Why does God keep making promises to particular people?
7 scenes · about 18 min read
So that the blessing can reach everyone. God works through one person or one people at a time, but the point is always the whole world.
The tells it through : solemn agreements, each with a named person and a sign.
The first, with , takes in every living creature. Then it narrows to 's family and widens again: a nation under , a kingdom under David.
Each time, the human side breaks it. So the prophets promise a new kind of covenant, written on people's hearts, not on stone.
At his last supper Jesus took a cup and called it the new covenant in his blood. Words like priest, altar, sacrifice and kingdom come from this chain. Catholics didn't invent them.
Jewish readers see God's covenant with Israel as still in force, not fulfilled in Jesus. The Catholic Church teaches it has never been revoked.
Seven scenes from Noah to Jesus: each covenant with its person, its sign and who it takes in.
Noah: every living thing
God and Noah, after the flood
Genesis, the Bible's first book, tells that after the great flood God made his first covenant. It wasn't made only with Noah and his family. It took in every animal from the boat and the whole earth, and its sign was a rainbow.
IWhat was going on
In the ancient Near East, the old world of Mesopotamia, Egypt and Canaan, people bound themselves to each other by covenant. It was a solemn agreement sealed with an oath and a sign, often with blood or a shared meal.
A covenant was more than a contract. It made the two sides something like family, and breaking one was among the worst things a person could do.
Genesis tells its flood story in that world. Nearby peoples had flood stories of their own, such as the Mesopotamian epic Atrahasis. The Genesis account partly follows it.
IIWhat was at stake
Genesis says that by Noah's time the earth was corrupt and full of lawlessness. People were destroying each other, and the world with them. It says God regretted making them, and was grieved.
In Genesis the flood is God's response to a world tearing itself apart. He kept Noah, his family and the animals alive in the ark, so that the human story could go on.
Afterwards the question was obvious. Would it happen again, every time people went wrong?
IIIWhat happened
When the waters went down, Genesis tells, Noah came out of the ark and built an altar, a raised place for offering sacrifice. A sacrifice was an animal or other gift given to God. There Noah made an offering.
God blessed Noah's family with the words he had spoken at creation: be fruitful and fill the earth.
In the Atrahasis epic, the gods change their plan and limit humans. In Genesis, God repeats his first blessing unchanged.
Then he made a covenant with Noah, his descendants and every living creature. He set the rainbow in the clouds as its sign.
IVWhat came of it
The promise is one-sided. God binds himself, and the promise doesn't depend on people behaving: never again will a flood destroy all life.
It comes with a few basic rules for everyone. Human life is sacred, because people are made in God's image. And blood, which the ancients saw as the seat of life, is not to be eaten.
Jewish tradition later treated that ban as binding on all humanity, not only on Israel. The first Christians kept it for a time.
VRead the source
See, I am now establishing my covenant with you and your descendants after you and with every living creature that was with you … I will establish my covenant with you, that never again shall all creatures be destroyed by the waters of a flood.
Why it matters
The Bible's first covenant takes in every living creature, not one tribe or one faith. The circle starts as wide as it can be, before it narrows to one family.
That shape matters for everything that follows. The narrowing to Abraham, to Israel and to David is for the sake of the whole world. The last covenant in the chain is meant to reach it again.
Abraham: a family, for the world
Abram, called out of Ur
Genesis tells that God called Abram, later named Abraham, to leave his home for a land he would be shown. God promised to make him a great nation. Through him, all the families of the earth would find blessing.
IWhat was going on
Genesis says Abram came from Ur of the Chaldeans, a city in southern Mesopotamia, in today's Iraq. His family moved north to Haran.
People there worshipped many gods, and Abram's family was no exception. The book of Joshua remembers that his father served other gods.
Abram and his wife Sarai were getting old, and Sarai could not have children. In a world where your name and land passed to your sons, they had no future to speak of.
IIWhat was at stake
Just before this, Genesis tells of the tower of Babel. People built a tower to make a name for themselves, and ended up scattered and unable to understand each other.
The human family was split and going its own way. How would God bring it back together?
