From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/was-jesus-crucified
← Another faithYes. Historians of every background, Christian or not, accept that Jesus was under . A Roman historian and a Jewish historian both mention it, and so do 's letters. For Christians, his death and rising are the centre of everything.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 599–618
- Vatican II
- Nostra Aetate, 3
Muslims honour Jesus as a prophet.1 So this question isn't disrespectful. It comes from a verse Muslims believe is God's own word.
The Qur'an says of Jesus: And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him; but [another] was made to resemble him to them.2
Most Muslims take this to mean God made another man look like Jesus, and took Jesus himself up to , from where he will return at the end of time.3 A few Muslim scholars about 1,000 years ago read it differently, and accepted the crucifixion.3
Crucifixion was the Romans' death penalty: being nailed to a wooden cross until you died.4 The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus truly died that way under Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor. And this isn't only a Christian claim.
Historians of every background treat the crucifixion, with his , as one of the two surest facts about his life.4
What outsiders wrote
Start with , a Roman senator and historian who had no love for Christians. Writing in the early 100s about the great fire of Rome, he explains where the name Christian came from:
Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus
Christus is , Jesus's title. A procurator was a Roman governor, and the extreme penalty means execution.5 Tacitus wasn't defending anyone. He mentions it in passing.
, a Jewish historian writing around AD 93, mentions it too.4 To be honest, Christians later added lines to his passage. But most scholars think a core is genuine, including that Pilate condemned him to the cross.6,4
Then there's Paul, a Christian leader who wrote letters to the first churches. Around the year 56 he wrote to Christians in Corinth, a Greek city.7
In that letter he passes on a short statement of faith he'd been taught: that Christ died for our in accordance with the scriptures; that he was buried.8
Many Muslims would object here: Paul never met Jesus before the cross, and they believe he changed Jesus's message. But Paul says he received this statement himself, and many scholars think it came from Jesus's first followers in Jerusalem.8,13
And the cross doesn't rest on Paul anyway. Tacitus and Josephus weren't Christians at all. "Didn't Paul change Jesus's message?" looks at the charge in full.
Think of it like this
Think of a family story. Grandpa's corner shop burned down in 1961. Your cousins tell it with different details. One says the fire started at night. Another swears it was at dawn. An uncle says the bakery next door caught first.
Then you go looking. The neighbours remember it. The old local newspaper has a photo of the smoke. Even the rival shop owner across the road, who never liked Grandpa, mentions it in a letter.
Friends, outsiders and a rival all agree on one thing. At that point you stop asking did the shop burn down? You start arguing about why, and what it meant for the family.
That's where historians are with the cross. The details get argued over. The fact itself doesn't.
Why historians are so sure
A well-known scholar who writes as a historian, not a believer, points to something odd.9
No Jew before Jesus expected the , the rescuer God had promised, to be crucified. Yet the first Christians preached a crucified Messiah anyway, because they knew full well that he was crucified.9
Nobody invents the most embarrassing possible ending for their hero.
What about a look-alike?
Muslims have a careful answer here. The verse says someone was made to resemble him, so of course people reported a crucifixion.2 The real question is who was on that cross.
Christians answer by pointing to the witnesses. Paul's list names , then the Twelve, Jesus's closest followers, then more than 500 others, most of whom are still living. Those were people a doubter could go and ask.8
The people who knew Jesus best had eaten and travelled with him. They said they met him alive again after he died.
To be fair, that comes from the Easter story itself, so on its own it can't prove who died on the Friday.
For that, go back to the outsiders. Tacitus and Josephus, neither of them Christian, and Paul's early creed all say the one who died was Jesus himself.5,6,8
No source from Jesus's own century, friend or enemy, says Rome crucified the wrong man. The first to say it was Basilides, a teacher in Egypt around AD 130, who taught that Simon of Cyrene died in Jesus's place.14
So it comes down to trust. On one side, sources from the first century or so after him, friendly and hostile. On the other, the Qur'an, which came six centuries later. If you believe it's God's own word, its date won't trouble you. That's a question of faith, and it's yours to weigh.
