Following the trail back
This is the detour I took into the rapture, and what I found when I read what the first Christians actually wrote.
Once I believed Jesus is who he said he was, the next question came almost straight away: where is the Church he started?
Some of the first people who helped me think seriously about Christianity were writers and speakers who make the case for the faith: Nabeel Qureshi, David Wood, Wes Huff, and Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle.
Cliffe and Stuart are the father and son who take people’s hardest questions on university campuses.
There was Bear Grylls, the TV survival adventurer, of all people, and his book about his faith. There was the Ear to Hear channel, and plenty more.
I’m grateful to every one of these teachers. They showed me that faith and evidence aren’t enemies, and they taught me to ask for sources.
For a while, I was especially caught up in one idea: the .
Looking back, I had picked it up from some of the Protestant teachers I was watching, without even realising.
The rapture is the belief, popular in some evangelical churches, that believers will suddenly be caught up to meet Jesus in the air.
Everyone else would be left behind to face a time of great trouble called the tribulation.
Had you heard of the rapture before?
Pick an answer below.
Even the people who believe in the rapture argue about when it will happen. Pre-tribulation says believers are taken before the trouble starts. Mid-tribulation says halfway through.
Post-tribulation says at the very end, and some claim that one is basically what Catholics teach.
A lot of these end-times teachers also say the Catholic Church will be corrupted in the last days and lead people astray.
I took all of it seriously, and I worried about that last part myself.
There was a stretch when I was completely convinced the rapture was about to happen. So many signs seemed to line up.
Spiritually I felt ready, even happy about it. But my body wasn’t.
As the day I expected got closer, I was filled with fear and trembling, because the flesh doesn’t want to go.
I also looked at the people around me who believed it too.
Most of them were anxious. A lot of them were defeatist, like nothing in this life was worth building any more.
Honestly, it wasn’t a nice place to be. Something was off.
If God really meant us to know the timing by reading between the lines of Scripture, why was knowing it making us more afraid, instead of more loving?
Looking back, it was a mercy that we don’t know when the end will come. If we did, our flesh couldn’t take it.
And that’s when I understood something about Jesus himself.
Think of Jesus in , the olive garden where he prayed the night before he died. He knew exactly what was coming.
Jesus told his friends his soul was sorrowful even to death.
He begged God his Father to let the cup of suffering pass from him, and he prayed so hard that his sweat fell like drops of blood.
Jesus was fully God, and fully human too, and the flesh itself doesn’t want to go through it.
I had felt a tiny piece of that. I understood now.
That’s where the Catholic view first started to make sense to me. For the record, the Catholic Church doesn’t teach a separate rapture at all.
Jesus comes back once, at the end of time, in glory, for everyone to see.
Before that, the Church itself will go through a final trial that shakes the faith of many. There’s no secret escape before it.
And Jesus said no one knows the day or the hour he will come back. It isn’t ours to know, or to obsess over.
Our job is to love God, and to love others the way Jesus loves us.
That means living the gospel out now, with the help God gives us for exactly that, in the , like and , and in prayer.
Getting the rapture wrong was a very humbling experience. I had been so sure.
And it showed me how easily I could read my own ideas into the , and how much I needed something older and steadier than my own reading.
So I went digging, deeper than before. Who chose the books of the Bible? What did the first Christians do on a Sunday?
What did the people taught by the , the closest followers Jesus chose and sent out, actually write?
That took me into the early Church, then the councils, the big meetings where settled disputes.
After that came 1054, when the Church split into the East and the Catholic West.
Then came 1517 and the Reformation, when the Protestant churches began. And eventually I looked into Mary, Jesus’s mother, too.
The early Christians left a lot behind, and it surprised me.
Around AD 107, , the bishop of a big city in what is now Turkey, was marched under guard to Rome to be killed.
He wrote letters to the churches on the way.
Ignatius wrote that the , the bread and wine of Communion, is the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ.
He told Christians to stay close to their bishop, the leader of their local church.
And he’s the first person we know of to use a name I had heard all my life:
“Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude [of the people] also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.”
Around AD 155, a Christian philosopher called wrote to the Roman emperor to explain what Christians actually did on Sunday.
He was later killed for his faith, which is why he’s known as Justin Martyr.
Justin describes readings, a sermon, prayers, bread and wine brought forward, a long prayer of thanksgiving, the people answering “Amen”, and Communion.
And about that bread and wine he says straight out:
“For not as common bread and common drink do we receive these”
I read that and thought: that’s the , the Catholic Sunday service.
Around AD 180, , a bishop in what is now France, listed the bishops of Rome in order, from Linus, who took over from the apostles, down to his own day.
Irenaeus said every church should agree with Rome, though scholars still argue over exactly what he meant by that.
To be fair, not everything is as tidy as Catholics sometimes make it sound.
No first-century text calls , the leader of Jesus’s twelve apostles, the bishop of Rome.
And the earliest lists of , the bishops of Rome after him, differ in some details.
I would rather tell you about those gaps myself than have you find out later and feel misled. But for me, the direction of the evidence was hard to miss.
Ignatius, Justin and Irenaeus wrote between AD 107 and 180. How much do they tell us about the first Christians?
Pick an answer below.
All of that led me to the Catholic Church. I researched it heavily, from every side, because I didn’t want to just take anyone’s word for it.
The evidence and the logic brought me to its door.
Just like believing in Jesus in the first place, it still took faith to walk in.
The way I see it, a lot of what Protestants object to in the Catholic Church comes from real misunderstandings.
Those misunderstandings were held in good faith, because there really was corruption in the Catholic Church in the 1500s, when the Protestant churches began.
And some of it isn’t misunderstanding at all. There are real disagreements, over things like the Bible’s authority and the pope’s.
What I found wasn’t a debate to win. It was a family history, with saints and scandals on every branch.