Council of Florence
In 1439 Catholics and Orthodox sign another reunion at Florence, and again most of the Orthodox reject it at home.
By the 1430s the Ottoman Turks had nearly surrounded Constantinople. Emperor John VIII and Patriarch Joseph II came to Italy with some 700 Greeks, hoping that church union would bring Western soldiers.
For over a year at Ferrara and Florence, Greek and Latin theologians argued over the Holy Spirit, purgatory, the bread of the Eucharist and the pope's authority.
On 6 July 1439 a decree of union was read in Greek and Latin in Florence cathedral. Every Greek bishop but Mark of Ephesus signed, yet at home clergy and people rejected it.
Western help failed at Varna in 1444, and on 29 May 1453 Constantinople fell to the Ottomans. Today 23 Eastern Catholic Churches are in communion with Rome; the Orthodox Churches are not, divided still over the pope's role and the Filioque.
The situation
By the 1430s the Byzantine Empire was little more than the city of Constantinople. The Ottoman Turks had crossed into Europe, defeated the Serbs at Kosovo in 1389 and crushed a Western crusade at Nicopolis in 1396.
Emperor John VIII Palaiologos needed soldiers from the West. As at Lyon in 1274, the price on offer was church union. Both the and a rival church in Basel offered to pay for the Greeks to come and talk.
The West was divided too. The council at Basel, in Switzerland, claimed authority over the pope. Pope Eugenius IV moved it to Ferrara in Italy; most of those at Basel refused to go, and in 1439 they elected a rival pope.
The Greeks chose the pope. About 700 of them came to Italy: the emperor, Patriarch Joseph II of Constantinople, and speaking for the patriarchs of Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
From Basel to Ferrara to Florence
The editors' introduction traces the council's movements and the sequence of unions it produced.
“The Greek bishops and theologians attended the council of Ferrara from 9 April 1438. The council was transferred to Florence on 10 January 1439. There, in the session on 6 July 1439, the decree of union with the Greek church was approved. Subsequently decrees of union with the Armenian and Coptic churches were approved.”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · editorial introduction (Tanner) on the papalencyclicals.net page - 02
Why the Greeks came to Italy at all
A reference dictionary of the Christian East summarises the tangle of Basel, the pope and the Greeks that preceded the council.
“The Greeks engaged in lengthy discussions with representatives from both Basel and Eugenius IV. Various motives, theological and otherwise, led them to accept the pope's offer.”
Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Florence, Council of' - 03
Why the Greeks chose the pope over the council at Basel
The Orthodox history notes that the emperor and patriarch had two Western invitations, from the Council of Basel and from Eugenius IV, and that by choosing the pope they strengthened the papacy against the conciliar movement before a word of theology was spoken.
“Understandably, Emperor John VIII and Patriarch Joseph II of Constantinople were much more accustomed to dealing directly with the Bishop of Old Rome rather than with a council—especially a council that the Pope was resisting! So, very fatefully, they decided to meet with the Pope instead of with the Council of Basle. This decision in itself gave a great boost to the prestige and authority of the Papacy over against the Conciliar Movement.”
The Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Fifteenth Century — The Great Schism in the Papacy, and the Conciliar Movement · Church History, fifteenth century
What was at stake
Four questions divided the Churches: the , the West's ‘and the Son’ in the creed; , a cleansing after death; and whether the could use unleavened bread. The fourth was the : the pope's place as first among bishops, and what power it gives him.
This time, unlike at Lyon, the Greek Church's best theologians came to argue. Mark Eugenikos, archbishop of Ephesus, became the leading voice against accepting the Latin positions. Bessarion, archbishop of Nicaea, came to support union.
The hard question was whether the two sides believed different things or the same thing in different words. And the Greeks were arguing far from home, on the Latin side's money, while their city waited under threat.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
The Filioque, argued for months from both sets of Fathers
The decree itself describes the method: texts from Scripture and from Eastern and Western doctors, and the discovery that 'from the Father and the Son' and 'from the Father through the Son' were aiming at one meaning.
