Part I · Chapter 1
Creation: what went wrong?

If everything was made good, why is the world like this?

7 scenes · about 18 min read

The short answer

Because people turned away from God. Genesis, the 's first book, says the world was made good, and that the damage came from a free human choice.

The first humans get a garden and one limit. A snake asks if God can really be trusted. They decide for themselves. Hiding, blame and shame follow at once, and death comes in time.

The Catholic Church calls this : damage everyone inherits as a condition, not a personal fault. It doesn't require reading the story literally, but it holds that a real first refusal of God stands behind it.

Not everyone agrees. Jewish readers read Genesis without original . Most academic readers, Catholics included, take Genesis 3 as a story explaining why the world is as it is.

Before the chapter ends there's a promise: the woman's offspring will strike the snake's head. Christianity claims to be the rescue that keeps that promise.

Follow the trail

Seven passages, in order: six from the first three chapters of Genesis, and one from a letter of Paul that reads them.

Genesis 1Revealed2 min read

Every person made in God's image

Genesis 1, the Bible's opening

The Bible's first book, Genesis, opens with God making the world and calling it good. On the sixth day he makes human beings, male and female, in his own image. That dignity isn't earned or ranked. Everyone starts with it.

IWhat was going on

Genesis is the first book of the Bible. Its name means beginning.

Jews and Christians traditionally credited it, with the next four books, to , the great leader and lawgiver of ancient Israel.

Modern scholars generally think these books reached their final form in the 500s BC. That was around the time Israel was taken into exile in Babylon.

Either way, Genesis was written in a world full of other creation stories, and it answers them.

IIWhat was at stake

Israel's neighbours told their own stories of how people came to be. In the Babylonian story Enuma Elish, the gods make humans from the blood of a slain god, so that people can do the gods' hard work.

In the Atrahasis story, humans are made to take over the labour the lesser gods were tired of.

In those cultures the king was sometimes called the image of a god. Ordinary people were servants. So what is a human being worth?

IIIWhat happened

Genesis 1 tells creation in six days of work and a seventh of rest. After each step God sees that what he made is good.

On the sixth day God makes human beings in his own image, male and female, and blesses them. He gives them the earth to care for.

Then he looks at everything he has made and finds it very good.

IVRead the source
Then God said: Let us make human beings in our image, after our likeness. … God created mankind in his image; in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Genesis 1:26–27 (NABRE)

Why it matters

In Israel's world, a king was sometimes called the image of a god. Genesis takes that title and gives it to every person: the farmer, the slave, the woman, the child.

Catholic teaching on human dignity starts here. It's why the Catholic Church says every human life is sacred, from the unborn child to the dying, and why no one can be treated as a tool.

God doesn't make people because he's lonely or needs workers. He lacks nothing: he is already love shared between Father, Son and Spirit. He creates because love wants to share.

Genesis 2Revealed2 min read

A whole garden and one limit

Genesis 2, the garden story

In Genesis 2, God puts the first man in a garden called Eden. He may eat from every tree but one, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Eat from it, God warns, and you will die.

IWhat was going on

Genesis 2 tells creation a second time, closer up. God forms the man from the dust of the ground and breathes life into him.

In Hebrew, the language of Genesis, the wordplay is clear: adam, the human, comes from adamah, the ground.

God plants a garden in Eden, full of trees, with a river to water it. He puts the man there to till it and look after it. Work comes before anything goes wrong.

IIWhat was at stake

Why have a limit at all? If God is good, why not let them have everything?

Because the tree isn't about fruit. In Hebrew, to know good and evil can mean to decide for yourself what is good and what is evil.

The tree is about trust. Will they live as creatures who trust the one who made them, or try to be their own god?

IIIWhat happened

God tells the man he's free to eat from every tree in the garden, including the tree of life. The one exception is the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.

The warning names a consequence, not a threat: eat from it and you will die.

Then God says it isn't good for the man to be alone, and makes the woman. The man greets her with joy.

They are naked and feel no shame. Nothing is hidden yet.

IVRead the source
The LORD God gave the man this order: You are free to eat from any of the trees of the garden except the tree of knowledge of good and evil. From that tree you shall not eat; when you eat from it you shall die.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Genesis 2:16–17 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Love that's forced isn't love. A creature that can't say no can't really say yes either.

