← Protestant or evangelical
History between us

Some say the pope is the antichrist. Where does that come from?

Read it as an illustrated story · 7 min

It comes from the Reformation, in the 1500s. Luther and several statements of faith called the the antichrist, believing he'd put himself above and the . Most Protestants don't say this now, though some churches still do. In the Bible, an antichrist is whoever denies Jesus really became human.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Catechism
675–677

If someone told you this, they probably meant it seriously, not as an insult. For some Christians it's how they read Bible prophecy, passed down by teachers they respect.

So where did it start? And does it fit the Bible?

Where it started

In 1537, called the pope the very Antichrist. His reason: the pope wouldn't let Christians be saved without going through his power.1

Luther had in mind a warning from about a lawless one who puts himself above everything people worship, and sits in God's temple.2 Luther thought the pope had done just that. He'd put himself above the Bible, instead of under it.3

Paul also says something is restraining the lawless one for now. Christians traditionally took that to be the Roman empire.2,13

Those who hold this view say that as the empire fell, the popes rose in its place, ruling from God's temple, meaning the Christian church.13

The idea spread fast. In 1647 the founding statement of the Presbyterian churches called the pope that Antichrist, that man of and son of perdition.4

Baptist statements of the 1600s used almost the same words, and so did the Congregationalists, churches where each congregation governs itself.4

Catholics weren't gentle either

The name-calling went both ways. One of Luther's Catholic opponents painted him as a heretic and a destroyer of the Christian world.3

In 2013, Lutheran and Catholic scholars looked back together. Both sides, they wrote, exaggerated and caricatured their opponents in order to make them look ridiculous.3 Both sides need to own that.

Think of it like this

Think of two brothers who ran the family business together. One day they had a real fight about it, over money and who was in charge. It was serious, and neither of them was completely wrong.

Both said terrible things that day. One called the other a thief. The other called him a traitor. They never ate at the same table again.

Now fast forward two generations. The grandchildren meet at a cousin's wedding. Hardly anyone remembers what the fight was actually about. But they all remember the words. Thief. Traitor. Those get repeated every time the family gets together.

That's where the antichrist label sits today. Some of the old disagreements were real, and they still matter. The harshest words don't help anyone talk about them. They just keep the cousins from sitting down together.

What the Bible means by antichrist

The word antichrist only appears in the short letters of John, near the end of the . And John tells you exactly what he means by it: Whoever denies the Father and the Son, this is the antichrist.5

He says many antichrists have appeared already, in his own day. They were teachers who wouldn't accept that Jesus had really become a human being.5

By John's test, the word fits badly on a who says the Creed every Sunday, out loud, confessing Jesus as God's Son made man.

Catholics answer the lawless one from Paul's own words. His figure claims that he is a god and opposes every so-called god and object of worship.2

A pope kneels to worship God and calls himself the servant of God's servants.9 That's the opposite of claiming to be a god.

And Jesus overcomes him by the manifestation of his coming, his return.2 So Catholics read him as one person, still to come.13

Catholics and Protestants can at least agree on John's definition.

The Catholic warning, aimed at itself

The Catholic Church does believe in an antichrist. It teaches that before Christ returns there'll be a final great deception.8

The describes it as a false rescuer: someone, or some movement, that puts humans in God's place and promises to build on earth without him.8

And it says the Church itself must go through a final trial that will shake the faith of many believers.8 No Christian body gets a free pass, the Catholic Church included.

And the woman on seven hills?

The passage most often quoted against Rome is in Revelation. It describes a woman called Babylon the great who sits on seven hills.6

And yes, the notes in a Catholic Bible say Babylon is the symbolic name of Rome.6 But which Rome? The Rome of the emperors.

The same notes explain that the kings under Rome worshipped the emperor, and they link the beast she rides to Nero, a Roman emperor.6 And the woman is drunk on the blood of the holy ones.6 That's the empire that was killing Christians, not the Christians it was killing.

And 666?

Then there's the mark of the beast. Revelation 13 describes a beast that forces everyone to take a mark on the right hand or the forehead. Without it, no one could buy or sell.11

And then a riddle: His number is six hundred and sixty-six.11

Reading the beast as the Catholic Church isn't new. In 1612 one of the first Baptist leaders named the first beast in this chapter as the Roman Catholic Church, and the second as the Church of England.12

But John, who wrote Revelation, gives his first readers a clue they could work out. It is a number that stands for a person.11 In Hebrew and Greek, every letter also counts as a number, so any name adds up to a total.11

That's why the number has been pinned on so many people. The notes in a Catholic Bible admit that many candidates have been nominated for this infamous number.11

Their best answer is Nero, the emperor who stands for the emperors who viciously persecuted the church. Write his name in Hebrew letters, spelled the Greek way, and it adds up to exactly 666.11

And there's a striking detail. A few old copies of Revelation give the number as 616. That's exactly what his name adds up to when it's spelled the Latin way.11

The mark belongs to the same world. In John's day, the notes say, Christians had either to worship the emperor and his image or to suffer .11 Going along with it kept your place in the market. Refusing could cost you everything.

So 666 points the same way as the seven hills: to the emperors of John's own day.

Who still holds it?

Since 1903, some Presbyterian churches have taken the word out of their statement of faith.4,7 And in 2013 Lutheran and Catholic scholars wrote together that Lutherans today reject Luther's identification of the pope with the Antichrist.3

Some still hold it. The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, a large American church, teaches that the Bible's prophecies about the Antichrist have been fulfilled in the Pope of Rome and his dominion.10 They mean the papacy as a whole, not one particular pope.10

Most Protestants who disagree with the papacy now say so without that word. That's a disagreement held in good faith, and it can be argued from the Bible.

A servant, by his own job title

The Catholic Church believes the pope's job is to serve the unity of all Christians. One of the pope's oldest titles says it: the servant of the servants of God.9

In 1995 used that title for himself in a letter about Christian unity. He admitted that the papacy is hard for most other Christians, because of painful memories.

Where Catholics were to blame for those memories, he wrote, I join my Predecessor Paul VI in asking forgiveness.9 And he asked other Christians to talk with him, patiently, about how the pope's role could become a service of love recognized by all concerned.9

So Catholics don't ask other Christians to stop disagreeing about the papacy. They ask that the argument be had from the Bible and history, as family, without the hardest word the Bible has.

Sources13
  1. 1Martin Luther, Smalcald Articles (1537), Part II, Article 4: Of the PapacyLuther's statement that the pope is the Antichrist, and his reasons, in the Book of Concord.
  2. 22 Thessalonians 2 (New American Bible, Revised Edition)Paul's warning about the “lawless one”, and the NABRE notes tying his picture to Daniel and Antiochus IV.
  3. 3Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity, From Conflict to Communion (2013), 22, 53, 229, 233What Luther meant, the Catholic caricature of Luther, and Lutherans' rejection of the charge today.
  4. 4Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3 (Westminster Confession 25.6, Savoy Declaration, Baptist Confession of 1688, and the 1903 American revision)The 1647 wording, its Congregationalist and Baptist parallels, and the PCUSA's 1903 rewrite.
  5. 51 John 2 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)“Whoever denies the Father and the Son, this is the antichrist”; the notes say the word appears only in 1–2 John, with Paul's “lawless one” a similar figure.
  6. 6Revelation 17 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Babylon as the symbolic name of imperial Rome, drunk on the blood of the holy ones.
  7. 7Orthodox Presbyterian Church, The Westminster Confession of Faith, 25.6The OPC's text keeps “head of the church” and has no antichrist clause.
  8. 8Catechism of the Catholic Church, 675–677The Church's final trial and the Antichrist's deception.
  9. 9John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (25 May 1995), 88, 95–96The pope as servant, a request for forgiveness, and an invitation to dialogue on the papacy.
  10. 10The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, Brief Statement of the Doctrinal Position of the Missouri Synod (1932), “Of the Antichrist”The LCMS still teaches that the Antichrist prophecies are fulfilled in the papacy.
  11. 11Revelation 13 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The mark of the beast and the number 666; the notes on the emperors, Nero, the 616 reading and emperor worship.
  12. 12Walter B. Shurden, review of Thomas Helwys, A Short Declaration of the Mystery of Iniquity (1612), Center for Baptist Studies, Mercer UniversityHelwys named the first beast of Revelation 13 as the Roman Catholic Church and the second as the Church of England.
  13. 13J. A. Maas, "Antichrist", Catholic Encyclopedia (1907)Readings of the restrainer (most Latin Fathers: the Roman Empire); the Protestant papal-Antichrist theory; Catholic teaching that Antichrist is one person still to come.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.