Part XV · Chapter 35
Peter → Bishop of Rome → Pope

How did the bishop of Rome come to claim authority over every Christian, and was that faithful to Peter or a power grab?

10 scenes · about 25 min read

The short answer

It grew over centuries, and Christians still disagree on whether it grew faithfully. The Catholic Church says the office grew from a charge gave , who died in Rome.

The early evidence is real. Around 96 Rome's church wrote to Corinth expecting to be obeyed. In 451 a of cried out that Peter had spoken through Leo.

So is the pushback. Carthage's bishop, , defied Pope Stephen in 256. Pope called the title "Universal Pope" proud.

No first-century text calls Peter bishop of Rome, and the first Roman Christians seem to have been led by a group of elders.

In 1870 the defined the pope's full authority. It said he is kept from error when he solemnly defines faith or morals. Outside those solemn definitions, popes can still be wrong.

The answer that Rome's first place was real but never meant rule.

Follow the trail

Ten moments from Peter's death to today, with Rome's claims and the pushback against them side by side.

AD 64 or laterHistorical2 min read

A letter in Peter's name greets from 'Babylon'

The First Letter of Peter

The First Letter of Peter, in the , ends with greetings from the church in 'Babylon', an early Christian code name for Rome. Whoever wrote it, and whenever, it is an early witness linking Peter with Rome.

Three labourers haul up a cross on which an old, bearded Peter is nailed with his head towards the ground.
The Crucifixion of Saint Peter, Caravaggio, 1600. Eusebius records that Peter was crucified under Nero.
IWhat was going on

Peter was a fisherman from Galilee, in what is now northern Israel. Jesus gave him the name Peter, the rock. After Jesus rose from the dead, Peter led the Twelve, his closest followers.

Acts, the New Testament's history of the first Christians, follows him in Jerusalem. Then it loses track of him after he escapes from prison and goes to another place.

meets him later in Antioch. The New Testament never says where he went in the end.

IIWhat was at stake

Was Peter ever in Rome? The whole Catholic claim about the papacy rests on the answer, because the bishop of Rome claims to carry on Peter's charge.

Some writers after the Reformation doubted he ever went there.

IIIWhat happened

The letter is sent from Peter to Christians across five provinces of today's Turkey. They were being mocked and mistreated for their faith.

It closes with greetings from the chosen one at Babylon, meaning the church there, and from Mark, my son.

The Catholic New American 's own note explains that Babylon was a code name for Rome. The Book of Revelation, the last book of the Bible, uses it the same way.

IVWhat came of it

From Irenaeus, a bishop writing around 180, onward, tradition held that Peter wrote it from Rome. He wrote it, they said, before he was killed under the emperor Nero.

The same Bible reports that some modern scholars date it later, about 70 to 90. On that view a of Peter wrote it in Rome, or it is later still.

Rome's own letter of about 96 remembers Peter's death as an example from our own generation. Around 200 a Roman Christian pointed to his monument on the Vatican hill.

VRead the source

Why it matters

Even if it was written late, the letter ties Peter to Rome early. Today that is widely accepted. Oscar Cullmann, a Protestant scholar, concluded in 1952 that Peter died in Rome.

But no first-century text calls Peter bishop of Rome. The Catholic claim rests on his death there and on what the Roman church did after.

c. AD 96Historical1 min read

Rome writes to Corinth, and expects to be obeyed

The church of Rome, in the letter known as 1 Clement

Around 96 the church at Corinth, in Greece, threw out its elders, the who led it. The church at Rome wrote telling the rebels to submit. It didn't offer advice to weigh up: it warned that disobeying was dangerous.

IWhat was going on

Corinth was a church the apostle Paul had founded. Around 96 a few members led a revolt. They removed the presbyters, the elders who led the church, though they had served well.

Rome was some 1,000 kilometres away. The letter opens by apologising for a slow reply to the points respecting which you consulted us. So someone in Corinth had written to Rome.

IIWhat was at stake

Who could settle a quarrel inside another city's church? There was no emperor of the Church and no rulebook.

The apostles were dead or dying. This is one of the first writings outside the New Testament in which one church speaks to another with authority.

IIIWhat happened

The church of Rome sent a long letter, carried by three named messengers. It argues for humility, peace and order. It says the apostles appointed ministers and arranged for successors.

The letter speaks as we, a church rather than one man. names as its author.

It warns that anyone who disobeys what God says through us is in serious danger.

IVWhat came of it

Around 170 Dionysius, bishop of Corinth, wrote that his church still read Rome's letter aloud in its Sunday services, decades later.

No one knows exactly how the quarrel ended. But Corinth kept and treasured the letter; it didn't resent it.

VRead the source
If, however, any shall disobey the words spoken by Him through us, let them know that they will involve themselves in transgression and serious danger
First Epistle to the Corinthians · 1 Clement 59 (Ante-Nicene Fathers translation, New Advent)

Why it matters

Catholics see here the Roman church acting beyond its own city very early, and expecting to be heard.

The Orthodox and Protestants read it as a respected sister church giving strong brotherly advice. The letter names no bishop of Rome, and both readings fit its words.

c. AD 180Historical2 min read

A bishop says every church must agree with Rome

Irenaeus of Lyon, Against Heresies

Around 180 Irenaeus, bishop of Lyon in Gaul, wrote against teachers he held to be false. He pointed to the public teaching of Rome, handed down from Peter and Paul. His key sentence turns on one Latin phrase that can be read two ways.

IWhat was going on

Irenaeus grew up in Smyrna, in today's Turkey. As a boy he had seen , who had known the apostle John.

He moved to Gaul, today's France. He became bishop of Lyon after a persecution there in 177 killed its old bishop.

Around 180 he wrote Against Heresies. It was aimed at the Gnostics, groups who claimed Jesus had passed secret knowledge to a chosen few.

IIWhat was at stake

The Gnostics said their teaching came from the apostles by a hidden line. How could ordinary Christians tell the true faith from these claims?

Irenaeus answered that the apostles' teaching isn't secret. It is public, handed down openly through the bishops of each church, whose names can be listed.

IIIWhat happened

Rather than list every church, Irenaeus takes the greatest and oldest-known: Rome, founded by Peter and Paul. He lists its bishops from Linus to Eleutherius, the twelfth, in his own day.

Then comes the famous sentence. Every church must agree with this church because of its potiorem principalitatem.

The phrase can mean greater authority, or more ancient origin.

IVWhat came of it

His list became the backbone of later lists of popes.

The First Vatican Council, in 1870, quoted his sentence and read it as authority. Others read it as Rome being the best example of a church whose teaching came straight from apostles.

The Latin is itself a translation. Irenaeus wrote in Greek, and the original is lost.

VRead the source
For it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority [potiorem principalitatem].
Against Heresies, book III · Against Heresies III.3.2 (Ante-Nicene Fathers translation, New Advent)

Why it matters

Either way, around 180 a bishop in Gaul pointed every church to Rome. It was the place where the apostles' teaching could be checked.

Did that mean Rome ruled, or that Rome simply bore witness? Catholics and Orthodox still argue about it.

c. AD 190Historical2 min read

A pope cuts off churches over Easter, and is rebuked

Victor of Rome and Irenaeus, in Eusebius's Church History

Around 190 Victor, bishop of Rome, tried to cut off the churches of the Roman province of Asia, in today's Turkey, over the date of Easter. Other bishops told him he was wrong.

IWhat was going on

Christians in the Roman province of Asia, the west of today's Turkey, kept Easter on the 14th day of the Jewish month. That was the day of , the great Jewish feast, whatever day of the week it fell on.

They said they had it from the apostles John and Philip, who had lived and died among them. Almost everywhere else, Easter was kept on a Sunday.

IIWhat was at stake

Should every church keep Easter on the same day? Most bishops thought so.

