Full text
Another faith · About 8 min ·  · Other religions

Can I be Buddhist and Catholic at once? Can Catholics meditate or do yoga?

The short answer

You can't hold both as your faith, because they answer life's biggest questions differently. But Catholics can learn a lot from Buddhists, and they can meditate and stretch. The Church's test is simple: does the practice lead you to the God who loves you, or replace him?

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · Two answers, not one

In many families, especially in Asia, it's normal to visit a temple and a church. Plenty of people meditate, or do yoga.

So does becoming Catholic mean giving all that up?

Start with what's true. Buddhism has a lot to admire.

The Buddha, the teacher whose path Buddhists follow, taught that craving is the root of suffering. And he offered a practical way out of it.

But Buddhism is more than meditation. Most Buddhists don't believe in a God who made the world.

They see life as a cycle of rebirths, until nirvana: the end of craving and suffering.

So the real question isn't the cushion or the posture. It's what the practice is for.

Here's where they differ. Catholics believe in a God who is a person, who made the world out of love.

And they believe each person lives once. There's no coming back for other lives on earth.

After this life, Christians hope to be brought home to God, for a life with him that never ends.

Buddhism traces suffering to craving, fed by greed, hatred and ignorance. The way out of it is awakening.

Christians see the deepest problem as : a broken relationship with God, who gives us life.

So for Christians the way out is a person: Jesus, who they believe is God become one of us.

Those are different answers, not the same answer in different words.

The same goes for being Hindu and Catholic at once. You can honour both, but you can't live by both answers.

And one of the world's best-known Buddhists agrees.

In 1994 the Dalai Lama, the famous Buddhist monk, spoke in London on the , the four books about Jesus's life.

His audience was Christians who meditate. He warned against blending the traditions into one. In his words:

I firmly believe that at a very profound level there is value in the distinctness and uniqueness of these different approaches.
The Dalai Lama, John Main Seminar, London (1994)

Respect sometimes means admitting that two paths aren't the same path.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of learning Japanese as a second language. You borrow its words, and sing along to its songs.

You start to notice how another people sees the world, and some of it changes how you see yours.

But try to say one sentence in two grammars at once.

English puts the verb in the middle of a sentence. Japanese puts it at the end.

Mix the two in the same line, and nobody can follow what you meant, not even you.

So you don't. You speak English, richer for what Japanese taught you. Or one day you switch, and speak Japanese properly.

Faith is a bit like that. You can learn from another tradition without trying to live by two answers to the same question.

Part 2 · Can Catholics meditate or do yoga?

Now the second question. Can Catholics meditate, or do yoga? Yes, as long as you know what each practice is for.

In 1989 the Vatican, the Church's headquarters, wrote a letter on eastern methods of meditation, inspired by Hinduism and Buddhism, such as Zen and yoga.

Christians can take from them what is useful, it says, as long as the Christian idea of prayer isn't lost.

It even says the way you hold your body and breathe can help you pray.

So in practice, stretching, breathing and sitting quietly are fine. What a Catholic can't do is worship other gods.

Where a chant or a pose is itself a prayer to another god, the letter doesn't rule on each one. We'll come back to that.

The letter's warning is about two mix-ups: mistaking a calm feeling for God, or settling for a mental void instead of meeting him.

To be fair, Zen teachers don't aim at a blank mind either.

For them, emptiness means seeing that nothing exists on its own, cut off from everything else.

Christian masters speak of emptying too, the letter notes. But the emptiness which God requires, it says, is that of the renunciation of personal selfishness.

Christian prayer is talking with someone.

For Catholics, prayer is a meeting between two persons, you and God, and every method has to serve that.

The letter calls it the meeting of two freedoms: God's and yours.

Some Hindu teachers, in the Advaita tradition, hold that the soul and God are ultimately one, and that freedom comes from realising it.

The letter doesn't name them, but it answers that kind of idea gently.

In Christian union with God, it says, the self doesn't end up dissolved or disappearing into the sea of the Absolute, meaning the ultimate reality.

Even in the closest union, you stay yourself. Catholics believe you're made to be loved by God, not to disappear into him.

Part 3 · Yoga, Om and the sun salutation

Yoga was born in India, and for many Hindus it's far more than exercise. It's a spiritual path, a way to reach God.

India's Catholic live with this question every day, and they draw the line in the same place as the 1989 letter.

In 2017 the bishops of the Syro-Malabar Church wrote to their priests about it.

It's one of India's three Catholic Churches. All three are fully united with the , each with its own way of worship.

Yoga may contribute to physical and mental health, they said, but it is not a means to experience the divine.

A Catholic bishop in the Indian state of Gujarat put it simply: We are not against yoga at all.

But Catholics there prefer not to recite slogans identified with the Hindu religion while they do it.