The Catholic Church reads the tree as a sign of the limits a creature accepts freely, because it trusts its maker. The garden isn't a trap. It's the one place where freedom is real.

Genesis 3Revealed1 min read

A snake asks a question

The snake

In Genesis 3 a snake comes to the woman in the garden. It doesn't use force. It asks a question that makes God sound stingy, tells her she won't die, and promises an upgrade: you will be like gods.

IWhat was going on

Genesis 3 brings in a snake, the cleverest of the wild animals. In the ancient world snakes were linked with wisdom, life and danger, and with the gods of Israel's neighbours.

Genesis doesn't explain where the snake's evil comes from. Later Jewish and Christian writers said it was the devil.

The Book of Revelation, the last book of the Bible, calls the devil the ancient serpent.

IIWhat was at stake

The snake's first question twists God's words. Did God really say you can't eat from any tree in the garden?

It makes a generous gift sound like a ban. Then it says: you won't die. God knows that when you eat it, you'll be like gods.

The real question is whether God is holding out on them.

IIIWhat happened

The woman corrects the snake. They may eat from the trees, she says, just not from the one in the middle of the garden.

The snake answers with a flat denial, You certainly will not die!

Then it offers a new picture of God. He isn't a giver, it suggests, but a rival guarding his own position.

IVRead the source
But the snake said to the woman: “You certainly will not die! God knows well that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened and you will be like gods, who know good and evil.”
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Genesis 3:4–5 (NABRE)

Why it matters

The first temptation isn't hunger for something. It's a lie about who God is.

That's why Christians say sin, at its root, is a failure of trust. Every later sin starts the same way: with the thought that God's limits are there to keep us small, not to keep us safe.

Genesis 3Revealed2 min read

They eat, and then they hide

The man and the woman

The woman eats the fruit and gives some to the man, who is with her, and he eats too. No thunderbolt follows. Instead come shame, covering up, hiding from God and blaming each other.

IWhat was going on

Notice what the woman sees in the tree: it is good for food, beautiful to look at, and desirable for wisdom. The things she wants aren't bad in themselves.

Genesis never says what kind of fruit it was. The apple came much later, probably from a pun in Latin, where malum means both apple and evil.

IIWhat was at stake

The question is no longer what the tree is, but what they'll do. The man is with her, and says nothing.

They can trust God's word, or the snake's. They choose to decide for themselves.

IIIWhat happened

She takes the fruit and eats, and gives some to her husband, and he eats. Their eyes are opened, but what they see is that they're naked. They sew fig leaves together to cover themselves.

That evening they hear God walking in the garden, and they hide among the trees. God calls: Where are you?

The man blames the woman, and God for giving her to him. The woman blames the snake. No one says sorry.

IVWhat came of it

Before they leave the garden, God makes them clothes out of skins and dresses them himself. They lose the tree of life, and the way back is closed.

The damage isn't something God adds from outside. It's what happens when people turn away from the source of life. Trust breaks first, then everything built on it.

VRead the source
The woman saw that the tree was good for food and pleasing to the eyes, and the tree was desirable for gaining wisdom. So she took some of its fruit and ate it; and she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it. Then the eyes of both of them were opened, and they knew that they were naked.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Genesis 3:6–7 (NABRE)

Why it matters

What breaks first is relationships: with God, with each other, with themselves, and with the world. Shame, hiding and blame are still how people react when they've done wrong.

The Catholic Church's name for this is original sin, but the idea is simple. The first humans turned from God, and everyone after them is born into a world, and a nature, marked by that turning.

Genesis 3Revealed2 min read

A promise inside the curse

God, speaking to the snake

After they eat, God speaks in turn to the snake, the woman and the man. In the middle of his words to the snake comes a promise: someone from the woman's line will strike the snake's head.

IWhat was going on

After the hiding and the blame, God speaks to each of them in turn: first the snake, then the woman, then the man.

The words to the snake come first. Before anything is said about pain or hard work, God announces a fight the snake will lose.

IIWhat was at stake

If humans have chosen to trust the lie, is that the end of the story? Will evil have the last word over the people God made in his image?

