Calvary Chapel baptises the Jesus People
In 1965 Chuck Smith, a pastor who had left the Foursquare Church, takes over a church of 25 in Costa Mesa, California. By 1971 it is baptising hippie converts by the hundred in the Pacific.
In the late 1960s many young Californians had dropped out into the hippie world of drugs, communes and beaches. In December 1965 Chuck Smith, a pastor who had left the Pentecostal Foursquare Church to work independently, took over Calvary Chapel, a church of about 25 people in Costa Mesa.
In 1968 he took into his home Lonnie Frisbee, an 18-year-old evangelist from the hippie scene, and Frisbee's wife Connie.
Frisbee preached on the beaches and brought converts home, and the church filled with hippies. It met in a tent while a bigger building went up, and its young musicians helped begin Christian rock.
In June 1971 Time described Smith baptising several hundred converts in the Pacific at Corona del Mar. Calvary Chapel never joined a denomination, and by 2006 more than 1,000 churches had grown from it.
The situation
In the late 1960s many young Americans were turning their backs on their parents' world. In California thousands drifted into the hippie life of drugs, communes and beaches. The Jesus People came from among them. Time found that the path into the movement was ‘often littered with drugs’.
Evangelical revival had always crossed church lines, from the travelling English preacher George Whitefield in the 1740s to the evangelist D. L. Moody's independent church in Chicago. But churches outside any denomination stayed a small minority: Scott Thumma of the Hartford Institute estimates 5 to 7 per cent of American congregations in the 1970s.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
One sect was not enough for Whitefield
Invited to Scotland in 1741 by the Erskine brothers of the Secession Church, Whitefield would not preach for them alone.
“But, as he refused to limit his ministrations to one sect, the Seceders and he parted company, and without their countenance he made a tour through the principal towns of Scotland”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), Whitefield, George - 02
Moody: no sect, but a Second Coming
The 1911 Britannica's summary of Moody's preaching names two marks of the later movement: indifference to denominations, and the belief that Christ would return before the thousand-year reign in the Book of Revelation.
“In his theology he laid stress on the Gospel and on no sectarian opinions—he was, however, a pre-millenarianite”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), Moody, Dwight Lyman - 03
Where Calvary's end-times teaching came from
Calvary Chapel's belief in a rapture before the tribulation came down a line from the Brethren, through Moody and the Bible conferences, to Scofield.
“dispensationalist theology was primarily systematized and promoted by John Nelson Darby (1800–1882) and the Plymouth Brethren in the mid-19th century.”
Wikipedia, 'Dispensationalism' · Dispensationalism, introduction (tertiary)
What was at stake
Chuck Smith had spent years in a denomination and disliked what he saw. He wrote later that he had been ‘under pressure to build the church’ with growth programmes and contests, and had ‘been wanting to leave the denomination’ to become independent.
He wanted simple worship and the taught verse by verse. In a rented hall he put the chairs in a circle and led the people in choruses instead of hymns.
The question was who could reach the hippies, and on whose authority. An independent pastor could change the worship overnight, with no or synod to consult. That freedom was Calvary Chapel's strength, and later the source of its troubles.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Smith leaves his denomination
Smith's own account of how he became independent, before he came to Costa Mesa.
“I had been wanting to leave the denomination I was involved in and become independent. These men invited me to start a church in Corona, which I did.”
Calvary Chapel Distinctives: The Foundational Principles of the Calvary Chapel Movement · Calvary Chapel Distinctives (2000), p. 54 - 02
Catholics among the Jesus People
Time noticed where many of the young converts had come from.
“There are a disproportionate number of Roman Catholics among the Jesus People, attracted by the movement's direct approach to Christ.”
The Alternative Jesus: Psychedelic Christ · Time, 21 June 1971, The Alternative Jesus: Psychedelic Christ, p. 7 of 11
The event
Smith took over Calvary Chapel in December 1965, when it had about 25 members. In March 1968 he took in Lonnie Frisbee and his wife Connie.
Frisbee preached to hippies on the beaches and brought converts home at night until Smith's house was full. Communal houses took the overflow. The congregation met in a tent while a new building went up.
Converts formed bands, and a label, Maranatha! Music, was set up to publish their songs.
On 21 June 1971 Time described Smith baptising several hundred converts in the cold Pacific at Corona del Mar, while hundreds more watched from the cliffs.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
A full house
Frisbee's method was simple: meet the hippies where they were, and bring them home.
“Frisbee moved into Smith's home, and he would minister to other hippies and counter-culture youth on the beaches. At night, he would bring home new converts, and soon Smith's house was full.”
Wikipedia, 'Calvary Chapel' · Calvary Chapel, History (tertiary) - 02
At the water's edge
Time's reporter recorded what the baptism meant to one of those baptised.
