greek Schism. Since 1964 the Catholic Church has asked only for a bare profession of the Catholic faith.

In October 1596 a synod at Brest proclaimed the union. The metropolitan and five other bishops accepted it; the bishops of Lviv and Przemyśl refused. The opponents met in Brest at the same time, with envoys of the patriarchs of Constantinople and Alexandria.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    What Rome conceded at the negotiation

    The Creed was to be recited without the Filioque, although the Ruthenian clergy themselves professed the doctrine. That is a striking concession and the 1912 account gives no document reference for it, so it is reported as that work's narrative rather than as a traced act.

    “the pope and the cardinals discussed the conditions of reunion proposed by the Ruthenian episcopate, and ungrudgingly conceded that the integrity of the Ruthenian Rite should be maintained; it was also agreed that the “Filioque” should not be inserted in the Nicene Creed , although the Ruthenian clergy professed and taught the procession of the Holy Spirit from the Son.”
    The Catholic Encyclopedia · Narrative of the negotiations at Rome, late 1595
  2. 02

    The ceremony was framed as an abjuration

    In Rome the bishops did not simply profess the Catholic faith. They read a formula abjuring the Greek Schism. Vatican II would reverse exactly this in 1964.

    “Then Pociej, in his own name and that of the Ruthenian episcopate, read in Latin the formula of abjuration of the Greek Schism, Terlecki read it in Ruthenian , and they affixed their signatures.”
    The Catholic Encyclopedia · Narrative of the Rome ceremony, 23 December 1595
  3. 03

    The dates, and which calendar they are in

    The papal letter of 1995 gives the two dates in the Gregorian reckoning. The Ruthenians had asked to keep the Julian calendar, on which the 1912 account narrates the synod as convoked for 8 October.

    “The union was effected at the meeting of representatives of the Metropolia of Kiev with the Pope on 23 December 1595 and was solemnly proclaimed at Brest-Litovsk on the River Bug on 16 October 1596. Pope Clement VIII, in the Apostolic Constitution Magnus Dominus et laudabilis nimis, announced the union to the whole Church and in the Apostolic Letter Benedictus sit Pastor he addressed the Bishops of the Metropolia, informing them that the union had taken place.”
    Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest · Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest, §1
What came of it

The outcome

The Catholic synod deposed the two bishops who refused, removing them from office, and excommunicated them, barring them from the sacraments until they reconciled. The other synod asked the same against those who joined.

Then King Sigismund III stepped in: only bishops who had accepted the union were to be recognised. In 1620 the Orthodox secretly rebuilt their hierarchy, and the conflict turned violent. Archbishop Josaphat Kuntsevych took over many Orthodox churches; in 1623 a crowd killed him.

By the 1700s two-thirds of the Orthodox in western Ukraine had become Greek Catholic. Then the costs ran the other way. As Russia took over Ukraine, Tsar Nicholas I abolished the union in his lands in 1839.

In 1946 the Soviet state staged a synod at Lviv that folded the Church into the Russian Orthodox Church. Its bishops were already in prison; Metropolitan Josyf Slipyj spent 18 years in the camps. The Church survived underground and was legal again in 1989.

Today the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church is the largest Church, with millions of faithful, led by a major archbishop in Kyiv. Ukraine's Orthodox Churches are not in with Rome.

Go further· 5 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The Church that came out of it was later destroyed twice over

    Tsar Nicholas I abolished the union in all areas under Russian rule in 1839. In the twentieth century the Soviet state liquidated the Church outright, and its metropolitan spent eighteen years in exile and prison.

    “Outstanding among the heroic witnesses to the rights not only of the faith but also of human conscience in those difficult years is the figure of Metropolitan Josyf Slipyj: his courage in enduring exile and prison for 18 years and his indomitable confidence in the resurrection of his Church make him one of the most powerful figures among the confessors of the faith in our time.”
    Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest · Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest, §3
  2. 02

    Two-thirds, then suppression

    The reference work's arithmetic on both halves of the story: how far the union spread, and how thoroughly it was undone by the Russian state.