And if not, who will undo it?

IIIWhat happened

God puts lasting hostility between the snake and the woman, and between the snake's offspring and hers. They will strike at its head, while it strikes at their heel.

A blow to the heel hurts. A blow to the head ends it.

IVWhat came of it

Early Christians read this line as the first announcement of the , the good news about Jesus. , a writing around AD 180, saw in it , born of a woman, defeating the devil.

The Catholic Church calls the verse the Protoevangelium, the first gospel.

The Vulgate, the Latin Bible used in the West for over a thousand years, reads she will crush your head. That's why Mary, the mother of Jesus, is often painted standing on a snake. The Hebrew points to the woman's offspring.

VRead the source
I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; They will strike at your head, while you strike at their heel.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Genesis 3:15 (NABRE)

Why it matters

The rescue is announced in the same breath as the damage. The Bible's story isn't a closed case. It's the opening of a long rescue.

Jewish readers understand the verse differently, as the ongoing struggle between humans and evil.

Christians read it as fulfilled in Jesus, Mary's son. On the cross he suffered the wound to the heel, and he crushed the snake's head.

Genesis 3Revealed2 min read

Back to dust

God, speaking to the man

God tells the man he will work hard all his life, until he returns to the ground he was made from. This is where death enters the story. Everything the Bible later says about answers it.

IWhat was going on

After the snake and the woman, God speaks to the man. The ground he was taken from, and was meant to tend with joy, will now give him thorns and thistles.

Work itself isn't the curse. It was given in the garden. What changes is that work becomes toil, a struggle against a world that pushes back.

IIWhat was at stake

The warning said they would die. They didn't drop dead that day. So what did it mean?

The story's answer is that they lost the tree of life. Cut off from the source of life, they begin to die, and death becomes part of being human.

IIIWhat happened

God tells the man he'll eat bread by the sweat of his brow until he returns to the ground: you are dust, and to dust you shall return.

The man then names his wife Eve. It sounds like the Hebrew for living, because she will be the mother of all the living. Even under the sentence, life goes on.

IVRead the source
By the sweat of your brow you shall eat bread, Until you return to the ground, from which you were taken; For you are dust, and to dust you shall return.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Genesis 3:19 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Even here God doesn't walk away. Before they leave the garden, Genesis says, he makes them garments of skin and clothes them himself (Genesis 3:21).

For Catholics, death isn't what God wanted for us. The Catechism, the Catholic Church's official summary of its teaching, says death entered the world through sin, and that Christ came to defeat it.

is the season of the weeks before Easter. On its first day, Ash Wednesday, a priest marks Catholics' foreheads with ashes. He often says these very words: remember that you are dust.

The rest of the Bible is the answer to that sentence.

c. AD 57Revealed2 min read

Paul: sin came in through one person

Paul, writing to the Christians in Rome

Around AD 57 Paul, one of the first Christian missionaries, wrote to the Christians in Rome. It's the fullest early Christian reading of Genesis 3: through one person sin came into the world, and death came to everyone.

IWhat was going on

Paul wrote his letter to the Christians of Rome around AD 57, probably from Corinth in Greece. He had never visited them. The church in Rome mixed Jewish and non-Jewish believers.

A few years earlier the emperor Claudius had expelled Jews from Rome. They had only recently come back, and the two groups were learning to live together again.

IIWhat was at stake

Some Jewish Christians felt they had an advantage, because they had God's law. Some non-Jewish Christians looked down on the Jews.

Paul's question is whether anyone is better placed before God. His answer: no one. All have sinned, and all need the same rescue.

IIIWhat happened

In Romans 5 Paul sets two men side by side. Through the disobedience of Adam, the first man, sin and death came to everyone.

Through the obedience of Jesus Christ, and life come to everyone who receives them. Grace means God's free gift of his own life.

And grace is bigger than the damage: where sin increased, grace overflowed all the more.

IVWhat came of it

In the early 400s, , bishop of Hippo in North Africa, built on this passage. He was writing against Pelagius, a British monk who taught that people could live without sin by their own effort.

The Church sided with Augustine. In 418 a at Carthage, in North Africa, condemned Pelagius's teaching.

In 1546, amid the debates of the Reformation, the , a meeting of Catholic bishops, restated original sin as official Catholic teaching.