Why it matters so much
For Christians this isn't a side detail. Christianity stands or falls on it. Paul wrote that if Jesus has not been raised, the whole message is empty.8 And you can't rise from the dead without dying first.
Why did he have to die at all? The says his death was not the result of chance. It was part of God's plan to free people from sin: the wrong we do, which breaks our bond with God and with each other.10
Christians believe that weight is too heavy for any human to carry. No one, not even the holiest, could carry the sins of all people, the Catechism says. Only someone who is both God and man could, so God carried it himself.10
It wasn't that God wanted blood. The Catechism says it's love to the end that gives his sacrifice its value.10
Christians also see the cross foretold in a prophecy of , written centuries before, about a suffering Servant.10 Jewish readers understand that passage differently.
That's why it matters who was on the cross. If Jesus didn't die there, he didn't freely give his life, and the heart of the Christian message goes with it.
Why can't God just forgive?
Many Muslims ask the obvious next question. The Qur'an says no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another.11 Each person answers for their own deeds. So why would anyone need to die for someone else's sins? Why can't God just forgive?
Catholic thinkers agree with more of that than you might expect. , the medieval teacher whose thinking still shapes Catholic teaching, said God could have forgiven sin with no payment at all. Since sin is against God himself, forgiving it outright wrongs no one.12
So the cross isn't God being unable to forgive. And Christians don't see Jesus as a stranger dragged in to pay for someone else's wrong. They believe he is God the Son, who gave his life freely, out of love, so on the cross God himself carries the cost.10
Then why this way? Aquinas's first reason is simple: through the cross, people see how much God loves them, and are moved to love him back.12 "Why did Jesus have to die?" goes further into this.
Both faiths believe God is merciful. Christians believe his mercy went as far as a cross.
None of this asks anyone to think less of Muslims. Since 1965 the Catholic Church has urged Christians and Muslims to forget the past and work for understanding.1
Both honour Jesus. Where they differ is on what happened that Friday, and Christians believe the evidence points one way.
Sources14
- 1Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (28 October 1965), 3Muslims revere Jesus as a prophet and honour Mary; a call to forget past quarrels.
- 2The Qur'an 4:157 (Sahih International translation, Quranic Arabic Corpus)They did not kill him, nor crucify him; another was made to resemble him.
- 3Wikipedia, Islamic views on Jesus' deathMainstream Muslims hold Jesus was not crucified but raised bodily to heaven, to return; the Ahmadi view; Ismaili scholars who accepted the crucifixion.
- 4Wikipedia, Crucifixion of JesusScholars nearly universally accept the crucifixion; with the baptism, the two most certain facts; Antiquities written about 93; Josephus's passage has an authentic core.
- 5Tacitus, Annals 15.44 (Perseus Digital Library, trans. Church and Brodribb)A hostile Roman historian on Christ's execution under Pontius Pilate.
- 6Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews 18.3.3 (63–64), trans. WhistonThe Testimonium: Jesus condemned to the cross by Pilate.
- 71 Corinthians, introduction (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Paul wrote the letter from Ephesus about the year 56.
- 81 Corinthians 15:3–17 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The early creed: Christ died, was buried, was raised on the third day.
- 9Bart D. Ehrman, Did Jesus Exist? (HuffPost, 20 March 2012)A non-Christian scholar on why no one would invent a crucified Messiah.
- 10Catechism of the Catholic Church, 599–618 (Christ's death in God's plan)Not chance but God's plan; Isaiah's Servant; love to the end.
- 11The Qur'an 6:164 (Sahih International translation, Quranic Arabic Corpus)"No bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another" (also 35:18).
- 12Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae III, q. 46, aa. 1–3 (New Advent)God could have freed us without satisfaction and wronged no one; the Passion was the fitting way, first because it shows how much God loves us.
- 13Wikipedia, Pauline ChristianityThe creed in 1 Corinthians 15:3–5, probably from the Jerusalem apostolic community.
- 14Irenaeus, Against Heresies I.24 (c. 180), on BasilidesBasilides taught that Jesus did not die, but Simon of Cyrene was crucified in his stead.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.