    “By the 18th century, two-thirds of the Orthodox in western Ukraine had become Greek Catholic. But as Orthodox Russia expanded its control into Ukraine, the union was gradually suppressed. In 1839, Tsar Nicholas I abolished it in all areas under Russian rule with the exception of the eparchy of Kholm (in Polish territory), which was itself integrated into the Russian Orthodox Church in 1875.”
    Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church'
  3. 03

    The archbishop who was killed, as a Ukrainian encyclopedia tells it

    A secular Ukrainian reference work gives both halves of Kuntsevych's story: a reforming archbishop, and one who, with the king behind him, took Orthodox churches. It dates the restored Orthodox hierarchy to 1620.

    “Supported by the Polish king and the Vatican, Kuntsevych took over many Orthodox churches and transformed them into Uniate ones. The re-establishment of the Orthodox hierarchy in 1620 and the appointment of a new Orthodox bishop for Polatsk resulted in intensified religious conflict in the region.”
    Encyclopedia of Ukraine, 'Kuntsevych, Yosafat' · Encyclopedia of Ukraine, 'Kuntsevych, Yosafat' (vol. 2, 1988)
  4. 04

    1946: how the Soviet state ended the union

    The synod at Lviv was staged by the state, with its bishops in prison. The same encyclopedia describes how priests were brought to agree.

    “Priests who were not convinced by these arguments were subjected to less subtle persuasion by Soviet security officials, through direct threats, deportation, or summary sentences to terms in forced labor camps.”
    Encyclopedia of Ukraine, 'Lviv Sobor of 1946' · Encyclopedia of Ukraine, 'Lviv Sobor of 1946' (Bohdan R. Bociurkiw, vol. 3, 1993)
  5. 05

    1989: legal again

    Forty-three years underground ended in the last years of the Soviet Union.

    “On 1 December 1989 the Ukrainian Catholic church was legalized by the authorities of the Ukrainian SSR.”
    Encyclopedia of Ukraine, 'Lviv Sobor of 1946' · Encyclopedia of Ukraine, 'Lviv Sobor of 1946', closing paragraph
Why it matters

For the trail

Brest shows both sides of the unions at once. Rome granted an Eastern Church its liturgy, its calendar and its own bishops; wrote that the union ‘did not involve passing over to the Latin tradition’.

It's also the clearest case of a union backed by a king against bishops who said no.

For the Orthodox, Brest is the model of : bringing one part of a Church over to Rome on its own, which splits it in two. After 1989, when the Greek Catholics came back above ground, the official dialogue had to deal with this first.

What still divides Catholics and Orthodox is mainly the pope's authority: how far it reaches over other Churches. Since 2006 the dialogue has worked on exactly that. In November 2025 Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew prayed the Nicene Creed together at İznik, ancient Nicaea.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The strongest Catholic sentence about Brest

    A pope, in a letter celebrating the union, claiming the thing that would matter most if it were kept: the Church that joined was not required to become Latin.

    “In the history of the Catholic Church, it is a highly significant fact that this just desire was respected and that the act of union did not involve passing over to the Latin tradition, as some thought would happen. Their Church saw an acknowledgment of its right to be governed by its own hierarchy with a specific discipline and to maintain its Eastern liturgical and spiritual heritage.”
    Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest · Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest, §2
  2. 02

    Why the old method worked the way it did

    A 2024 study from the Vatican's office for Christian unity explains the thinking behind uniatism: a claim of direct authority over every local Church, which made other Churches a mission field.

    “It implied that Churches not in communion with this See could be the object of missionary activity “to bring them back” into communion with the Catholic Church, while allowing them to preserve their own liturgy and discipline.”
  3. 03

    İznik, 28 November 2025

    At the 1,700th anniversary of the Council of Nicaea, Pope Leo XIV spoke beside Patriarch Bartholomew before the Creed was prayed together.

    “In this way, we are all invited to overcome the scandal of the divisions that unfortunately still exist and to nurture the desire for unity for which the Lord Jesus prayed and gave his life.”
    Ecumenical Prayer Service near the archaeological excavations of the ancient Basilica of Saint Neophytos, İznik · Holy See Press Office bulletin, 28 November 2025, address of Leo XIV at İznik
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Catholic Church teaches that the Eastern Catholic Churches are Churches in their own right, equal in dignity to the Latin Church, and must keep their own liturgy and traditions whole (Orientalium Ecclesiarum 3 and 6).

