Full text
No religion, or not sure · About 9 min ·  · The Church's record

What about the abuse scandal? How can you stay in an institution that covered up child abuse?

The short answer

It happened, and it was that bad. Thousands of priests abused children, and many bishops hid it for decades. Staying doesn't mean denying any of that. Those who stay do it because they believe Jesus is in the Church these men betrayed, and they want to help make it safe.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The question

How can anyone stay in a church that hid men who hurt children? And it's worse when that church claims to speak for God.

That's the right question, and it deserves a straight answer, not a defence.

So here are the facts first, as bad as they are. Then, at the end, why so many Catholics still stay.

Part 2 · How big it was

A study was paid for by the Catholic of the United States, the Church's leaders there.

It found accusations against 4,392 priests who served between 1950 and 2002.

That's about 4% of all priests in those years, with 10,667 reports of abuse.

It wasn't just the United States. In Australia, 7% of priests from 1950 to 2010 were accused.

In France, an independent inquiry estimated that about 216,000 children were abused from 1950 to 2020, by priests, , monks and nuns.

It counted religious brothers too: men in religious orders who aren't priests.

Part 3 · How it was hidden

Most bishops focused on the priest, not the child. There's little evidence US bishops met victims before 2002.

And the police were told about only 14% of the accused.

Benedict XVI, then the leader of the whole Catholic Church, wrote a letter to the Catholics of Ireland about the abuse there in 2010.

He named one of the causes himself: a misplaced concern for the reputation of the Church.

The rules made hiding easy. They came from the Vatican, the Church's head office in Rome, and were written in 1922 and reissued in 1962.

They were made for a different crime: a priest using confession, where Catholics tell a priest their , to ask for sex.

Child abuse was covered only in a short extra section, so it came under the same secret process.

Everyone in these church trials was bound to strict secrecy.

Officials who broke it were automatically cut off from , which Catholics believe is Jesus himself, and from the Church's other sacred rites.

Even the person who reported the abuse could be sworn to silence, under the same threat if needed.

And the rules said nothing about going to the police.

The Vatican now admits that from 1965 to 1983, bishops were expected to “heal” rather than “punish” the priests.

They hoped far too much from therapy.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Picture a school with its values painted in big letters on the wall: every child is precious.

One day a teacher hurts a student. The parents come in to complain.

The head teacher is kind to them, and asks them to keep it quiet, for the school's sake. Nothing is reported.

Next term the teacher is quietly moved to another branch across town, where nobody has been warned. It happens again.

Were the words on the wall false? No, they were true. The school betrayed them.

You wouldn't judge that school by its posters. You'd ask hard questions. Does it call the police now? Does it let outsiders check its files?

Does it punish head teachers who hide things? That's the test the Catholic Church has to pass too.

Part 4 · Is celibacy to blame?

Most Catholic priests promise never to marry. That promise is called celibacy.

Many people assume the strain of it turns into abuse.

The biggest US study looked at when the abuse happened. Cases rose from the mid-1960s, peaked in the late 1970s, and fell sharply by 1985.

Celibacy stayed the same through all of that, so it can't explain the rise and the fall.

To be honest, the researchers admit no other institution has studied itself like this, so there's nothing like it yet to compare with.

Critics add that the study relied on the dioceses' own files, and that many victims take decades to speak.

So the fall after 1985 may partly be cases not yet reported.

Australia's national inquiry was tougher. It said celibacy isn't a direct cause.

But it said compulsory celibacy, where priests aren't allowed to marry, is a contributing factor, especially alongside other risks.

The Australian inquiry named clericalism as a major factor too: a culture that puts priests above question.

Pope Francis agrees: To say “no” to abuse is to say an emphatic “no” to all forms of clericalism.

Part 5 · What changed, and when

In 2001 made sexual abuse of anyone under 18 by clergy one of the gravest crimes in church law.

From then on, these cases were judged in Rome, not by local bishops alone.

