From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/orthodoxy-grants-rome-a-primacy-of-honour-why
← OrthodoxOrthodoxy grants Rome a primacy of honour. Why does Rome claim more than that?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minPrimacy means being first. Both Churches agree Rome came first among the ancient churches. The say that first place was an honour. Catholics believe gave a real job, keeping the whole Church together, and that the of Rome still carries it. And a first place like that, they say, has to be able to act.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 882
- Vatican I
- Pastor Aeternus, chapters 1, 3 and 4
A of honour is a first place of respect: you're named first and you sit at the head, but you don't give the others orders.
Start with what the Orthodox actually say. They don't deny that in the first thousand years, among the great ancient churches, Rome came first.1
But for them, being first means leading, not commanding. A very old church rule that both Churches still quote, Apostolic Canon 34, says the first bishop of a region cannot do anything without the consent of all.1
For the Orthodox, a first who rules the others on his own breaks that balance.
Honour, not power: the Orthodox reasons
The Russian Orthodox Church set out the reasons in 2013.10 Christ himself is the true head, it says, and every human first comes after him.
Across the whole Church there's only an order of honour. The early councils ranked the great churches, but gave the first bishop no power over the others. Rome's first place was instituted not by God but men.10
Give one bishop power over every Church, it warns, and bishops stop being equal, and each Church loses its right to run itself. In the Orthodox Church, there was no and has never been a single administrative center.10
Since the split, the Orthodox give that first place of honour to the Patriarch of Constantinople (today's Istanbul), the Ecumenical Patriarch: first among equals, not a boss.10 Bartholomew, who holds the title today, has said Rome's old first place was honorary primacy, in love, without being legal dominion.10
So here's the real question. Is Rome first like the oldest guest at the table, or first like the one who runs the house?
What Rome claims, and why
In 1870 the , a meeting of Catholic bishops in Rome, went well beyond honour. It said Peter was given real power to govern, not just a primacy of honour, and that the can act directly in any church.2
Today's says the pope has full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church, which he can always use freely.6
The same said that when the pope solemnly defines a teaching on faith or morals for the whole Church, God keeps him from error.2
Why? Catholics point first to the . Jesus renames Simon Peter, which means rock, and gives him the keys of the kingdom.4 After rising from the dead, he asks Peter three times if he loves him, and three times tells him to feed his sheep.5
Peter was given a job: feed the flock, keep the family together.
Under Apostolic Canon 34 the first bishop does act, but with everyone's consent.1 Catholics say he must also be able to act when agreement fails. They believe that job carries on in the bishop of Rome.
In the early centuries, bishops, even from the East, appealed to Rome in disputes.3 And St , a bishop writing around AD 110, called Rome the church that presides in love.1 The Orthodox know him as Ignatius the God-Bearer.10
Think of it like this
Think of a big family with an eldest brother. At every holiday dinner he sits at the head of the table. At family meetings he speaks first. When two cousins stop talking to each other, he's the one everyone calls.
Then Grandma's house has to be sold, and there's a real decision to make. Everyone waits to hear what he thinks. But can he just decide for everyone?
This is where the family divides. Some say no: he leads, he's respected, but the decision belongs to all of them together. That's the Orthodox view of Rome.
Others say their father gave the eldest a real job before he died: keep this family together, whatever happens. And sometimes that means making the call. That's the Catholic view. A job you're not allowed to do isn't really a job.
Same verses, two readings
Many Orthodox read the verses about Peter as words for every bishop who keeps Peter's faith, not only Rome's.
The two Churches' official joint commission, which studies their differences together, found that in the West Rome's first place was tied to Peter from the 300s. But This understanding was not adopted in the East.3 And for all those appeals, Rome didn't govern the Eastern churches by church law.3
In 2023 it recorded that, for the Orthodox, the 1870 teaching is a serious break from how the early Church worked. For them, Peter was first among the , not a king over them.9
The same verses, read two ways, sit at the root of the whole question.
