The RiverRevolutions and missions
1878

Booth's mission becomes The Salvation Army

William Booth's Christian Mission, begun among London's poor in 1865, becomes The Salvation Army: a deed makes Booth its sole leader, preachers become officers, and five years later it gives up baptism and communion.

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

In 1865 William Booth, a former Methodist minister, and his wife Catherine began preaching to the poor of London's East End. Their Christian Mission meant to send its converts to the churches, but the churches did not take them, so it kept them and slowly became a church of its own.

In August 1878 a deed made Booth its sole leader, and that year he crossed out Volunteer in the phrase ‘a Volunteer Army’ and wrote Salvation.

Preachers became officers, members became soldiers and Booth became the General. Women preached and led as equals. Mobs attacked the marches, and magistrates jailed Salvationists for breaking the peace.

In 1883 Booth stopped the Army holding baptism and the Lord's Supper, the two rites most churches hold Jesus himself commanded. It works today in 134 countries, and in Singapore since 1935.

Where we are

The situation

Victorian London was the largest city in the world, and its East End was among its poorest corners. Families crowded into single rooms, work was irregular, and drink was everywhere. Many of its people had never been inside a church.

William Booth came out of Methodism, the movement John Wesley had begun to take the gospel to people the established church was missing. Booth was a minister of the Methodist New Connexion until 1861, when he left to be free to preach as a travelling evangelist.

From 1865 he and Catherine worked among the poor of the East End. In the words of the Army's own historian of , the mission ‘was unsectarian. Its creed was the .’

Booth did not set out to found a church. His first idea, he wrote later, was ‘to get the people saved and send them to the churches.’

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Methodist to the bone

    Booth looked back on his youth in these words. The Army's doctrine historian Earl Robinson adds that its eleven doctrines closely follow those of the Methodist New Connexion, in which Booth was ordained.

    “I worshipped everything that bore the name of Methodist. To me there was one God, and John Wesley was his prophet.”
    The History of Salvation Army Doctrine · The History of Salvation Army Doctrine, p. 36
  2. 02

    Catherine Booth's first sermon, Gateshead, 1860

    Catherine had defended women's preaching in print but had never preached. One Sunday morning she walked up the aisle of her husband's chapel and asked to speak. She later described what went through her mind.

    “I have never yet been willing to be a fool for Christ. Now I will be one!”
    Catherine Booth: A Sketch · Mildred Duff, Catherine Booth: A Sketch, the Gateshead chapter
The problem

What was at stake

The churches did not take the converts. Booth gave three reasons: ‘First, they would not go when sent. Second, they were not wanted. And third, we wanted some of them at least to help us in the business of saving others.’

So the mission kept its people, and it needed doctrines, rules and leaders for them. A mission meant to serve every church was turning into a church of its own.

In 1877 some of its evangelists wanted it run by committees, like other churches. Booth refused. ‘My comrades,’ he told them, ‘the formation of another Church is not my aim.’

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A mission for members of every church

    At first the mission asked nothing of its helpers' church loyalties. Members of other churches gave it one, two or three days a week without leaving their own.

    “Working within William Booth's society meant no cancellation of existing connections with churches.”
    The History of Salvation Army Doctrine · The History of Salvation Army Doctrine, p. 33
  2. 02

    The evangelists who wanted a church, 1877

    Booth described the dispute of February 1877 that ended the conference system. After it, he said, the last Christian Mission conference met to give it up.

    “Some of the evangelists whom I had engaged to assist me rose up and wanted to convert our Mission into a regular Church, with a Committee of Management and all that sort of thing.”
    The Authoritative Life of General William Booth, Founder of the Salvation Army · Railton, Authoritative Life, chapter IX, Army Leading
What happened

The event

On 7 August 1878 Booth signed a deed of constitution, enrolled in the Court of Chancery. It fixed the mission's eleven doctrines and placed it for ever under ‘some one person’, the General Superintendent, who was Booth himself.

That year George Scott Railton was writing a report that called the mission ‘a volunteer army’. Booth's son Bramwell objected that he was ‘a regular or nothing’. His father crossed out Volunteer and wrote Salvation.