Popes have admitted, late, that the leaders failed. In that 2010 letter, told abusive priests in Ireland to answer to God and the courts.

He told the bishops to cooperate with the civil authorities, meaning the police and the courts.

In 2018 Pope Francis wrote: We showed no care for the little ones; we abandoned them.

In 2019 Francis made clergy, nuns and brothers report abuse to their bishop.

He set up a place for the public to report it in every diocese, the area a bishop looks after.

And now bishops themselves can be reported for cover-ups. In 2023 that law became permanent.

In December 2019 Francis also lifted the Vatican's highest level of secrecy from these cases.

Victims and witnesses can't be sworn to silence, and local laws on reporting must still be obeyed.

In 2020 the Vatican published its own report on Theodore McCarrick, an American cardinal, one of the Church's most senior leaders.

He was later thrown out of the priesthood for abusing minors and adults.

John Paul II had made him archbishop of Washington in 2000, though warnings had already reached church leaders.

John Paul II believed McCarrick's written denial. Three of the four US bishops Rome asked had given it inaccurate and incomplete information.

The report doesn't hide that the final decision was his, and that he trusted a senior churchman over the warnings.

In 2021 Francis rewrote the Church's criminal law, admitting that not using penalties had done great damage.

A bishop who neglects to use them, he said, shows that he has failed to carry out his duties honestly and faithfully.

Part 6 · Why not leave it to the police?

So why does the Catholic Church run its own investigations at all? Isn't that a job for the police?

The two do different jobs. Only a court can send an abuser to prison. Only the Church can stop a man being a priest.

In the worst cases, the Vatican can dismiss him from the priesthood for good.

So a church trial doesn't replace a criminal trial. It decides whether he can ever lead a parish or stand at an altar again.

The Vatican's own handbook for bishops says the church inquiry must run separately from any police investigation.

Where a country's law forbids a parallel inquiry, the bishop must hold off on his own and report the case to Rome instead.

Bishops must obey every local law on reporting abuse to the authorities.

Even where no law requires it, they should report to the police when that's needed to protect the child or other children.

And victims must be encouraged to go to the police, never talked out of it.

Notice the gap, though. Where local law is silent, reporting still rests on a bishop's judgement.

If anyone ever abuses you or someone you know, a priest or anyone else, tell a parent or another adult you trust.

You can go to the police too: the Church's rules don't replace your country's law. And it's never the child's fault.

If you're in danger right now, call your local emergency number.

You can find a free, confidential helpline in your country at findahelpline.com.

Part 7 · Is it fixed now?

So is it fixed now? Church law has changed a lot since 2001, but it isn't fully fixed.

And mostly it changed after survivors, journalists and public inquiries forced the facts out.

One survivors' advocacy group, BishopAccountability.org, says the 2023 law still lets bishops investigate fellow bishops.

It also says the law doesn't require reporting to police where local law doesn't.

So go back to the school's test. Does it call the police now? Where the law requires it, yes. Elsewhere, it's still the bishop's call.

Does it let outsiders check its files? Mostly, outsiders had to force them open.

Does it punish head teachers who hide things? The same group counted only about 40 bishops investigated in four years, out of roughly 5,600.

Fewer than half were punished.

Part 8 · So why stay?

If this happened to you, or to someone you love, none of this is telling you to go back.

But it's fair to ask why so many Catholics stay.

Some survivors have stayed too, though nobody owes the Church that. Juan Carlos Cruz was abused as a teenager by a powerful priest in Chile.

For years church leaders there didn't believe him. Even Pope Francis at first defended a bishop Cruz said had covered it up.

In 2018 Francis apologised to him. In 2021 he named Cruz to the Vatican's commission for protecting children.

Cruz said it renewed his commitment to change things from within, for survivors.

The Catholic Church teaches that abusing a child is one of the gravest wrongs there is, and that hiding it makes it worse.

Jesus warned about anyone who leads a little one who believes in him away from God.

He said that person would be better off thrown into the sea with a millstone round his neck.