In 1993, at Balamand in Lebanon, the official Catholic–Orthodox dialogue looked back at unions like this one. In each, ==one part of an Eastern Church came into communion with Rome on its own==, and that Church ended up split in two.

Both sides agreed that this way of seeking unity should not be used any more. Unity should come from the two Churches talking as equals, not from winning people over one group at a time.

In the same document they agreed that the Eastern Catholic Churches that already exist have every right to exist and to look after their people.

Josaphat Kuntsevych, the Catholic archbishop of Polotsk, worked hard to bring people into the union. In 1623 a crowd opposed to it killed him at Vitebsk, in today's Belarus. The Catholic Church honours him as a saint and martyr; he was canonised in 1867.

The Orthodox remember him very differently: as a bishop who pressed the union on people who didn't want it, and who took over their churches.

In plain terms

Think of it like this

A treaty whose terms were generous and whose signing was not free.

The conditions the Ruthenian bishops brought to Rome were largely granted: their rite, their calendar, their hierarchy, their married clergy. Then a king made recognition as a bishop conditional on having signed, and two bishops who refused lost their sees. Good terms and coerced consent are different questions, and a union can fail the second while passing the first.

Read the text
“Bishops Gideon Balaban, of Lemberg , and Michael Kopystenski, of Przemysl, having declared themselves opposed to the union, were deposed and excommunicated . Their dioceses remained in schism until 1720. [...] But Sigismund III efficaciously undertook the defence of the union; in an edict of 5 December, 1596, he ordered the Ruthenians to recognize as bishops only those who had accepted the act of union.”
The Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Union of Brest' · 'Union of Brest', narrative of the Synod of Brest, October to December 1596

The spacing before commas is New Advent's markup, where inline links insert whitespace; the words are unaltered. The ' [...] ' skips two sentences on the opposition's published protest. This is a Catholic reference work of 1912, openly partisan in its language elsewhere on the page, supplying the concrete content of what Balamand would later call the interference of extraecclesial interests.

Other readings

Where people disagree

The Orthodox Church in America teaches these events as a ‘forced imposition’. It counts the bishops differently: nine of eleven for the union, where the Catholic account names the metropolitan and five bishops for it and two against.

Both agree that most of the bishops said yes, and that the rites were promised; they differ completely on how the union was lived.

Ukrainian Greek Catholics remember Brest as the way their Church kept its Eastern identity, and as the faith they suffered for under the tsars and the Soviets.

In 1993 the dialogue tried to hold both. It rejected uniatism as a method and said the Eastern Catholic Churches ‘have the right to exist’. The Moscow Patriarchate agreed to work from it; the Church of Greece rejected it.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The same events, as Orthodox Christians are catechised in them

    Written for an Orthodox readership by the Orthodox Church in America. It counts nine of eleven bishops for the union, where the Catholic account has six of eight, and agrees on the guarantee of rites. The word it uses for what followed is imposition.

    “In 1596, at the Council of Brest-Litovsk, nine of the eleven Ruthenian Orthodox bishops formally accepted union with the Roman Church, with the agreement that the Orthodox would be allowed to maintain all their liturgical rites and customs. This arrangement, built upon the decisions of the Council of Florence in 1439, was contemptuously rejected by many of the Orthodox faithful. [...] The Orthodox who resisted the forced imposition of this “Unia” arrangement were given much support in their struggle by the Cossack brotherhoods”
  2. 02

    A pope concedes the objection in his own words

    In the same letter for the fourth centenary, John Paul II states the difficulty without arguing with it first.

    “There are those who see the existence of the Eastern Catholic Churches as a difficulty on the road of ecumenism.”
    Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest · Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest, §6
  3. 03

    What each side feared in 1993

    A Catholic priest who worked for the Vatican's unity office explains why Balamand said two things at once.

