Didn't the Church torture heretics and burn witches?
The Church's courts, called inquisitions, did torture suspects, and handed convicted heretics to the state to be burned, from the 1200s to the 1800s. Their dead number in the thousands, not millions. Most of the people executed as witches were condemned by local and state courts, Protestant and Catholic. The Catholic Church has repented of it.
Part 1 · What happened
Most people picture dungeons, torture, and crowds watching people burn. Some have heard that millions died.
The core of that picture is true. Catholic Church courts used torture, and sent people to their deaths for what they believed.
Those courts were called inquisitions. They tried people for heresy: when a Christian stubbornly denies a truth of the Catholic faith.
If someone was found guilty and refused to take it back, the court handed him to the state to be burned.
How did it start? In medieval Europe, heresy was treated like treason.
Sometimes mobs burned suspects with no trial at all.
It began in southern France in the 1180s. A , the head of the Catholic Church, told to search their areas for heretics.
In 1231 another pope appointed his own inquisitors.
Historians give two reasons: to bring the mobs under law, and to put the hunt for heresy under the popes' own control.
Inquisitors thought they were saving souls: keeping people from being lost to God for ever.
Many of the accused thought they were following their conscience.
Explaining what the inquisitors feared doesn't make what they did right.
Here's an analogy that might help. Picture a school where, whenever a wallet goes missing, a crowd of students corners whoever they suspect.
They beat him up behind the gym. Nobody asks any questions or looks for proof.
The head teacher finally steps in. She sets up a discipline committee, with teachers, a hearing and a written record.
At least now there's a process. That's better than a mob.
But then you find out how the committee works. It keeps suspects in a room and hurts them until they confess.
And when it finds someone guilty, it hands him over to people it knows will do far worse to him.
On paper, the committee looks fair. But a fair hearing doesn't make it okay to hurt someone until they confess.
That's the honest way to see the inquisitions: a court instead of a mob, and still deeply wrong.
Part 2 · What the numbers say
There wasn't one Inquisition. There were several.
The first was the medieval one we've just met. In 1252 a pope let its judges use torture, within limits.
The Spanish Inquisition lasted from 1478 to 1834, and Spain's kings ran it, with the pope's permission.
Its main targets were Jews who'd been pressured or forced to become Christian, and were suspected of secretly keeping their old faith.
Historians estimate about 150,000 trials and 3,000 to 5,000 executions.
The Spanish Inquisition tortured people: hanging them by the wrists, stretching them on the rack, forcing water into them.
In 1482 the pope himself complained that its judges in eastern Spain were driven by lust for wealth, and had tortured faithful Christians.
Notice what he complained about: faithful Christians tortured and condemned without real proof.
He didn't object to torture itself, and church courts went on using it.
The Roman Inquisition was a Catholic court set up in 1542, mainly to stop ideas spreading.
Protestant churches are the ones that split from Rome in the 1500s.
It passed about 1,250 death sentences, by the Italian historian Andrea Del Col's estimate, out of 51,000 to 75,000 cases.
Not all of those condemned were Protestants.
One was the philosopher Giordano Bruno, burned in 1600.
Portugal's inquisition in Goa, its colony in India, tried about 16,000 people. It burned 57 by one count.
It used prison and torture, mostly against converts from Hinduism, Islam and Judaism accused of secretly keeping their old faith.
It reached Brazil too, though Portugal never set up an inquisition court there.
It sent inspectors from the 1590s, to Bahia and Pernambuco in the north-east, and other regions.
Later it relied on local clergy and agents who reported suspects to Lisbon. Those arrested were shipped to Portugal for trial.
The most common charge was secretly keeping the Jewish faith. About 400 people from Brazil were tried for it, and 18 were sentenced to death.
So the dead number in the thousands, not millions.
That's still thousands of people killed for what they believed.
Part 3 · And the witches?
Between about 1400 and 1775, 40,000 to 60,000 people were executed as witches.
Most were condemned by local and state courts, in Catholic lands and in Protestant ones.
In 2004 the Vatican, the Catholic Church's headquarters, published a study of the inquisitions.
In the witch trials, a historian presenting it counted fewer than 100 people sent to the stake by church courts in Portugal, Spain and Italy.
But his count leaves out Germany, where the worst hunts were.
Why did people believe in witches at all?
Picture a village where a baby dies, a cow sickens or the harvest fails, and nobody can say why.
Many people believed a neighbour could cause harm like that by magic.
Among ordinary people, accusations usually came from neighbours.
For most of the Middle Ages, mainstream church teaching had called belief in witches a pagan superstition.
In the 1400s some inquisitors, and some theologians, meaning scholars of the faith, argued that witches were real.
They said witches had made a pact with the Devil and met in secret to worship him.
Hard times made it worse. Some historians link the peaks of the trials to cold years, failed harvests, war and disease.
That's when people looked for someone to blame, they say. Others call that too simple, since trials also happened in places spared those disasters.
Catholics don't come off well here. A handbook for hunting witches, called the Hammer of Witches, spread the panic.
It was written by a German inquisitor in 1487, and came with a pope's 1484 letter backing inquisitors against witches.
In Catholic southern Germany, some bishops also ruled their lands as princes, and some of the worst hunts happened there.
In south-western Germany from 1561 to 1670, 2,527 people were executed in Catholic lands and 702 in Protestant ones.