“Texts were produced from divine scriptures and many authorities of eastern and western holy doctors, some saying the holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, others saying the procession is from the Father through the Son. All were aiming at the same meaning in different words.”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6 (6 July 1439), decree of union with the Greeks
The event
Sessions began in Ferrara on 9 April 1438, first on purgatory, then on the Filioque. Many Greeks talked of going home, but the emperor would not let them. In January 1439, with plague in Ferrara, the council moved to Florence.
There Bessarion and Isidore of Kiev came out for the Latin teaching. After Eugenius promised military and financial help, the Greeks accepted in June that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son as from one source. Patriarch Joseph II died in Florence on 10 June.
On 6 July 1439 the decree of union, Laetentur caeli, ‘Let the heavens be glad’, was read in Greek and Latin in Florence cathedral. It accepted ‘and the Son’ in the creed, taught cleansing after death, and let each Church keep its own bread.
It also defined the pope's primacy over the whole Church, with the patriarchs keeping their rights. Every Greek bishop signed except Mark of Ephesus, who refused.
The Latins stayed on and made similar unions with other Eastern Churches, among them the Armenians in 1439 and the Copts of Egypt in 1442.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
'Let the heavens be glad'
The decree's opening words, from which it takes its Latin name, Laetentur caeli.
“Let the heavens be glad and let the earth rejoice. For, the wall that divided the western and the eastern church has been removed, peace and harmony have returned”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6, decree of union - 02
The definition on the Spirit and on the creed
The council defined the procession 'as from one principle and a single spiration', and declared the words 'and from the Son' licitly added to the creed.
“that the holy Spirit is eternally from the Father and the Son, and has his essence and his subsistent being from the Father together with the Son, and proceeds from both eternally as from one principle and a single spiration. ... We define also that the explanation of those words “and from the Son” was licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake of declaring the truth and from imminent need.”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6, decree of union - 03
Bread, purgatory and the primacy
The decree settles the bread of the Eucharist by allowing each church its custom, affirms cleansing after death and the value of prayers for the dead, and defines the Roman primacy.
“the body of Christ is truly confected in both unleavened and leavened wheat bread, and priests should confect the body of Christ in either, that is, each priest according to the custom of his western or eastern church. ... their souls are cleansed after death by cleansing pains; and the suffrages of the living faithful avail them in giving relief from such pains ... We also define that the holy apostolic see and the Roman pontiff holds the primacy over the whole world and the Roman pontiff is the successor of blessed Peter prince of the apostles, and that he is the true vicar of Christ, the head of the whole church and the father and teacher of all Christians”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6, decree of union - 04
The order of the patriarchs kept
The decree ends by confirming Constantinople's place second after Rome, with the other patriarchates in their canonical order.
“the patriarch of Constantinople should be second after the most holy Roman pontiff, third should be the patriarch of Alexandria, fourth the patriarch of Antioch, and fifth the patriarch of Jerusalem, without prejudice to all their privileges and rights.”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6, decree of union
The outcome
Back home, the signers met fury. Mark led the opposition, strongest among monks and ordinary people. Some of the bishops who had signed took back their support.
In Moscow, Isidore of Kiev, now a cardinal, tried to proclaim the union; he was arrested and barely escaped. The one big crusade the union brought was destroyed by the Ottomans at Varna in November 1444, leaving Constantinople all but defenceless.
The union was finally proclaimed in Hagia Sophia on 12 December 1452, as the Turks gathered. Most people stood with its opponents. One senior official was remembered as saying: ‘We would prefer to see the Turkish turban in our City than the Latin tiara.’
On 29 May 1453 the Ottomans took Constantinople, and , the last emperor, died in the fighting. Hagia Sophia became a mosque. The first patriarch under the sultan was George Scholarios, Mark's chosen successor in opposing the union.
Today 23 , with their own liturgies and bishops, are in with Rome: they share one Eucharist and one church life. The Churches are not. The pope's role and the Filioque still divide them.
Go furtherFold· 6 notes, each with its source
- 01
The Turkish turban and the Latin tiara
The Orthodox history records how the union was finally proclaimed in Constantinople, months before the city fell, and how most people received it.