Genesis gives a surprising answer: start again with one childless old couple.
IIIWhat happened
God told Abram to leave his land, his relatives and his father's house for a land he would be shown. There was no map and nothing in writing.
He was promised a land, a great nation from his descendants, and a great name. Through him, all the families of the earth would find blessing.
Genesis says Abram went, at 75 years old, with Sarai, his nephew Lot and everything they owned. They went to Canaan, roughly today's Israel and the Palestinian territories.
IVWhat came of it
Abram lived in tents as a herder at the edge of Canaan's towns. The promises stayed promises for a long time: years went by with no son and no land of his own.
Genesis doesn't make him a hero. During a famine he went down to Egypt and passed Sarai off as his sister to save his own skin. The text doesn't excuse it.
VRead the source
The LORD said to Abram: Go forth from your land, your relatives, and from your father's house to a land that I will show you. I will make of you a great nation, and I will bless you … All the families of the earth will find blessing in you.
Why it matters
This is where God's plan for the whole world narrows to one family. It is particular so that it can become universal.
The Hebrew of that last promise can mean two things. Nations will bless themselves by Abraham's name, or they will be blessed through him.
Christians read it the second way. , an early Christian teacher whose letters are in the , argues that the blessing reaches non-Jews through Jesus Christ, Abraham's descendant.
Abram trusts God under the stars
Abram, under the night sky
Abram was old and childless. Genesis tells that God told him to count the stars: his descendants would be as many. Abram believed, and God counted it as righteousness. Centuries later, that verse became the centre of the Reformation's argument about faith.
IWhat was going on
Years after leaving home, Abram still had no child. Genesis tells that he complained to God: as things stood, a servant of his household would inherit everything.
God took him outside at night and told him to count the stars, if he could. His descendants would be as many.
IIWhat was at stake
Nothing had changed. Abram was old, Sarai still had no child, and he had only a promise to go on. Would he take God at his word?
He also asked how he could know the land would be his. In his world, a promise that big called for a covenant, sealed in the way everyone understood.
IIIWhat happened
Abram believed God. Genesis says God counted it to him as righteousness: being in a right relationship with God.
Then came the covenant. Abram cut animals in two and laid the halves facing each other. People sealing a treaty walked between such pieces. In effect they said: may this happen to me if I break my word.
After dark, Abram lay in a deep sleep. A smoking fire pot and a flaming torch, signs of God's presence, passed between the pieces. Only God walked through.
IVWhat came of it
God promised the land to Abram's descendants. He also warned that they would first be strangers and slaves in a land not their own for 400 years, a hint of Egypt to come.
Two chapters later God renamed him Abraham, father of many nations. He gave circumcision as the covenant's sign. Later Sarah bore him a son, Isaac, in their old age.
VRead the source
Look up at the sky and count the stars, if you can. Just so, he added, will your descendants be. Abram put his faith in the LORD, who attributed it to him as an act of righteousness.
Why it matters
The Paul, one of the first Christian missionaries, built on this verse. In his letters to the Romans and the Galatians he argues that Abraham was right with God by trusting him, before any law was given. So non-Jews can belong by faith too.
In the 1500s the Reformation, the movement that formed the churches, made this its centre. taught that we are put right with God by faith alone, not by anything we do.
Catholics answered that true faith works through love. They pointed to the letter of James in the New Testament, which uses Abraham too.
On 31 October 1999 in Augsburg, the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church signed a joint declaration. It says we are accepted by God by alone, through faith in Christ's saving work, not because of any merit of ours.
Moses: a nation of priests
Moses and the Israelites, at Mount Sinai
Moses led the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt to Mount Sinai. There God made a covenant with the whole people: they would be a kingdom of priests. Moses read its terms aloud and sealed it with blood.
IWhat was going on
Genesis ends with Abraham's great-grandson Joseph in Egypt. His jealous brothers sold him as a slave, but he rose to run Egypt's food stores. When famine struck, his whole family moved there to survive.
Exodus, the Bible's second book, picks up generations later. A new king feared how many Israelites there were. He made them slaves, forced them to build his cities, and ordered their baby boys killed.
