Did Rome change the Creed without an ecumenical council?
On the history, yes. The words and the Son were added to the Creed in the West without a council of the whole Church, and the Catholic Church admits it. What Catholics deny is that those words changed the faith the Creed teaches.
Part 1 · A few extra words
Every Sunday, many Christians stand in church and say the Creed together, a short statement of what they believe.
Most of it was agreed at two , in 325 and 381.
The 381 Creed says the proceeds from the Father.
In other words, he comes forth from the Father. The Churches of the East still say exactly that, and no more.
But in most Catholic churches in the West, you'll hear a few extra words. The Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son.
In Latin, the language of the Western Church, that's one word: filioque. East and West have argued about it for over a thousand years.
It was one of the two big issues when East and West split, a break usually dated to 1054.
The other was the role of the .
So did Rome change the Creed on its own?
Part 2 · Yes, it really happened
Here's the surprising part. The Catholic Church agrees with the Orthodox on what happened.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says the words weren't in the Creed of 381.
It says they were added in the West bit by bit, between the 700s and the 1000s.
It even calls them a point of disagreement with the Orthodox Churches.
The words first show up in the Creed in Spain in 589, said by the Goths, a people ruling Spain who had just become Catholic.
They probably didn't know the words were extra. From there they spread through France and Germany.
But Rome itself held back. Around 810 Pope Leo III agreed with the idea.
But he refused to add the words, because the old councils had banned additions.
He had the Creed engraved on two silver shields at St 's in Rome, without the extra words.
Rome only started using the longer Creed at in 1014.
The pope gave in to the urgent request of the king of Germany.
So why were the words added? It wasn't to pick a fight with the East.
Some in the West, like the Goths until they became Catholic, believed the Son was less than the Father.
The words stressed that the Spirit and Son share one divine nature.
And the idea is older than the words. A pope taught it in 447, before Rome had even received the Creed of 381.
Part 3 · The Orthodox case, at full strength
Now here's the other side, and it's strong. In 431 a banned writing a different creed to rival the agreed one.
A creed the whole Church agreed can only be changed by the whole Church.
Photius was patriarch of Constantinople in the 800s, and the Orthodox honour him as a saint.
He was the first great teacher to accuse Rome of heresy, teaching that breaks with the faith, over these words.
For him, they struck at the heart of who God is.
In 879–880 a council in Constantinople, with the pope's own envoys there, repeated the ban on changing the Creed.
Many Orthodox count it as a council of the whole Church, later confirmed by the pope.
Historians still argue about that, Catholic ones included.
One older Catholic reference book says the pope refused to confirm it. Others think he accepted it.
And many Orthodox think the words are wrong, not just added.
The Orthodox Church in America says they aren't backed by Scripture, and don't fit the Orthodox understanding of God.
Some Orthodox see a way to read them that works: the Spirit comes from the Father through the Son.
A great Eastern monk put it that way in the 600s. What most reject is making the Son a second source of the Spirit.
Here's an analogy that might help. Picture an apartment block with house rules agreed by every resident at a big meeting years ago.
A copy hangs on the noticeboard on every floor.
Then one floor has a problem. People there keep misreading the rule about bicycles in the corridor.
So they reprint their copy with one extra line to make it clearer, and pin it up by the lift.
Within a few years, everyone on that floor knows the longer version by heart.
One day a neighbour from another floor comes up and reads it. The extra line might be perfectly true.
But the first thing she asks is: who said you could change our notice?
The Orthodox complaint is just that: one floor changed a text that belonged to the whole building.
The Catholic reply is that the extra line explains the rule. It doesn't change it.
Many Orthodox answer that it does change it. And either way, they say, it wasn't one floor's text to rewrite.
Part 4 · What Catholics answer
In Catholic eyes, the ban of 431 was against a different faith, a rival to the one agreed at Nicaea in 325.
The extra words explain that same faith, not replace it. The Catechism says the West uses them legitimately and with good reason.
In 1438–39, Greek from the East and Latin bishops from the West met at Florence, in Italy, to end the split.
Together they agreed the words had been added rightly, to make the truth clearer.
But here's the honest part. The emperor in Constantinople badly needed the West's help against the Ottoman Turks.
The Greek bishops signed under heavy pressure from him, all except one, St Mark of Ephesus.
Back home, nearly the whole Orthodox world rejected the deal. So for the Orthodox, Florence doesn't count as a council of the whole Church.
For Catholics it does. Underneath it all is one question: who gets to decide?
Part 5 · The original still comes first
The Catholic Church treats the original Greek Creed of 381 as the standard. A 1995 Vatican document says it can never be taken back.
It says that Creed expresses:
the one common faith of the Church and of all Christians
So Rome won't add the words when the Creed is said in Greek, even in its own Greek-speaking churches.
Praying the original, the document says, remains always legitimate in the Catholic Church.
So something beautiful could happen in November 2025. The pope and Bartholomew, the Ecumenical Patriarch, said the Creed together at Nicaea, now İznik in Turkey.
Bartholomew is first in honour among the Orthodox bishops. It was the Creed's 1,700th birthday, and they said it without the added words.
So yes, the West added the words without the whole Church. But Catholics don't believe that changed the faith of 381.
How East and West settle it together is still on the table.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 11
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 245–248 · The Creed of 381, the filioque's history in the West, and the two traditions as complementary.
- First Council of Constantinople (381), the Creed and canons (NPNF translation, New Advent) · The Creed: the Spirit "proceeds from the Father".
- Council of Ephesus (431), canon 7 (NPNF translation, New Advent) · Forbids composing a different faith as a rival to Nicaea's.
- Henry R. Percival, Excursus on the words "and the Son", Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers II.14 (1900) · Toledo 589, Leo III's silver shields, and Rome's use of the addition from 1014.
- Council of Florence, Laetentur Caeli (6 July 1439) · Defines the filioque and says the words were lawfully added to the Creed.
- Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, The Greek and Latin Traditions regarding the Procession of the Holy Spirit (1995) · The Greek Creed of 381 as normative; Rome refuses the addition in Greek.
- Catholic News Service via USCCB, "Though Nicaea is a ruin, its Creed stands" (28 November 2025) · Leo XIV and Bartholomew recite the Creed at İznik without the filioque.
- Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 1: The Holy Spirit · The Orthodox view: the filioque is unscriptural and inconsistent with Orthodox faith.
- Orthodox Church in America, Church History: The Great Schism in the Papacy and the Conciliar Movement · The Greek bishops at Florence, St Mark of Ephesus, and the union's rejection.
- OrthodoxWiki, Filioque · The Orthodox case: the addition breaks the ban of 431, repeated at Constantinople in 879–880.
- Catholic Encyclopedia, “Photius of Constantinople” (1911) · The Catholic account of the synod of 879–880: John VIII refused to confirm its acts and excommunicated Photius again.