“The Union of Florence was not publicly proclaimed in the Eastern Church until December 12, 1452, in the Cathedral of Hagia Sophia in Constantinople, as the Turks were amassing their forces to begin their siege of the city. Even at that most desperate moment, there was so much popular resistance to the Union that most of the people stood behind George Scholarios”
The Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Fifteenth Century — The Great Schism in the Papacy, and the Conciliar Movement · Church History, fifteenth century - 02
Varna, 1444, and the fall of the city
The Catholic Encyclopedia's account of how the last Western help ended, and of the final assault.
“This defeat left Constantinople defenceless.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' - 03
Mark of Ephesus refuses, and Constantinople follows him
The reference dictionary records that Mark Eugenicus would not subscribe and, back home, led the movement that blocked the union.
“he refused to subscribe to the union reached in Florence on 7 June and solemnly proclaimed on 6 July 1439. Upon his return to Constantinople, he took advantage of the freedom accorded him by Emperor John VIII to initiate a movement to block putting the decree of union into effect. His campaign was successful especially among the lower classes and the monks, although it personally cost him two years in prison on the island of Lemnos.”
Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Mark Eugenicus' - 04
Rome's own account two months later
In September 1439 the council described the union as ending a schism of 'almost five hundred years', and announced that Armenian representatives had arrived to seek union too.
“the most disastrous schism, which had endured in God’s church for almost five hundred years to the immense harm of the whole of Christianity, ... was removed and the most holy union of the Greeks and the Latins was happily achieved”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 7 (4 September 1439) - 05
Run out of Moscow
The union's reception in the Orthodox world, in one incident: one of its major architects went to Moscow to impose it and was run out of the city.
“When the Greek Metropolitan Isidore of Kiev and All Russia, one of the major architects of the Union of Florence, traveled to Moscow to try to impose the Union there, he was run out of the city, barely escaping with his life.”
The Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Fifteenth Century — The Great Schism in the Papacy, and the Conciliar Movement · Church History, fifteenth century - 06
Twenty-three Eastern Catholic Churches
The Catholic Church today is a communion of the Latin Church and 23 Eastern Churches with their own traditions.
“the Catholic Church is actually composed of 24 “sui iuris” or autonomous Churches: the Latin Church and 23 Eastern Catholic Churches”
The 23 Eastern Catholic Churches: Ancient traditions in communion with Rome · Catholic World Report, 20 September 2026
For the trail
Florence came closer to reunion than anything since 1054: long debate, agreed texts, every Greek bishop but one signing. It still failed, because the clergy and people at home would not accept it.
Its terms later became the basis on which parts of Eastern Churches joined Rome while keeping their own , such as the Ruthenians at Brest in 1596 and the Melkites in 1724. Each time, it split the Church they came from.
In 1993, at Balamand, Catholic and Orthodox theologians agreed that this way of seeking unity ‘can no longer be accepted’. The Churches now talk as equals, and in November 2025 Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew prayed the creed together at Nicaea.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
The pattern for later unions
Florence's decrees, not Lyon's, are the terms on which later Eastern churches entered communion with Rome while keeping their rites: Brest in 1596, the Melkites in 1724. The decree's own rule on leavened and unleavened bread is the first sign of that method.
“each priest according to the custom of his western or eastern church”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6, decree of union - 02
Balamand, 1993: no longer the method
Catholic and Orthodox theologians rejected 'uniatism', bringing part of an Eastern Church over to Rome, as the way to unity, while affirming the Eastern Catholic Churches' right to exist.
“this form of "missionary apostolate" described above, and which has been called "uniatism", can no longer be accepted either as a method to be followed nor as a model of the unity our Churches are seeking.”
Uniatism, Method of Union of the Past, and the Present Search for Full Communion · Balamand Document §12
What the Church says
The Church counts Florence as the seventeenth ecumenical council. Its teaching on the Holy Spirit, purgatory and the pope's primacy remains Catholic doctrine, and the First Vatican Council built on its decree on the papacy.
The Church no longer seeks unity by bringing parts of Eastern Churches over one at a time. Since the Balamand statement of 1993 it seeks full communion with the Orthodox through dialogue between sister Churches, while upholding the Eastern Catholic Churches' right to exist (Balamand Document 12, 3).
