From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/eastern-catholic-churches
← OrthodoxWhy do Eastern Catholic ('Uniate') Churches exist?
Read it as an illustrated story · 8 minThey're 23 Churches with Eastern worship, united with the ; many call them 'Uniates'. Most began when part of an Eastern Church joined Rome, splitting that Church in two. In 1993 official Catholic-Orthodox talks rejected that method, but agreed these Churches have the right to exist.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Vatican II
- Orientalium Ecclesiarum, 3, 5, 6, 24, 30
Walk into some Catholic churches and you'd swear you were in an Orthodox one. Icons everywhere, incense, chanting, a priest with a beard. But they pray for the pope.
These are the . Many Orthodox know them as the Uniates, after the unions with Rome that created most of them. There are 23 of these Churches, with about 18 million members, from Ukraine to the Middle East to India.1,2 Each keeps its own Eastern worship, laws and customs.3
The name hurts on both sides. For many Orthodox, it recalls how those unions split their own communities, and they see these Churches as a block to reunion.1 Eastern Catholics hear Uniate as an insult, and Catholic writers no longer use it.1,2
How most of them began
From the 1500s on, part of an Eastern Church, often a group of its , joined Rome while keeping its own worship. The rest of that Church didn't. One Church became two.2,4
Eastern Catholics see it as coming home to the unity East and West once shared.5 A few, like the Maronites of Lebanon, say they never broke with Rome at all.1,2
Think of it like this
Picture a big family whose two halves stopped speaking years ago. The western half has its holiday dinners in one house, the eastern half in another.
Then one branch of the eastern half starts coming to the western side's dinners again. It still cooks its own recipes, speaks its own language and keeps its own customs. It just sits at the other table now.
To that branch, it feels like coming home. They're finally back with family they had lost, at a table their great-grandparents once shared.
To the relatives they left behind, it feels like the family split a second time. Both feelings are real. That's why the Eastern Catholic Churches look like hope to one side and a wound to the other.
The best-known case is the Union of Brest. In 1596, at the town of Brest, most of the Orthodox bishops of the Church of Kyiv joined Rome and kept their own worship.6 Their dioceses covered lands that are now in Ukraine and Belarus.7
Orthodox historians point to the pressure from the Catholic king of Poland, and the privileges the bishops were promised. Many ordinary Orthodox rejected it.6 Greek Catholics, as Eastern Catholics who worship the Byzantine way are called there, point out that the bishops asked for the union themselves.5
It turned violent. A Greek Catholic archbishop, Josaphat Kuntsevych, took over Orthodox churches and pushed the union by force. In 1623 an angry Orthodox crowd killed him.8 Catholics honour him as a . Many Orthodox remember the force he used.
Pressure from the other side too
Force didn't only run one way.
In 1946 the Soviets staged a church meeting that shut down the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church and handed it to the Russian Orthodox Church.9
Its bishops were in prison. Priests were deported or sent to labour camps. The Church survived in secret until 1989.9
Was the Russian Orthodox Church a willing partner, or one more victim? The record shows it took part. The new Russian Orthodox bishop for western Ukraine was instructed to assist the group pushing the merger. The Moscow Patriarchate two of that group's priests as Orthodox bishops, so the meeting would have bishops at all.9
In 1972 a of the Russian Church confirmed the merger.9 But the plan, the arrests and the threats came from the Soviet state.9 How freely the Russian Church's leaders acted, under a state that was jailing bishops, is harder to say.
After that, the two Churches fought bitterly over churches the communists had taken from the Greek Catholics and given to the Orthodox. Some Greek Catholics also still believed they should win Orthodox believers over, which Rome now forbids.10
The numbers show how much changed hands. In the 1980s the Russian Orthodox Church claimed more than 1,200 parishes in the Lviv region. By 2001, an American journal that follows religion in the news reported, it had about 15, and more than 400 Orthodox priests had moved over to the Greek Catholics.11
Greek Catholics saw this as getting back what had been taken from them. But they took it back sometimes violently, and Orthodox believers who lost their churches ended up worshipping in cottages and even old buses.11
Latin ways pushed on the East
Eastern Catholics also paid a price inside the Catholic Church. Many were pushed towards Western, Latin ways, sometimes brutally.
In India in 1599, a Portuguese-led church meeting forced Latin practices on the St Thomas Christians, an ancient community in the south. Their Syriac books judged heretical were burned. In 1653 many revolted, and the community split.12
The changed course. It taught that every Church in the Catholic family, Eastern or Western, is of equal dignity. It told Eastern Catholics to keep their own ways, and return to their ancestral traditions.3
What changed in 1993
In 1993, at Balamand in Lebanon, the official Catholic-Orthodox commission agreed that bringing part of a Church over to Rome on its own can no longer be accepted.4
The two Churches called each other Sister Churches, not hunting grounds for converts. The Catholic Church, the commission said, no longer aims to win Orthodox believers over to its side.4
Both sides also agreed that Eastern Catholic Churches have the right to exist.4 So the old method is rejected, but the people it produced are protected.