“A freshly dunked teenager, water streaming from her tie-dyed shirt, threw her arms around a woman and cried, "Mother, I love you!"”
The Alternative Jesus: Psychedelic Christ · Time, 21 June 1971, The Alternative Jesus: Psychedelic Christ, p. 7 of 11 - 03
Where Christian rock began
The converts brought their music with them, and Calvary gave it a church.
“The converts included musicians who began writing music for praise and worship. This became the genesis for Jesus music and Christian rock concerts.”
Wikipedia, 'Calvary Chapel' · Calvary Chapel, History (tertiary)
The outcome
Calvary Chapel never joined a denomination. Smith taught that a pastor should lead like , answering to God, with a board of elders to pray with him and support him.
Churches that shared his teaching could join the Calvary Chapel movement, and by 2006 more than 1,000 had grown from it.
In 1982 one of its pastors, John Wimber, parted from Calvary over healing and the gifts of the Spirit and led the Vineyard, which by 2022 counted 2,400 churches in 95 countries. Smith died in 2013.
Lonnie Frisbee, the young preacher who had filled the church, left Calvary in the early 1970s and later joined the church at Yorba Linda that soon became part of Wimber’s Vineyard. He died in 1993.
For years Calvary’s own telling said little about him, and in 2005 a local paper asked why he was ‘missing from church history’.
The pattern spread far beyond Calvary. In Hartford's 2020 survey the median non-denominational church was founded in 1970, and about one American congregation in five belongs to no denomination.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
The Vineyard leaves Calvary, 1982
A major parting came over the gifts of the Spirit, the very question Calvary claimed to hold in balance.
“In a meeting with Calvary Chapel leaders, it was suggested that Wimber's church stop using the Calvary name and affiliate with Gulliksen's Vineyard movement.”
Wikipedia, 'Association of Vineyard Churches' · Association of Vineyard Churches, History (tertiary) - 02
Founded around 1970
Scott Thumma's survey dates the typical non-denominational church to the years of the Jesus movement.
“A significant portion of nondenominational churches are recently founded (with a median founding of 1970 versus 1958 for Evang.) especially during the 70’s and 80’s”
A Report on the 2020 Faith Communities Today Study of U.S. Nondenominational and Independent Churches · Thumma, 2020 FACT study of nondenominational churches, p. 2 - 03
Not every megachurch
The largest American churches are often assumed to be non-denominational. In Hartford's 2020 survey, 40 per cent were.
“Most impressions are that megachurches are nondenominational, but in fact a majority have a denominational affiliation.”
Megachurch 2020: The Changing Reality in America's Largest Churches · Megachurch 2020, p. 3 - 04
Lonnie Frisbee, missing from the story
Wikipedia lists Frisbee (1949-1993) as a Calvary pastor until 1971, and cites a 2005 OC Weekly article on how he left and why Calvary's history left him out.
“So why is Lonnie Frisbee missing from church history? … Lonnie left after about four years as Calvary's unofficial youth pastor and, after a brief time in the Shepherding movement, wound up at the soon-to-become Vineyard Church of Yorba Linda.”
Wikipedia, 'Calvary Chapel' · Calvary Chapel, notes (tertiary, citing Matt Coker, OC Weekly, 3 March 2005)
For the trail
Here the modern non-denominational church takes its shape: no denomination by choice, informal worship, verse-by-verse Bible teaching, adult of believers, and a pastor answerable to no bishop.
Its music and style spread far beyond it. Independent churches later multiplied in Asia too; Singapore and Malaysia are two examples, especially since the 1990s.
For Catholics the story is not only about others. Time reported ‘a disproportionate number of Roman Catholics among the Jesus People’, drawn by ‘the movement's direct approach to ’.
The evangelical and Catholic members of the 1977–84 dialogue on mission agreed that in Latin America many baptised Catholics had had only a minimal relationship with their Church.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Evangelicals on visible unity
The Lausanne Covenant, the evangelical world's own charter, names the cost of going it alone.
“We affirm that the Church’s visible unity in truth is God’s purpose. ... We confess that our testimony has sometimes been marred by a sinful individualism and needless duplication.”
The Lausanne Covenant (1974) · Lausanne Covenant (1974), §7, Cooperation in Evangelism - 02
Catholic and evangelical at once
The consultation between the Catholic Church and the World Evangelical Alliance put its hope in one sentence.
“Since Evangelicals believe their church to be catholic, and Catholics believe their church to be evangelical, it would seem that our future task is to recognize better the aspects that each of us emphasizes in the others’ view as well.”
