The RiverA global Church
7 Dec 1965

The Church declares religious freedom

The Council declares, in Dignitatis Humanae, that no one may be forced in religion. It is issued on the same day the 1054 excommunications are lifted.

Revealed / dogmatic Quotes checked
In brief

For more than a century Catholic teaching had been summed up as ‘error has no rights’: ideally the state should support the true Church, and other religions could only be tolerated. Yet by the 1960s Catholics were themselves being jailed for their faith under Communist governments, and many bishops came from countries where religious freedom had served the Church well.

On 7 December 1965, the last working day of the Second Vatican Council, the bishops passed the declaration *Dignitatis Humanae* by 2,308 votes to 70. It says every person has a right to religious freedom, meaning freedom from being forced in religion by any human power, because of the dignity of the person.

It is the principle that rules out the reasoning behind heresy burnings, penal laws and religious wars.

Where we are

The situation

For more than a century, Catholic teaching on other religions had been summed up in a phrase: ‘error has no rights.’ Ideally, the state should recognise the true Church. Other faiths could be tolerated where they had to be, but not as a right.

Popes had said so firmly. In 1832 Gregory XVI called it ‘absurd and erroneous’ to claim that ‘liberty of conscience must be maintained for everyone’.

By the 1960s the world looked different. Catholics were themselves being jailed for their faith in Communist countries. Many came from places like the United States, where the Church had grown strong as a minority under religious freedom.

An American Jesuit, John Courtney Murray, had argued for religious freedom and had been silenced by Rome in the 1950s. At the he became one of the declaration's authors.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    ‘Error has no rights’

    A Catholic ethicist, writing for the fiftieth anniversary, sums up the older position.

    “The "Declaration on Religious Freedom" called into question a position that the Catholic Church had held for more than a century, often paraphrased in the statement "error has no rights.”
    Ethics - Celebrating Human Dignity: Two Documents of Vatican II · Health Progress, November-December 2015
  2. 02

    Gregory XVI, 1832

    The encyclical *Mirari Vos* on liberty of conscience.

    “This shameful font of indifferentism gives rise to that absurd and erroneous proposition which claims that liberty of conscience must be maintained for everyone.”
    Mirari Vos · Mirari Vos (1832), §14
  3. 03

    Silenced, then an architect

    The historian John O'Malley on the theologians who had been under a ban when the council opened.

    “As the council got under way, these theologians not only had the ban on them implicitly lifted but went on to be among the principal architects of the council's decrees.”
    Vatican II: Did Anything Happen?, Theological Studies 67 · O'Malley, 'Vatican II: Did Anything Happen?', Theological Studies 67 (2006)
The problem

What was at stake

Two camps reached a deadlock. One insisted that rights must be tied to truth, so the true Church has rights that error does not. The other started from freedom of conscience.

Opponents had real fears. They worried the Church would seem to say every religion is equally good, the view earlier had condemned as indifferentism. And how could the Church contradict what popes had taught so firmly?

Murray said later that the real sticking point was not religious liberty itself but the development of : can the Church's teaching grow without breaking?

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    Murray: the real sticking point

    The same anniversary article recalls what Murray thought the argument was really about.

    “He said it was not really the notion of religious liberty that was a sticking point for many of the bishops at the council but, rather, the idea of the development of doctrine.”
    Ethics - Celebrating Human Dignity: Two Documents of Vatican II · Health Progress, November-December 2015
What happened

The event

Some bishops pressed to shelve it right to the end. On 7 December 1965, the council's last working day, it passed by 2,308 votes to 70.

It grounds the right not in whether a person is right, but in the dignity of the person, known both from revelation and by reason. So the right belongs to the person who is wrong as much as to the person who is right.

Religious freedom, it says, means being free from coercion by any human power, ‘within due limits’ such as public order. The state must protect it as a civil right.

It also names the governments that ‘make life very difficult and dangerous for religious communities’, while claiming to allow worship.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The vote: 2,308 to 70

    The final vote came on 7 December 1965, the last day of the council's last session.

    “The council approved, by a vote of 2,308-70, the "Declaration on Religious Freedom" ( Dignitas Humanae ), and, by a vote of 2,309-75, approved the "Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World" ( Gaudium et Spes ).”
    Ethics - Celebrating Human Dignity: Two Documents of Vatican II · Health Progress, November-December 2015
  2. 02

    The Council's own statement of what it is not changing

    The paragraph immediately before the declaration of the right is there to stop it being read as indifferentism.

    “Therefore it leaves untouched traditional Catholic doctrine on the moral duty of men and societies toward the true religion and toward the one Church of Christ. Over and above all this, the council intends to develop the doctrine of recent popes on the inviolable rights of the human person and the constitutional order of society.”
  3. 03

    Why the ground is dignity, not correctness

    The reason given is the dignity of the person, known from revelation and by reason, which is why the right belongs to the person who is wrong as much as to the person who is right.

    “The council further declares that the right to religious freedom has its foundation in the very dignity of the human person as this dignity is known through the revealed word of God and by reason itself. This right of the human person to religious freedom is to be recognized in the constitutional law whereby society is governed and thus it is to become a civil right.”
What came of it

The outcome

The principle that rules out the reasoning behind penal laws, which punished people for their faith, behind the burning of heretics and behind the wars of religion became Catholic teaching.

The same declaration insists it leaves untouched the duty of people and societies toward the true religion. Truth still matters; it simply may not be imposed by force. That clause is the hinge of every argument about continuity.

It also admits that in the Church's past ‘there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the or even opposed to it’. The Church named its own record as part of the problem.

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    Governments that make faith dangerous

    The declaration's closing section has the Communist states of 1965 plainly in view.

    “The further fact is that forms of government still exist under which, even though freedom of religious worship receives constitutional recognition, the powers of government are engaged in the effort to deter citizens from the profession of religion and to make life very difficult and dangerous for religious communities.”
Why it matters

For the trail

Every persecution footprint on this River, in both directions, is judged by this declaration.

The Church did not merely apologise later for the methods. It rejected the reasoning that produced them.

It is also the test case for how doctrine develops. The Church holds that coming to faith must always be free, and that the 1965 teaching draws out what that always meant.

The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

This is the Church's teaching: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2), and the Catechism repeats it (CCC 2106–2109).

The same declaration admits that in the Church's history ‘there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it’.

It still holds that ‘the doctrine of the Church that no one is to be coerced into faith has always stood firm’ (Dignitatis Humanae 12).

In plain terms

Think of it like this

A family that finally writes down the house rule it had been breaking: you may argue with me, and I may not hit you.

The Council did not discover that coercion was cruel; martyrs on every side had been saying so for centuries, usually while it was being done to them. What changed is that the Church wrote the rule down as a right belonging to the person, which means it now binds the Church's own arguments about how to treat people who say no.

Read the text
“This Vatican Council declares that the human person has a right to religious freedom. This freedom means that all men are to be immune from coercion on the part of individuals or of social groups and of any human power, in such wise that no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs, whether privately or publicly, whether alone or in association with others, within due limits.”
Other readings

Where people disagree

Traditionalist Catholics argue this cannot be reconciled with nineteenth-century teaching, and the Society of St Pius X, the traditionalist group founded by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, made it one of its reasons for refusing the council.

The mainstream Catholic answer separates two things. The council affirms a civil right not to be coerced. It does not affirm a right to believe error before God.

Benedict XVI treated this as the test case for reading the council as reform in continuity. Others say plainly that the Church changed its mind, and was right to.

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next