    “Since many Greek Catholics feared that rejection of uniatism as a policy called into question the very existence of their churches, the document states without equivocation that they do have a right to exist and to care for their faithful.”
    Balamand and Beyond: The State of Catholic-Orthodox Relations, ONE Magazine · Section on the Balamand Document's two affirmations

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Claims behind this footprint

What this rests on

Each claim says one thing, shows the words it rests on, and says how far it has been checked. Long passages are folded; open them to read the whole text.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Union of Brest was agreed at a meeting of representatives of the Metropolia of Kiev with the Pope on 23 December 1595 and solemnly proclaimed at Brest-Litovsk on 16 October 1596; Clement VIII announced it in the constitution Magnus Dominus et laudabilis nimis. It is the origin of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church.

Rests on
  • Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest, §1
    “The union was effected at the meeting of representatives of the Metropolia of Kiev with the Pope on 23 December 1595 and was solemnly proclaimed at Brest-Litovsk on the River Bug on 16 October 1596. Pope Clement VIII, in the Apostolic Constitution …”
    Read the full passage
    “The union was effected at the meeting of representatives of the Metropolia of Kiev with the Pope on 23 December 1595 and was solemnly proclaimed at Brest-Litovsk on the River Bug on 16 October 1596. Pope Clement VIII, in the Apostolic Constitution Magnus Dominus et laudabilis nimis, announced the union to the whole Church and in the Apostolic Letter Benedictus sit Pastor he addressed the Bishops of the Metropolia, informing them that the union had taken place.”
Limits
  • The letter is a Catholic account of the union; the Orthodox reading of Brest, and the later history of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church under suppression, must come from other sources.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

02HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

The Union of Brest was negotiated by Ruthenian bishops on their own initiative and concluded at Rome on 23 December 1595 on terms that preserved their rite, including the agreement that the Filioque would not be inserted into the Creed; it was proclaimed at Brest-Litovsk in October 1596, nine of the eleven Ruthenian bishops accepting it. The two who refused were deposed and excommunicated, and on 5 December 1596 King Sigismund III ordered that only bishops who had accepted the union be recognised.

