From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/second-commandment
← Protestant or evangelicalDid Catholics delete the second commandment?
Read it as an illustrated story · 4 minNo. Every Catholic prints the full ban on carved idols. The Bible doesn't number the commandments, so Christians count them differently. Catholics and Lutherans fold idols into the first commandment. The , Anglicans and Reformed churches, like the Presbyterians, make it a separate second one.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 20662129–2132The Ten Commandments
You may have seen a chart online comparing the and Catholic Ten Commandments.
On the Catholic side, You shall not make idols is missing. To many evangelicals, it looks like the Catholic Church quietly dropped the one verse that's against its statues.
And part of that is real. The short list many Catholics learn by heart leaves out the line about idols.1
But look at the Lutherans. The short list wrote for them leaves it out too.2
The full text is still there
A short list isn't the Bible. It's a teaching aid, made for learning by heart. The full text is in every Catholic Bible.3,4
The opens its whole section on the commandments by printing all of Exodus 20, word for word, idols and all. Beside it sits the other telling in Deuteronomy 5, and the short list.1
The Catholic Church teaches all ten as God's word for every Christian.
The Bible gives no numbers
Most people never notice this. The Bible calls these the ten words, but it never numbers them. And the passage actually holds more than ten instructions.3,5
So someone has to decide where one ends and the next begins. A footnote in the New American Bible, a Catholic translation, admits the numbering is somewhat uncertain.3
Jewish people count God's opening words, I am the Lord your God, as the first.5
, a North African around AD 400, kept no other gods and no idols together, since both are about worshipping the one true God. To still make ten, he split the last command, about wanting what isn't yours, into two.6
The text itself gives a reason. In Deuteronomy 5, the neighbour's wife gets a line of her own: You shall not covet your neighbor's wife.4
Then comes a separate line, with a different verb: You shall not desire your neighbor's house or field, and so on.4
Wanting someone's wife and wanting their things are two different wrongs, so counting them separately follows the text.
Think of it like this
Think of two teachers at the same school, handing out the same page of revision notes before a big exam. Every word on the page is identical.
The first teacher numbers it into ten points one way. The second looks at it and thinks: points one and two are really about the same thing, so she joins them into one. But the last point covers two different ideas, so she splits it in half. She still ends up with ten.
Now imagine a student from each class comparing their lists. One says: your teacher left out point two! But nothing's missing. Every sentence is still on both pages.
The words are the same; only the numbers differ. That's what happened with the Ten Commandments.
Three ways to count
Catholics and Lutherans count Augustine's way.7 The Orthodox, Anglicans and the Reformed churches, meaning the Presbyterians and others who follow , make idols a separate second commandment.3,7
The Heidelberg Catechism, a Reformed teaching book from 1563, uses that second commandment to say images don't belong in churches at all.8
The Orthodox count it as a second commandment too, but they don't read it that way. Like Catholics, they hold that honour shown to an image goes to the person it shows.9
And the Catholic Catechism is open about all of this:
The division and numbering of the Commandments have varied in the course of history. The present catechism follows the division of the Commandments established by St. Augustine, which has become traditional in the Catholic Church. It is also that of the Lutheran confessions.
Was it a cover-up?
No. Augustine's way of counting is over 1,000 years older than the Reformation of the 1500s.6
So it wasn't made up to dodge Protestants. And the Lutherans, who broke with Rome, kept it.2
The real disagreement is about images, not about numbers.
What the idols verse means
Catholics don't skip the verse. The Catechism teaches it under the first commandment, and says God's command in the forbade every representation of God by the hand of man.9 But when God became a man in Jesus, he could be seen, so he could be shown.9
Catholics read the commandment as forbidding the worship of images, not every image. Why they read it that way, and why their churches have statues, is a question with its own answer.
But nothing was deleted. Catholics count the commandments the way Augustine did and Lutherans still do, and every word of the text is in their Bibles.
Sources9
- 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, The Ten Commandments (Exodus 20, Deuteronomy 5 and the traditional formula, before 2052)Prints Exodus 20:2–17 in full and Deuteronomy 5 in short beside the traditional catechetical list.
- 2Martin Luther, Small Catechism (1529), the Ten Commandments (Book of Concord)Luther's numbering: no other gods is first; the ninth and tenth are coveting, in Exodus order.
- 3Exodus 20, with notes (New American Bible)The commandments; the note says the numbering is uncertain and lists who counts which way.
- 4Deuteronomy 5 (New American Bible)The second telling of the commandments, with the neighbour's wife named before his house.
- 5Wikipedia, Ten CommandmentsThe Jewish, Augustinian, Lutheran and Reformed ways of dividing the text.
- 6Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), The Ten CommandmentsNo numbering in the Books of Moses; Augustine's division and the other one.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2066The numbering has varied; Augustine's is that of Catholics and Lutherans; the Greek Fathers' that of the Orthodox and Reformed.
- 8Heidelberg Catechism (1563), Q&A 96–98 (Christian Reformed Church)The Reformed second commandment: God may not be visibly portrayed, and images don't belong in churches.
- 9Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2129–2132No image of God by human hands; images God ordered; Nicaea II on the veneration of images.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.