From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/oriental-orthodox
← OrthodoxDo Catholics think Copts, Armenians, Syriacs and Ethiopians are 'Monophysites'?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minNo. Monophysite is an old label these Churches never accepted. Since 1971 the Catholic Church has signed joint statements with four of them, saying both share the same faith in , fully God and fully human, in different words.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Vatican II
- Unitatis Redintegratio, 17
Here's a story most Christians have never heard. There's a family of six ancient Churches called the : the Coptic, Ethiopian, Eritrean, Syriac, Armenian and Indian . All six are in with one another: they belong together as one family of Churches.1
They aren't the Greek, Russian, Serbian and other Churches most people mean by Orthodox, even though Oriental and Eastern sound alike. So there are two Orthodox families: the Eastern Orthodox, and these six Oriental Orthodox Churches.
The Oriental Orthodox parted from the Churches that became Catholic and Eastern Orthodox after a meeting of at in 451. That meeting said Christ is one person in two natures, divine and human, and they couldn't accept that wording. Rome and Constantinople were on the same side of that split.1
For centuries others called them Monophysites, Greek for one nature. The label suggests they deny Jesus was truly human. They don't, and they never did.1
The label fits a man called Eutyches, who taught that Christ's humanity was absorbed into his divine nature. The Oriental Orthodox reject Eutyches too.1
Same faith, different words
Their own word is miaphysite. They follow St Cyril of Alexandria, a great bishop of Egypt, who spoke of Christ's one incarnate nature: one Christ, fully God and fully human, without mixing the two.1,2
So where did it go wrong? With one word. At Chalcedon, nature meant what makes something what it is. Some scholars think Cyril used nature to mean something close to person.2
Heard Cyril's way, two natures sounds like two Christs, which no one meant. Heard Chalcedon's way, one nature sounds like Jesus wasn't really human, which Cyril's followers never meant either.
Both sides were guarding the same thing from opposite directions.
Think of it like this
Think of two branches of a family who argue for years over the recipe card for their grandmother's famous stew.
One side writes it as one dish made from two ingredients. The other side insists it's two ingredients in one dish. Each thinks the other has got Grandma's recipe badly wrong. Tempers rise, and they stop visiting each other over it.
Years later, a wedding finally gets them all into the same kitchen. They cook side by side, then sit down and taste each other's pot. It's the same stew. Same ingredients, same flavour, same grandmother.
The fight was over the card, not the cooking. That's roughly what Catholic and Oriental Orthodox leaders found when they finally sat down together.
Today, many theologians and church leaders on both sides of Chalcedon recognise that the difference over Christ was mainly in the words.1
The Eastern Orthodox talks
The Eastern Orthodox, who accept Chalcedon as Catholics do, have held their own talks with the Oriental Orthodox, and reached much the same answer.
At official talks in 1989 and 1990, they agreed that both families have always loyally maintained the same authentic Orthodox Christological faith, the same faith in Christ, even though they used the words differently.3
Each side even accepted the other's wording. The Oriental Orthodox may keep saying one nature of the incarnate Logos (the Logos is the Word, the ), and the Eastern Orthodox say they use it too. The Oriental Orthodox accept that the Eastern Orthodox are justified in saying two natures, since the two are told apart in thought alone.3
And they asked both families to lift every old condemnation of the other's councils and saints, on the basis that the Councils and Fathers previously anathematized or condemned are not heretical.3
So why aren't they one Church already? The commission could only recommend. The old condemnations should be lifted by the Churches, and each Church has to decide for itself.3
Some Churches in both families have accepted the agreement. Others still have questions to talk through.4
So as a rule, the two Orthodox families don't yet share Communion.4,5
Where they already share
But in the Middle East they've come very close. In 1991 the heads of two Churches, the Syriac Orthodox and the Greek Orthodox Patriarchs of Antioch, made an agreement.6
Antioch is an ancient city of the early Church, and both Churches trace themselves back to it.
Where a town has only one priest from either Church, he will celebrate services for the faithful of both Churches, including the Divine Liturgy.6 The Divine Liturgy is their Communion service.
Members of each Church can also be godparents and wedding witnesses in the other. But neither Church takes members from the other.6
That's what sharing one faith in Christ can look like, even before full unity.