VRead the source
Therefore, just as through one person sin entered the world, and through sin, death, and thus death came to all, inasmuch as all sinned—
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Romans 5:12 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Christianity claims to be a rescue, and a rescue only makes sense if something is really wrong.

Catholics teach that original sin is passed on as a state, not as a personal fault. We're born into it. We don't commit it.

The Orthodox Churches of the East, such as the Greek and Russian, stress more that we inherit mortality and weakness, not guilt. Judaism reads Genesis without the doctrine at all.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church doesn't require anyone to read the six days as a calendar, or the snake as a report about an animal. It has long been comfortable with figurative language in Genesis.

It is just as comfortable with what science says about the age of the universe and how species came from earlier ones.

What it does hold is that a real event at the beginning of human history stands behind the story: the first human beings freely refused God.

All of us inherit what followed as a condition, not as a personal fault. That is what original sin means.

It's why , the washing with water that makes someone a Christian, is described as a remedy, not a graduation.

That raises a hard question, and a skeptic is right to press it. Population genetics says the human population never shrank to just two people. How can there be a first couple?

The Church's teaching has two parts. In 1950 Pius XII's letter Humani generis allowed Catholics to study the evolution of the human body from earlier life, but held that every human soul is created directly by God.

The same letter said Catholics may not hold that Adam stands for a number of first parents, because it was "in no way apparent" how that could fit original sin. The of 1992 keeps the line: Genesis 3 "uses figurative language, but affirms a primeval event".

Catholic thinkers today work inside that "in no way apparent". One proposal, from the philosopher Kenneth Kemp, separates the biological species from the first beings with rational souls. God gives souls to a first pair within an evolving population, and over generations their descendants and that population become one.

The Church has not ruled on any such proposal. What it hasn't changed is its teaching that a real first refusal of God stands behind the story.

The story comes first because everything after it is a rescue.

Then come God's , his binding promises to his people. Then the prophets, God becoming human in Jesus, the cross, the such as baptism, and the Church.

Each one only makes sense if something is really wrong. And the wrong has to be more than a bad habit that better education would fix.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Readers who take the six days literally

Many Evangelical Protestants and some Christians read Genesis 1 as a step-by-step account of how a young earth was made.

They argue that reading the opening chapters as figurative weakens what says about in Romans 5, where he treats Adam as a real man in history.

Historical-critical scholars

Most academic readers, Catholic ones included, see two creation accounts in Genesis 1 and 2. They think these come from different traditions, written in the story forms of the ancient Middle East.

They read Genesis 3 as an aetiology: a story explaining why the world is as it is, not a report of an event.

Jewish readers

Judaism reads the same chapters without the of original sin.

For Jewish readers the story describes a human pull toward evil, and the responsibility to master it. It is not about an inherited state that needs redeeming.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself2
Good, then broken, then promised6 steps

The first three chapters of the Bible follow a clear shape: good, then broken, then promised. Everything the Bible says after them depends on that shape.

  1. A world called good

    Six times the account stops to say that what has been made is good. At the end, it calls everything very good. Whatever is wrong with the world now, Genesis won't say it was built wrong.

    “God looked at everything he had made, and found it very good.”
  2. A creature like God

    Human beings are made in God's image. They are given charge over the earth, work to do and a garden. They are not slaves of the gods, which is what the surrounding cultures said people were for.

    “Let us make human beings in our image, after our likeness.”
  3. A real limit, freely given

    The tree is not a trap. It is the one place where the creature's freedom is really tested. That is what makes it freedom, not just instinct.

    “You are free to eat from any of the trees of the garden except the tree of knowledge of good and evil.”
  4. A lie about God's motive

    The temptation is not hunger for something. It is a new picture of God: a rival who is holding out on you.

    “God knows well that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened and you will be like gods.”
  5. The consequences are relational

    Shame, hiding, blame, hard labour, pain and death. Genesis describes the damage as broken relationships before it describes it as a punishment.

    “Then the eyes of both of them were opened, and they knew that they were naked.”
  6. And a promise, before the gate closes

    The rescue is announced in the same speech as the damage.

    “I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; They will strike at your head.”
Questions people ask next