Church, Evangelization, and the Bonds of Koinonia: A Report of the International Consultation between the Catholic Church and the World Evangelical Alliance · Church, Evangelization, and the Bonds of Koinonia, §72 - 03
The Catholic side of the problem
The first evangelical–Catholic dialogue said plainly why so many baptised Catholics were open to evangelical preaching.
“It is particularly acute in places like Latin America, where large numbers of baptized Roman Catholics have had a minimal relationship with the Roman Catholic Church since their baptism.”
The Evangelical–Roman Catholic Dialogue on Mission, 1977–1984: A Report · ERCDOM report, 4.3, Church Membership
What the Church says
The Catholic Church does not treat these converts as strangers to Christ. Those who grow up believing in Christ in such communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’, and the Church embraces them ‘as brothers, with respect and affection’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).
Baptism ‘by immersion, or by pouring, together with the Trinitarian formula is, of itself, valid’ (Ecumenical Directory 95). So where the Pacific baptisms were given in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, ==they were real baptisms, and the Church would never repeat them==.
The Church also says what is missing. These communities lack full unity with it, ‘especially because of the absence of the sacrament of Orders’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 22), the ordination of bishops and priests in a line from the apostles.
A pastor answerable to God alone is not a bishop in the succession ‘running from the beginning’ (Lumen Gentium 20).
On 28 July 2014, at a Pentecostal church in Caserta, Pope Francis said of Catholics who had persecuted Pentecostals: ‘I am the Pastor of Catholics: I ask your forgiveness for this!’
“On a cul-de-sac beach at Corona del Mar, Calif., the Rev. Chuck Smith recently held another of the mass baptisms that have made his Calvary Chapel at Santa Ana famous. Under a setting sun, several hundred converts waded into the cold Pacific, patiently waiting their turn for the rite. On the cliffs above, hundreds more watched.”
The report goes on: most of the baptised were ‘young, tanned and casual in cut-off blue jeans, pullovers and even an occasional bikini’. Afterwards the crowd climbed ‘a narrow stairway up the cliff, singing a moving Lord's Prayer in the twilight’.
Where people disagree
Calvary Chapel calls itself a balance between Bible teaching and openness to the . Smith wrote: ‘We don't take a typical Pentecostal view, nor do we take a typical Baptist view.’ He rejected congregational rule, the usual Baptist pattern, as unbiblical.
Critics inside evangelicalism say his model leaves pastors unaccountable. Christianity Today reported in 2006 that Calvary pastors and elders had ‘little or no requirement to disclose finances or decisions to church members’.
Smith also set a date. He taught that Christ could return for his church ‘any time before 1981’, and some followers left when 1981 came and went.
The Catholic reading is that leaving a denomination does not settle the question of authority; it moves it into every congregation.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
Answerable to God alone
Christianity Today summed up the church government Smith taught.
“Smith had resisted the oversight of his denomination, and he now teaches that the senior pastor is solely accountable to God.”
Unaccountable at Calvary Chapel · Christianity Today, May 2006, Unaccountable at Calvary Chapel - 02
Not Baptist either
Smith rejected the congregational rule that most Baptist and many non-denominational churches follow.
“So woe to the man who pastors a congregational church.”
Calvary Chapel Distinctives: The Foundational Principles of the Calvary Chapel Movement · Calvary Chapel Distinctives (2000), Church Government, p. 19 - 03
The generation of 1948
In his 1978 book End Times, Smith set a limit for the Lord's return. Some followers left when it passed.
“I believe that the generation of 1948 is the last generation.”
Wikipedia, 'Calvary Chapel' · Calvary Chapel, Eschatology (tertiary, quoting Smith, End Times, 1978) - 04
No such thing as non-denominational?
The Baptist theologian Steven Harmon, as Wikipedia summarises him, argues that every church's choices place it in some tradition.
“as soon as a supposedly non-denominational church has made decisions about what happens in worship, whom and how they will baptize, how and with what understanding they will celebrate holy communion, what they will teach, who their ministers will be and how they will be ordered, or how they relate to those churches, these decisions have placed the church within the stream of a specific type of denominational tradition”
Wikipedia, 'Nondenominational Christianity' · Non-denominational Christianity, Criticism (tertiary, citing Harmon, Ecumenism Means You, Too, 2010, pp. 61–62)
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Chuck Smith · 2000 · The Word for Today, Costa Mesa (digital edition on archive.org)
- Time magazine staff · 1971-06-21 · Time (content.time.com archive)
- Scott Thumma · 2020 · Hartford Institute for Religion Research
- Evangelical–Roman Catholic Dialogue on Mission (ERCDOM); Catholic participants named by the Secretariat for Promoting Christian Unity · 1984 · christianunity.va (Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity), reprinting the Paternoster / Eerdmans edition
- International Consultation between the Catholic Church and the World Evangelical Alliance · 2002 · christianunity.va (Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity)