From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/did-jesus-exist
← No religion, or not sureDid Jesus even exist? Wasn't he copied from Horus and Mithras?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minACG works this question through in his own story. Read that part of his story: I don’t believe things easily · 4 min
Jesus really existed. Almost every historian, believer or not, accepts that he was a real Jewish preacher executed by the Roman governor around AD 30. And he wasn't copied from Horus or Mithras: those parallels come mostly from modern books and videos, not from ancient sources.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
It's a fair question. Jesus left no writings, no coins, no statue with his name on it.
And online you'll hear that he was copied from older gods who were also born of a virgin on 25 December, died and rose again.6
It's true that no Roman wrote about Jesus while he was alive. But Roman writers barely mention anyone from his small corner of the empire. Not even its governor, Pontius Pilate.6
Silence from Rome is normal, not suspicious.
Two enemies who mention him
What we do have starts with two Romans who couldn't stand Christians.
Around AD 116, the Roman historian was writing about the great fire of Rome. The emperor Nero had blamed it on the Christians, a class hated for their abominations, Tacitus says.4
So he stops to explain who they were. Their founder, , was executed by Pilate while Tiberius was emperor. Their faith was a most mischievous superstition, and it kept breaking out again, even in Rome.4
Christ isn't a surname, by the way. It's a title: the Greek form of , meaning the anointed one, the king the Jewish people were waiting for God to send.11
Around AD 112, a Roman governor called Pliny was putting Christians on trial in what's now Turkey. Those who wouldn't give up the faith, he had executed.10
Former Christians told him they used to meet before dawn to sing a hymn to Christ as to a god. He still had two enslaved women from the church tortured, to find out what they really did. All he found, he wrote, was depraved, excessive superstition.10
Neither man was on the Christians' side. Yet Tacitus takes their founder's execution for granted. Pliny tells us nothing about Jesus's life, but he shows his followers, about 80 years later, worshipping him and dying for it.
A man who knew his brother
Now go back even earlier, to . He started out hunting Christians down, then became one. He wrote to the church in the Greek city of Corinth in about AD 56.2
In another letter he says he went to Jerusalem and stayed 15 days with , one of Jesus's closest friends and one of the twelve , his inner circle. And there he met James the brother of the Lord: the Lord is what the first Christians called Jesus.3
Paul personally knew one of Jesus's closest friends, and a member of his family. That's not a legend growing over centuries. That's one handshake away.
As Bart Ehrman, an agnostic scholar and sharp critic of Christianity, puts it: If Jesus did not exist, you would think his brother would know it.6
The Jewish historian, honestly
Then there's , a Jewish historian writing around AD 93. He mentions Jesus twice.
The short mention says a high priest had James, the brother of Jesus who was called Christ, stoned to death.5 Most scholars accept this as genuine, though some don't.7
The longer passage is a problem, and it's only fair to say so. It calls Jesus the Christ and says he came back to life on the third day.7 A Jewish historian who never became a Christian is very unlikely to have written that.
Most scholars think Josephus wrote a plainer note about Jesus, and Christian copyists later added to it. In one older survey of 52 scholars, 35 thought that, 13 thought the whole passage was added, and only 4 thought all of it was genuine.7
And a few scholars go further, and think both passages were added later.7
So Josephus is disputed. Historians don't rest the case on him.
Here's one more reason historians are sure. Nobody inventing a promised king would have him die on a Roman cross. Back then, that looked like total defeat.
The strongest case on the other side comes from Richard Carrier, a historian, in his 2014 book On the Historicity of Jesus.12
He argues the first Christians believed in a heavenly Jesus, a kind of archangel, by demons in the heavens, not on earth. Only later, he says, was that Jesus given an earthly life story.12
Most historians reply that Paul himself puts Jesus on earth.12 He says Jesus was born of a woman, and Paul met his brother.13,3
Carrier himself calls belief in a real Jesus the near-universal consensus of well-qualified experts.12
Ehrman notes that historians who are Christian, Jewish, Muslim, pagan, agnostic, atheist all reach the same conclusion about whether he existed.6
He puts it bluntly: Whether we like it or not, Jesus certainly existed.6
Think of it like this
Think of a great-grandfather who crossed the sea to a new country as a young man, about a hundred years ago. There's no photo of him and no passport. Nothing he wrote survives.
But at every big family dinner, someone tells a story about him. How he arrived with one suitcase. How he worked nights. The stories don't always match, and some have probably grown a bit with each telling.
Then there's more. An uncle of yours once met his brother, and remembers him. And an old club newsletter from the town where he settled mentions him in passing, next to a small donation, written by people who weren't family and had no reason to flatter him.
You wouldn't decide he was made up. Even if some of the stories had grown, you'd still say the man was real. That's where historians land on Jesus: a brother someone met, enemies who mention him, and his followers' own accounts, all pointing at one real man.
Even a skeptic can say that much. Christians believe the , the four accounts of Jesus's life, are far more than family stories. But that's a question of its own.
What about Horus and Mithras?
Horus was an Egyptian god, often shown as a falcon. His main story is a fight with his uncle for the throne of Egypt.8 There's no virgin birth on 25 December, no twelve , no crucifixion.
Mithras was a Persian god who became popular with Roman soldiers. But signs of his worship in the Roman world only show up in large numbers from AD 136.9 Paul's letters were already decades old by then.
Old religions did share broad themes, like sacred meals. But sharing a theme isn't copying a person. Ehrman says the supposed parallels in most instances reside in the modern imagination.6
A real man in real history
The Catholic Church, like every Christian church, ties its whole faith to Jesus being a real man. The names him with the places and rulers of his day: a Jew born in Bethlehem, a carpenter, crucified in Jerusalem under the Roman governor Pontius Pilate while Tiberius was emperor.1
Those rulers are checkable, and Tacitus, no friend of Christians, names the same emperor and the same governor.4 And the same sentence of the Catechism goes on to say who Catholics believe that man is: the eternal made man.1
If Jesus never lived, Christianity would be false. Catholics accept that test.
So the question isn't really whether Jesus lived. The real question is who he was, and what happened after Pilate's soldiers took him down from the cross.
Sources13
- 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 423Jesus named with his birthplace, rulers, trade and the governor who executed him.
- 2Catechism of the Catholic Church, 639Paul writing to the Corinthians in about AD 56.
- 3Galatians 1 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Paul's visit to Peter in Jerusalem and his meeting with James.
- 4Tacitus, Annals 15.44 (c. AD 116), trans. Church and BrodribbA hostile Roman historian records Christ's execution under Pilate.
- 5Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, book 20, chapter 9 (trans. Whiston)The stoning of James, "the brother of Jesus who was called Christ", in AD 62.
- 6Bart D. Ehrman, "Did Jesus Exist?", HuffPost (20 March 2012)An agnostic scholar's case that Jesus existed and that the pagan parallels fail.
- 7Peter Kirby, "Josephus and Jesus: The Testimonium Flavianum Question", Early Christian WritingsText of both Josephus passages and a survey of scholarship on them, including Feldman's count.
- 8Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Horus"Who Horus was in Egyptian religion and what his myths say.
- 9Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Mithraism" (Reinhold Merkelbach)Roman Mithraism appears around AD 100 and spreads from AD 136.
- 10Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96 (c. AD 112), Early Christian WritingsA Roman governor's report on interrogating and executing Christians: the hymn 'to Christ as to a god', the two enslaved women tortured.
- 11Catechism of the Catholic Church, 436'Christ' is the Greek form of the Hebrew Messiah, 'anointed': the one God would send.
- 12Wikipedia, On the Historicity of Jesus (Richard Carrier, 2014)Carrier's celestial-Jesus thesis; his own description of historicity as the near-universal consensus; Hurtado's reply that Paul believed Jesus lived on earth.
- 13Galatians 4:4 (New American Bible, Revised Edition, USCCB)Paul: God sent his Son, born of a woman.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.