From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/papacy-and-unity
← OrthodoxHas any pope admitted that the papacy itself is an obstacle to unity?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minYes. In 1967 Paul VI said the is the biggest obstacle to Christian unity. In 1995 asked forgiveness for the Catholic side's part in that painful history, and invited other Churches to help him find a new way of doing the pope's job. That invitation is still open.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 882
For Christians, and many Protestants, the pope is the biggest thing standing in the way of Christians coming back together.
You'd expect Rome to deny that. Instead, the clearest admissions have come from popes themselves.
Yes, in their own words
In 1967, Pope Paul VI said the pope is undoubtedly the gravest obstacle on the path of .1
Ecumenism is the work of bringing separated Christians back together. So a pope said, out loud, that his own job was its biggest roadblock.
In 1987, Pope John Paul II welcomed the Ecumenical Patriarch, first in honour among the Orthodox , to St 's in Rome.1,9
He admitted that, against the will of all concerned, what should have been a service had sometimes looked like something very different.2 And he asked the pastors and theologians of both Churches to look, together, of course, for a way of doing his job that everyone could recognise as a service of love.1
In 1995 he wrote a letter about Christian unity. He said the Catholic belief about the pope is hard for most other Christians, because of painful memories. And he wrote: To the extent that we are responsible for these, I join my Predecessor Paul VI in asking forgiveness.2
Why a pope would say this
Because of what Catholics believe the job is for. The calls the pope the perpetual and visible source and foundation of the unity of bishops and believers.8
So if that office has become a cause of division, that's a problem for Catholics first, not only for their critics.
Behind it is a line Catholics draw carefully: what the pope's job is, and how it's done. The first, they believe, comes from . The second has changed a lot over the centuries. A 2024 Vatican study says that line is what gave hope for real talks.1
What he asked for
John Paul II pointed back to the first thousand years, when Rome helped settle disputes between East and West with everyone's agreement.2
And he said he couldn't fix this alone: This is an immense task, which we cannot refuse and which I cannot carry out by myself. So he asked leaders and scholars of other Churches to join him in a patient and fraternal dialogue.2
Think of it like this
Picture the longest-serving stallholder at a busy town market. He's been there forty years. When the market was new, everyone looked to him to sort things out, and he was good at it.
But over the years he started deciding everything. Who sweeps up. Who gets the corner spot. What time the gates open. Some of the other stallholders got fed up, and a few stopped talking to him altogether.
Then one morning he walks from stall to stall. He says sorry for the way he's handled things. And then he asks each of them a question: how should I do this job so it actually helps you?
He doesn't hand in his keys. He still thinks the market needs someone to hold it together. But he's asking the people he's hurt to help him rewrite how he does it. That's roughly what John Paul II did.
The catch
To be honest, the invitation came with a limit. He wanted a way of doing the job that was open to a new situation, but in no way renouncing what is essential to its mission.2
And the Orthodox point out the catch. What Rome counts as essential is the pope's authority as the defined it in 1870. That's exactly what the two Churches still list as an open question.3
Saying sorry for how a job was done isn't the same as changing what the job claims.
Thirty years later
Progress has been slow, and a pope said so.
In 2013 Pope Francis wrote, We have made little progress in this regard.1
Did the Orthodox Churches write back to John Paul II? Not officially. About 30 replies came in, mostly from and Anglican Churches in Europe and North America. The 2024 study notes that There were no official answers from the Orthodox Churches.1
Their views have come mainly through the official dialogue. The Russian Church, for one, replied to the dialogue's 2007 text on the pope's first place with a paper of its own in 2013.1,9
But things have moved. Since 2007 the official Catholic–Orthodox dialogue commission has agreed three joint texts on how bishops and the first bishop worked together through history.3,7,6
The 2024 Vatican study gathered the ideas that keep coming up in the talks. Two stand out. Reread what was decided in 1870, maybe even in new words. And draw a clearer line between the pope as head of the Western Church and the pope as servant of unity for everyone.1
Others ask for more shared decision-making inside the Catholic Church, and regular meetings of the leaders of all the Churches.1 That's what could change: not the claim itself, but how it's lived, and with whom.
Sister Churches
In November 2025, the pope and Bartholomew, today's Ecumenical Patriarch, met at Nicaea in Turkey, where the Creed was first agreed 1,700 years before.5
The next day they signed a statement looking towards the hoped-for restoration of between our sister Churches.4 Full means being one Church again, sharing one altar. And sister Churches is what both now call each other.
None of this changes the Catholic belief that the pope's role comes from Christ. But popes have put on record that the way it's been used has hurt unity.
To be clear, nothing official has changed yet. No pope or has reread the 1870 teaching, and the Churches still don't share one altar.3
And a better way has to be found together with the other Churches, not handed to them.
Sources9
- 1Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, The Bishop of Rome (2024), Introduction 2–5, 12, 30–31 and 177–181Quotes Paul VI (1967) and Francis (Evangelii Gaudium 32, 2013); the responses to Ut Unum Sint, none official from the Orthodox; proposals for a renewed papacy.
- 2John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 88, 95, 96The papacy as a difficulty, the request for forgiveness, and the invitation to find a new way.
- 3Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Ravenna Document (2007), 45Names how to understand Vatican I and II on primacy as the crucial open question.
- 4Joint Declaration of Pope Leo XIV and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew (29 November 2025)Commits both Churches to the path towards full communion between sister Churches.
- 5USCCB / Catholic News Service, Though Nicaea is a ruin, its Creed stands (28 November 2025)Report of the joint recitation of the Creed at İznik, without the filioque.
- 6Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, International Catholic-Orthodox Dialogue (9 June 2023)The Alexandria meeting agreed Synodality and Primacy in the Second Millennium and Today.
- 7Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Synodality and Primacy during the First Millennium (Chieti, 2016)The agreed reading of the first thousand years.
- 8Catechism of the Catholic Church, 882The pope as the visible source and foundation of unity.
- 9Moscow Patriarchate, Position on the Problem of Primacy in the Universal Church (December 2013)The Russian Orthodox view: Rome's primacy was one of honour, set by the councils; disagreement with Ravenna.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.