← Protestant or evangelical
History between us

Was the Church Roman Catholic from the beginning?

Read it as an illustrated story · 7 min

Not by that name. “Roman Catholic” is an English label from the late 1500s. But Christians were calling the Church “catholic” around AD 110. Catholics believe the Church Jesus founded is the same body that's joined to the of Rome today.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

A lot of people picture it like this. Jesus and the had a simple little church. Then, centuries later, in Rome, it turned into something else: , cathedrals, Latin, the works.

So the real question is this. Is today's Catholic Church the same Church as the first one, or something new wearing its clothes?

Where the name came from

Start with the name, because it has a surprising story. “Roman Catholic” comes from English writers in the 1580s.1

They didn't want to call their opponents just “Catholic”. They believed their own church was the truly catholic one.1 Later it became the polite name in English law, while Catholics mostly kept calling themselves plain Catholic.1

So no Christian in the first century ever said “Roman Catholic”. Fair enough. But that's not the end of the story.

Catholic from the start

The word catholic is much, much older. It means universal, or whole.

Around AD 110, a bishop called was being taken under guard to Rome, to be killed for his faith. On the way he wrote letters to the churches. In one he wrote: wherever Jesus is, there is the Catholic Church.2

That's about 80 years after Jesus. And his letters already show a lot. Each church had a bishop, elders and . , the shared bread and wine, only counted as proper if the bishop led it, or someone he'd chosen.2

Around AD 155, a letter telling how another bishop died for his faith was sent to all the congregations of the Holy and Catholic Church in every place.3 Catholic was already the Church's normal name for itself.

Around AD 350, a bishop in Jerusalem gave new Christians some travel advice. Other groups called their meeting places churches too. So when you arrive in a new city, he said, ask where is the Catholic Church.4

The even says the Church was, in this fundamental sense, catholic on the day of , the day the came on the apostles.9

For Catholics, the word means two things. Everything Christ gave his Church is there in full: the whole faith, all the , and leaders in an unbroken line from the apostles. And the Church is sent to the whole human race.9

What wasn't there yet

To be honest, a lot looked different. Christians met in homes. The oldest house church found so far, in Syria, was an ordinary house turned into a church before AD 256.5

Rome may not even have had one bishop at first. One respected Catholic historian concluded that a group of elders seems to have led it. But he held that the apostles did pass their work on to successors.6

So who was the first pope? Catholics count first, and that question has its own answer.

Popes as we know them, big cathedrals and the Latin all came later. Catholics don't deny that.

Their claim is that it's the same Church growing, not a different one taking its place.

Think of it like this

Think of a family bakery. A grandmother started it in the 1960s with one oven and a counter by the window. Her bread became famous in the neighbourhood.

Sixty years on, a lot has changed. The sign has been repainted three times. The bakery moved to a bigger shop on the main road, and the name on the sign changed when it did. Her grandson runs it now, with new ovens and a card machine by the till.

So is it still the same bakery? The regulars don't decide by reading the sign. They ask different questions. Same family? Same recipe, handed down? Does the bread still taste the way it did when they were kids?

That's the Catholic claim about the Church. The name is only the signboard. The real question is whether the family, the recipe and the taste have been handed on unbroken, from the first baker to today.

In the Church, that means bishops in the apostles' line, the apostles' teaching, and the same , the Communion meal.

Why Rome?

Because the early Christians already treated the church in Rome as the reference point for the rest. Ignatius, that bishop on his way to die, called it the church that presides in charity, the old word for love.9

That's why Catholics see the bishop of Rome, the pope, as the visible centre of unity. The Catechism says the one Church of Christ is found in the Catholic Church, led by Peter's successor, the pope, together with the bishops united to him.9

Other Christians read the same history differently, and they have their reasons. Protestant churches generally see the apostles' legacy in staying faithful to their teaching in the , not in a line of bishops.6

The churches of the East, such as the Greek and Russian, have bishops in the apostles' line too. They agree the early Church gave Rome the first place of honour.12 Where the two differ is whether that means authority over every other bishop.

So why does the line run through Rome, not Constantinople? Catholics point to Peter, who led the apostles and died in Rome.11

Constantinople's high rank came later, in 381, because Constantinople is New Rome: it had become the empire's capital.12

The Catholic answer is that the teaching and the line belong together. The apostles' teaching was handed on by the people the apostles appointed, and the Catholic Church believes that chain has never broken.9

And today's Protestant traditions? As separate churches, they date from the Reformation of the 1500s and the revivals that followed it. Pentecostal churches, for example, grew out of revivals in the US in the early 1900s.10

Not only Roman

The Catholic Church isn't only the Roman Church. It also includes 23 , fully united with the pope, each with its own way of worship and its own traditions.7

The said these Churches are of equal dignity, so that none of them is superior to the others as regards rite.8 A Maronite Catholic in Lebanon or a Syro-Malabar Catholic in India is fully Catholic, but doesn't worship the Roman way.7

The label on the door is the least of it. What matters is whether what happens inside has been handed on, unbroken, from the apostles.

Sources12
  1. 1Catholic Encyclopedia, “Roman Catholic” (1912)The phrase was coined by English Protestant writers in the 1580s and became official in the 1600s.
  2. 2Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans, 8 (c. AD 107–110)Bishop, presbyters, deacons and the earliest use of “the Catholic Church”.
  3. 3The Martyrdom of Polycarp, greeting (c. AD 155)Addressed to “all the congregations of the Holy and Catholic Church in every place”.
  4. 4Cyril of Jerusalem, Catechetical Lecture 18, 23–26 (c. AD 350)Why the Church is called Catholic, and the advice to ask for the Catholic Church when travelling.
  5. 5Wikipedia, “Dura-Europos church”The earliest identified Christian house church: the house dated by an inscription to 232–233, converted between 233 and 256.
  6. 6David A. Fiensy, review of Francis A. Sullivan SJ, From Apostles to Bishops (2001), Catholic Books Review (2002)Sullivan's findings on early church leadership in Rome, and the Protestant view of apostolicity.
  7. 7Wikipedia, “Eastern Catholic Churches”The 23 Eastern Churches in full communion with the pope.
  8. 8Second Vatican Council, Orientalium Ecclesiarum (21 November 1964), 3The Eastern and Latin Churches are of equal dignity.
  9. 9Catechism of the Catholic Church, 816, 830–834What “catholic” means, the Church of Rome “presiding in charity”, and “subsists in”.
  10. 10J. Gordon Melton, "Pentecostalism", Encyclopaedia Britannica (updated 15 December 2024; archived copy)Holiness roots, Topeka 1901, the Azusa Street revival of 1906 and the first Pentecostal churches.
  11. 11Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), "St. Peter, Prince of the Apostles"Peter laboured in Rome at the end of his life and died there as a martyr.
  12. 12Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), "First Council of Constantinople"Canon 3 (381): because Constantinople is New Rome, its bishop has pre-eminence of honour after the bishop of Old Rome.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.