Power that exists to serve
Catholics stress the limits too. The 1870 council said the pope's power doesn't take away each bishop's own.2 And in 1964 the said bishops aren't the pope's deputies. Their authority is their own.7
An early pope, St , called himself servus servorum Dei: the servant of God's servants. In 1995 took that title as his own, and called it the best possible safeguard against the risk of separating power from service.11
The Catholic Church also admits the first thousand years looked different from 1870. At the Second Vatican Council, its bishops said that back then, when East and West disagreed, the Roman See by common consent acted as guide.8
A see is a bishop's seat, so the Roman See means Rome's church and its bishop. Guide, by common consent. That's very close to the Orthodox account.
Where the talks are now
In 2007, meeting at Ravenna in Italy, the joint commission said both Churches accept that Rome was first.1
The Russian Church's delegates weren't there when it was agreed. They had walked out on the first day. Their quarrel was with Constantinople, over the Orthodox Church in Estonia, not with Rome.12,13
So the text was agreed without the Russian Church in the room.
Later the Russian Church said the Ravenna text was adopted without consideration for her opinion, and it disagreed with what the text said about a first bishop for the whole Church.10
Its 2013 statement, quoted earlier, sets out that disagreement in full.
Catholics also see two roles in the pope: head of the Latin Church, which is the Western part that grew up praying in Latin, and servant of the unity of all Churches. In 2023 the commission noted a willingness to tell the two apart.9
It called that offering new opportunities for the future.9 What the pope does as head of the West needn't be the shape of what he does for the East.
Has a pope ever met the Russian Patriarch? Once. In February 2016 Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill of Moscow met at the airport in Havana, Cuba. Their joint statement calls it the first in history.14
They talked for two hours. They wrote that Catholics and Orthodox share the same spiritual of the first millennium, and they put it simply: We are not competitors but brothers.14
And the Catholic Church says openly that the Orthodox have true : real priests, a real and bishops in the apostles' line.8
Catholics believe Christ gave his Church a first bishop who can actually serve its unity. What that service should look like, East and West, is still being worked out together.
Sources14
- 1Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Ravenna Document (2007), 24, 41, 45Both sides agree Rome was first among the patriarchs; they disagree on what that allowed. Quotes Apostolic Canon 34.
- 2First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus (1870), chapters 1, 3 and 4Defines a primacy of jurisdiction, not of honour only, and says it doesn't detract from bishops' own power.
- 3Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Synodality and Primacy during the First Millennium (Chieti, 2016), 16, 19Appeals to Rome under Sardica (343); Rome did not exercise canonical authority over the East.
- 4Matthew 16 (New American Bible)Jesus calls Simon the rock and gives him the keys.
- 5John 21 (New American Bible)The risen Jesus tells Peter three times to feed his sheep.
- 6Catechism of the Catholic Church, 882The pope's full, supreme and universal power over the whole Church.
- 7Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), 27Bishops are not vicars of the pope; their authority is their own.
- 8Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 14–15In the first millennium Rome acted as guide by common consent; the Orthodox have true sacraments.
- 9Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Synodality and Primacy in the Second Millennium and Today (Alexandria, 2023), 3.10, 5.2The Orthodox judgement on Vatican I and their reasons; the willingness to separate the pope's Western role.
- 10Moscow Patriarchate, Position on the Problem of Primacy in the Universal Church (December 2013)The Russian Orthodox view: Rome's primacy was one of honour, set by the councils; disagreement with Ravenna.
- 11John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 88Gregory the Great's title servus servorum Dei as the safeguard against power cut off from service.
- 12Fr Leonid Kishkovsky, "Primacy theme of Catholic-Orthodox dialogue" (Orthodox Church in America, Holy Synod statements, 2007)An Orthodox account of why the Moscow delegation withdrew from Ravenna: the dispute with Constantinople over the Church in Estonia.
- 13Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, Joint International Commission: 2007 Plenary Session (Ravenna)The Vatican report: Moscow withdrew over the Estonian delegates despite a compromise offered by the other Orthodox.
- 14Joint Declaration of Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and All Russia, with the Patriarch's words (Havana, 12 February 2016), 1, 4, 24The first meeting in history of a pope and a Patriarch of Moscow; the shared tradition of the first millennium; "not competitors but brothers".
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.