Why doesn't the Vatican sell its treasures and feed the poor?
Most of the Vatican's treasures are paintings on walls, buildings and museum pieces on public show, not cash in a vault. Its property and investments already pay its running costs, and still fall short. The Catholic Church's real giving runs through thousands of hospitals, schools and charities. The fair criticism is about how its money has been managed, sometimes badly.
Part 1 · An old question
People have asked this for 2,000 years. Once, a woman poured very expensive perfume on the feet of Jesus, the teacher Christians follow.
Judas, one of his own followers, who later betrayed him, asked why it wasn't sold and the money given to the poor.
Jesus answered: You always have the poor with you, but you do not always have me.
He was echoing a line from the Jewish scriptures, the : there will always be poor people, so keep helping them.
Jesus's answer isn't permission to ignore the poor. So the real question stands.
Does a church that follows Jesus, a poor man from Nazareth, need the Sistine Chapel, the 's chapel with a ceiling painted by Michelangelo?
Part 2 · You can't sell a ceiling
The pope, the Catholic Church's leader, lives in Vatican City, a tiny country inside Rome. Much of its art can't be carried out the door.
Michelangelo's famous ceiling is painted straight onto the Sistine Chapel itself.
The 1929 treaty that created Vatican City says its treasures must remain open to scholars and visitors.
It doesn't ban selling them. But it treats them like a museum, not a bank account.
Under the same treaty, St 's Basilica, the great church at the Vatican, stays open for public worship.
Anyone can walk in, rich or poor.
The Catholic Church sees beauty as one way people meet God, not as a luxury for the rich.
Its , the summary of its beliefs, says real sacred art draws man to adoration, to prayer, and to the love of God.
Here's an analogy that might help. Imagine a city that decides to sell its national art gallery's whole collection.
It needs the money to repair its public housing. Every painting and every statue goes to the highest bidder.
It would raise a lot of money, once. The repairs would get done that year, and people would cheer.
Then the paintings would vanish into private homes and bank vaults, and the families who wandered through on Sundays would never see them again.
And next year the flats would need repairs all over again, with nothing left to sell.
Most people would call that a bad trade.
The art belongs to everyone, and the repairs need a steady budget, not a one-off sale.
The Vatican's treasures and the poor work the same way. The poor need help that keeps coming, every single year.
You might reply: then sell the art, invest the money, and give away what it earns every year.
Big charities work that way, and it's a fair point.
Part of the answer is that the Vatican already lives that way, on its property and investments.
The other part is how far that money stretches.
Part 3 · Less to spare than you'd think
The Vatican has less money to spare than people imagine. In 2023 the pope's central offices ran €51.2 million short.
In 2024 they only just came out ahead, thanks to one-off sales.
And that's with the income from its property counted in. In 2023 its property office looked after more than 5,000 properties.
About 4,250 are in Italy, mostly in Rome. About 1,200 more are in London, Paris, Geneva and Lausanne.
Only about 1 in 5 is rented out at market rates. About 1 in 10 is let cheaply, and about 70% for free.
With its cautious investments, that office made €45.9 million in 2023. Most of it, €37.9 million, went to run the pope's offices.
So the Vatican already lives on something like an endowment. It just doesn't cover the bills.
Then there's Peter's Pence, the yearly collection for the pope. In 2024 it raised €58 million.
Of what it paid out, €13.3 million went to 239 aid projects. Almost all the rest, €61.2 million, went to the Vatican's own departments.
Wait, most of it went to offices? That's by design. The fund pays for the pope's whole mission, not only charity.
That means help for churches in difficulty, the Vatican's embassies, education and more.
Counting other gifts from his offices, the pope's direct charity came to €50.6 million that year.
Still, if you assumed every coin of Peter's Pence went to the poor, it's worth knowing where most of it goes before you give.
Many givers didn't know the fund paid for more than charity. In 2019 The Wall Street Journal said as little as 10% went to charity.
About two-thirds of the rest, it reported, filled the hole in the Vatican's budget.
The collection was promoted as A Day for the Works of Charity, so some church leaders worried donors were being misled.
Church law lets a pope use it for anything that serves his work. So it was allowed, but it wasn't what many givers thought.
Then the Vatican's investment in a London building went badly wrong.
In 2020 Pope Francis took the investments, Peter's Pence included, away from the pope's main office.
