← Protestant or evangelical
History between us

Didn't Catholics burn Protestants?

Read it as an illustrated story · 7 min

Yes. Catholic rulers and courts killed many Protestants in the 1500s, from about 280 burned in England to a massacre of thousands in France. rulers killed Catholics and other Christians too. Today the Catholic Church and many Protestant churches say it was wrong, and several have asked forgiveness.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Yes. And that should be said first, without any “but”.

What Catholics did

In England, the Catholic Queen Mary I, remembered as “Bloody Mary”, brought back the old laws against heresy, which meant teaching against what the Catholic Church believed. Between 1555 and 1558, at least 280 people were burned alive for their Protestant faith.1

In France, on St Bartholomew's Day, a saint's feast day, in 1572, Catholics began killing Protestants in Paris. It started as a royal order to kill the Protestant leaders. It turned into a massacre.

A French Protestant museum puts the dead at about 4,000 in Paris, and at least 10,000 more across France.2

When the news reached Rome, the ordered special Masses to thank God, and had a medal made.2 A pope gave thanks for a massacre. Catholics shouldn't look away from that.

Across Europe in the 1500s, about 5,000 people were executed for their faith. Between 2,000 and 2,500 of them were Anabaptists, Christians who only adults, whose heirs include today's Mennonites. Most were killed in Catholic lands. Those are the figures Catholics and Mennonites give together, in their joint talks.3

In Italy, the Roman Inquisition, a Catholic court set up in 1542 mainly to stop Protestant ideas spreading, sentenced about 1,250 people to death. Not all of them were Protestants.4

The other direction

Protestant governments killed too, and that half is told less often.

In England, King Henry VIII broke from Rome and made himself head of the Church. Catholics who refused to accept that were executed, among them a and the king's own former chancellor, in 1535.5

Later, after the pope declared Henry's Protestant daughter, Queen , cut off from the Church in 1570, her laws grew harsher.6 Englishmen who trained as priests in Catholic colleges abroad and came home could be executed for treason just for being in England. Over 150 Catholics were executed between 1581 and 1603.6

In Protestant Zurich, an leader was drowned in 1527. In Protestant Geneva, a scholar was burned in 1553 for denying the .8

And the Anabaptists were hunted by both sides. Lutheran rulers persecuted them too, and Luther and his close colleague, Philip Melanchthon, gave it their backing.7

And the Baptists?

If you're a Baptist, the Anabaptists can sound like your own family. They also baptised only people old enough to believe.

Baptist churches began a little later, though, in 1609, among English Christians who had fled to Amsterdam. There they decided to stop baptising babies.11

They knew the Mennonites, the Anabaptists' heirs, in Amsterdam, and historians think they may have been influenced by them.11,12

So the link is real, but Baptists didn't simply grow out of the Anabaptists.

Were Baptists persecuted? Yes. Even before there were Baptists, England had put Anabaptists to death, as early as 1535.11

In 1612 one of their leaders, Thomas Helwys, went home to London with about a dozen others and started the first Baptist church in England.12 He wrote what a Baptist historian calls the first plea in English for complete freedom of religion, for everyone, not only Christians.13

He sent a signed copy to the king, with a note in his own hand. The king, he wrote there, is a mortal man, and not God, therefore he hath no power over the mortal soul of his subjects. He was thrown into prison, and most likely died there, around 1616.12,13

So Baptists suffered too, and in England it was at the hands of a Protestant king.

And Pentecostals? Their churches didn't exist yet. They began in the early 1900s.14

Why did Christians do this?

Explaining isn't excusing. But it helps to see their world. In the 1500s, faith and power politics were tangled up together.7

And both sides believed people's eternal lives were at stake.7 To them, a false teacher could cost people .

Catholic theology backed it. , the great Catholic thinker of the 1200s, wrote that heretics deserve to be severed from the world by death.15

Corrupting the faith, he argued, was worse than forging money, and forgers were already put to death.15 Many Protestant leaders reasoned the same way.7

That's how they talked themselves into it.