Rests on
  • 'Union of Brest', narrative of the negotiations at Rome, late 1595
    “the pope and the cardinals discussed the conditions of reunion proposed by the Ruthenian episcopate, and ungrudgingly conceded that the integrity of the Ruthenian Rite should be maintained; it was also agreed that the “Filioque” should not be …”
    Read the full passage
    “the pope and the cardinals discussed the conditions of reunion proposed by the Ruthenian episcopate, and ungrudgingly conceded that the integrity of the Ruthenian Rite should be maintained; it was also agreed that the “Filioque” should not be inserted in the Nicene Creed , although the Ruthenian clergy professed and taught the procession of the Holy Spirit from the Son.”
  • 'Union of Brest', narrative of the Rome ceremony, 23 December 1595
    “Then Pociej, in his own name and that of the Ruthenian episcopate, read in Latin the formula of abjuration of the Greek Schism, Terlecki read it in Ruthenian , and they affixed their signatures.”
  • 'Union of Brest', narrative of the Synod of Brest, October to December 1596
    “Bishops Gideon Balaban, of Lemberg , and Michael Kopystenski, of Przemysl, having declared themselves opposed to the union, were deposed and excommunicated . Their dioceses remained in schism until 1720. [...] But Sigismund III efficaciously …”
    Read the full passage
    “Bishops Gideon Balaban, of Lemberg , and Michael Kopystenski, of Przemysl, having declared themselves opposed to the union, were deposed and excommunicated . Their dioceses remained in schism until 1720. [...] But Sigismund III efficaciously undertook the defence of the union; in an edict of 5 December, 1596, he ordered the Ruthenians to recognize as bishops only those who had accepted the act of union.”
  • Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest §1
    “The union was effected at the meeting of representatives of the Metropolia of Kiev with the Pope on 23 December 1595 and was solemnly proclaimed at Brest-Litovsk on the River Bug on 16 October 1596.”
  • Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest §2
    “In the history of the Catholic Church, it is a highly significant fact that this just desire was respected and that the act of union did not involve passing over to the Latin tradition, as some thought would happen. Their Church saw an …”
    Read the full passage
    “In the history of the Catholic Church, it is a highly significant fact that this just desire was respected and that the act of union did not involve passing over to the Latin tradition, as some thought would happen. Their Church saw an acknowledgment of its right to be governed by its own hierarchy with a specific discipline and to maintain its Eastern liturgical and spiritual heritage.”
  • Body of the article, paragraphs 3-4
    “In 1596, at the Council of Brest-Litovsk, nine of the eleven Ruthenian Orthodox bishops formally accepted union with the Roman Church, with the agreement that the Orthodox would be allowed to maintain all their liturgical rites and customs. This …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 1596, at the Council of Brest-Litovsk, nine of the eleven Ruthenian Orthodox bishops formally accepted union with the Roman Church, with the agreement that the Orthodox would be allowed to maintain all their liturgical rites and customs. This arrangement, built upon the decisions of the Council of Florence in 1439, was contemptuously rejected by many of the Orthodox faithful. [...] The Orthodox who resisted the forced imposition of this “Unia” arrangement were given much support in their struggle by the Cossack brotherhoods”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox Church in America teaches the same events as the forced imposition of a 'Unia', resisted by the faithful and supported by the Cossack brotherhoods.
  • John Paul II's reading is that a just desire was respected and no passing over to the Latin tradition occurred. That is a claim about the terms agreed, not about how the terms were kept afterwards.
  • Neither 'coerced' nor 'freely sought' fits the record as a whole. The initiative came from inside the Ruthenian episcopate; the coercion documented here is chiefly the state's, applied after the fact against those who refused.
Limits
  • No primary text of the union was read for this chapter: not the conditions of 1595, not Clement VIII's bulls Magnus Dominus et laudabilis (23 December 1595), Benedictus sit Pastor ille bonus (7 February 1596) or Decet Romanum Pontificem (23 February 1596). Every statement about what the articles said rests on two secondary accounts, one from 1912 and one from 1995, both Catholic.
  • The retention of the Julian calendar is often listed among the terms conceded at Rome. No text read for this chapter states it. The 1912 narrative quoted here names the rite and the Filioque only, so the chapter does not claim the calendar among the terms.
  • The earliest account read here is 316 years after the event and is openly partisan: its author elsewhere on the same page calls the Orthodox 'the so-called Orthodox Church'. Its facts are usable; its judgements are not neutral history.
  • The Orthodox account used here is an undated catechetical web page that cites no sources. It is quoted as the Orthodox self-understanding, not as a historical finding.
  • The date 16 October 1596 is the Gregorian equivalent. The 1912 narrative has the synod convoked for 8 October and the declaration read on 9 October, on the Julian reckoning the Ruthenians had asked to keep. A single date should not be presented as uncontested.
  • The spacing before some punctuation marks in the 1912 quotations is New Advent's markup around inline links, not an alteration of the words.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

03HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

A papal agency for the Eastern churches describes most Orthodox Christians as regarding the Eastern Catholic Churches as an obstacle to reconciliation, and as holding that the unions grew from efforts to split local Orthodox communities; an Orthodox catechetical history of Brest describes that union as a forced imposition rejected by many of the Orthodox faithful. No survey measures how many Orthodox hold the view. The official Catholic-Orthodox dialogue itself concedes that these initiatives broke communion with the Mother Churches of the East and took place 'not without the interference of extraecclesial interests', and a Catholic source gives a concrete case of it at Brest in 1596: the king ordered the Ruthenians to recognise only bishops who had accepted the union.

