Can Catholic teaching change? What about the death penalty and limbo?
Catholics believe the Church's understanding can grow, but its core can't be reversed. Limbo was only ever a theory. The Vatican calls its 2018 change on the death penalty growth, though some Catholics dispute that.
Part 1 · Why people ask
People ask because they've seen things move.
In 2018 the was changed to call the death penalty inadmissible: not acceptable.
And many Catholics were once taught that babies who died unbaptised went to limbo, a place of their own, outside .
is the washing with water that makes someone a Christian. You hardly hear about limbo now.
So if teaching moved there, why not anywhere? Either the Church was wrong before, or it's quietly rewriting itself.
Part 2 · Growing, not changing
The Catholic Church teaches that God's message was complete with the . Nothing new gets added.
But the Church's understanding of it grows.
The said how it grows.
It grows as believers pray and study, as they live their faith, and through the teaching of the .
What was always there is seen more clearly.
The idea is very old. Around 434, a monk named Vincent asked whether the Church could ever make progress.
His answer: Certainly; all possible progress. But it has to be real growth, not a change into something else.
He compared it to a body. Over the years it grows to its full size, yet remains still the same.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a photo of you at five, in your first school uniform.
Now put it next to a photo of you at thirty.
You're a lot taller. Your face has changed, and your voice is deeper.
You've learned to drive, to cook, to look after other people. Some things you believed at five, you now understand far better.
But nobody who knows you thinks you're a different person. Your mum would recognise you in both photos straight away.
Your arms didn't turn into wings. You didn't become someone else. You grew into more of yourself.
Catholics use the same test for teaching. Growth is the same thing becoming more itself. A reversal is becoming something else.
Part 3 · Not every teaching weighs the same
It also matters what kind of teaching changed. The Catholic Church sorts its teaching into three levels.
The first is what God revealed, like Jesus rising from the dead. Catholics believe it with faith.
The second is teachings closely tied to what God revealed, like the Vatican's own example: that a 's election was valid.
Catholics hold those as final.
The third is ordinary teaching, like much of what popes write in their teaching letters.
It asks Catholics for a respectful yes, and a real effort to accept it.
Below all three sit theories that theologians, people who study the faith for a living, put forward. Catholics may hold them or drop them.
And a judgement on how to apply a principle today is something else again. Each famous case sits somewhere on those levels.
Part 4 · Limbo was only a theory
Limbo is the clearest case of something people thought was teaching, but wasn't.
The theory said babies who die unbaptised don't suffer, but don't see God either.
In 2007, theologians who advise the Vatican looked at it closely.
They found it had been widely taught, and popes sometimes mentioned it. But it was never defined as part of the faith.
So it's still a possible theory, which Catholics may hold or drop.
But the Catechism, which is official, simply entrusts these babies to God's mercy, with hope.
Part 5 · The death penalty
Even before 2018, the Catechism allowed the death penalty only when nothing else could protect people's lives.
It said such cases were very rare, if not practically non-existent.
In 2018 Pope Francis had it rewritten. The Vatican's office for teaching explained why.
It said the principle stays: public authorities must still protect citizens' lives.
What changed, it said, is the judgement that executing a prisoner is still needed to do that, because prisons today can keep people safe.
And the new text points to a deeper sense:
the dignity of the person is not lost even after the commission of very serious crimes
The office called it an authentic development of doctrine: real growth, not a contradiction.
Now the honest part. Not everyone agrees.
A group of Catholic scholars asked the cardinals, the pope's senior advisers, to urge him to withdraw the paragraph.
They argued that the , and the Church for centuries, taught that the death penalty can be right in principle.
So here's a fair question. If the Church itself decides what counts as growth, isn't that convenient?
Catholics answer that the test happens in the open. The old and new texts are public, and anyone can compare them.
Those scholars did exactly that.
And the Church can't call just anything growth. It's bound by what it has already solemnly defined.
If it ever reversed one of those, it would be there in black and white for anyone to see.
Part 6 · Two harder cases: interest and slavery
Does that tell Catholics how to vote? The Church works for the death penalty's end worldwide, but it doesn't hand out voting lists.
Each Catholic weighs a vote in conscience.
Critics raise two other cases, and they're harder than limbo. The first is charging interest on a loan.
For centuries the Church called it usury, a .
In 1745 Pope Benedict XIV taught that any gain which exceeds the amount he gave is illicit and usurious.
Today the Church doesn't object to ordinary interest. Critics call that a reversal.
Catholics answer that the same letter already allowed gain from other titles, like a real loss the lender takes by lending.