The military style followed. Mission stations became corps, evangelists became officers and members became soldiers. Booth became the General, and uniforms came in. On 24 June 1880 a note on the back of the deed recorded the new name.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Volunteer or regular

    Begbie tells the story of the name as Bramwell Booth remembered it. Railton was writing at the table, and William Booth was walking up and down the room.

    “took the pen from his hand, scratched out the word " Volunteer " and wrote in its place the word " Salvation."”
    The Life of General William Booth, the Founder of the Salvation Army, vol. I · Chapter XXVII, Becomes General of the Army, p. 439
  2. 02

    The new name on the deed, 24 June 1880

    The Army's archive explains why the 1911 Britannica dates the name to June 1880: that is when the deed itself was altered.

    “On 24 June 1880 an addition was made to the reverse of the 1878 Deed of Constitution, stating that the title of General Superintendent had been shortened to General and that the name Christian Mission had been changed to The Salvation Army”
    'The Foundation Deeds have never failed': The Salvation Army Acts deconstructed · International Heritage Centre blog, September 2018
  3. 03

    Thirty stations to eighty

    Railton, who was there, dates the name to the end of 1878. The Army's official history puts it in that year's annual report.

    “It was only at the end of 1878, during which year the "Stations," which we now call Corps, had increased from thirty to eighty, that in a brief description of the work we called the Mission a "Salvation Army."”
    The Authoritative Life of General William Booth, Founder of the Salvation Army · Railton, Authoritative Life, chapter IX, Army Leading
What came of it

The outcome

The Army grew fast. Railton says its stations rose from thirty to eighty in 1878, and a Salvationist scholar, Kenneth Lawson, puts the corps at over a thousand by 1886. It crossed to the United States and Australia in 1880.

It also met mobs, magistrates and bans. Gangs calling themselves Skeleton Armies attacked its marches, and magistrates jailed Salvationists for breaking the peace.

In January 1883 Booth told his officers that the Army would stop holding and the Lord's Supper.

He did not call the question closed. It was wise, he said, ‘to postpone any settlement of the question, to leave it over to some future day, when we shall have more light’.

The Army has kept the rule ever since. Its social work, shelters, food and rescue homes, spread with it. In 1890 Booth's In Darkest England set out a plan for the poorest tenth of the nation.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Booth's own words, 2 January 1883

    Booth opened his address to his officers on the sacraments with a principle. It was printed in The War Cry on 13 and 17 January 1883, and Lawson quotes it from there.

    “I cannot accept any obligation as binding upon my conscience, neither will I seek to bind any upon yours, to do, or believe, or teach anything for which authority cannot be furnished from the Word of God”
    Sacraments and Symbols in the Salvation Army · Lawson, Sacraments and Symbols, chapter 1, p. 10
  2. 02

    His reasons, as he gave them in 1895

    Interviewed by Henry Lunn, Booth gave six reasons. The sacraments are not essential to salvation. The Church already ignores other commands, such as washing feet. The Army had decided not to be a church. Clergy had refused Communion to unconfirmed Salvationists. People trusted in rites instead of holy living. And the question was not settled. He began with the first.

    “In the first place, we do not consider that the Sacraments are essentials of salvation”
    The Life of General William Booth, the Founder of the Salvation Army, vol. I · Chapter XXVIII, The Question of Holy Communion, p. 468
  3. 03

    Singapore, 1935

    Herbert Lord came from Korea in March 1935, found ten Salvationists among the British troops, and set up at 47 Killiney Road. By 1936 the Army had a home for boys and one for young women.

    “The history of the Salvation Army in Singapore goes back to at least 1935.”
    The Salvation Army in Singapore · BiblioAsia 19:4 (2024), opening section
Why it matters

For the trail

Most channels on the River keep baptism, and with it a bond the Catholic Church recognises: ‘Baptism therefore establishes a bond of unity which links all who have been reborn by it’ (UR 22).

The Salvation Army let that bond go. Booth's reason was that the Army was ‘a force for aggressive purposes’, not a church.

Cardinal Manning, the Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, saw where that would lead. The Army, he wrote, ‘will either ... become a sect, or it will melt away.’ It did not melt away.

Since 2008 it has called itself ‘a distinct Christian denomination’, and it still keeps Booth's rule of worship without the sacraments, as its own calling.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Cardinal Manning: a spirit, or a sect?

