Full text
Another faith · About 8 min ·  · Jesus and God

Isn't Jesus just one enlightened teacher among many? Didn't he study in India?

The short answer

Jesus was a great teacher, but he never presented himself as one teacher among many. He spoke as if he shared God's own name and authority. And the story that he studied in India comes from an 1894 book that was quickly shown to be a hoax.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The question

This question usually comes from a generous place. Some Hindus honour Jesus as a holy man.

Some see him as an avatar: God coming into the world in a personal form.

In the Bhagavad Gita, a Hindu holy book, Krishna, speaking as God, says he comes age after age.

Some Buddhists see Jesus as a wise, awakened teacher. Muslims honour him as a prophet: more than a teacher, but not God.

Either way, Jesus gets a place of honour, next to others. And the Catholic Church returns that respect.

In 1965 its , meeting at the , said it honours what is true and holy in other religions.

So the question isn't whether Jesus was wise. It's whether one teacher among many fits what he said about himself.

Part 2 · What Jesus said about himself

Look at what he actually said, starting with Mark, the earliest of the four , the books about his life.

At his trial, Jesus was questioned by the high priest, the top Jewish religious leader.

The high priest asked: Are you the Messiah, the son of the Blessed One?

The Blessed One was a Jewish way of saying God. So he was asking: are you the rescuer God promised, the ?

Jesus answered: I am. The high priest tore his clothes and called it blasphemy, an insult to God.

Mark tells of an earlier moment too. Jesus said to a paralysed man: Child, your sins are forgiven.

The religious lawyers watching thought: Who but God alone can forgive sins?

John, the last of the Gospels to be written, has something even stranger. Jesus says: before Abraham came to be, I AM.

, the father of the Jewish people, had lived many centuries before.

His listeners picked up stones to throw at him. Why such anger?

A footnote in a Catholic explains that Jewish tradition heard I AM as God's own name for himself.

To be fair, most critical scholars don't take the long speeches in John as Jesus's own words. They see them as John's telling.

But the point doesn't hang on John. Even in Mark, Jesus forgives , which only God can do, and answers I am at his trial.

In John he goes further still. He uses God's name.

He wasn't pointing to a path. He was pointing to himself.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a school with lots of good teachers.

One makes maths finally click. Another makes history come alive. A third is the one every student goes to when life falls apart.

You'd happily call them all great teachers. Now imagine one of them walks onto the stage at a school assembly and takes the microphone.

He says: I'm the principal's son. This school is mine. The rules here are my rules. The hall goes completely quiet.

You can't just file him as another good teacher after that. Either he's telling the truth, or he's badly mistaken, or he's lying.

But nice teacher is off the table.

Jesus's claim was bigger, about God himself, but the logic is the same. He didn't leave room to be just one of the staff.

Many Muslims, and many skeptical scholars, would add a fourth option.

Maybe Jesus never said these things, and the Gospels were changed later.

Whether they were changed is a fair question about the sources, and part of the answer is already here.

The claim isn't only in John. It's in Mark too.

It's even in the letters of , an early Christian leader who had once hunted Jesus's followers down.

Paul wrote them about 20 years after Jesus.

There Paul sets Jesus right beside God the Father: one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom all things are.

Whether the Gospels were changed later has its own full answer, under the question Wasn't the Bible changed over time?

Part 3 · Who Christians believe he is

So who do Christians believe Jesus is? They believe the one God is Father, Son and .

And they believe God the Son became one of us. That's Jesus.

The Catholic Church teaches that he became man once, in one place and time.

Its , the summary of what it believes, says: He became truly man while remaining truly God.

In 2000 the Vatican, the Catholic Church's headquarters in Rome, looked hard at the idea that Jesus is just one of many faces of God.

It said such ideas are in profound conflict with the Christian faith.

Why so firm? Look at the Letter to the Hebrews, a book from the , the part of the Bible written after Jesus.

It says God once spoke through prophets, meaning people who carried his message.

Long ago, it says, God spoke in many and various ways.

But in the end, it says, God has spoken to us by a Son. A prophet brings God's word. Christians believe Jesus is God's Word.

The Catechism quotes those words, and then says:

In him he has said everything; there will be no other word than this one.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 65

Here's the real difference from an avatar. In the Gita, God comes age after age, in many forms.

Christians believe God became one particular man, once. Saying so isn't a put-down of Krishna's devotees. It's two different pictures of how God comes close.

It's a real difference from other great teachers too. The Second Vatican Council said Buddhism teaches a way to acquire the state of perfect liberation.

Or, it said, a way to attain, by their own efforts or through higher help, supreme illumination.

Christians don't believe Jesus found a way up by his own efforts and showed it to others. They believe God came down in him.

Part 4 · Did he study in India?