Not everyone accepted it. Several Orthodox Churches weren't there. The Church of Greece, home to only a tiny Eastern Catholic community, rejected the text: it didn't condemn these Churches' existence, and it seemed to recognise Catholic too soon.10
Romania's Greek Catholic bishops rejected it from the other side, for turning against the unions that made them. By 1995 the Moscow Patriarchate had given no formal reply, but had agreed with Vatican officials that Balamand should be the basis for better relations.10
And today?
So is the Catholic Church using these Churches against the Russian Church now? Moscow has said, in effect, yes. In 2014, as fighting began in eastern Ukraine, Metropolitan Hilarion, then the Russian Church's head of foreign relations, said Ukraine's Greek Catholics had played a very destructive role.13
He called the union with Rome a special project of the Catholic Church aimed at undermining canonical Orthodoxy.13
In 2016 Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill of Moscow met in Havana, Cuba, the first meeting ever between a pope and a Russian patriarch.14 Their joint declaration said the old method of union is not the way to re-establish unity, but that these Churches have the right to exist.14
It also asked both Churches in Ukraine to refrain from taking part in the confrontation.14
Ukraine's Greek Catholics didn't hear that as Rome standing behind them. Their leader, Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk, said in an interview that many of his people felt deeply disappointed and betrayed by Rome.15
Pope Francis said that feeling was understandable, and called the declaration debatable on the issue of Ukraine. But he stood by it, because it called for the fighting to stop.15
So Moscow sees the Greek Catholics as Rome's project against Orthodoxy, while many Greek Catholics felt Rome had let them down. What Rome signed is clear, though: no winning Orthodox believers over, and no Church taking sides in the fighting.14
A bridge, not a recruiting office
So why not simply close these Churches down? Because they're millions of real believers who kept faith with Rome, many through prison and martyrdom. The Catholic Church won't abandon them.
Instead the Council gave them a special job: promoting the unity of all Christians, especially Eastern Christians.3 And it said its rules for them hold only until such time as the Catholic Church and the separated Eastern Churches come together into complete unity.3
So in the Catholic view today, the method that produced most of these Churches was the wrong way to seek unity. The Churches themselves are meant to help it happen the right way.
Sources15
- 1Ronald Roberson, The Eastern Christian Churches: The Catholic Eastern Churches (CNEWA)How most Orthodox see these Churches; "Uniate" now considered derogatory; the Maronite and Bulgarian cases.
- 2Wikipedia, Eastern Catholic Churches23 Churches and about 18 million members (Annuario Pontificio figures); which Churches claim unbroken communion.
- 3Second Vatican Council, Orientalium Ecclesiarum (1964), 3, 5, 6, 24, 30Eastern Catholic Churches: equal dignity, own traditions, duty to work for unity, rules until full unity.
- 4Catholic-Orthodox Joint Commission, Balamand Document (1993), 3, 8, 11, 12, 14, 22Rejects 'uniatism' as a method, affirms Eastern Catholics' right to exist, names pressure on both sides.
- 5John Paul II, Apostolic Letter for the fourth centenary of the Union of Brest (12 November 1995)The Greek Catholic view: the bishops restored communion, citing Florence, and kept their Eastern identity.
- 6Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. III: The Union of Brest-LitovskAn Orthodox account of the 1596 union and the pressure behind it.
- 7Internet Encyclopedia of Ukraine, Kyiv metropolyBefore 1596 the Kyiv metropoly in Poland-Lithuania held eight Ukrainian and two Belarusian eparchies; its bishops, the metropolitan among them, accepted the Union of Berestia (Brest).
- 8Internet Encyclopedia of Ukraine, Kuntsevych, YosafatHis forced implementation of the union and his killing in 1623.
- 9Internet Encyclopedia of Ukraine, Lviv Sobor of 1946The Soviet-staged abolition of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church; legalised again in 1989.
- 10Ronald Roberson, Balamand and Beyond (ONE Magazine, CNEWA, July-August 1995)The post-1989 clashes over churches, who was absent at Balamand, and how Orthodox and Greek Catholics received it.
- 11Andrew Walsh, The Pope Among the Orthodox, Religion in the News (Trinity College), Summer 2001Press reports on Ukraine in 2001: the Lviv parishes, Orthodox communities displaced, Greek Catholics restoring the pre-Soviet situation.
- 12Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage, Diamper, Synod of (1599)Latinisation of the St Thomas Christians, burned books, the 1653 revolt and split.
- 13Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, Greetings to the 4th European Orthodox-Catholic Forum (Minsk, June 2014)The Moscow Patriarchate's charge that Ukraine's Greek Catholics worsened the conflict and that the union undermines Orthodoxy.
- 14Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill, Joint Declaration (Havana, 12 February 2016), 1, 24–26The first meeting in history; no proselytism; uniatism is not the way, but these Churches have the right to exist; the Churches in Ukraine asked not to take part in the confrontation.
- 15Pope Francis, press conference on the flight from Mexico (17 February 2016)Shevchuk's report that many faithful felt betrayed by Rome; the Pope calls the declaration debatable on Ukraine.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.