Around 190 synods, gatherings of bishops, in Palestine, Rome, Gaul and elsewhere agreed on Sunday. But Polycrates, bishop of Ephesus, wrote that Asia would keep the custom handed down to it.

IIIWhat happened

Victor declared the churches of Asia cut off from the common unity. He excommunicated them: they were barred from sharing the with the other churches.

Other bishops rebuked him sharply. Irenaeus wrote that earlier bishops of Rome had stayed in with Asia despite the difference.

Decades earlier, around 155, Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, had visited Rome. He and Bishop Anicetus disagreed on the custom. They still parted in peace.

IVWhat came of it

The sources don't say whether Victor backed down. The Sunday Easter won out over time. The Council of Nicaea in 325 set one rule for the date for the whole Church.

In 2025, by a coincidence of calendars, all Christians kept Easter on the same Sunday. The pope and the Ecumenical Patriarch, first in honour among Orthodox bishops, said they wanted to find a way to celebrate it together every year.

VRead the source
Thereupon Victor, who presided over the church at Rome, immediately attempted to cut off from the common unity the parishes of all Asia, with the churches that agreed with them, as heterodox; and he wrote letters and declared all the brethren there wholly excommunicate.
Church History (Historia Ecclesiastica) · Church History V.24.9 (McGiffert, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 1)

Why it matters

Both sides of the papacy argument use this story. Irenaeus didn't tell Victor he had no right to act. He told him not to cut off churches over a custom.

The Orthodox reply that it shows Rome's bishop could be overruled by his fellow bishops. The text carries both readings.

AD 251–256Historical2 min read

A bishop praises Rome, then defies its pope

Cyprian, bishop of Carthage

In 251 Cyprian, bishop of Carthage in North Africa, wrote that the Church is one because Christ began it from Peter. He called Rome the chair of Peter. Five years later he defied the bishop of Rome over baptism.

IWhat was going on

Cyprian became bishop of Carthage, in today's Tunisia, around 249, just before the Decian persecution. In 251 the Roman church split. Cornelius was elected bishop, and a priest named Novatian set himself up as a rival.

Cyprian backed Cornelius. In his letters he called Rome the chair of Peter and the principal church. A bishop's chair stood for his office.

IIWhat was at stake

Then a new question arose. What about people baptised by groups outside the Church, such as Novatian's followers? Were they really baptised?

The African bishops said no: they must be baptised properly. Pope Stephen said yes. Baptism in the name of the , Father, Son and , was valid wherever it was done.

IIIWhat happened

In 256 Stephen ruled that such converts must not be baptised again. He threatened to break communion, the sharing of the , with those who did.

Cyprian and the African bishops refused. Firmilian, a bishop in Cappadocia in today's Turkey, wrote backing Cyprian. He mocked Stephen's appeal to Peter's .

IVWhat came of it

Stephen died in 257, and the quarrel seems to have been quietly dropped. Cyprian was executed in 258 in the next persecution. He is honoured as a saint and .

The Catholic Church kept Stephen's view on baptism: baptism with water in the Trinity's name is valid, whoever gives it.

VRead the source

Why it matters

Cyprian's high view of Rome didn't stop him defying its bishop. It can't have been easy: five years earlier he had stood by Rome's bishop against a rival, and now he refused Rome's bishop to his face.

Catholics read it as a quarrel about the limits of an authority both men recognised. The Orthodox read it as proof that bishops were equals, and that Rome's word could be refused.

AD 451Historical2 min read

Bishops cheer the pope, then overrule him

The bishops at the Council of Chalcedon

In 451 bishops met at Chalcedon, near Constantinople. When Pope Leo's letter was read, they shouted that Peter had spoken through Leo. The same council then gave Constantinople second place among the churches, over Leo's protest.

IWhat was going on

In the 440s Eutyches, a monk in Constantinople, taught that once the became human, he had only one nature: the divine one.

Pope Leo of Rome wrote a letter, the Tome. It explained that Christ is one person with two natures, divine and human.

In 449 a backed Eutyches by force and refused to read Leo's letter. Leo called it a robber council.

IIWhat was at stake

A new emperor called a new council at Chalcedon, near Constantinople, in 451. Hundreds of bishops came, almost all from the East.

They needed to settle who Christ is, and to undo the damage of 449.

IIIWhat happened

Leo's letter was read aloud. The bishops cried out: Peter has spoken thus through Leo. In the same breath they cried so taught Cyril, the great bishop of Alexandria.

They checked Leo against Cyril, and found them in agreement.

Later, with Leo's representatives absent, the council passed canon 28, a church law. It ranked Constantinople next after Rome, because Constantinople was the new imperial city.

IVWhat came of it

Leo's representatives protested at the council's next sitting. Leo refused to accept canon 28, citing Peter's authority and the order of churches set at Nicaea.

The Eastern churches kept the canon anyway. At the Council of Florence in 1439, Rome itself ranked Constantinople second.

The council's teaching on Christ split off the churches of Egypt, Syria and Armenia. They are today's , a family of Churches separate from both Rome and the Eastern Orthodox.

VRead the source
This is the faith of the fathers, this is the faith of the Apostles. So we all believe, thus the orthodox believe. Anathema to him who does not thus believe. Peter has spoken thus through Leo. So taught the Apostles. Piously and truly did Leo teach, so taught Cyril.
Council of Chalcedon (451): Definition of the Faith · Acts, Session II, acclamations after the reading of Leo's letter to Flavian (Percival, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 14)

Why it matters

Both sides read Chalcedon as theirs. Catholics point to Peter has spoken through Leo.

The Orthodox point out that the bishops checked Leo against Cyril before agreeing. They also note that the council ranked churches by the importance of their cities.

The same council shows Rome honoured and Rome overruled.

c. AD 598Historical2 min read

A pope refuses to be called 'Universal Pope'

Gregory the Great, to Eulogius of Alexandria

Around 598 Eulogius, bishop of Alexandria in Egypt, wrote to Pope Gregory the Great and called him 'Universal Pope'. Gregory refused the title. If one bishop is universal, he said, the others are no longer truly bishops.

Medieval miniature of Pope Gregory the Great enthroned at a lectern with a dove at his ear, while a scribe peers round a curtain.
Gregory the Great with the dove of the Holy Spirit at his ear. Miniature from a manuscript of his letters, Trier, after 983.
IWhat was going on

Gregory became pope in 590. Rome had been hit by plague and was threatened by the Lombards, a Germanic people who had invaded Italy. The emperor was far away in Constantinople.

Gregory fed the city from the Church's estates and negotiated with the Lombards himself. In 596 he sent monks to convert the English.

He was the most powerful bishop in the West, and he knew it.

IIWhat was at stake

John, bishop of Constantinople, had begun calling himself ecumenical, or universal, patriarch. A patriarch was the leading bishop of one of the great old cities. Gregory protested that the title was proud.

Then Eulogius, bishop of Alexandria, wrote to Gregory and used the title for Gregory himself. Would Gregory accept for Rome what he refused to Constantinople?

IIIWhat happened

He refused. If Eulogius called him universal pope, Gregory replied, Eulogius would be denying that he himself was truly a bishop.

His honour, he says, is the honour of the whole Church and the strength of his brother bishops. He didn't want a title that took anything from them.

IVWhat came of it

Constantinople kept the title. Its patriarch is still called Ecumenical Patriarch today.

Gregory called himself servant of the servants of God, and popes still use that title.

Nearly five centuries later, a list of papal claims entered in the records of Pope Gregory VII said only the pope may be called universal.

VRead the source
For if your Holiness calls me Universal Pope, you deny that you are yourself what you call me universally.
Registrum Epistolarum (Letters) · Register VIII.30, to Eulogius, bishop of Alexandria (Barmby, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 12)

Why it matters

Gregory's letter is the sharpest early text against the later papacy, and a pope wrote it.

