← No religion, or not sure
Jesus and the Bible

Did Jesus really rise from the dead?

Read it as an illustrated story · 8 min

ACG works this question through in his own story. Read that part of his story: Did he really rise? · 7 min

Christians believe he did, in his body. History can't prove a miracle, but it can show what needs explaining. Jesus died, the earliest accounts say his tomb was found empty, and his followers, even a former enemy, said they saw him alive and wouldn't take it back.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Catechism
638–658

Dead people stay dead. Everyone in the ancient world knew that as well as we do.

So when Christians say Jesus came back to life on the third day after he was executed, it's fair to want strong evidence. They call it the , and it's the claim Christianity stands or falls on.

The Catholic Church is upfront about what nobody saw, not even the four writers, the authors of the four books about Jesus's life.

But no one was an eyewitness to Christ's Resurrection and no evangelist describes it. No one can say how it came about physically.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 647

So what can we actually look at? What came before and after: a dead man, a tomb, and the people who said they met him.

Muslims, who honour Jesus as a great prophet, believe he wasn't at all.11 Their view has its own answer in this FAQ.

The earliest report

In about AD 56, wrote a letter to the Christians in Corinth, a city in Greece. In it he passed on a short summary he'd been taught.

died, was buried, was raised on the third day, and appeared to , then to the Twelve, the friends he'd chosen to carry on his work.2 (Christ is a title, not a surname: Christians gave it to Jesus as the promised rescuer.)

Then Paul adds something bold. Jesus appeared to more than five hundred brothers at once, most of whom are still living.2

He was pointing to people his readers could still go and ask.

To be fair, none of the 500 left an account of their own that survives.

That's less strange than it sounds. Most people in Jesus's homeland couldn't read or write anything like a book, a historian of ancient Jewish life explains.9 They'd have told what they saw out loud, to anyone who asked. That's exactly what Paul was inviting.

And Paul himself had been an enemy. He says he tried to destroy the church.3 Then, he says, the risen Jesus appeared to him too, and the man hunting Jesus's followers became one of them.2

Witnesses nobody would choose

The Gospels agree that women found the tomb empty first.4,5

That matters, because back then a woman's word counted for little in court. , a Jewish historian of the time, records the rule: let not the testimony of women be admitted.6

If you were making the story up, you wouldn't pick them. And even the men closest to Jesus thought the women's report was nonsense, Luke says.4

The other explanations

So what else could explain it?

The body was stolen. Matthew's Gospel says this story was already going around.5 But the people who'd have stolen it, Jesus's followers, later suffered for saying he rose.

To be fair, the early sources tell us how only a few of them died. But they agree the were jailed, beaten and threatened, and kept saying it.12

People die for things they wrongly believe. They rarely die for something they know they made up.

They were grieving and saw things. Bart Ehrman, a leading agnostic scholar, says belief began because some followers had visions of him afterward.8 He thinks they were probably the kind of visions grieving people often have.7

But those don't usually convince a whole group that a buried body came back. And Paul wasn't grieving. He was trying to wipe Jesus's followers out.3

It's a legend that grew. Ehrman now thinks Jesus was probably thrown into a common grave of some kind. He says the empty tomb leads to confusion but it doesn't lead to belief.8

Others answer that Paul's early summary already says he was buried. To them, that points to a proper grave, not a mass one.2,7

Think of it like this

Think of a court case about a man's death. The judge has no video. Nobody filmed what happened. All she has is what both sides agree on, and what they argue about.

Both lawyers accept that the man really died. Both accept that his friends ran away the night he was arrested, and hid. And both accept that, weeks later, those same frightened friends were suddenly willing to go to jail, and worse, for saying they'd seen him alive. Other facts, like the empty tomb, are fought over.

So the judge lines up the explanations one by one. Theft. Grief. Legend. Each covers a piece. Then she asks which story covers all of it, without leaving anything awkward in the corner.

The best explanation is the one that leaves nothing out. That's how Christians invite you to weigh the resurrection. Not with a video, but by asking which account explains everything we know.

