From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/pius-xii
← No religion, or not sureDid Pope Pius XII stay silent during the Holocaust?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minIn public, mostly yes. Pius XII never named the Jews or openly condemned their murder, and nobody disputes that. Historians still argue about why, and about how much he did quietly, while Catholic houses in Rome hid thousands of Jews.
During the Second World War, Nazi Germany and its allies murdered millions of Jews.5 The pope could speak to Catholics in every country at war. So why didn't he say clearly that the Jews were being killed, and that it was evil?
The honest answer: he didn't. Pius XII never publicly named the Jews as victims, or condemned the Nazis for killing them.5
What he did say stayed general. In 1939 he taught that the human race is one family. Quoting the , Christianity's holy book, he said that in there's neither Gentile nor Jew: no wall between Jews and everyone else.1
At Christmas 1942 he mourned hundreds of thousands of innocent people sent to their deaths, sometimes only because of their nationality or race.2
But he named neither the killers nor the Jews.
Trapped in Rome
Picture where he was. He became pope six months before the war began.4 Vatican City is a tiny country inside Rome, surrounded by Mussolini's Italy, and from late 1943 by German troops.6
Then the killing reached his own city. In October 1943, German troops seized more than 1,000 of Rome's Jews. Of 1,007 sent to Auschwitz, the Nazi death camp, only 15 came back.6
Pius never spoke publicly about it.6
Why he said he stayed quiet
Pius said he'd like to speak words of fire. But he feared making the plight of the victims even worse.5
He had a reason to fear it. In 1942 the Catholic of the Netherlands publicly condemned the deportations of Jews. The Nazis answered by sending Catholics of Jewish descent to their deaths, among them Edith Stein, a nun born into a Jewish family.5
Historians still argue over how much this case shaped Pius's choices. Some think it weighed on him heavily. Others say there's little firm evidence that it did.5
Think of it like this
Think of a head teacher who learns that a gang outside the school gates is beating up students on their way home. The last teacher who spoke out about it in public was attacked too.
He has two choices. He could call a press conference, name the gang, and tell the whole city what's happening. Or he could stay quiet in public, hide students in the staff room after school, and make phone calls behind the scenes.
Quiet help might save the students hidden inside. A loud protest might shame the gang into backing off. Or it might make the gang angrier, and send it after the hidden ones.
Years later, people still argue about which he should have done, and whether he could have done both. That's the argument about Pius XII. Nobody disputes that he stayed quiet in public. The question is what it cost, and what it saved.
The case against him
He knew early. In 1942 one of his closest aides wrote that the massacres of the Jews reach frightening proportions and forms.5 That December the Vatican told an American diplomat it was unable to denounce publicly particular atrocities.5
David Kertzer, an American historian, went through the files opened in 2020. He argues Pius didn't want to offend Hitler and Mussolini. He feared Communism, expected their side to win, and wanted to protect the Catholic Church.8
Kertzer also found that a German prince, a committed Nazi, was a secret go-between for Pius and Hitler. During the October 1943 round-up, he says, the pope's aides pushed only for Catholics of Jewish descent, and about 250 were freed.8
His verdict: Pius was no monster, but no hero either.8
The case for him
Defenders point to what happened quietly. In 2023 researchers found a list of more than 4,300 people hidden by Catholic religious communities in Rome. At least 3,200 of them were Jews.7
Did Pius order that hiding? That's disputed. One priest who hid Jews, later a cardinal, said Pius told them to do whatever they could. Another historian says there's no written evidence of any such order.6
And one defender says Kertzer got facts wrong, and left out files on 2,700 requests for help from Jews.9
Today the argument is less about whether he spoke out, and more about what his silence cost and what his quiet help saved.
What the Catholic Church says
The Catholic Church condemns hatred of Jews in every form. In 1998 the Vatican said so again, in a document called We Remember, about the Shoah, the Hebrew word for the Holocaust.3
It says the Nazis were a new kind of pagan regime, whose hatred of Jews had its roots outside Christianity.3 But it also admits that centuries of Christian hostility to the Jewish faith had fed discrimination, and that many Christians failed:
Nevertheless, as Pope John Paul II has recognized, alongside such courageous men and women, the spiritual resistance and concrete action of other Christians was not that which might have been expected from Christ's followers.
It ends with an act of repentance.3 But on Pius himself, it defends him, pointing to the thanks Jewish leaders gave him after the war.3
That defence was disputed. The New York Times said the document went further than the Church ever had, but called its account of Pius incomplete, because it didn't face his public silence.10
Jewish leaders were divided too. One leading rabbi regretted that it never admitted how the Church's teaching against Jews had prepared the ground for deadly hatred. Another defended the Vatican against the newspaper.10
Then Pope Francis chose to open the files rather than close the question. On 2 March 2020, the archives of Pius XII's whole time as pope opened to researchers. The Church is not afraid of history, Francis said.4
Pius XII's cause for sainthood, the Church's formal inquiry into whether he can be declared a saint, is still being studied.8 So the Catholic Church hasn't given a final verdict either.
His public silence is a fact. Whether it was wisdom or failure is still an open question.
Sources10
- 1Pius XII, Summi Pontificatus (20 October 1939)His first encyclical: the unity of the human race, "neither Gentile nor Jew", grief for Poland.
- 2Pius XII, Christmas radio message (24 December 1942), Papal Encyclicals OnlineThe passage on those killed "only because of their nationality or race".
- 3Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews, We Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah (16 March 1998)The Church's reflection on the Holocaust, its admission of Christian failure, and its defence of Pius XII.
- 4Pope Francis, Address to the officials of the Vatican Secret Archive (4 March 2019)Announces the opening of Pius XII's archives on 2 March 2020.
- 5Wikipedia, Pope Pius XII and the HolocaustThe debate in full: his statements, Montini's 1942 letter, Maglione's reply to the US envoy, the Dutch bishops, Yad Vashem's 2012 caption.
- 6Wikipedia, Pope Pius XII and the Roman razziaThe round-up of 16 October 1943, Chadwick's figures, the refuge in Church houses, and the dispute (Palazzini, Zuccotti) over whether Pius ordered it.
- 7National Catholic Register (CNA), Documents Identify Thousands of Jews Hidden by Catholic Religious (7 September 2023)The Biblicum list: 4,300 people hidden in 155 religious houses, 3,200 of them Jews.
- 8The Boston Globe, Deep in Vatican archives, a Brown University professor discovers 'flabbergasting' secrets (27 May 2022)David Kertzer's findings in The Pope at War (2022), as reported, and a defender's reply.
- 9Ronald J. Rychlak, The Spurious Effort to Make Pope Pius XII a Villain, Public Discourse (2 October 2022)A defender's critique of Kertzer's book and of what it leaves out.
- 10Wikipedia, We Remember: A Reflection on the ShoahHow the press and Jewish leaders (Rudin, Klenicki, Dalin) received the 1998 document.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.