Rests on
  • Introductory essay, paragraph beginning 'Most Orthodox view these churches'
    “Most Orthodox view these churches as an obstacle in the way of reconciliation between the Catholic and Orthodox churches. They feel that their very existence constitutes a denial by Catholics of the ecclesial reality of the Orthodox Church, and that these unions grew from efforts to split local Orthodox communities.”
  • Balamand Document §8
    “In the course of the last four centuries, in various parts of the East, initiatives were taken within certain Churches and impelled by outside elements, to restore communion between the Church of the East and the Church of the West. These …”
    Read the full passage
    “In the course of the last four centuries, in various parts of the East, initiatives were taken within certain Churches and impelled by outside elements, to restore communion between the Church of the East and the Church of the West. These initiatives led to the union of certain communities with the See of Rome and brought with them, as a consequence, the breaking of communion with their Mother Churches of the East. This took place not without the interference of extraecclesial interests. In this way Oriental Catholic Churches came into being. And so a situation was created which has become a source of conflicts and of suffering in the first instance for the Orthodox but also for Catholics.”
  • Body of the article, paragraphs 3-4
    “In 1596, at the Council of Brest-Litovsk, nine of the eleven Ruthenian Orthodox bishops formally accepted union with the Roman Church, with the agreement that the Orthodox would be allowed to maintain all their liturgical rites and customs. This …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 1596, at the Council of Brest-Litovsk, nine of the eleven Ruthenian Orthodox bishops formally accepted union with the Roman Church, with the agreement that the Orthodox would be allowed to maintain all their liturgical rites and customs. This arrangement, built upon the decisions of the Council of Florence in 1439, was contemptuously rejected by many of the Orthodox faithful. [...] The Orthodox who resisted the forced imposition of this “Unia” arrangement were given much support in their struggle by the Cossack brotherhoods”
  • 'Union of Brest', narrative of the Synod of Brest, October to December 1596
    “Bishops Gideon Balaban, of Lemberg, and Michael Kopystenski, of Przemysl, having declared themselves opposed to the union, were deposed and excommunicated. Their dioceses remained in schism until 1720. [...] But Sigismund III efficaciously undertook …”
    Read the full passage
    “Bishops Gideon Balaban, of Lemberg, and Michael Kopystenski, of Przemysl, having declared themselves opposed to the union, were deposed and excommunicated. Their dioceses remained in schism until 1720. [...] But Sigismund III efficaciously undertook the defence of the union; in an edict of 5 December, 1596, he ordered the Ruthenians to recognize as bishops only those who had accepted the act of union.”
  • Apostolic Letter for the Fourth Centenary of the Union of Brest §6
    “There are those who see the existence of the Eastern Catholic Churches as a difficulty on the road of ecumenism.”
Other readings
  • Eastern Catholics reject the characterisation outright. On their account their Churches are not an instrument against Orthodoxy but communities that chose communion and then paid for it, in several cases under persecution.
  • A Catholic reading points out that Balamand §8 says the initiatives were taken "within certain Churches", and calls the interference that accompanied them "extraecclesial".
Limits
  • 'Most Orthodox' here rests on the characterisation of a Catholic papal agency and on Orthodox catechetical writing, not on any survey. It is a fair summary of how the objection is stated by Orthodox bodies; it is not a measurement of opinion.
  • The CNEWA page was last modified on 25 March 2015, had to be retrieved through the Internet Archive, and therefore reflects nothing after the Havana declaration of 2016.
  • 'Not without the interference of extraecclesial interests' is negotiated language, deliberately vague about who pressured whom. The concrete case cited here, Sigismund III's edict, is one instance and is not evidence about every union.
  • Not every Eastern Catholic Church fits the pattern. The same CNEWA page records that 'The Bulgarian Byzantine Catholic Church, for example, was the direct result of a spontaneous movement of Orthodox towards Rome. And the Maronites in Lebanon claim never to have been out of communion with the Roman Church.'
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The official Catholic-Orthodox theological dialogue has rejected uniatism as a method and a model of union, and the Catholic side took part in that rejection. It was first stated at Freising in June 1990 and set out in the document the joint international commission finished at Balamand on 23 June 1993. John Paul II commended the commission's work on the method in Ut Unum Sint §60 on 25 May 1995, and Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill signed a declaration at Havana on 12 February 2016 saying that the past method of uniatism is not the way to re-establish unity. The same documents affirm that the existing Eastern Catholic Churches have the right to exist.