Once money could be invested almost anywhere, lending it nearly always cost the lender something. The rule against profit from the loan alone still stands.
The second is slavery.
Popes condemned the enslaving of native peoples, as Paul III did in 1537, and the slave trade, as Gregory XVI did in 1839.
But in 1452 Pope Nicholas V let Portugal's king put conquered Saracens and pagans into perpetual servitude.
And Catholic religious orders owned slaves. One example, from the US: in 1838 the Jesuits of Maryland sold 272 men, women and children.
Today the Catholic Church teaches that slavery is wrong in every case.
In 1993 listed it among acts that are always seriously wrong.
Some Catholics say the old texts allowed only limited forms of servitude, so the principle grew.
Others, like the Catholic legal historian John Noonan, call it a real change. Both readings are argued in the open.
Part 7 · The hardest case
In 1864 Pope Pius IX condemned the claim that everyone has a personal right to worship as they choose.
His document rejected the idea that liberty of conscience and worship is each man's personal right.
Then in 1965 the Second Vatican Council said the human person has a right to religious freedom.
It looks like a straight U-turn. Is it?
Some Catholics say the two meant different things. The pope was rejecting a freedom built on the idea that every religion is equally true.
The Council meant that no one may be forced to believe, by the state or by anyone else.
Others see a real break. In 2005 Pope Benedict XVI answered them without denying all change.
He accepted that some past decisions had been left behind, but said the deeper principles had not been abandoned. It's still debated.
So when you hear that the Church changed, ask two questions.
Was the old position something God revealed, ordinary teaching, an opinion, or a practical judgement? And does the new one keep the same principle?
Catholics believe the keeps the core from being reversed, not that nothing ever grows.
Think of the two photos: you at five, and you at thirty. Which of these would mean you'd become someone else?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 20
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2267 (revised 2018) · The current text: the death penalty is inadmissible.
- Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum (18 November 1965), 8 · Tradition from the apostles develops in the Church, through study, experience and preaching.
- Vincent of Lérins, Commonitory (c. 434), chapter 23 · Real progress in doctrine, not alteration: the body that grows but stays the same.
- International Theological Commission, The Hope of Salvation for Infants Who Die Without Being Baptised (2007) · Limbo was common doctrine, never a statement of faith; it remains a possible theological opinion; grounds for hope.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1261 · Children who die without baptism are entrusted to God's mercy, with hope.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Letter to the Bishops on the revision of 2267 (1 August 2018) · Explains the change as an authentic development, citing the earlier text and Vincent of Lérins.
- First Things, An Appeal to the Cardinals of the Catholic Church (15 August 2018) · Catholic scholars ask that the new paragraph be withdrawn.
- Pope Pius IX, Quanta Cura (8 December 1864), 3 · Condemns the opinion that liberty of conscience and worship is each person's right.
- Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 1–2 · Declares a right to religious freedom, while keeping the duty toward the true religion.
- Pope Benedict XVI, Address to the Roman Curia (22 December 2005) · Two ways of reading Vatican II; religious freedom as continuity of principle with some discontinuity.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio fidei (1998) · The three levels of Church teaching: what God revealed, what is held as final, and ordinary teaching.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Note on some questions regarding the participation of Catholics in political life (24 November 2002), 3–4 · Not the Church's task to set out specific political solutions; no single issue exhausts a Catholic's responsibility.
- Pope Francis, Fratelli tutti (3 October 2020), 263–270 · All Christians called to work for the abolition of the death penalty and for better prison conditions.
- CBCP Episcopal Commission on Prison Pastoral Care, Statement on the 15th Anniversary of Republic Act 9346 (24 June 2021) · The Philippine bishops' prison ministry opposes Congress's move to restore the death penalty and urges young people to elect defenders of life.
- Benedict XIV, Vix Pervenit (1 November 1745) · Any gain beyond the amount lent is usurious; gain may still come from other titles not intrinsic to the loan.
- Paul III, Sublimis Deus (2 June 1537) · The native peoples of the Americas may not be deprived of their liberty or enslaved.
- Gregory XVI, In Supremo Apostolatus (3 December 1839) · Condemns the slave trade.
- Wikipedia, Dum Diversas · Nicholas V's 1452 bull lets the king of Portugal reduce conquered Saracens and pagans to perpetual servitude.
- Georgetown Slavery Archive · The sale of 272 men, women and children by the Maryland Jesuits in 1838.
- John Paul II, Veritatis Splendor (6 August 1993), 80 · Acts always seriously wrong by reason of their object, slavery among the examples.