Catholics answer that Gregory refused a title, not the first place he plainly used. Elsewhere he wrote that Constantinople was subject to the Apostolic See, as Rome's church was called.

The Second Vatican Council taught in 1964 that bishops govern by their own authority, not as the pope's deputies. Catholics see Gregory's point in that.

18 November 1302Historical2 min read

A pope says salvation needs submission to him

Pope Boniface VIII, the bull Unam Sanctam

In 1302 Pope Boniface VIII was locked in a struggle with Philip IV, king of France. He issued a formal letter, Unam Sanctam, saying every human must be subject to the pope to be saved. It is the papal claim at its height.

Fresco fragment of Pope Boniface VIII in a tall white crowned mitre, between two attendants, one holding a scroll.
Boniface VIII in a fresco fragment attributed to Giotto, painted about 1300 and now in St John Lateran, Rome.
IWhat was going on

For two centuries before 1300, popes had claimed the right to correct kings. King Philip IV of France, called Philip the Fair, was building a strong state. He needed money for his wars with England.

He taxed the French clergy without the pope's consent. Boniface forbade it in 1296, and Philip cut off the flow of money from France to Rome.

In 1301 Philip had a French bishop arrested and tried.

IIWhat was at stake

Who had the final say: the king over his own kingdom's clergy, or the pope over every Christian, kings included?

For Boniface, if the king could arrest bishops and tax the Church at will, the Church's freedom was gone.

IIIWhat happened

On 18 November 1302 Boniface issued a bull, a formal papal letter named after its seal. It is called Unam Sanctam, One Holy.

It says the Church holds two swords, the spiritual power and the earthly one. The earthly must be subject to the spiritual.

It ends with a solemn sentence: subjection to the pope is necessary for .

IVWhat came of it

Philip's men seized Boniface at Anagni, south of Rome, in September 1303. He was released after a few days, and died a month later.

In 1306 Pope Clement V assured France that the bull had not made it more subject to Rome.

From 1309 the popes lived in Avignon, in what is now southern France, under heavy French influence.

VRead the source
Furthermore, we declare, we proclaim, we define that it is absolutely necessary for salvation that every human creature be subject to the Roman Pontiff.
Unam Sanctam · Unam Sanctam, final sentence (papalencyclicals.net translation)

Why it matters

Unam Sanctam is the high point of medieval popes' claims over kings. The papacy never again ruled kings that way.

The Catholic Church today teaches that no salvation outside the Church is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ or his Church. Its Catechism says so (CCC 847).

The power over kings is long gone. The call to unity with Peter's successor remains.

18 July 1870Revealed2 min read

A council defines the pope's authority

The First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus

In 1870 the First Vatican Council, meeting in Rome, taught that Peter's first place passes to every bishop of Rome by Christ's will. It said the pope is kept from error when he solemnly defines a teaching on faith or morals.

IWhat was going on

In the 1860s the pope was losing his lands in central Italy, the Papal States, to the new kingdom of Italy. Pope Pius IX felt the Church was under siege from liberal governments that wanted it out of public life.

Many Catholics wanted a strong papacy as an anchor. They were called ultramontanes, those looking over the mountains to Rome.

In December 1869 Pius opened the First Vatican Council in Rome, a meeting of the Catholic world's bishops.

IIWhat was at stake

A majority wanted the pope's , his freedom from error in solemn teaching, to be defined.

A minority, many of them French, German and Austrian bishops, thought a definition unwise or wrongly worded. Outside the council, Ignaz von Döllinger, a historian in Munich, argued that history spoke against it.

Inside the council, both sides were loyal Catholics.

IIIWhat happened

In a trial vote days before the end, 88 of the 601 bishops present voted no. Many of the minority then left Rome rather than vote against the pope in public.

On 18 July 1870 the council passed Pastor Aeternus, Eternal Shepherd, by 533 votes to 2. The two who still said no, in front of the pope, were Bishop Aloisio Riccio of Cajazzo in Italy and Bishop Edward Fitzgerald of Little Rock, Arkansas. During the session a thunderstorm broke over the Vatican.

It defined the pope's full and direct authority over every church, and his infallibility under strict conditions.

IVWhat came of it

The next day France declared war on Prussia and pulled its troops out of Rome. Italian troops took Rome in September, and the council never met again.

The minority bishops all accepted the definition in time. A small group in Germany, Switzerland and Austria did not. They formed the Old Catholic churches, joining the older Church of Utrecht in the Netherlands.

Infallibility has been used explicitly once since, in 1950.

VRead the source
Therefore whoever succeeds to the chair of Peter obtains by the institution of Christ himself, the primacy of Peter over the whole church.
Pastor Aeternus, First Dogmatic Constitution on the Church of Christ · Pastor Aeternus, chapter 2 (Tanner translation, papalencyclicals.net)

Why it matters

Infallibility doesn't mean popes are always right, wise or holy. It covers only solemn definitions of faith or morals for the whole Church.

The council ended before it could say how the bishops fit in. The Second Vatican Council did that in 1964.

The Orthodox reject the definition. It remains the biggest barrier between them and Rome.

1995–2024Historical2 min read

A pope asks other Christians for help

John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint, and the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity

In 1995 admitted that the papacy is a difficulty for most other Christians. He asked their leaders to help him find a new way of exercising it, without giving up what is essential to it.

Pope Francis in white and Patriarch Bartholomew in black stand side by side against a stone wall.
Pope Francis and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, Jerusalem, 25 May 2014.
IWhat was going on

In 1965 Rome and Constantinople lifted the excommunications of 1054, the sentences each side had passed on the other's leaders. Since the Second Vatican Council, talks with the Orthodox, Anglicans and Lutherans had made real progress.

But the papacy kept coming back as the hardest question. Pope Paul VI himself had said the pope was undoubtedly the most serious obstacle on the path to unity.

IIWhat was at stake

Catholics hold that Peter's office is Christ's gift to serve unity. Yet it was the thing dividing Christians most.

Could the office be exercised differently, as it had been in the first thousand years, without the Catholic Church giving up what it believes the office is?

IIIWhat happened

On 25 May 1995 John Paul II published Ut Unum Sint, That They May Be One. It is an encyclical, a pope's formal teaching letter. In it he asked other Church leaders and theologians to help him.

He proposed a patient, brotherly dialogue about how the pope's first place could be exercised. It should serve the unity of all Christians, not only Catholics.

IVWhat came of it

In 2007, at Ravenna in Italy, Catholic and Orthodox theologians agreed that Rome held first place in the first thousand years. They disagreed on what that first place included.

In 2024 the Vatican's office for Christian unity gathered the replies. It called for a fresh Catholic reading of the First Vatican Council, and quoted Pope Francis: little progress has been made.

On 28 November 2025, at İznik, ancient Nicaea, Pope Leo XIV, Patriarch Bartholomew and other church leaders prayed the Nicene Creed together. It was 1,700 years after the council.

VRead the source
Could not the real but imperfect communion existing between us persuade Church leaders and their theologians to engage with me in a patient and fraternal dialogue on this subject, a dialogue in which, leaving useless controversies behind, we could listen to one another
Ut Unum Sint, Encyclical Letter on Commitment to Ecumenism · Ut Unum Sint 96 (vatican.va)

Why it matters

For the first time a pope asked other Christians how his own office should work. The Catholic Church separates what the primacy is, which it holds as Christ's gift, from how it is used, which has changed before.

Catholics and Orthodox now agree on far more than in 1054. But they are still not in communion: they don't share the sacraments as one Church.

The papacy is the main reason. The other is the old dispute over the filioque, the West's addition to the Creed saying the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son.

The LineSee the line from the apostles to today’s bishops
Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

Chapter 5 followed the keys Jesus gave Peter, and chapter 9 the handing on of office from the to bishops. The Catholic Church teaches that Peter's office continues in the bishop of Rome. It does not claim the first century looked like 1870.