Since 2021 they've been run by another Vatican office, in separate accounts, checked by the Vatican's economy office. The fund now publishes a yearly report.
Part 4 · The fair criticism
None of this makes the Vatican's money handling clean. Prosecutors say that London deal lost it €140 million to €190 million.
The Vatican itself said the losses ate into money meant for charity.
In 2023 a Vatican court sentenced Angelo Becciu to five and a half years over it. He's a cardinal, one of the Church's top leaders.
In 2026 an appeals court ordered a new trial, because the defence hadn't seen all the evidence. The guilty verdict stays in place until then.
And critics who say the Church should live more simply have popes on their side.
In 2013 Francis wrote: This is why I want a Church which is poor and for the poor.
That's the measure the Vatican's own spending has to meet.
Part 5 · Where the giving really happens
The Catholic Church teaches that the good things of the earth are meant for everyone, and that owning things comes with a duty to share.
The Catechism says the Church has never stopped working for the poor, in spite of the failings of many of her members.
It doesn't pretend Catholics always lived up to it. It sets the standard they'll be judged by.
Jesus set that standard first. Whatever you do for the hungry, the stranger and the prisoner, he said, you do for him.
And here's the part most people never see. Most Catholic charity isn't run from Rome at all.
It's local: parishes, which are local churches, religious orders of nuns, brothers and priests, and ordinary Catholics.
At the end of 2023 they ran 5,377 hospitals, 15,566 homes for the elderly, sick or disabled, and 8,593 orphanages.
Selling a famous statue would feed people for a while.
A hospital that keeps running feeds and heals people for decades.
Caritas Internationalis, the Catholic Church's network of 162 national charities, works in disasters and in long-term development around the world.
And the Vatican publishes its accounts, so you can check.
Of what it set aside in 2024 for its mission and the pope's funds, 37% went to churches in difficulty, and 10% to direct charity.
The treasures don't matter more than the poor.
The poor are owed far more than a one-off sale: steady, lasting care, and honest books.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 14
- John 12:1–8 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Mary anoints Jesus; Judas's complaint; 'You always have the poor with you'.
- Lateran Treaty between the Holy See and Italy (11 February 1929), Articles 3 and 18 · Article 18: the Vatican's artistic and scientific treasures remain open to scholars and visitors.
- Holy See Press Office, Secretariat for the Economy: Holy See Consolidated Financial Statements 2024 (25 November 2025) · The 2023 deficit, the 2024 surplus, and where the mission budget goes.
- Vatican News, Peter's Pence 2024 report (27 June 2025) · Peter's Pence raised €58 million in 2024: €13.3 million to 239 aid projects, €61.2 million to the Holy See's offices; €50.6 million in papal charity in all.
- Agenzia Fides, Catholic Church Statistics 2025 · Catholic hospitals, clinics, homes and orphanages worldwide at the end of 2023.
- Vatican News, Caritas Internationalis General Assembly interview (May 2023) · Caritas Internationalis: 162 national member charities.
- UCA News, Vatican orders retrial for Cardinal Becciu, convicted of fraud (March 2026) · The London property losses (€140–190 million, per prosecutors), the 2023 sentence and the March 2026 retrial order.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2443–2449 · Love for the poor as part of the Church's constant tradition.
- Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium (24 November 2013), 198 · 'A Church which is poor and for the poor'.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2402–2406 · The goods of creation are meant for the whole human race; owners are stewards who must share.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2500–2503 · Beauty and sacred art: genuine sacred art draws people to prayer and to the love of God.
- CNBC, Vatican uses donations for poor to fight budget deficit, report says (11 December 2019), reporting The Wall Street Journal · As little as 10% of Peter's Pence went to charity; about two-thirds of the rest filled the budget deficit; concern that donors were misled; a pope may use the fund for any purpose of his ministry.
- Vatican News, Administration of Secretariat of State holdings passes to APSA (28 December 2020) · From 1 January 2021 the Secretariat of State's investments, including Peter's Pence, are managed by APSA, in separate sub-accounts, under the Secretariat for the Economy.
- Vatican News, APSA makes 45.9 million euros in profit in 2023 (July 2024) · APSA's properties (4,249 in Italy, about 1,200 abroad), rents (19.2% market, 10.4% subsidised, 70.4% free), €45.9m profit, €37.9m to the pope's mission