What history can and can't do

Now the limit. A historian can show the tomb was reported empty and the said they saw him. A historian can't, just by the rules of the job, say God did this. Ehrman says the same: whether God actually raised Jesus is something historians can't decide.8

So a lot depends on where you start. If you're sure miracles can't happen, no evidence will ever be enough. If you're open to them, the question is simply which explanation fits best.

The most famous case for ruling miracles out comes from David Hume, a Scottish philosopher of the 1700s. When someone says a dead man came back to life, he said, ask which is more likely: that the witness was fooled or lying, or that it really happened.10

His conclusion: no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless its being false would be even more of a miracle.10

Critics answered him in his own century. One pointed to how the apostles lived: they chose hard work, shame and misery over an easy, respected life. People choosing that for a story they knew was false, he argued, would break the laws of nature as surely as a lump of lead floating in the air.10

That shows, at most, that the witnesses were honest. Whether they could have been mistaken is a separate question.10

Philosophers still argue about Hume. A leading encyclopedia of philosophy sums up the debate: how you weigh a miracle report depends a lot on what else you believe, above all about God.10

Being sure miracles can't happen and being open to them are both starting points, not findings. Which one you bring depends on whether you think God exists at all, which is where the first answers on this page begin.

What the Catholic Church teaches

The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus truly rose from the dead, in his body, on the third day. The calls it a real event that people at the time could check, not just a feeling.1

About the empty tomb it says: In itself it is not a direct proof of Resurrection; the absence of Christ's body from the tomb could be explained otherwise.1

The tomb is a sign, not the proof.

And they weren't easy believers. They were frightened, they doubted, and some thought they were seeing a ghost. So the idea that they simply talked themselves into it, the Catechism says, will not hold up.1

In the Gospels, the risen Jesus eats with his friends and lets them touch him. His body still carries the wounds of his execution.1

And this wasn't Jesus going back to his old life. The Gospels tell of Lazarus, a friend Jesus brought back from the dead. But Lazarus only came back to an ordinary life. As the Catechism points out, one day he would die again. Catholics believe Jesus passed into a new kind of life that death can't touch.1

Everything rests on this, and the Catholic Church says so without hedging. It quotes Paul: If Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain.1 The , from the ancient Churches of the Christian East, and Protestants stand on the same ground.

History can't force you to believe. But the disciples' faith, the Catechism says, was born from their direct experience of the reality of the risen Jesus.1 They didn't talk themselves into it, the Church says. They met him.

Sources12
  1. 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 638-658The resurrection as a real event, the empty tomb, the doubting disciples, and what no one saw.
  2. 21 Corinthians 15 (New American Bible, Revised Edition, USCCB)The early formula: died, buried, raised, appeared, with over 500 witnesses.
  3. 3Galatians 1 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Paul on his years persecuting the Church.
  4. 4Luke 24 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The women at the tomb and the apostles' disbelief.
  5. 5Matthew 28 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The women at the tomb and the story that the body was stolen.
  6. 6Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, book 4, chapter 8 (trans. Whiston)The rule that women's testimony was not to be admitted.
  7. 7Trent Horn, "How Jesus Became God: A Critical Review", Catholic AnswersA Catholic critic's summary of Ehrman's 2014 book (the grief-vision view), and his reply on the burial.
  8. 8NPR, Fresh Air: Bart Ehrman on How Jesus Became God (7 April 2014)Ehrman in his own words: visions led to belief, the burial, and what historians can't say.
  9. 9Wikipedia, Literacy (history: Roman Judea, citing Catherine Hezser, Jewish Literacy in Roman Palestine, 2001)Hezser: the majority of people in Roman Judea could not read or write literary texts.
  10. 10Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, MiraclesHume's maxim on testimony to miracles, early replies such as William Adams's (1767), and the role of background beliefs about God.
  11. 11The Qur'an 4:157 (Sahih International translation, Quranic Arabic Corpus)Muslims believe Jesus was not crucified.
  12. 12Acts 5 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The apostles jailed, flogged and ordered to stop speaking, and they kept preaching.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.