John Henry Newman, an English scholar who became a Catholic cardinal, described the pattern: "While Apostles were on earth, there was the display neither of Bishop nor Pope".

First the bishop's power showed itself, then the pope's. Rome's authority was spelled out when it was challenged, not before.

Read the early quarrels closely and most of them point the same way. did not tell Victor he had no right to act. He told him not to cut off churches over a custom.

Cyprian called Rome the chair of Peter before he argued with Stephen. And Stephen's view on is the one the Catholic Church kept.

Leo cancelled 28 "by the blessed Apostle Peter's authority". Firmilian, it is true, granted Stephen nothing.

People argue about the limits of an authority they recognise, not one they have never heard of.

Gregory the Great is the hardest case, and the Catholic reading takes him at his word. He refused "universal" because it implied that other bishops were not truly bishops.

Elsewhere in his letters he wrote that no one could doubt that Constantinople was "subject to the Apostolic See", meaning Rome.

The First Vatican Council quoted his letter against the title to make its own point. The pope's power exists to uphold the bishops' authority, not to swallow it.

Gregory refused a title; he did not refuse the first place he exercised.

The thinnest stretch of the Catholic case is the first hundred years. In those years Rome's leaders appear as presbyters, a group of elders.

The Catholic answer is that what passes down is Peter's charge within the Roman church, not one form of government.

That church was already writing to others with authority in 96. The words bishop and presbyter were not yet clearly told apart. A list of Scripture usually dated to about 170 says Pius had occupied the Roman chair.

On Newman's account the office came before its shape was fixed.

What was defined in 1870 is narrower than its reputation. The bishops keep their own authority. The added that they hold supreme power together, always with the pope and never without him.

Infallibility covers solemn definitions of faith and morals. The says it "extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself": as far as what God has revealed.

It is not a promise that popes judge well, and the next chapter shows how badly some did.

John Paul II made the strongest Catholic argument in 1995. The office exists to serve unity. So when the way it is exercised divides Christians, that way should be open to change.

The Catholic Church separates what the primacy is from how it is used. The first it holds as Christ's gift. The second has changed before, and the Catholic Church says it can change again.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Eastern Orthodox

The Orthodox Church honours Rome's first place in the first thousand years. It holds that this was a first place of honour, set by the order in which the churches were listed. It was not a power over other churches.

In a statement of 2013 the Russian Orthodox Church says across the whole Church "represents primacy in honour". It says the canons, the early church laws, "do not vest the primus ... with any powers on the church-wide scale".

The primus is the bishop who holds first place.

It adds that the Orthodox Church rejected Rome's teaching on a papal power given by God. Rome's honour, it holds, was set up by men, not by God.

Orthodox writers often point to canon 28 of , which ranked churches by the importance of their cities. Since the break with Rome, first place among the Orthodox has passed to Constantinople.

They also answer the Catholic point that people argue only about the limits of an authority they recognise. Firmilian, they note, recognised none: he mocked Stephen's claim outright.

And the same Moscow statement quotes Cyprian's council of 256: "neither does any one of us set himself up as a bishop of bishops". On their reading, the early quarrels show bishops honouring Rome and refusing its orders, which is just what a first place of honour looks like.

Lutheran

The Lutheran Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537) denies that the bishop of Rome is above other bishops by divine right, by Christ's own will. Christ, it argues, forbade lordship among the apostles and sent them out as equals.

In Matthew 16 Jesus calls Peter the rock on which he will build his Church. The Treatise reads that rock as "the ministry of the confession which Peter made", as had also read it.

It also cites Gregory the Great's refusal of the title universal bishop. Even a pope with divine right, it says, would not be owed obedience while he defended teaching contrary to the .

Melanchthon, Luther's closest colleague, added a personal note when signing the Smalcald Articles, a Lutheran statement of faith. If the pope allowed the Gospel, his higher place could be granted "by human right".

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself7
The documents in order, including the ones that cut against Rome12 steps

The same road walked again, with the texts on the table. Several of these are the strongest early evidence against the Catholic reading.

  1. A letter to Rome that names no bishop

    c. 107

    Ignatius of Antioch, a bishop on his way to execution, praised the Roman church as the church that "presides over love". He said he would not give it orders as Peter and Paul had.

    In letters that tell other churches to obey their bishop, he greets no bishop at Rome.

    John Henry Newman, making the Catholic case, granted that Ignatius is silent about the pope's authority. He argued that such silence was natural at that stage.

    “I do not, as Peter and Paul, issue commandments unto you. They were apostles; I am but a condemned man”
    HistoricalLetter to the RomansLetter to the Romans 4 (Ante-Nicene Fathers translation, New Advent)The evidence ↓
  2. Presbyters preside at Rome

    2nd century

    The Shepherd of Hermas, a book of visions written in Rome, tells its author to make two copies. One goes to Clement, who has leave to send writings abroad. The other goes to Grapte, for the widows and orphans.

    Hermas himself is to read it in Rome with the presbyters, the elders who lead the church. The picture is a group of elders, one of whom handles letters.

    The Muratorian list, an early list of the books of Scripture usually dated to about 170 (some scholars place it in the 300s), says Hermas's brother Pius was then occupying the chair of the Roman church.

    “You will write therefore two books, and you will send the one to Clemens and the other to Grapte. And Clemens will send his to foreign countries, for permission has been granted to him to do so. And Grapte will admonish the widows and the orphans. But you will read the words in this city, along with the presbyters who preside over the Church.”
    HistoricalThe Shepherd of Hermas, Book I (Visions)The Shepherd, Book I, Vision 2, chapter 4 (Ante-Nicene Fathers translation, New Advent)The evidence ↓
  3. Irenaeus calls the earlier bishops of Rome 'presbyters'

    c. 190

    In the same letter that rebukes Victor, Irenaeus names Victor's predecessors. He calls them presbyters who presided over the Roman church. They kept a different Easter custom from Asia and stayed in communion with it.

    The same men appear as bishops in Irenaeus's own list of the bishops of Rome.

    The two words were not yet fixed, and each side of the argument reads that fact its own way.

    “Among these were the presbyters before Soter, who presided over the church which you now rule. We mean Anicetus, and Pius, and Hyginus, and Telesphorus, and Xystus. They neither observed it themselves, nor did they permit those after them to do so.”
    HistoricalChurch History (Historia Ecclesiastica)Church History V.24.14, quoting Irenaeus's letter to VictorThe evidence ↓
  4. Peter's grave, pointed out around 200

    c. 200

    Gaius, a Christian at Rome in the time of Pope Zephyrinus, was arguing with a leader of the Phrygian sect, the Montanists, a movement of new prophets from Phrygia, in today's Turkey.

    He offered to show the 'trophies', the monuments, of the apostles who founded the Roman church. One was on the Vatican hill, and one on the road to Ostia.

    Around 170 Dionysius, bishop of Corinth, had already written that Peter and Paul taught in Italy and died as martyrs at the same time.

    “But I can show the trophies of the apostles. For if you will go to the Vatican or to the Ostian way, you will find the trophies of those who laid the foundations of this church.”
    HistoricalChurch History (Historia Ecclesiastica)Church History II.25.7, quoting GaiusThe evidence ↓
  5. Two versions of Cyprian's key chapter

    251 and after

    Chapter 4 of Cyprian's treatise on unity survives in two versions. One speaks of a primacy given to Peter and of Peter's chair. The other stresses that all the apostles had equal power.

    Maurice Bévenot, a Jesuit scholar, argued in 1957 that both are Cyprian's. On his view the primacy version came first, and Cyprian toned it down during his quarrel with Stephen.

    John Chapman, an English Benedictine monk and scholar, had argued the reverse order in 1908. Both men were Catholics, and both read 'Peter's chair' in chapter 4 as the chair every lawful bishop holds, not Rome's in particular.