God sent Moses to lead them out. On the last night came the first . Each family killed a lamb, marked its doorposts with the blood and ate in haste, and death passed over their homes.
IIWhat was at stake
Freedom was only half of it. The Israelites were former slaves in a desert, with no land, no law and nothing in common but what they had suffered.
Exodus says God had carried them out on eagle's wings to bring them to himself. The question was whether they would become his people, or stay people who just got away.
IIIWhat happened
At Mount Sinai God offered a covenant. If they kept it, they would be his treasured possession, a kingdom of priests, a holy nation. A priest stands between God and people and offers sacrifice for them.
God gave the Ten Commandments. Moses wrote down the terms and read the book of the covenant aloud. The people answered that they would do all of it.
Young men offered sacrifices of animals. Moses splashed half the blood on the altar and half on the people, and called it the blood of the covenant.
Then the elders, the leaders of the tribes, went up the mountain and ate and drank in God's presence.
IVWhat came of it
While Moses was still on the mountain, Exodus says, the people made a golden calf and worshipped it. The human side broke the covenant almost at once.
God did not walk away. The covenant was renewed, and Israel's life came to centre on it: the law, a tent for God's presence, priests, sacrifices and feasts. Passover was kept every year.
VRead the source
You will be to me a kingdom of priests, a holy nation. … Then he took the blood and splashed it on the people, saying, “This is the blood of the covenant which the LORD has made with you according to all these words.”
Why it matters
To the ancients, blood was life. Sealing a covenant with it said this bond was a matter of life and death.
It wasn't God wanting blood. It showed how serious the bond was, and how serious breaking it would be.
Priest, altar, sacrifice and holy people were Israel's words first. Catholics didn't invent them. When Jesus later speaks of my blood of the covenant, he is quoting Moses.
David: a throne that never ends
King David and the prophet Nathan, Jerusalem
Around 1000 BC, King David wanted to build a temple for God in Jerusalem. Through the prophet Nathan, God said no. Instead he promised that David's family line would rule forever. Every later hope for a grows from this promise.
IWhat was going on
After Moses, Israel settled in Canaan as a loose league of tribes, often at war with their neighbours. In time they asked for a king, to be like the nations around them and lead them into battle.
David, the youngest son of a family in Bethlehem, was a shepherd. The prophet Samuel, a man who spoke for God, anointed him: he poured oil on David's head as a sign that God had chosen him.
Anointed in Hebrew is mashiach, which gives us the word Messiah. David ruled around 1000 BC, took Jerusalem and made it his capital.
IIWhat was at stake
Kings in that world built temples for their gods. Settled in his palace of cedar, David wanted to build a house for God.
The Ark of the Covenant, the chest that held the stone tablets of the law, was still kept in a tent. A king in a palace and God in a tent looked wrong to him.
IIIWhat happened
The prophet Nathan brought God's answer. David would not build God a house. God would build David a house: not a building, but a family line.
One of David's sons would build the temple. God would be a father to him, and he would be a son to God. If he did wrong he would be corrected, but God's favour would not be taken away.
David's house and kingdom would stand firm forever.
IVWhat came of it
But the king who received the promise broke his side of it. David saw Bathsheba, the wife of Uriah, one of his own soldiers, and took her. When she became pregnant, he had Uriah sent to the front of the battle to be killed.
Nathan came back with a story: a rich man who stole a poor man's only lamb. David was furious at the rich man, and Nathan said: you are the man. David made no excuses. He said: I have sinned against the LORD.
The promise stood. David's son Solomon built the Temple in Jerusalem, the centre of Israel's worship. After Solomon the kingdom split in two. In 587 BC the Babylonians took Jerusalem and burned the Temple, and no son of David sat on a throne again.
VRead the source
He it is who shall build a house for my name, and I will establish his royal throne forever. I will be a father to him, and he shall be a son to me. … Your house and your kingdom are firm forever before me.
Why it matters
A promise of a throne forever, with no king left on it, is what made Israel hope for a Messiah: a future son of David whom God would send.
