The RiverCrisis and calls for reform
1309–77

The popes live at Avignon

After a French king's men seize Pope Boniface VIII, seven French popes rule the Church from Avignon. Gregory XI goes back to Rome in 1377.

Historical evidence Quotes not yet checked
In brief

Around 1300 Pope Boniface VIII clashed with King Philip IV of France over the king's power to tax and judge the clergy. In 1303 Philip's men seized the pope at Anagni, and he died weeks later. Rome itself was torn by feuding noble families.

In 1305 the cardinals elected a Frenchman, Clement V, who settled at Avignon in 1309. Seven popes in a row, all French, lived there for nearly 70 years, close to the French crown.

Urged by Catherine of Siena, Gregory XI returned to Rome in January 1377 and died there in 1378.

Where we are

The situation

Around 1300 the kings of Europe were growing stronger, and they wanted control of the Church in their lands: its courts, its appointments and its money. Boniface VIII pushed back hard.

In 1296 he forbade rulers to tax the clergy without the pope's consent, on pain of excommunication, a church penalty that cuts someone off from the . In 1302 his bull Unam Sanctam, a formal papal letter, taught that being subject to the pope is necessary for .

King Philip IV of France answered with force. On 7 September 1303 his agent Guillaume de Nogaret and Sciarra Colonna, from a Roman family at war with the pope, broke into Boniface's palace at Anagni, his home town south of Rome, and seized him. The townspeople freed him after three days; he died weeks later.

Rome was no refuge either. The Colonna and Orsini families fought for control of the city, and popes of the 1200s had often lived in smaller towns like Viterbo, Orvieto and Perugia to be safe.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The bull on clergy taxes

    The Catholic Encyclopedia's summary of *Clericis laicos*, the 1296 ruling that started the clash.

    “he forbade the laity to exact or receive, and the clergy to give up, ecclesiastical revenues or property , without permission of the Apostolic See ; princes imposing such exactions and ecclesiastics submitting to them were declared excommunicated .”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Pope Boniface VIII
  2. 02

    Anagni, 7 September 1303

    The Catholic Encyclopedia's account of the raid on the pope's home town.

    “Very early on the morning of 7 September the band appeared suddenly before Anagni , under the lilies of France , shouting, "Long live the King of France and Colonna!"”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Pope Boniface VIII
  3. 03

    Rome's noble feuds

    Why even Italian popes had lived away from Rome before Avignon.

    “Confusion and anarchy were prevalent, owing to the implacable mutual hatred of the Colonna and Orsini, the traditional turbulence of the Romans, and the frequent angry conflicts between the people and the nobles”
The problem

What was at stake

After Anagni came Benedict XI, who reigned less than a year. When he died in 1304 the cardinals, the senior clergy who elect the pope, were split between those who wanted to stand up to France and those who wanted peace with it. It took them 11 months to choose a pope.

Underneath was a hard question: where could a pope be both safe and free? Rome was violent. France was safe, but under the eye of the strongest king in Europe. Either way, the pope's freedom was at risk.

What happened

The event

In 1305 the cardinals chose a Frenchman, Bertrand de Got, archbishop of Bordeaux, as Clement V. He was crowned at Lyon with King Philip watching, and never went to Rome.

In 1309 he settled at Avignon, a town on the Rhône beside the Comtat Venaissin, land the popes already held. They bought Avignon itself in 1348. The 1908 Catholic Encyclopedia says love of France and fear of Italy's near-anarchy both drove the choice.

Philip kept the pressure on. He demanded that the dead Boniface be condemned as a heretic, a betrayer of the faith; stalled and gave ground elsewhere. In 1312, under the king's pressure, he suppressed the Knights Templar, a religious order of knights whose wealth Philip wanted.

Seven popes in a row lived at Avignon, all of them French. They built a great fortress-palace there and ran the Church from it.

Many begged them to come back. Catherine of Siena, a laywoman famous for her holiness, went to Gregory XI at Avignon in 1376 and urged him to return. On 17 January 1377 he entered Rome, against the wishes of the French king and most of his cardinals.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Why Clement stayed in France

    The Catholic Encyclopedia gives two motives and a cost.