    “The view here taken is that Cyprian himself revised his text, and that what is known as the 'Primacy Text' (because it contains the word primatus) is the original one, whereas the generally received text is his correction of it.”
  6. Firmilian scorns Stephen's appeal to Peter

    256

    Firmilian, bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia, wrote to Cyprian to back him against Stephen.

    His letter shows that Stephen defended his ruling by appealing to Peter's succession. It also shows that a senior Eastern bishop rejected the appeal with contempt.

    Firmilian wrote that in excommunicating everyone, Stephen had cut off only himself. To him a ruling from Rome could be wrong, and could be refused.

    “And in this respect I am justly indignant at this so open and manifest folly of Stephen, that he who so boasts of the place of his episcopate, and contends that he holds the succession from Peter, on whom the foundations of the Church were laid, should introduce many other rocks and establish new buildings of many churches”
    HistoricalEpistle 74 (Firmilian, bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia, to Cyprian, against the letter of Stephen)Epistle 74 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers numbering (Firmilian to Cyprian), 17The evidence ↓
  7. A council writes down the right of appeal

    343 or 344

    Bishops met at Sardica, today's Sofia in Bulgaria, during the Arian crisis, the long fight over whether the Son is fully God. There Hosius of Cordoba proposed a rule.

    A bishop condemned by his neighbours could have his case referred to Julius, bishop of Rome, who could order a retrial. The reason given is to honour Peter.

    The Greek Church later took these canons into its law. But when Rome cited them in Africa as canons of Nicaea, the African bishops checked their copies of Nicaea and could not find them.

    “let us, if it seem good to your charity, honour the memory of Peter the Apostle, and let those who gave judgment write to Julius, the bishop of Rome, so that, if necessary, the case may be retried by the bishops of the neighbouring provinces and let him appoint arbiters”
    HistoricalCouncil of Sardica (343 or 344): Canons, with Hefele's notesCanon 3, Greek text (Percival, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 14)The evidence ↓
  8. Leo annuls canon 28 by Peter's authority

    After 451

    Leo wrote to the empress Pulcheria rejecting canon 28. He appealed both to Peter and to the canons of Nicaea, which, he said, gave Alexandria second place and Antioch third.

    The Eastern churches kept the canon anyway. At Florence in 1439 Rome itself ranked the patriarch of Constantinople second after the pope.

    The Vatican's 2024 study document notes that the Orthodox usually argue from canon 28 that Rome's first place had a political basis.

    “But the bishops' assents, which are opposed to the regulations of the holy canons composed at Nicæa in conjunction with your faithful Grace, we do not recognize, and by the blessed Apostle Peter's authority we absolutely dis-annul in comprehensive terms”
    HistoricalLetter 105, to Pulcheria Augusta (on canon 28 of Chalcedon)Letter 105, to Pulcheria Augusta, chapter 3 (Feltoe, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 12)The evidence ↓
  9. Five centuries later, the word Gregory refused

    1075

    A list of 27 short claims was entered in the register, the official record, of Pope Gregory VII. It says the pope may depose emperors, may be judged by no one, and alone may be called universal.

    The Fordham source book, an online collection of medieval texts, notes a dispute over who wrote it and when. But the list states Gregory VII's programme.

    Set beside Gregory the Great's letter, it shows how far the Western claim had moved.

    “That the Roman pontiff alone can with right be called universal. ... That it may be permitted to him to depose emperors. ... That he himself may be judged by no one.”
    HistoricalDictatus Papae (Internet Medieval Sourcebook)Dictatus Papae, items 2, 12 and 19 (trans. E. F. Henderson, 1910, Internet Medieval Sourcebook)The evidence ↓
  10. Vatican II sets the pope inside the college of bishops

    1964

    The Second Vatican Council did not withdraw the First Vatican Council's teaching. It set it in a wider frame.

    The bishops together succeed the apostles and hold supreme authority over the whole Church, but only with the pope as their head.

    The same document says bishops are not the pope's deputies: they govern their dioceses by an authority of their own. That is Gregory the Great's concern, written into Catholic teaching.

    “The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.”
  11. Catholics and Orthodox agree on first place, and disagree on what it meant

    2007

    At Ravenna, in Italy, the official Catholic-Orthodox commission agreed that Rome held first place among the churches in the first thousand years. Its bishop was first among the patriarchs. In the Greek words of the text, Rome stood first in the taxis, the order of rank, and its bishop was the protos, the first.

    It also recorded that the two sides read the evidence for his powers differently, and had already done so then.

    The Russian Orthodox delegation was absent, and in 2013 Moscow rejected the text's account of primacy over the whole Church.

    “Both sides agree that this canonical taxis was recognised by all in the era of the undivided Church. Further, they agree that Rome, as the Church that "presides in love" according to the phrase of St Ignatius of Antioch (To the Romans, Prologue), occupied the first place in the taxis, and that the bishop of Rome was therefore the protos among the patriarchs. They disagree, however, on the interpretation of the historical evidence from this era regarding the prerogatives of the bishop of Rome as protos, a matter that was already understood in different ways in the first millennium.”
  12. Rome's unity office asks for Vatican I to be read again

    2024

    A Vatican study document summarised some thirty replies to John Paul II's invitation, and fifty texts from the dialogues between Churches.

    Among the proposals, it singled out a Catholic 're-reception' of the First Vatican Council. That means reading it again in the light of the Second, with clearer terms for words such as jurisdiction and infallibility.

    It calls itself a study document, not a summary of Church teaching.

    “Among the proposals expressed by the dialogues, the call for a Catholic 're-reception' or official commentary of Vatican I seems particularly important.”
    HistoricalThe Bishop of Rome: Primacy and Synodality in the Ecumenical Dialogues and in the Responses to the Encyclical Ut unum sintThe Bishop of Rome (2024), 'Principles and proposals for a renewed exercise of primacy', 14The evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on12 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Peter went to Rome and was martyred there under Nero. The earliest witnesses are the First Letter of Peter, written by Peter or later in his name, which sends greetings from 'Babylon', a Christian code name for Rome; the Roman church's letter to Corinth of about 96, which recalls his martyrdom as recent; Ignatius's letter to the Romans of about 107; and, by about 200, Dionysius of Corinth and the Roman Christian Gaius, who pointed to the apostles' monuments on the Vatican and the road to Ostia.

Rests on
  • 1 Peter 5:13 and note 7 (New American Bible, vatican.va IntraText, ENG0839 __P125)
    “The chosen one at Babylon sends you greeting, as does Mark, my son.”
  • 1 Peter 5:13, note 7
    “The chosen one: feminine, referring to the Christian community (ekklesia) at Babylon, the code name for Rome in Rev 14:8; 17:5; 18:2.”
  • Introduction to 1 Peter (ENG0839 __P120)
    “From Irenaeus in the late second century until modern times, Christian tradition regarded Peter the apostle as author of this document. Since he was martyred at Rome during the persecution of Nero between A.D. 64 and 67, it was supposed that the letter was written from Rome shortly before his death.”
  • 1 Clement 5
    “Let us take the noble examples furnished in our own generation. Through envy and jealousy the greatest and most righteous pillars [of the church] have been persecuted and put to death. Let us set before our eyes the illustrious apostles. Peter, …”
    Read the full passage
    “Let us take the noble examples furnished in our own generation. Through envy and jealousy the greatest and most righteous pillars [of the church] have been persecuted and put to death. Let us set before our eyes the illustrious apostles. Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured not one or two, but numerous labours; and when he had at length suffered martyrdom, departed to the place of glory due to him.”
  • Letter to the Romans 4
    “I do not, as Peter and Paul, issue commandments unto you. They were apostles; I am but a condemned man”
  • Church History II.25.5-8 (McGiffert)
    “It is, therefore, recorded that Paul was beheaded in Rome itself, and that Peter likewise was crucified under Nero.”
  • Church History II.25.7, quoting Gaius
    “But I can show the trophies of the apostles. For if you will go to the Vatican or to the Ostian way, you will find the trophies of those who laid the foundations of this church.”
  • Church History II.25.8, quoting Dionysius of Corinth
    “And they taught together in like manner in Italy, and suffered martyrdom at the same time.”
Other readings
  • Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestant readers accept that Peter died in Rome; the disagreement is over what that death means for the Roman bishop's authority, not over the fact.
  • The New American Bible's own introduction reports that some modern scholars regard 1 Peter as the work of a later Christian writer, from the end of the first century or the beginning of the second, and that others take a middle position: about AD 70-90, by a disciple of Peter in Rome. On those readings the letter still witnesses to a link between Peter and Rome, but it is not Peter's own evidence.
Limits
  • 1 Clement 5 recalls Peter's martyrdom but does not say where it took place; the place comes from 1 Peter's 'Babylon', Ignatius, Dionysius and Gaius.
  • No first-century text calls Peter bishop of Rome. The claim that he headed the Roman church rests on later succession lists and on the tradition of his death there.
  • Gaius's 'trophies' are monuments, not a description of a tomb's contents. Nothing here establishes the identification of any bones.
  • The trail's date 'AD 64 or later' covers the traditional dating (before Peter's death, 64-67) and the later datings reported in the New American Bible's introduction (70-90, or the end of the first century or after).
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