The , the four accounts of Jesus's life, open on that hope. Matthew's first line calls Jesus the son of David.
Christians read his kingdom as that forever throne, though not the kind anyone expected. Jewish readers are still waiting for the Messiah.
Jeremiah: a law written on hearts
The prophet Jeremiah, around the exile
Around Jerusalem's fall to Babylon in 587 BC, the prophet Jeremiah promised a new covenant. It wouldn't be a better version of the old one. God would put his law inside people, writing it on their hearts.
IWhat was going on
Jeremiah was a prophet in Jerusalem in the decades before its fall. He warned again and again that the city would be lost if it kept breaking the covenant. He was beaten and jailed for it.
He was right. In 587 BC the Babylonian army burned the Temple. It took many of the people into exile: forced to live far from home, in Babylon.
IIWhat was at stake
The covenant made at Sinai had been broken again and again. If the people couldn't keep it, was it over?
The deeper trouble was the human heart. A law on stone tablets could tell people what was right. It couldn't make them want it.
IIIWhat happened
In the middle of the disaster, Jeremiah announced hope. God would make a new covenant with Israel and Judah. It would not be like the one their ancestors broke after he led them out of Egypt.
This time God would write his law on their hearts. Everyone would know him, from the least to the greatest, and he would forgive their .
It isn't a new law but a new relationship with the same law: kept from the inside, gladly, instead of broken over and over.
IVWhat came of it
About 50 years later, Persia conquered Babylon and the exiles were allowed home. They rebuilt the Temple, but the promise of a new covenant stayed open.
Some Jews of Jesus's time were still waiting for it. The community behind the , ancient Jewish writings found near the Dead Sea, called themselves partners in a new covenant.
VRead the source
See, days are coming—oracle of the LORD—when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah. It will not be like the covenant I made with their ancestors … I will place my law within them, and write it upon their hearts; I will be their God, and they shall be my people.
Why it matters
The name New Testament comes from this passage: testament is an old word for covenant. The letter to the Hebrews, in the New Testament, quotes the promise in full and applies it to Jesus.
Jewish readers see Jeremiah's promise as God renewing his covenant with Israel, not replacing it.
The Catholic Church teaches that God's covenant with the Jewish people has never been revoked. It also believes that Jesus opens the new covenant to everyone.
Jesus: the cup of the new covenant
Jesus and the Twelve, in an upstairs room
Around AD 33 in Jerusalem, the night before he was , Jesus ate a last supper with his closest followers. He took a cup of wine and called it the new covenant in his blood.
IWhat was going on
Jesus of Nazareth was a Jewish teacher from Galilee whom his followers believed to be the Messiah. He came to Jerusalem at Passover time, when the city filled with pilgrims remembering the escape from Egypt.
Jerusalem was under Roman rule. The Temple's leaders and the Roman governor were wary of crowds at the feast. A man hailed as son of David looked like trouble.
IIWhat was at stake
Jesus knew he was about to be handed over and killed. One of his own, Judas, had already agreed to betray him.
His friends would be left without him, and to everyone else he would look like a failed Messiah. What would his death mean?
He answered at supper, the night before, with words and actions they never forgot.
IIIWhat happened
Jesus ate with the Twelve, his closest followers, in an upstairs room. Luke presents it as the Passover meal; the Gospels differ on the exact day.
He took bread, gave thanks, broke it and said it was his body, given for them: do this in memory of me. After supper he took the cup and called it the new covenant in his blood, shed for them.
Two old promises meet in that line: the blood of the covenant from Sinai, and the new covenant Jeremiah foretold.
IVWhat came of it
That night he was arrested in , an olive garden outside the city walls. The next day the Roman governor, , had him crucified.
His followers said he rose from the dead, and they kept the meal. About 25 years later Paul, an early Christian missionary, wrote out the same words over the bread and cup for the church in Corinth, a Greek city. Christians were already repeating them.
VRead the source
Then he took the bread, said the blessing, broke it, and gave it to them, saying, “This is my body, which will be given for you; do this in memory of me.” And likewise the cup after they had eaten, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood, which will be shed for you.”