Protestants hunted witches too. Protestant Scotland executed far more people as witches than Catholic Spain.
In 1610 the Spanish Inquisition burned accused witches in Logroño, a town in Spain, even though one of its own judges doubted they were guilty.
In 1614 it adopted the stricter rules his doubts had shaped, and after that Spain rarely executed witches.
Part 4 · What the Catholic Church says now
Today the Catholic Church teaches that torture is wrong, whether it's used to force confessions, punish or frighten people.
It calls torture contrary to respect for the person and for human dignity.
It also teaches that faith can't be forced.
quoted the , the meeting of the world's bishops in the 1960s.
The said truth wins people over only in virtue of its own truth: by being true, gently, never by force.
And the , the Church's summary of its beliefs, admits what the Church's own courts did:
In times past, cruel practices were commonly used by legitimate governments to maintain law and order, often without protest from the Pastors of the Church, who themselves adopted in their own tribunals the prescriptions of Roman law concerning torture.
In plain words: governments used cruel methods like torture then, church leaders often didn't protest, and the Church's own courts used torture too.
The Catechism goes on: the Church always taught the duty of clemency and mercy.
It also forbade clerics to shed blood: priests and monks were never to kill anyone themselves.
But its courts still handed people to the state to be burned, like the school committee handing suspects to people who'll do far worse.
Before apologising, the Catholic Church wanted the facts. In 1998 the Vatican opened the Roman Inquisition's files to researchers.
That October it gathered historians from around the world to study them.
On 12 March 2000, John Paul II held a service called the Day of Pardon.
One by one, senior churchmen led seven confessions of committed by Catholics through history. After each, the pope asked God's forgiveness.
The first was a confession of sins in general. The second was this one:
men of the Church, in the name of faith and morals, have sometimes used methods not in keeping with the Gospel
The is Jesus's message, so those methods went against it.
The other confessions named sins against Christian unity, the Jewish people, other cultures and religions, women, other races, the poor and the unborn.
To be honest, those prayers were general. There's no known papal apology for the Goa Inquisition by name.
After each confession, a lamp was lit before a crucifix: a cross bearing the figure of the dying Jesus.
At the end the pope embraced and kissed it. It was the Catholic Church saying sorry to God, in public, for its own members.
When the historians' study came out in 2004, John Paul II explained why it mattered.
He said: before asking for forgiveness it is necessary to have exact knowledge of the facts.
An apology for a legend wouldn't reach the real people who suffered.
And when the smaller numbers came in, he didn't use them as an excuse.
He said Catholics cannot but return with a spirit of repentance to those times.
Those were the times the Church accepted intolerance and even the use of violence in the service of the truth.
In other words, Catholics can't look back on those times without repenting.
So the Catholic Church holds two things at once. The legend of millions burned isn't true.
And the real record is still a sin to repent of.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 14
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2297–2298 (torture) · Torture is contrary to human dignity; Church tribunals once adopted it.
- John Paul II, Letter to Cardinal Roger Etchegaray on the Proceedings of the Symposium on the Inquisition (15 June 2004) · Repentance for intolerance and violence in the service of the truth; the Day of Pardon.
- Agenzia Fides, presentation of the Acts of the 1998 Symposium on the Inquisition (15 June 2004) · The symposium of 29–31 October 1998, and Agostino Borromeo's count of burnings by church courts in Portugal, Spain and Italy.
- National Catholic Register, Without 'Fear of Past,' Vatican Opens Secret Archives (1998) · The Holy Office archives (1542–1903) opened to all qualified researchers, presented at a day of study on 22 January 1998.
- Wikipedia, Medieval Inquisition · Origins against the Cathars, Gregory IX's inquisitors (1231), Ad extirpanda (1252), Bernard Gui's 636 convictions and no more than 45 executions.
- Wikipedia, Goa Inquisition · The Portuguese inquisition in India (c. 1560–1812), its targets, and Machado's count of 57 burned at the stake.
- Wikipedia, Spanish Inquisition · 1478–1834; about 150,000 trials, 3,000–5,000 executions; torture; Sixtus IV's bull of 1482.
- Wikipedia, Roman Inquisition · Founded 1542; Del Col's estimate of about 1,250 death sentences; most witch trials run by local and secular courts.
- Wikipedia, Witch trials in the early modern period · About 100,000 tried, 40,000–60,000 executed; the Hammer of Witches and Innocent VIII's bull of 1484; Catholic and Protestant regions compared.
- Wikipedia, Alonso de Salazar Frías · The Logroño burnings of 1610 and the inquisitor whose skepticism shaped the Spanish Inquisition's 1614 rules on witchcraft.
- Office for the Liturgical Celebrations of the Supreme Pontiff, Universal Prayer: Confession of Sins and Asking for Forgiveness (Day of Pardon, 12 March 2000)
- Wikipédia (Portuguese), Inquisição portuguesa (the Inquisition in Brazil) · Portugal never created a tribunal in Brazil; visitations, then local agents reporting to Lisbon, with prisoners sent to Portugal; main charge Judaism.
- Wikipedia, History of the Jews in Brazil · The Portuguese Inquisition in Brazil: visitations to Bahia and Pernambuco from 1591, later activity in Rio de Janeiro and Minas Gerais; about 400 'judaizers' prosecuted, 18 condemned to death in Lisbon.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2089 · Heresy: the obstinate post-baptismal denial of a truth that must be believed.