From the end of the first century the church of Rome acted beyond its own borders and was looked to by others. Around 96 it wrote to Corinth, sent envoys, and warned that disobedience carried serious danger; Corinth was still reading the letter in the 170s. Around 107 Ignatius called Rome the church that 'presides over love', and around 180 Irenaeus wrote that every church must agree with Rome, in a sentence whose key Latin phrase can be read as greater authority or as older origin.

Rests on
  • 1 Clement 59
    “If, however, any shall disobey the words spoken by Him through us, let them know that they will involve themselves in transgression and serious danger”
  • 1 Clement 63
    “Joy and gladness will you afford us, if you become obedient to the words written by us and through the Holy Spirit root out the lawless wrath of your jealousy according to the intercession which we have made for peace and unity in this letter.”
  • Church History IV.23.11, quoting Dionysius of Corinth to Soter
    “Today we have passed the Lord's holy day, in which we have read your epistle. From it, whenever we read it, we shall always be able to draw advice, as also from the former epistle, which was written to us through Clement.”
  • Letter to the Romans, greeting
    “which also presides in the place of the region of the Romans, worthy of God, worthy of honour, worthy of the highest happiness, worthy of praise, worthy of obtaining her every desire, worthy of being deemed holy, and which presides over love”
  • Against Heresies III.3.2
    “For it is a matter of necessity that every Church should agree with this Church, on account of its preeminent authority [potiorem principalitatem].”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 2, with footnote 48 citing Irenaeus, Against Heresies III.3
    “For this reason it has always been necessary for every church–that is to say the faithful throughout the world–to be in agreement with the Roman church because of its more effective leadership.”
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: a church that corrects another in a tone of command, and that a bishop in Gaul says all must agree with, already exercises something like the primacy later defined. Vatican I cites Irenaeus for exactly this.
  • Orthodox and many Protestant readings: 1 Clement is one church writing to another as 'we', with no bishop named, and Irenaeus's phrase can mean that Rome is the older, apostolic church whose teaching is a sure test, not that it governs the rest.
Limits
  • 1 Clement is written in the name of the church, not of one bishop; Clement's authorship is tradition.
  • The opening of 1 Clement in this translation says Corinth had 'consulted us', which cuts against the idea that Rome intervened unasked; the Greek can be read either way and no Greek text was compared.
  • Everything in Irenaeus III.3.2 turns on the Latin phrase potiorem principalitatem, which survives only in Latin translation. It can be translated 'greater authority' or 'more ancient origin', and the choice changes what the passage proves.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Rome's authority was contested by bishops later honoured as saints. Around 190 Irenaeus and others rebuked Pope Victor for trying to excommunicate the churches of Asia over the date of Easter. In 256 Cyprian of Carthage and Firmilian of Caesarea resisted Pope Stephen's ruling on baptism by heretics, and Firmilian mocked Stephen's claim to hold Peter's succession. Cyprian himself called Rome 'the Chair of Peter' in a letter to Pope Cornelius, and his treatise on unity survives in two versions of its key chapter, one mentioning a primacy given to Peter.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: the rebukes were about how Rome used an authority everyone recognised, not whether it had any. Irenaeus asked Victor not to cut off churches; he did not deny his standing. On baptism Stephen's view became the Catholic Church's own.
  • Orthodox and Protestant reading: bishops honoured as saints treated Rome's rulings as open to refusal, which is hard to square with the universal jurisdiction defined in 1870.
  • On Cyprian's two versions, Maurice Bévenot (1957) holds the primacy version was Cyprian's first draft, toned down during the quarrel with Stephen; John Chapman (1908) held the primacy version was Cyprian's later alteration for the Roman confessors. Both read 'the chair of Peter' in Unity 4 as the chair every lawful bishop holds: Chapman calls it a mistake to find Rome there, and Bévenot says the context is against restricting it to Rome. Cyprian's plain reference to Rome as the Chair of Peter is in his Letter 59 to Cornelius.
  • Bévenot's own judgement: Cyprian recognised the Bishop of Rome's special position in practice, but never held, and never denied, that the pope had universal jurisdiction. His practice went further than his theory.
Limits
  • Firmilian's letter survives only in Latin, among Cyprian's correspondence; its tone is its own and it is a partisan document.
  • The received text of Unity 4 quoted is the Ante-Nicene Fathers translation; the primacy version is quoted in the Catholic Encyclopedia's translation, so the two English wordings differ for reasons of translation as well as of text.
  • The Bévenot quotations are from an OCR text of the 1957 volume; the OCR's mismatched quotation marks have been normalised.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia's 'generally admitted' is Chapman's own judgement in 1908, and Bévenot's footnote 11 lists scholars on both sides of the order of the versions.
  • Firmilian conceded nothing to Stephen; his letter is evidence of Stephen's appeal to Peter's succession, not of its acceptance in the East.
  • The saved Catholic Encyclopedia page quotes Letter 59 without its number; the number 59.14 comes from Bévenot's notes (ACW 25), which cite the same Latin phrase.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Councils both recognised and limited Rome. The Council of Sardica (343 or 344) let a condemned bishop's case be referred to Julius of Rome 'to honour the memory of Peter'. At Chalcedon in 451 the bishops acclaimed Leo's letter with 'Peter has spoken thus through Leo', while its canon 28 gave Constantinople rank next after Rome because it was the imperial city. Rome's legates protested and Leo annulled the canon 'by the blessed Apostle Peter's authority'. When Rome cited Sardica's canons in Africa as Nicene, the African bishops could not find them in the Nicene copies.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: Sardica made written law of an appeal to Rome grounded in Peter, Chalcedon heard Peter in Leo, and Leo's annulment of canon 28 was an act of Petrine authority the council's own legates called that of 'the ruler of the whole church'.
  • Orthodox reading: canon 28 states the real ground of Rome's first place, that it was the imperial capital, and the East kept the canon whatever Leo said. The acclamation praised Leo because he taught what Cyril taught, not because Rome's word settled the question.
  • African reading of the 420s: appeals across the sea were not established by Nicaea, and Rome should stop hearing them.
Limits
  • Sardica was not an ecumenical council, and its date is uncertain between 343 and 344.
  • The legate Lucentius's words are quoted from the NPNF English, which notes a variant Latin reading of the preceding sentence.
  • The letter to Celestine is undated on the page; it is placed in the 420s only because Celestine succeeded Boniface, to whom the Nicene copies were sent in 419.
  • The acclamation is in the section Percival heads 'Session II (Continued)'; session numbering differs between editions of the acts.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Gregory the Great condemned the title 'universal bishop' taken by John of Constantinople, and refused 'Universal Pope' for himself, because a universal bishop would make the others no longer truly bishops. The same Gregory wrote that Peter was given 'the care and principality of the whole Church' and that no one could doubt Constantinople was subject to the Apostolic See. Vatican I quoted his letter to Eulogius to say the pope's power upholds the bishops' own. Gregory VII's register in 1075 claimed the word 'universal' for the pope alone.

Rests on
  • Register V.20, to the Emperor Maurice
    “Lo, he received the keys of the heavenly kingdom, and power to bind and loose is given him, the care and principality of the whole Church is committed to him, and yet he is not called the universal apostle; while the most holy man, my fellow priest John, attempts to be called universal bishop.”
  • Register VII.33, to the Emperor Maurice
    “Now I confidently say that whosoever calls himself, or desires to be called, Universal Priest, is in his elation the precursor of Antichrist, because he proudly puts himself above all others.”
  • Register VIII.30, to Eulogius of Alexandria
    “For I said that neither to me nor to any one else ought you to write anything of the kind; and lo, in the preface of the epistle which you have addressed to myself who forbade it, you have thought fit to make use of a proud appellation, calling me Universal Pope.”
  • Register VIII.30
    “For if your Holiness calls me Universal Pope, you deny that you are yourself what you call me universally.”
  • Register VIII.30
    “Moreover, at the solemnity of the Lord's Nativity which occurred in this first indiction, more than ten thousand Angli are reported to have been baptized by the same our brother and fellow bishop.”
  • Register IX.12, to John, bishop of Syracuse
    “For as to what they say about the Church of Constantinople, who can doubt that it is subject to the Apostolic See, as both the most pious lord the emperor and our brother the bishop of that city continually acknowledge?”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 3, with footnote 51 (Ep. ad Eulog. Alexandrin. VIII 29 (30))
    “for St Gregory the Great says: “My honour is the honour of the whole church. My honour is the steadfast strength of my brethren. Then do I receive true honour, when it is denied to none of those to whom honour is due.””
  • Dictatus Papae, item 2
    “That the Roman pontiff alone can with right be called universal.”
  • Ut Unum Sint 88
    “In the beautiful expression of Pope Saint Gregory the Great, my ministry is that of servus servorum Dei .”
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: Gregory refused a title that implied the other bishops were not bishops, while exercising and asserting Rome's primacy, including over Constantinople. Vatican II's teaching that bishops are not vicars of the pope keeps his concern.
  • Lutheran and Orthodox reading: the Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537) cites Gregory's refusal against the papacy, and the Dictatus Papae's claim to the title shows how far the later West moved from him.
Limits
  • The New Advent pages print the letters without dates. VIII.30 is placed about 598 because it reports the Christmas baptisms in England after the mission's landing in 597.
  • The letter numbering is that of the NPNF translation; Pastor Aeternus cites the same letter as VIII 29 (30).
  • Whether 'universal' in 1075 meant what it meant to Gregory the Great is itself part of the dispute.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The medieval West claimed far more for the pope than the early Church had. A list entered in Gregory VII's register in 1075 says the pope may depose emperors, may be judged by no one, and alone may be called universal. Boniface VIII's Unam Sanctam (1302) set temporal power under spiritual power and defined that subjection to the Roman Pontiff is necessary for salvation; four years later Clement V assured France the bull had not made it more subject to Rome. The Catholic Church now teaches that 'no salvation outside the Church' is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church.

Rests on
  • Dictatus Papae, items 2, 12, 19 and 22
    “That the Roman pontiff alone can with right be called universal. ... That it may be permitted to him to depose emperors. ... That he himself may be judged by no one. ... That the Roman church has never erred; nor will it err to all eternity, the Scripture bearing witness.”
  • Editor's headnote (Paul Halsall)
    “The Dictatus Papae was included in Pope's register in the year 1075. Some argue that it was written by Pope Gregory VII (r. 1073-1085) himself, others argues that it had a much later different origin.”
  • Unam Sanctam, on the two swords
    “However, one sword ought to be subordinated to the other and temporal authority, subjected to spiritual power.”
  • Unam Sanctam, final sentence
    “Furthermore, we declare, we proclaim, we define that it is absolutely necessary for salvation that every human creature be subject to the Roman Pontiff.”
  • “Consequently, when King Philip protested, Clement V was able, in his Brief "Meruit", of 1 February, 1306, to declare that the French king and France were to suffer no disadvantage on account of the Bull "Unam Sanctam", and that the issuing of this …”
    Read the full passage
    “Consequently, when King Philip protested, Clement V was able, in his Brief "Meruit", of 1 February, 1306, to declare that the French king and France were to suffer no disadvantage on account of the Bull "Unam Sanctam", and that the issuing of this Bull had not made them subject to the authority of the Roman Church in any other manner than formerly.”
  • CCC 847
    “This affirmation is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church”
Other readings
  • Catholic reading, as in the Catholic Encyclopedia: only the final sentence of Unam Sanctam is a definition, and it states the necessity of belonging to the Church and so of being subject to the pope in religious matters; the political theory of the two swords belongs to its time.
  • Protestant reading: the Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537) names 'the Constitution of Boniface VIII' among the claims that the pope is by divine right ruler of kingdoms, and treats them as usurpation.
Limits
  • The Dictatus Papae's author and date are disputed, as the Fordham headnote says; it expresses Gregory VII's programme, not a law of the Church.
  • Whether the final sentence of Unam Sanctam is an infallible definition is argued among Catholic theologians; the Catholic Encyclopedia treats it as a dogmatic definition.
  • CCC 847 comments on the patristic saying 'outside the Church no salvation', not on Unam Sanctam by name.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The First Vatican Council defined in 1870 that Peter's primacy passes by Christ's institution to every bishop of Rome, that the pope has ordinary and immediate jurisdiction over every church, and that his solemn definitions on faith or morals are kept from error. It also said the pope's power upholds the bishops' own. The Second Vatican Council taught that the bishops together, with the pope as head and never without him, hold supreme power, and that bishops are not vicars of the pope. Infallibility extends only as far as the deposit of revelation, and is not a promise that popes are always right.

Rests on
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 2
    “Therefore whoever succeeds to the chair of Peter obtains by the institution of Christ himself, the primacy of Peter over the whole church.”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 3
    “we teach and declare that, by divine ordinance, the Roman church possesses a pre-eminence of ordinary power over every other church, and that this jurisdictional power of the Roman pontiff is both episcopal and immediate.”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 3
    “This power of the supreme pontiff by no means detracts from that ordinary and immediate power of episcopal jurisdiction, by which bishops, who have succeeded to the place of the apostles by appointment of the holy Spirit, tend and govern individually the particular flocks which have been assigned to them.”
  • Lumen Gentium 22
    “The order of bishops, which succeeds to the college of apostles and gives this apostolic body continued existence, is also the subject of supreme and full power over the universal Church, provided we understand this body together with its head the Roman Pontiff and never without this head.”
  • Lumen Gentium 27
    “The pastoral office or the habitual and daily care of their sheep is entrusted to them completely; nor are they to be regarded as vicars of the Roman Pontiffs, for they exercise an authority that is proper to them”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Vatican Council', on the minority before the fourth session
    “Shortly before the fourth public session a large number of the bishops of the minority left Rome with the permission of the directing officers of the council. They did not oppose the dogma of papal infallibility itself, but were against its definition as inopportune.”
  • CCC 882
    “For the Roman Pontiff, by reason of his office as Vicar of Christ, and as pastor of the entire Church has full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church, a power which he can always exercise unhindered.”
  • CCC 891, final sentence
    “This infallibility extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself.”
Other readings
  • Orthodox reading: universal, immediate jurisdiction was never recognised in the first millennium and turns a primacy of honour into lordship (Position of the Moscow Patriarchate, 2013).
  • Lutheran reading: no primacy by divine right; at most, for the sake of peace, a superiority by human right if the pope allowed the Gospel (Melanchthon, 1537).
  • Within Catholic dialogue: the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity's study document of 2024 reports proposals for a Catholic 're-reception' of Vatican I read in the light of Vatican II.
Limits
  • This claim states what was defined; it does not show that the defined doctrine was held in this form in the early centuries. That is the point in dispute, and chapter 37 treats Vatican I in depth.
  • Pastor Aeternus's statement that Peter's presiding in his successors 'was known in every age' is a statement of faith about continuity, not a historian's finding.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