A millstone is a heavy stone for grinding grain. It's in Matthew's , one of the four accounts of Jesus's life.

Catholics believe the Church is holy because Jesus is holy, not because its people are good.

The , the Church's summary of its beliefs, says all its members, including her ministers, must acknowledge that they are sinners.

The Catechism calls the Church at once holy and always in need of purification.

And its leaders must be held to account.

Catholics also believe it's Jesus himself who acts in the Church's , which are its sacred rites like and Communion.

The Catechism says even the minister's sin cannot impede the fruit of grace.

In plain words, a priest's sin can't spoil what Jesus gives there.

So the honest Catholic answer to how can you stay? isn't it wasn't that bad.

It was that bad.

When crowds walked away from Jesus, , one of his closest friends, said:

Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life.

Many Catholics feel the same. Leaving the Church, for them, would mean leaving him.

People stay because they believe Jesus is in the Church these men betrayed, and they want to help make it safe.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 16
  1. John Jay College, The Causes and Context of Sexual Abuse of Minors by Catholic Priests in the United States, 1950–2010 (2011) · The US bishops' study, summarising its 2004 Nature and Scope findings: 4,392 accused priests (4%), how dioceses responded, and why celibacy doesn't explain the rise and fall.
  2. Holy Office, Instruction Crimen sollicitationis (1922, reprinted 1962), 11–13 and 23 · The secret of the Holy Office, binding tribunal officials under automatic excommunication; the accuser sworn to confidentiality.
  3. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Historical introduction to Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela (2001) · Rome's own account: what Crimen was for, the 'heal rather than punish' years, and the 2001 law.
  4. Benedict XVI, Pastoral Letter to the Catholics of Ireland (19 March 2010) · Names the concern for reputation as a cause; tells abusers they must answer to the courts.
  5. Pope Francis, Letter to the People of God (20 August 2018) · The Pope's confession of failure, and his diagnosis of clericalism.
  6. Pope Francis, Vos estis lux mundi, updated (25 March 2023) · The 2019 law made permanent: duty to report, public reporting offices, bishops reportable for covering up abuse.
  7. Secretariat of State, Rescript On the Confidentiality of Legal Proceedings (6 December 2019) · Lifts the pontifical secret from abuse cases; no silence imposed on victims; civil law to be obeyed.
  8. Holy See, Report on the Holy See's Institutional Knowledge and Decision-Making Related to Theodore McCarrick (10 November 2020) · How McCarrick was promoted despite warnings, and his dismissal from the priesthood.
  9. Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Final Report, Volume 16, Book 2 (2017) · 7% of priests in ministry 1950–2010 were alleged perpetrators; compulsory celibacy a contributing factor; clericalism highly significant; voluntary celibacy to be considered.
  10. BishopAccountability.org, response to the updated Vos estis lux mundi (March 2023) · A survivors' advocacy group's critique: bishops still judge bishops; about 40 investigated in four years, fewer than half sanctioned.
  11. Independent Commission on Sexual Abuse in the Church (CIASE, France), Summary of the Final Report (5 October 2021) · Estimates about 216,000 children abused by priests, deacons and religious in France, 1950–2020.
  12. Pope Francis, Apostolic Constitution Pascite gregem Dei (23 May 2021) · The revised penal law of the Church; failing to punish did great damage; a bishop who neglects penalties fails in his duty.
  13. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vademecum on certain points of procedure in treating cases of sexual abuse of minors committed by clerics (16 July 2020), 17, 26, 48, 56 and note 7 · The church inquiry runs independently of the civil one and yields to it where state law requires; report to civil authorities even without a legal duty when needed to protect minors; never dissuade victims; dismissal from the clerical state.
  14. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 827 · The Church is at once holy and always in need of purification; all its members, including her ministers, must acknowledge that they are sinners.
  15. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1550 · Christ acts in the sacraments, so even the minister's sin cannot block the fruit of grace.
  16. John 6:60–69 (New American Bible, USCCB) · verse 68, Peter: 'Master, to whom shall we go?'