Faith must never be forced

Today the Catholic Church teaches that this was wrong at the root. In 1965 the declared that no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs.9

The reason goes to the heart of the gospel. God invites people. He doesn't force them. As the Council put it, the truth cannot impose itself except by virtue of its own truth.9

And it admitted the past in the same document. In the Church's long history, it said, there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the or even opposed to it.9

The Council said the Church had always taught that no one is to be coerced into faith.9 To be honest, that teaching wasn't always lived. In talks with the Mennonites, the Catholic side wrote that the culture of those times doesn't let the Church off: it still has to express profound regret.3

On 12 March 2000, at a in St 's in Rome, led the Catholic Church in asking forgiveness:

Let us ask pardon for the divisions which have occurred among Christians, for the violence some have used in the service of the truth and for the distrustful and hostile attitudes sometimes taken towards the followers of other religions.
John Paul II, homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000)

Saying sorry, on both sides

In 2010, for what their churches had done to the Anabaptists, Lutherans asked forgiveness from God and from our Mennonite sisters and brothers.7

In the Catholic-Mennonite talks, the Catholics asked forgiveness for against Mennonites. And the Mennonites said they regretted spreading hostile images and false stereotypes of Catholics.3

Think of it like this

Think of a brother and sister who have been at war since they were small. It started with a broken toy. Then came the borrowed clothes, the read diary, the things said in front of friends, the doors slammed so hard the house shook.

Ask either of them and they can tell you, in detail, every single thing the other one did. Ask what they did themselves, and suddenly their memory goes vague. “Well, maybe I said something, but she started it.”

Years later they're grown up, and the fight still hangs over every family gathering. Nothing changes until one of them sits down next to the other and says, “I was wrong about this. I'm sorry.”

Healing starts when each one names their own part, without adding “but you started it”. That's what the churches have finally begun to do.

Nobody's hands were clean, and more and more churches now say so.

The Catholic Church also honours its own from these years, like the bishop and the chancellor Henry VIII executed, just as Protestants remember theirs.5 Remembering them isn't keeping score.

The point of telling all of it is that no Christian should ever do this to another again.

Sources15
  1. 1Wikipedia, “Marian persecutions”At least 280 to 287 burned under Mary I, 56 of them women; about 30 died in prison.
  2. 2Musée protestant, “St. Bartholomew's Day (24th August 1572)”The French Protestant account: how it began, the death toll, and the pope's thanksgiving.
  3. 3Catholic Church and Mennonite World Conference, Called Together to be Peacemakers (1998–2003), 46, 202–206About 5,000 executed for faith in the 1500s, 2,000–2,500 of them Anabaptists; forgiveness asked on both sides.
  4. 4Wikipedia, “Roman Inquisition”Founded in 1542 against Protestantism; Andrea Del Col's estimate of about 1,250 death sentences.
  5. 5Catholic Encyclopedia, “English Confessors and Martyrs (1534–1729)” (1909)The Catholics executed under Henry VIII, with dates, and the Church's honouring of them.
  6. 6Catholic Encyclopedia, “Penal Laws” (1911)Elizabeth's treason laws; over 150 Catholics executed between 1581 and 1603.
  7. 7Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity, From Conflict to Communion (2013), 229–237Politics and faith interwoven; Lutheran persecution of Anabaptists; the 2010 Lutheran apology.
  8. 8Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 8: Modern Christianity, the Swiss Reformation (1892), §§ on the Zurich Anabaptists and § 155, Execution of ServetusA Protestant historian on Zurich drowning Felix Manz (1527) and Geneva burning Servetus (1553).
  9. 9Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 1, 2, 12Religious freedom, and the admission of ways of acting opposed to the Gospel.
  10. 10John Paul II, Homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000)The pope asks pardon for divisions and for violence in the service of truth.
  11. 11Catholic Encyclopedia, “Baptists” (1907)Anabaptists executed in England from 1535; Smyth's exiled church in Amsterdam rejects infant baptism in 1609, "possibly in some measure" under Mennonite influence.
  12. 12Wikipedia, “Thomas Helwys”The Amsterdam church, its Mennonite landlord, the split with Smyth, the return to London in 1612, Newgate prison and death around 1616.
  13. 13Walter B. Shurden, review of Thomas Helwys, A Short Declaration of the Mystery of Iniquity (1612), Center for Baptist Studies, Mercer UniversityA Baptist historian on the first plea in English for complete freedom of religion, and its cost.
  14. 14J. Gordon Melton, "Pentecostalism", Encyclopaedia Britannica (updated 15 December 2024; archived copy)Pentecostal churches began in the US in the early 1900s.
  15. 15Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 11, a. 3 (New Advent translation)Heretics deserve 'to be severed from the world by death'; corrupting the faith is graver than forging money.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.