In Ut Unum Sint (1995) John Paul II acknowledged that the papacy is a difficulty for most other Christians and asked their leaders to help him find a way of exercising the primacy open to a new situation, without renouncing what is essential. In 2024 the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity published a study document summarising some thirty responses and fifty dialogue texts, proposing among other things a Catholic 're-reception' of Vatican I. It quotes Pope Francis: 'We have made little progress in this regard'.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: the invitation shows the office distinguishing what it is from how it is exercised, and the 2024 document shows the invitation still being worked through.
  • Orthodox and Protestant reading: an invitation issued by the pope, on the pope's terms and keeping 'what is essential', leaves untouched exactly what they dispute.
Limits
  • The Bishop of Rome is a study document, not teaching, and it says so.
  • Nothing structural in the definition of the primacy has changed since 1995.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

The earliest Roman sources describe a church led by presbyters, and do not name a single bishop. Ignatius's letter to Rome names none. The Shepherd of Hermas, written in Rome, has its author read his book with 'the presbyters who preside over the Church' and send a copy to Clement to forward abroad. Irenaeus, writing to Victor around 190, calls the earlier Roman leaders 'presbyters'. By the middle of the second century one man, Pius, is said to have occupied the Roman chair.

Rests on
  • The Shepherd, Book I, Vision 2, chapter 4
    “You will write therefore two books, and you will send the one to Clemens and the other to Grapte. And Clemens will send his to foreign countries, for permission has been granted to him to do so. And Grapte will admonish the widows and the orphans. …”
    Read the full passage
    “You will write therefore two books, and you will send the one to Clemens and the other to Grapte. And Clemens will send his to foreign countries, for permission has been granted to him to do so. And Grapte will admonish the widows and the orphans. But you will read the words in this city, along with the presbyters who preside over the Church.”
  • The Shepherd, Book I, Vision 3, chapter 9
    “Wherefore I now say to you who preside over the Church and love the first seats, Be not like drug-mixers.”
  • Church History V.24.14, quoting Irenaeus to Victor
    “Among these were the presbyters before Soter, who presided over the church which you now rule. We mean Anicetus, and Pius, and Hyginus, and Telesphorus, and Xystus.”
  • Against Heresies III.3.3
    “Alexander followed Evaristus; then, sixth from the apostles, Sixtus was appointed; after him, Telephorus, who was gloriously martyred; then Hyginus; after him, Pius; then after him, Anicetus.”
  • Muratorian Fragment, lines 73-76
    “But Hermas wrote the Shepherd (74) very recently, [7c] in our times, in the city of Rome, (75) while bishop Pius, his brother, was occupying the [episcopal] chair (76) of the church of the city of Rome.”
  • Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine, chapter 4, section 3, paragraph 2 (1878 edition)
    “For instance, it is true, St. Ignatius is silent in his Epistles on the subject of the Pope's authority”
Other readings
  • One reading: Rome was governed by a college of presbyters into the second century, with one of them, such as Clement, handling correspondence, and a single presiding bishop emerged only around the middle of the century.
  • The Catholic reading: the words bishop and presbyter were not yet fixed, so a presiding elder can be called either; Irenaeus lists the same men as bishops. What is handed on is Peter's charge within the Roman church, which was already writing with authority in 96, and the form of its leadership sharpened over time, as Newman argued.
Limits
  • Silence is not evidence of absence: Ignatius not naming a Roman bishop does not show there was none.
  • The date of the Shepherd of Hermas is uncertain; the Muratorian list places it under Pius, while the mention of Clement in Vision 2 suggests some of it may be earlier.
  • The Muratorian list's own date is given as about 170 by the page on which it was read; other datings exist and were not examined.
  • The Catholic Church does not teach any particular date for the rise of a single presiding bishop at Rome; its teaching concerns the succession of the office, not its early form.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

Catholics and Orthodox agree that Rome held first place among the churches in the first millennium, and disagree about what that place carried. The Ravenna Document (2007) records both points. The Russian Orthodox Church, absent at Ravenna, stated in 2013 that universal primacy is a primacy of honour fixed by the diptychs, that the canons gave the first bishop no church-wide powers, and that the Orthodox Church rejected the Roman doctrine of papal primacy. The joint commission also agreed that the bishop of Rome did not convene the early ecumenical councils or personally preside over them.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: the first-millennium record shows Rome acting as a court of appeal and a voice for Peter (Sardica, Leo, Gregory), which is more than precedence; Vatican I and II state what that role was.
  • Orthodox reading: Rome's first place was a primacy of honour, of human institution and tied to the imperial city (Chalcedon canon 28), and the Orthodox Church has kept the first-millennium structure without a single administrative centre.
Limits
  • The Moscow statement speaks for the Russian Orthodox Church; the Ecumenical Patriarchate and other Orthodox churches took part at Ravenna.
  • The Ravenna Document is a dialogue text agreed by commission members; neither Church has adopted it as teaching.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

11InferenceDisputed Quotes checked

The Catholic account of the papacy is an account of development: a real charge given to Peter, carried on in the Roman church, whose powers were spelled out as they were challenged. John Henry Newman argued that neither bishop nor pope was prominent while the apostles lived, that the bishop's power showed itself first and the pope's afterwards, and that no doctrine is defined until it is violated. Joint Catholic dialogues describe the Western understanding of Rome's primacy as developing gradually, particularly from the fourth century, in reference to Peter.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Orthodox reading: what developed in the West was a new doctrine, not the unfolding of an old one; the East kept the first-millennium structure (Position of the Moscow Patriarchate, 2013).
  • Protestant reading: development can explain anything; the test is Scripture, and Scripture shows no succession to Peter's office.
Limits
  • Newman's argument shows how the papacy could have developed legitimately; it does not by itself show that it did. It is a theological account, not a historical proof.
  • The Bishop of Rome is a study document and, in its own words, does not summarise the Catholic magisterium.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

12InferenceDisputed Quotes checked

Christians have read the 'rock' of Matthew 16:18 both as Peter and as the faith he confessed, and the two readings are old. Augustine, in a sermon on John, read the rock as the confession and ultimately as Christ. The Lutheran Treatise of 1537 reads it as 'the ministry of the confession which Peter made' and denies that the bishop of Rome is above other bishops by divine right, though Melanchthon allowed the pope a superiority by human right if he allowed the Gospel. The Catechism holds both readings together.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: the confession and the confessor are not rivals. The Catechism says Christ built his Church on the faith Peter confessed, and also that he made Simon alone the rock and shepherd of the whole flock.
  • Lutheran reading: Christ forbade lordship among the apostles and sent them out as equals; the promise attaches to the ministry of the Gospel wherever it is exercised, not to a see or a person; even a pope with divine right would not be owed obedience while he defended teaching contrary to the Gospel. Melanchthon, personally, would accept a papacy by human arrangement for peace if the pope allowed the Gospel.
Limits
  • Augustine gives more than one reading of the rock across his works; the Tractate is one of them and does not deny Peter a special role, since in the same passage Peter 'represented the universal Church'.
  • The Treatise and Smalcald Articles quoted are the Triglot Concordia English on bookofconcord.org, with that edition's bracketed additions from the German text.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next