Rests on
  • Balamand Document §2
    “With regard to the method which has been called "uniatism", it was stated at Freising (June 1990) that "we reject it as method for the search for unity because it is opposed to the common tradition of our Churches".”
  • Balamand Document §12
    “Because of the way in which Catholics and Orthodox once again consider each other in their relationship to the mystery of the Church and discover each other once again as Sister Churches, this form of "missionary apostolate" described above, and …”
    Read the full passage
    “Because of the way in which Catholics and Orthodox once again consider each other in their relationship to the mystery of the Church and discover each other once again as Sister Churches, this form of "missionary apostolate" described above, and which has been called "uniatism", can no longer be accepted either as a method to be followed nor as a model of the unity our Churches are seeking.”
  • Balamand Document §3
    “Concerning the Oriental Catholic Churches, it is clear that they, as part of the Catholic Communion, have the right to exist and to act in answer to the spiritual needs of their faithful.”
  • Balamand Document §30
    “To pave the way for future relations between the two Churches, passing beyond the outdated ecclesiology of return to the Catholic Church connected with the problem which is the object of this document, special attention will be given to the …”
    Read the full passage
    “To pave the way for future relations between the two Churches, passing beyond the outdated ecclesiology of return to the Catholic Church connected with the problem which is the object of this document, special attention will be given to the preparation of future priests and of all those who, in any way, are involved in an apostolic activity carried on in a place where the other Church traditionally has its roots.”
  • Ut Unum Sint §60, opening sentences
    “More recently, the Joint International Commission took a significant step forward with regard to the very sensitive question of the method to be followed in re-establishing full communion between the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church, an issue …”
    Read the full passage
    “More recently, the Joint International Commission took a significant step forward with regard to the very sensitive question of the method to be followed in re-establishing full communion between the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church, an issue which has frequently embittered relations between Catholics and Orthodox. The Commission has laid the doctrinal foundations for a positive solution to this problem on the basis of the doctrine of Sister Churches.”
  • Ut Unum Sint §60
    “Here too it has become evident that the method to be followed towards full communion is the dialogue of truth, fostered and sustained by the dialogue of love. A recognition of the right of the Eastern Catholic Churches to have their own …”
    Read the full passage
    “Here too it has become evident that the method to be followed towards full communion is the dialogue of truth, fostered and sustained by the dialogue of love. A recognition of the right of the Eastern Catholic Churches to have their own organizational structures and to carry out their own apostolate, as well as the actual involvement of these Churches in the dialogue of charity and in theological dialogue, will not only promote a true and fraternal mutual esteem between Orthodox and Catholics living in the same territory, but will also foster their joint commitment to work for unity.”
  • Joint Declaration of Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill §25
    “It is today clear that the past method of “uniatism”, understood as the union of one community to the other, separating it from its Church, is not the way to re–establish unity. Nonetheless, the ecclesial communities which emerged in these …”
    Read the full passage
    “It is today clear that the past method of “uniatism”, understood as the union of one community to the other, separating it from its Church, is not the way to re–establish unity. Nonetheless, the ecclesial communities which emerged in these historical circumstances have the right to exist and to undertake all that is necessary to meet the spiritual needs of their faithful, while seeking to live in peace with their neighbours.”
  • CNA interview with Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk, 23 February 2016
    “He noticed that “The joint declaration by Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill in the end makes this acknowledgement, and this is positive.” But on the other hand, the joint declaration referred to the Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church as among the “ecclesial communities.””
Other readings
  • Many Catholics read §3 and Havana §25 as the operative sentences: the method is disowned, the Churches are affirmed, and nothing in Catholic teaching has changed.
  • Many Orthodox read §3 as the reason the document fails, since it leaves in place the very thing they object to. The rejection of the method without a remedy for the result strikes them as a concession that costs nothing.
  • Some Eastern Catholics read the rejection as an abandonment of the communities the method produced, and objected to it in those terms.
Limits
  • Balamand is not a definition of faith. It is the report of a joint commission. The Catholic Church has never received it as binding doctrine and the Orthodox Church as a whole never received it at all.
  • The rejection did not originate at Balamand. Balamand §2 quotes Freising, June 1990.
  • The English text is a same-day working translation of a French original, as the document's own closing note states. No argument should be built on a single English word without checking the French.
  • Ut Unum Sint §60 commends the commission's conclusion without naming Balamand, without ever using the word uniatism and without repeating the admissions of Balamand §§8-11; its footnote cites John Paul II's 1991 letter to the bishops of Europe. It restates the half of Balamand that Catholics found easy.
  • Havana §25 calls Eastern Catholics 'ecclesial communities' rather than Churches, in a text a pope signed. Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church welcomed its acknowledgement of their right to exist but objected publicly to that phrase, which Catholic usage applies to Protestant bodies. His objection is known here from a CNA news report of an interview, not from a statement of his Church's synod.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

Go deeper
Questions people ask next