What the Catholic Church has signed
The Catholic Church holds that the Oriental Orthodox share its faith in Christ, even where the words differ. In its joint statements it speaks of them as sister Churches, not heretics.7
The first step came in 1971. Paul VI and the Syriac Orthodox Patriarch said there was no difference in the faith they confessed about Christ.7
In 1973 Paul VI and the head of the Coptic Church, Egypt's ancient Church, confessed together that Christ is perfect God with respect to His divinity, perfect man with respect to His humanity.8
In 1984 and the next Syriac Patriarch went further. The old splits, they said, in no way affect or touch the substance of their faith. They came only because of differences in terminology and culture.7
Similar agreements followed with the Orthodox Church of India and the Armenian Church.9,10 The Indian text says the differences in wording need not and should not divide us.9
Why accept different words for the same faith? Because the taught that East and West often describe the mystery of God in ways that are mutually complementary rather than conflicting: they fill each other out.11
Not only a quarrel over words
To be honest, not everyone thinks the gap was only words. The 1973 Catholic-Coptic statement itself says the differences since 451 cannot be ignored.8
It adds that they were nourished and widened by non-theological factors: things that had nothing to do with belief.8 The fight was also a rivalry between two great cities, Alexandria and Antioch.2
And there was harm on more than one side. After 451, emperors in Constantinople persecuted Egyptians who rejected the . It only made them hold on harder.12
Catholics did harm too. In Ethiopia in the 1620s, a Catholic emperor and a Portuguese Jesuit bishop condemned local customs, like keeping Saturday holy. Rebellion followed. Catholicism was forced on people with executions, until the emperor gave up in 1632.13
In 1996 the pope and the Armenian leader promised together to remove the bitterness, mutual recriminations and even hatred of the past.10
Saints in common
But this isn't full unity yet. The 1984 statement with the Syriac Orthodox says their priests can't yet celebrate Communion together, because questions about the Church itself remain.7
It does let their people receive Communion from each other's priests when they can't reach their own.7 Since 2004 an official commission of the Catholic Church and the Oriental Orthodox Churches has been working on those open questions.12
Then, in 2023, something moving happened. Pope Francis added 21 Coptic Orthodox to the Catholic Church's official list of saints and martyrs. They had been beheaded in Libya in 2015 by the so-called Islamic State. He did it as a sign of the spiritual communion that unites our two Churches.14
You don't put heretics in your calendar of saints. You put family there.
Sources14
- 1Ronald Roberson, The Eastern Christian Churches: Oriental Orthodox Churches (CNEWA)The six Churches, their rejection of Eutyches, and why 'monophysite' is erroneous.
- 2Wikipedia, MiaphysitismCyril's formula, McGuckin on what Cyril meant by "nature", and the Alexandria-Antioch rivalry.
- 3Joint Commission of the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Oriental Orthodox Churches, Second Agreed Statement (Chambésy, 1990)Both families have kept the same faith in Christ in different words; each accepts the other's formula; the anathemas should be lifted.
- 4Carrie Frederick Frost, Vigen Guroian and others, In the Hope of Restoration of Communion between the Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox Churches (Ecumenical Patriarchate's Holy and Great Council site, 2016)Three Orthodox and three Oriental Orthodox Churches have accepted the agreed statements; communion not yet restored.
- 5Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia, MarriageCopts and Armenians among the non-Orthodox an Orthodox may marry; non-Orthodox spouses do not receive Communion.
- 6Orthodox Church of Antioch and Syriac Orthodox Church, Synodal and Patriarchal Letter (Damascus, 12 November 1991)One priest may serve the faithful of both Churches, including the Divine Liturgy; godparents and witnesses from either; no taking members.
- 7John Paul II and Patriarch Ignatius Zakka I Iwas, Common Declaration (23 June 1984)Recalls the 1971 Catholic-Syriac confession of one faith; the old divisions don't touch the substance of the faith; no shared Eucharist yet.
- 8Pope Paul VI and Pope Shenouda III, Common Declaration (10 May 1973)Catholic and Coptic confession of one faith in Christ, perfect God and perfect man.
- 9Catholic Church and Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church, Christological agreement (3 June 1990), via CNEWADifferences in terminology need not divide.
- 10John Paul II and Catholicos Karekin I, Common Declaration (13 December 1996)Catholic and Armenian agreement on Christ; sorrow for past bitterness.
- 11Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 17Eastern and Western expressions of doctrine often complementary rather than conflicting.
- 12Ronald Roberson, The Eastern Christian Churches: The Coptic Orthodox Church (CNEWA)Byzantine persecution after 451; the international dialogue since 2004.
- 13Wikipedia, Susenyos IThe forced Catholicisation of Ethiopia in the 1620s and its end in 1632.
- 14Vatican News, Pope Francis adds 21 Coptic Orthodox martyrs to Catholic list of saints (11 May 2023)The Libya martyrs entered in the Roman Martyrology.
- And the Eastern Orthodox? Does Rome see them as true Churches, or as schismatics?
- I'm Orthodox. Can I receive Communion at a Catholic Mass?
- Why are there Eastern Catholic Churches, with Eastern worship but united with the pope?
- Did lifting the old condemnations in 1965 end the split between Rome and Constantinople?
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.