Neither statement names Om, a sacred Hindu sound. Some Hindus hear in it creation, keeping and destruction, together standing for Brahman, the ultimate reality.

Chanted as a prayer, it belongs to Hindu worship. So, by the same reasoning, a Catholic leaves it out, out of respect for both faiths.

Surya Namaskar, the sun salutation, is a flowing set of poses. But it's also traditionally a prayer offered to the sun god.

In 2007 one Indian state, Madhya Pradesh, made it compulsory in schools. The Catholic archbishop of Bhopal, its capital, asked for freedom to say no.

The archbishop's faith, he said, means we should not bow down in front of any idol or any other god.

An idol here isn't a celebrity. It's a statue or image treated as a god.

A Muslim group went to court, and the court made it optional for students of other faiths.

So the stretches are exercise. Words or bows offered to Surya, the sun god, are worship, and that's the part a Catholic leaves out.

Classes differ a lot. If you're unsure about one, ask the teacher what the words mean, and ask a priest.

Part 4 · Learning from Buddhists

The 1989 letter is generous too. Other religions' ways of prayer shouldn't be rejected out of hand simply because they are not Christian.

And Christians have their own meditation. The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, describes it.

It's prayerful thinking about the Gospels, holy pictures and the events of your own life. It even says a method is only a guide.

The important thing, it goes on, is to keep moving forward along the one way of prayer: Christ Jesus.

Eastern Christians, like the , pray with the body and the breath too, a little like Asian practices.

The 1989 letter says this is often absent in western forms of prayer.

One example is the Jesus Prayer, a short prayer to Jesus, said in rhythm with your breath.

The letter says it can, at least for a certain time, be of real help to many people.

And the Catholic Church encourages the friendships monks and nuns have built with Buddhists.

They're people rooted in their own religious traditions, who share with each other how they pray.

One of them was Thomas Merton, an American Catholic monk who wrote about Zen. In 1968 he travelled to India and met the Dalai Lama.

The Dalai Lama later said Merton understood Buddhism more deeply than any other Christian he had known.

So you can't live by both answers at once.

But you don't have to stop going to the temple with your family.

Being there out of love and respect isn't the same as worshipping there.

But learn from Buddhists with gratitude, meditate and stretch freely, and keep your prayer turned towards the God who knows your name.

Quick check

Say you're in a yoga class, and the teacher asks everyone to chant Om. What would a Catholic do?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 17
  1. BBC Religions, Buddhism: The Four Noble Truths · Suffering, its roots in greed, hatred and ignorance, its end, and the Eightfold Path.
  2. BBC Religions, Buddhism at a glance · No belief in a personal god; impermanence, rebirth and nirvana.
  3. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1013 · One earthly life; no reincarnation after death.
  4. World Community for Christian Meditation, The Good Heart: John Main Seminar 1994 · The organisers' record: the Dalai Lama led the 1994 seminar in London, commenting on texts from the four Gospels.
  5. Claire Sykes, review of The Good Heart, Parabola 22:2 (1997) · Quotes the Dalai Lama on the value of each tradition's distinctness.
  6. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Orationis Formas: Letter on some aspects of Christian meditation (15 October 1989) · What Christians may take from Zen, Transcendental Meditation and Yoga, and what to avoid.
  7. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2110–2114 · The first commandment: worship of the one God.
  8. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2705–2708 · Christian meditation: "a method is only a guide".
  9. Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue, Dialogue and Proclamation (1991), 42 · The dialogue of religious experience, among people rooted in their own traditions.
  10. BBC Religions, Hinduism: Hindu concepts (archived 2014) · Advaita Vedanta holds the soul and God ultimately identical; theistic traditions keep them distinct.
  11. AsiaNews, "For the Indian Church, yoga is not needed to experience the divine" (5 April 2017) · The Syro-Malabar Synod of Bishops: yoga helps body and mind but is not a means to experience the divine.
  12. UCA News via LiCAS, "Indian students bring yoga in from the cold" (28 June 2019) · Catholic schools in India mark Yoga Day; a bishop prefers no Hindu slogans while practising.
  13. Wikipedia, Trimurti · Om's three sounds read as creation, preservation and destruction, together representing Brahman.
  14. Catholic News Agency, "Catholic archbishop opposes government-imposed Hindu practice" (16 January 2007) · Madhya Pradesh orders mass Surya Namaskar in schools; the archbishop of Bhopal asks for freedom to say no.
  15. Vatican Radio, "Bishops withdraw case against state govt." (3 July 2012) · The High Court made Surya Namaskar optional for minority students; the bishops withdrew their case.
  16. Wikipedia, Śūnyatā · In Mahayana Buddhism, including Chan/Zen, emptiness means all things lack intrinsic, independent existence.
  17. Wikipedia, Thomas Merton · Trappist monk who wrote most about Zen of the Eastern traditions; in 1968 met the Dalai Lama in India three times.