Now the India story, and it's a proper detective tale. In 1894 a traveller named Nicolas Notovitch published a book.

He said monks at Hemis, a monastery in Ladakh in India's far north, had shown him an old text about Saint Issa.

Isa is the Arabic name for Jesus. But the story fell apart fast.

In 1895 a professor travelled to Hemis to check. The head monk signed a statement. It said: There is no such book in the monastery.

A famous Oxford scholar of the day, Max Müller, had first wondered in 1894 whether the monks had fooled Notovitch.

After the check at Hemis, he took that back, in 1896. Of Notovitch, he wrote:

He was not hoaxed, but he tried to hoax us. Nobody fooled him. He was the one doing the fooling.

To be fair, in 1922 a Hindu monk, Swami Abhedananda, said he was shown such a text there.

Still, Bart Ehrman, a skeptical Bible scholar, says there is not a single recognized scholar on the planet who doubts it was made up.

And the Gospels point the other way. In Jesus's home town, Nazareth, people asked: Is he not the carpenter?

They knew him as a local tradesman, not a man back from years abroad.

There's a second India story, about the end of his life. Christians believe he died on the cross, and rose from the dead.

Some say Jesus survived the cross, travelled to Kashmir, and is buried in Srinagar, in a shrine called the Roza Bal.

That claim is younger than it sounds. Locals long said a holy man called Yuz Asaf was buried there.

In 1899 the founder of the Ahmadiyya, a Muslim movement in India, declared it was Jesus. Ahmadi Muslims still hold it today.

And the name may point somewhere unexpected. Scholars trace Yuzasaf back through Arabic and Persian to the Sanskrit word Bodhisattva.

In an old legend, it's a name for the Buddha.

Historians who have studied the claim reject it, and so do the shrine's own Muslim caretakers.

Most Muslims believe God took Jesus up to . One caretaker said the idea that Jesus is buried anywhere on earth is blasphemous to Islam.

Part 5 · What this means for other faiths

None of this makes the Buddha or the Hindu sages worthless.

The Catholic Church says what's good in other religions often reflects the truth that lights up every person.

Christians believe that light has a face and a name: Jesus.

Here's the real difference, and it's said with respect. Christians don't believe he found the light on a journey, in India or anywhere else.

They believe he is that light, come close to us. And that's something you can weigh for yourself.

Quick check

Back to the school assembly. After what that teacher said, can you still call him just another good teacher?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 17
  1. Bhagavad Gita 4.8, trans. and commentary Swami Mukundananda (Bhagavad Gita, The Song of God) · Krishna: to protect the righteous and reestablish dharma, I appear on this earth, age after age; the commentary on God's descent.
  2. Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (28 October 1965), 2–3 · The Church rejects nothing true and holy in other religions; Muslims revere Jesus as a prophet.
  3. Mark 14:61–64 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus before the high priest: I am.
  4. John 8:24–59 and notes (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Before Abraham came to be, I AM; the footnote on God's self-designation.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 464–469 (true God and true man) · He became truly man while remaining truly God.
  6. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dominus Iesus (6 August 2000), 9–10, 15 · Rejects the idea that Jesus is one of many faces of the divine; his unique significance.
  7. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 65–67 (Christ, God's last Word) · In his Son God has said everything; there will be no other word.
  8. Wikipedia, Nicolas Notovitch · The 1894 Unknown Life of Jesus Christ and the Hemis claim; Abhedananda's 1922 account; Ehrman's verdict.
  9. J. Archibald Douglas, "The Chief Lama of Himis on the Alleged 'Unknown Life of Christ'", The Nineteenth Century 39 (1896), with Max Müller's postscript (text on the Internet Archive) · The head lama's signed statement of 3 June 1895: no injured European, no Life of Issa; Müller: he tried to hoax us.
  10. Mark 6:1–3 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · His home town knew him as the carpenter.
  11. Wikipedia, Tahrif · The Muslim belief that earlier scriptures, including the Gospel, were altered in text or in meaning.
  12. Wikipedia, Roza Bal · The Srinagar shrine of Yuz Asaf; Ghulam Ahmad's 1899 claim; Yuzasaf from Bodhisattva; rejected by scholars and by the Sunni caretakers.
  13. Mark 2:1–12 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus forgives the paralysed man's sins; the scribes ask who but God alone can forgive sins.
  14. Wikipedia, Gospel · Mark is generally agreed to be the first gospel; John dated AD 90–100.
  15. Wikipedia, Gospel of John · Since the 19th century scholars have agreed the Johannine discourses are less likely to be historical than the synoptic parables, and were written for theological purposes.
  16. 1 Corinthians 8 (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Verse 6: one God, the Father, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom all things are.
  17. 1 Corinthians, introduction (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Paul wrote the letter from Ephesus about the year 56.