Think of it like this
A second merger attempt, with better lawyers and the same result.
This time the Greek theologians were present and argued for months, and the decree was read aloud in both languages in Florence cathedral. Mark of Ephesus refused to sign, Constantinople repudiated it, and fourteen years later the city fell to the Turks. The terms of Florence did, however, become the template by which Eastern churches later entered communion one at a time.
“that the holy Spirit is eternally from the Father and the Son, and has his essence and his subsistent being from the Father together with the Son, and proceeds from both eternally as from one principle and a single spiration. ... We define also that the explanation of those words “and from the Son” was licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake of declaring the truth and from imminent need.”
The definition on the Filioque that the Greek delegation signed and Constantinople rejected.
Where people disagree
Was it agreement or pressure? The Orthodox account says the Greek bishops were ‘strongly pressured’ by their own emperor and patriarch. The decree says union came after ‘a long and very toilsome investigation’.
Catholic historians stress that the debates lasted over a year and that Greek theologians such as Bessarion argued for union themselves. Orthodox historians stress that the Greeks were far from home, on Latin money, with their city under threat. Both are in the record.
Mark of Ephesus is a saint in the Orthodox Church, honoured as one of the ‘Three Pillars of Orthodoxy’. For Catholics, Florence is the seventeenth ecumenical council, meaning a general council of the whole Church, and its teaching stands.
The same man is a hero to one Church and the man who blocked unity to the other.
Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
- 01
Duress, or argument?
Orthodox accounts say the Greeks signed under pressure; the decree itself insists on 'a long and very toilsome investigation'. Both readings are in the record. The Orthodox one follows, in the Orthodox Church's own words.
“After a long and very toilsome investigation, at last by the clemency of the holy Spirit they have achieved this greatly desired and most holy union”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks · Session 6, decree of union - 02
Mark of Ephesus's reasons, as the dictionary states them
The same entry gives the theological ground of his refusal: he held the Latin positions on the Filioque and other points to be heretical.
“he opposed any agreement with the Latins whatsoever, despised their arguments and considered their positions on the doctrine of the Filioque and on other points heretical.”
Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Mark Eugenicus' - 03
'Strongly pressured': the Orthodox account of the signing
The Orthodox history does not deny that the debates were long; it says the Greeks were under orders from their own emperor and patriarch to accept Rome's terms whatever they were.
“The Greek delegation was strongly pressured by both the Emperor and the Patriarch to accede to Rome's terms for reunion, whatever they might be. So, after long and sometimes bitter debating, the Greeks finally agreed to accept”
The Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Fifteenth Century — The Great Schism in the Papacy, and the Conciliar Movement · Church History, fifteenth century - 04
All signed but one, and the pope knew what that meant
Every Greek bishop signed except Mark of Ephesus. The Orthodox history records the remark attributed to Eugenius IV on hearing it.
“Under severe pressure from the Emperor and the Patriarch, every bishop in the Greek delegation signed this so-called “Decree for the Greeks” promulgated at the Council of Florence—all except Saint Mark, Bishop of Ephesus. When told that Mark had refused to sign, Pope Eugenius is reputed to have said, “Then we have accomplished nothing.””
The Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Fifteenth Century — The Great Schism in the Papacy, and the Conciliar Movement · Church History, fifteenth century - 05
What the Orthodox made of Mark
The man who refused to sign is a saint in the Orthodox Church and one of its 'Three Pillars'. That is the measure of how Florence is remembered in the East.
“for his courageous resistance to this unjust union, and for his eloquent defense of Orthodoxy over against the errors of Latin Scholastic theology—especially their positions on the filioque and purgatory—he is popularly venerated in the Orthodox Church as one of the Three Pillars of Orthodoxy, along with Saint Photios the Great and Saint Gregory Palamas”
The Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Fifteenth Century — The Great Schism in the Papacy, and the Conciliar Movement · Church History, fifteenth century
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Council of Florence · 1439-07-06 · papalencyclicals.net
- Orthodox Church in America (series by Fr Thomas Hopko; author not named on the page) · Orthodox Church in America (oca.org)