Why it matters
Each covenant in the chain had a sign and a sacrifice or a meal. Here the sign is Jesus himself, and the circle is no longer one family or one nation but everyone.
Christians of every tradition trace their Lord's Supper back to this night. Catholics, the and many others call it the Eucharist, from the Greek for thanksgiving. Catholics call its celebration the Mass.
What exactly happens in it is where the traditions differ.
The chain began with a rainbow over every living thing. It ends at a table, with a cup Jesus says is poured out for many.
Why Catholics read it this way
Catholics read this chain as one story with one author. The later covenants fulfil the earlier ones. They don't cancel them.
That's why the , the Catholic Sunday service, keeps the shape of a covenant meal. It's why the building has an altar, and why the person at the altar is called a priest.
It also explains a habit that puzzles outsiders. The Catholic Church's instinct is that God works through particular, visible, physical things: a family, a nation, a man, a meal.
He doesn't only offer general truths, open to everyone in the abstract.
At the same time, the Catholic Church holds that God's covenant with the Jewish people was never revoked. The , the Catholic Church's worldwide meeting of that ended in 1965, taught that God does not take back his gifts or his call to the Jewish people.
In 1980 spoke of the old covenant as never revoked by God, and the repeats it.
How others read the same evidence
Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.
Jewish readers
Judaism reads the same covenants as still in force on their own terms. It does not read 's new covenant as fulfilled in Jesus.
Since 1965 Catholic teaching has affirmed that God's gifts and call to Israel can never be taken back. That rules out the older Christian claim that the Church simply replaced Israel.
Reformed covenant theology
Reformed Protestants, the tradition that goes back to , have a classic way of reading the Bible through its covenants. It follows the same chain and draws different conclusions.
The biggest difference is the Lord's Supper, the . Reformed Christians hold that 's sacrifice on the cross was offered once for all and is not offered again; the Supper is a sign and seal of the covenant, where believers feed on Christ by faith. Catholics hold that the Mass makes that one sacrifice present.
Historical-critical scholars
Academic scholars think these texts were written in several different periods. They see later beliefs read back into earlier figures, especially in the stories of Sinai and David.
Many historians and archaeologists doubt that Abraham, or a whole nation's escape from Egypt, can be confirmed as history: no trace of the patriarchs or of a desert journey has been found. Many date the written form of these stories, and of Nathan's promise to David, to the time of the kings or to the exile in Babylon in the 500s BC.
The stones do give one fixed point. An inscription found at Tel Dan in northern Israel in 1993 speaks of the House of David: a royal line known by his name in the 800s or 700s BC.
The Catholic Church asks readers to attend to the kind of writing each book is, and doesn't require every detail to be read as a report. The trail above reads the finished book, because that is the book the Church received, and what it means as one story doesn't hang on when each part was written down.
Check it yourself
Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.
Read the sources yourself2
- 2011 · United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
- Holy See · 1997 · Libreria Editrice Vaticana (vatican.va IntraText)
The circle keeps widening6 steps
Read who each covenant takes in, in order, and the shape of the whole Bible appears. It isn't a string of different religions. It's one agreement, being extended.
It starts with every living creature, narrows to one family, then reaches out again until it takes in everyone.
Noah: all flesh
—Every living creature, with a sign in the sky.
“and with every living creature that was with you: the birds, the tame animals, and all the wild animals that were with you—all that came out of the ark.”
Abraham: a family for all families
A couple, then a clan, with the whole world named as the point.
“All the families of the earth will find blessing in you.”
Moses: a nation
A people with a law, priests and a place of worship.
“You will be to me a kingdom of priests, a holy nation.”
David: a kingdom
A throne promised forever, to a king God calls his son, a title for Israel's kings.
“Your house and your kingdom are firm forever before me; your throne shall be firmly established forever.”
Jeremiah: written on the heart
A covenant that works from the inside, still to come.
“I will place my law within them, and write it upon their hearts.”
Jesus: the cup, and everyone
Jesus uses the covenant words again. The Church that follows him is not one family or one nation, but open to everyone.
“This cup is the new covenant in my blood, which will be shed for you.”