Do Christians worship three gods? How can God have a son?
Christians believe in only one God, just as Jews and Muslims do. This one God is Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Son isn't biological: God has no wife and no birthday. It means the Son comes from the Father forever, the way light comes from the sun.
Part 1 · The worry
If you're Muslim, this question goes to the heart of your faith. Islam's first truth is that God is one.
The Qur'an, which Muslims believe is God's own word, tells Christians not to say Three. And it says of God:
Exalted is He above having a son
Muslims honour Jesus deeply. The Qur'an calls him the Messiah, the rescuer God had promised. It calls him a messenger of God, not God's son.
It even pictures Jesus being asked if he told people to worship him and his mother as gods.
So there are two worries. Have Christians set up other gods beside the one God? And how can anyone call a man God?
The first has a short answer: Christians don't believe in any god beside God. The second deserves a real one.
What about Mary, Jesus's mother? Catholics honour her. But the Catholic Church says that honour is completely different from the worship given to God.
No Christian church counts her as part of the : the Christian name for one God as Father, Son and .
Part 2 · One God, not three
Christianity began among Jews, and their great prayer says:
Hear, O Israel: the LORD our God is one LORD
The first Christians never let go of that line. The Catholic Church doesn't add three gods together, or cut one God into three parts.
Its , the summary of its beliefs, puts it simply:
We do not confess three Gods, but one God in three persons
And each of the three is God whole and entire, not a third of God each. Here's one way in.
The word God answers what is it? There's one God. The word person answers who? There are three: Father, Son and Spirit.
We already use those two words differently. You are one what, a human being, and one who: you.
They're not three masks on one face, and not three gods sharing a name. What makes them distinct is only how they relate.
The Father is the source, the Son comes from the Father, and the Spirit comes forth from God too.
In God, Christians say, there's one what and three whos. Nothing in our world is quite like that. But strange isn't the same as impossible.
In everything else, they are one.
That's why, when Christians are , meaning washed with water as they become Christians, it's in one name, not three:
in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the holy Spirit
Is it a mystery? Yes. But a mystery isn't a contradiction.
One God and three gods would contradict each other. One God in three persons doesn't.
A contradiction says yes and no to the same question. Here, one answers what? and three answers who?
Part 3 · Can a man be God?
Now the deeper worry. Christians don't believe a man worked his way up to become God.
A man who did that would be another god beside God, and they reject it too. They believe the opposite happened.
God's own Word came down and became a man. John's , one of the four books about Jesus's life, puts it like this:
the Word was with God, and the Word was God
A few lines later, John's Gospel says the Word became flesh. In other words, God's Word became a real human being.
Think about what a word is. A thought comes from your mind without splitting it, and your mind is never without its thought.
Christians believe the Son is God's Word in that sense: from God, and fully God.
The Qur'an uses some of the same words about Jesus. But it means something very different by them.
The Qur'an calls Jesus His word which He directed to Mary. But in the same verse, it calls him a messenger.
And it calls him a soul [created at a command] from Him. Christians read the Word in John's Gospel as God himself.
The Gospels show Jesus praying to God, whom he called his Father. So if Jesus is God, who was he praying to?
Christians answer: the Son was talking with his Father. They're truly distinct, and they're still one God.
The Catechism puts it like this: He is not the Father who is the Son, nor is the Son he who is the Father.
In plain words, the Father isn't the Son, and the Son isn't the Father.
Part 4 · What Son means, and doesn't
In everyday life, a son has a mother, a birthday and a beginning. Jesus was born as a man, to Mary.
But Christians say the Son didn't begin then. God has no wife, and the Son has no beginning.
The Catechism even says God is neither man nor woman: he is God.
So when the Qur'an says God neither begets nor is born, Christians agree, if that means having a child the way people do.
Then why say Son at all? Because of how Jesus spoke. He called God his Father in a way no prophet had.
The Catechism says Jesus showed that God is eternally Father by his relationship to his only Son, not only Father as our Creator.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of the sun and its light. The light comes from the sun.
But there was never a moment when the sun existed and hadn't started shining yet. As long as there's been a sun, there's been sunlight.
And sunlight isn't a second sun. When it warms your face, you don't say something from the sun touched me.
You say the sun is out. It's the sun itself, reaching you.
So the light comes from the sun, it's never apart from it, and it's never less than it. Coming from doesn't mean coming after.
The creed, which is the statement of belief Christians say together, calls the Son light from light.
The Son comes from the Father, and the Father has never been without him.
And that isn't a late invention. The creed was agreed by at Nicaea, in what is now Turkey, in 325.
It was filled out at Constantinople, now Istanbul, in 381.
Catholics, the and many Protestants still say it today. Those are the three main branches of Christianity.
The creed calls the Son begotten not made. In plain words, he comes from the Father, but he was never created.
So the sun picture only goes so far. The Son isn't a ray God gives off. He's a person, fully God, as the Father is.
Part 5 · Isn't that like the Trimurti?
If you grew up Hindu, you may be thinking of the Trimurti: Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva, three forms of the divine.
Isn't that the same idea? It's a fair question, and the two do sound alike.
Trimurti means three forms. Brahma creates the world, Vishnu keeps it going, and Shiva destroys it, in cycles that repeat age after age.
But Hindus don't all see it the same way.
Some old texts describe one supreme reality taking three forms. Many followers of Shiva see Brahma and Vishnu as forms of Shiva.
Many followers of Vishnu see the others as forms of Vishnu. And few Hindus have ever worshipped Brahma as the supreme God.
So where's the difference? First, the jobs. In the Trimurti, each form has its own task. In the Trinity, nothing is divided up like that.
The Catechism says they are not three principles of creation but one principle. In plain words, everything God does, all three do together.
Second, the persons. In many Hindu readings, the three are forms that the one divine reality takes on.
Christians say Father, Son and Spirit aren't forms or roles at all. They're truly distinct, and they have loved each other from all eternity.
So these are two different pictures of God, not one picture in two languages.
Part 6 · Why believe something this hard?
Why believe something this hard? Christians don't believe it because someone did the maths and liked the answer.
The Catechism says only God could make it known, by showing himself as Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
Christians believe it because of Jesus: how he prayed to his Father, what he claimed, and the Spirit he promised.
And look at what it means. If God is Father, Son and Spirit, then love isn't something he started doing once he made us.
In the Catechism's words, God himself is an eternal exchange of love.
He didn't create us because he was lonely. He created because love wants to share.
The Catholic Church says of Muslims that together with us they adore the one, merciful God.
The disagreement is real. But it's about who the one God is, never about whether there's only one.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 10
- The Qur'an 4:171 (Sahih International translation, Quranic Arabic Corpus) · Do not say Three; God is above having a son.
- The Qur'an 5:116 (Sahih International translation, Quranic Arabic Corpus) · The Qur'an rejects taking Jesus and his mother as gods.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 969–971 (devotion to Mary) · Honour given to Mary differs essentially from the adoration given to God.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 200–202, 221, 228 (one God) · God is one; the Shema, quoted by Jesus; God is an eternal exchange of love.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 232–267 (the Trinity) · One God in three persons; the Son eternally begotten; the Nicene wording; a mystery known by revelation.
- Matthew 28:19 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Baptism in the one name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
- The Qur'an 112:3 (Sahih International translation, Quranic Arabic Corpus) · God neither begets nor is born.
- John 1:1–14 (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · The Word was with God, and the Word was God.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 839–843 (other religions) · Muslims, together with Christians, adore the one, merciful God.
- Wikipedia, Trimurti · Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva as creator, preserver and destroyer; Shaiva and Vaishnava readings; Brahma rarely worshipped as supreme.