    “Strong affection for his native France and an equally influential fear of the quasi-anarchical conditions of Italy , and in particular of the States of the Church and the city of Rome , led him to this fateful decision”
  2. 02

    The Templars

    A modern summary of how the order was ended at the Council of Vienne. Tertiary source.

    “Exerting massive pressure in order to gain part of the substantial funds of the order, the King managed to get the ruling he wanted, and Pope Clement V ordered by decree the suppression of the order.”
    Avignon Papacy · Papacy in the 14th century
  3. 03

    Catherine and Gregory XI

    Benedict XVI's account of what Catherine did.

    “including Pope Gregory xi who was living at Avignon in that period and whom she energetically and effectively urged to return to Rome.”
What came of it

The outcome

Gregory found Rome and the Papal States, the lands in central Italy the popes ruled, in revolt. He died there on 27 March 1378. The Catholic Encyclopedia says only death stopped him going back to Avignon.

His death set up a worse crisis. The cardinals met in a Rome that wanted an Italian pope, and within months two men claimed to be pope: the Western Schism.

The Avignon years left the Church with a stronger central government, run from the pope's court, with taxes reaching every diocese. They also left a reputation for luxury and money-raising that critics never let go.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Back in Rome, and wishing he weren't

    The Catholic Encyclopedia's verdict on Gregory XI's last months.

    “He was so disgusted with the conditions at Rome that only death prevented him from returning to Avignon .”
  2. 02

    A government with taxes everywhere

    A modern summary of how the Avignon court centralised Church finances. Tertiary source.

    “The Catholic Church successfully reorganised and centralized its administration under Clement V and John XXII .”
    Avignon Papacy · Centralization of church administration
Why it matters

For the trail

For nearly 70 years the of Rome didn't live in Rome. To many Christians, especially Italians, it looked as if the pope now belonged to the King of France.

That suspicion, fair or not, wore down trust in the papacy just before the made it far worse. Calls to reform the Church grew louder from here.

It also shows a pattern the River keeps meeting: a Church that leans on a strong ruler for safety soon finds the ruler wants something back.

The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Church counts the seven Avignon popes as true popes: being bishop of Rome doesn't depend on where the pope lives.

It honours Catherine of Siena, the laywoman who pressed Gregory XI to go home, as a saint. In 1970 Paul VI declared her a Doctor of the Church, a title for saints whose teaching has special value for everyone.

Vatican II teaches that ‘Christ summons the Church, as she goes her pilgrim way, to that continual reformation of which she always has need’ (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 6).

In plain terms

Think of it like this

A head office that moves next door to its biggest customer for safety, and slowly starts taking his calls first.

Rome was dangerous, so the popes stayed where they were safe, beside the King of France. Nobody signed the Church over to him. But a guest who depends on his host for protection finds it hard to say no to him, and everyone else notices.

Read the text
“Here reign the successors of the poor fishermen of Galilee; they have strangely forgotten their origin.”
Letter Criticizing the Avignon Papacy · Petrarch, letter to a friend, 1340–1353

Petrarch was a hostile witness: an Italian poet who wanted the popes back in Rome.

Other readings

Where people disagree

The nickname ‘Babylonian captivity’, comparing the popes to the Jews exiled in Babylon, came from Italian critics. Petrarch called Avignon ‘the Babylon of the West’. It's a critic's name, not a neutral one.

How far the Avignon popes served France is argued. The Catholic Encyclopedia rejects as ‘quite unhistorical’ the story of a secret deal between Clement V and Philip, while admitting the cardinals wanted to please the king.

Not all of them were worldly. Benedict XII and Urban V are remembered as austere, and Urban V moved back to Rome in 1367, though he returned to Avignon in 1370. Others, like Clement VI, ran a famously lavish court.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Petrarch's Babylon

    The letter that gave the period its hostile name.

    “...Now I am living in France, in the Babylon of the West.”
    Letter Criticizing the Avignon Papacy · Letter to a friend, 1340–1353
  2. 02

    No secret deal

    The Catholic Encyclopedia rejects the chronicler Villani's story of a bargain between Clement and Philip, but not the king's influence.

    “is quite unhistorical; on the other hand, the cardinals were willing to please the powerful French king”

This page was written from general knowledge. Its key quote hasn’t been checked against the source yet, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next