    Manning, the Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, took Booth's promise that the Army would never become a sect seriously, and doubted it. Randall Davidson, then chaplain to the Archbishop of Canterbury, had the same doubt.

    “He seems to wish that it may not be a sect but a spirit which, like the four winds, may blow upon all in the Valley of Dry Bones”
  2. 02

    What the Army now says it is

    The Army's 2008 ecclesiological statement, issued by authority of the General, settles the question Booth left open.

    “WE BELIEVE that The Salvation Army is an international Christian church in permanent mission to the unconverted, and is an integral part of the Body of Christ like other Christian churches”
    The Salvation Army Handbook of Doctrine · Appendix 5, The Salvation Army in the Body of Christ (2008), §8, p. 316
  3. 03

    A Pope's first lesson in ecumenism

    Departing from his prepared text in December 2014, Pope Francis told the Army's leaders what he saw as a boy of four in 1940, when, he said, it was thought that all Protestants went to hell.

    “And my grandmother said: “No, they are Protestants, but they are good”. Therefore, because of your good witness, my grandmother opened the door to ecumenism to me.”
    Address of Pope Francis to a Delegation of the Salvation Army · Address to a Delegation of the Salvation Army, 12 December 2014
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

In 2014 Pope Francis told the Army’s leaders that the differences between them ‘need not impede the witness of our shared love of God and love of neighbour’. He also owned an older Catholic narrowness: in 1940, he said, ‘it was thought that all Protestants went to hell.’

The Catholic–Salvation Army conversations, whose report was signed in May 2012, found ‘encouraging degrees of consensus’ and ‘areas of sincerely held difference’, among them ‘the role of the sacraments in Christian life’.

That difference is real.

The Church teaches that baptism ‘constitutes the foundation of communion among all Christians’ (Catechism 1271), so the sacramental bond it recognises reaches Salvationists who were baptised in another church.

But faith, hope and charity live outside the Church’s visible boundaries too (UR 3), and ‘God has bound salvation to the sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments’ (Catechism 1257).

On the mobs and the jailings, the Second Vatican Council’s rule is plain: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

Read the text
“shall be always hereafter under the oversight direction and control of some one person who shall be the General Superintendent and thereof whose duty it shall be to determine and enforce the discipline and laws and superintend the operations of the said Christian Mission and to conserve the same to and for the objects and purposes for which it was first originated”
'The Foundation Deeds have never failed': The Salvation Army Acts deconstructed · Deed of Constitution of the Christian Mission, 7 August 1878, as quoted by the Army's International Heritage Centre

The same deed fixed the Army's eleven doctrines as its permanent beliefs. Booth refused to include any clause that would let the deed be changed, so later reforms needed Acts of Parliament (1931, 1963, 1968, 1980). On 24 June 1880 a note on its back shortened General Superintendent to General and recorded that the Christian Mission was now The Salvation Army.

Other readings

Where people disagree

Salvationists answer from experience. Their Handbook of Doctrine calls the Army a witness to ‘the possibility, and practicability, of sanctification without formal sacraments’: a holy life without the rites. Booth himself called it ‘not a settled question’ in 1895.

A Salvationist scholar, Kenneth Lawson, argued in 1996 that the Army was ‘inconsistent with itself’. Sacramental ideas live on in its many symbols, he said, while it opposes the sacraments outright.

The Catholic answer grants part of the Army's case: ‘God has bound salvation to the sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments’ ( 1257).

God can save without baptism; the Church may not drop what commanded.

Go further· 5 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The Army's case

    The Army does not say churches that baptise are wrong to do so. It says its own calling is different.

    “Early in our history, The Salvation Army was led of God not to observe specific sacraments, that is baptism and the Lord’s Supper, or Holy Communion, as prescribed rituals.”
    The Salvation Army Handbook of Doctrine · The Church: study notes, E4, The Salvation Army and the Sacraments, p. 271
  2. 02

    A Salvationist's dissent

    Kenneth Lawson, writing 'as a Salvationist' in a 1996 Durham thesis, set out to show this.

    “though the Army formally abolished the sacraments in 1883, in actual practice through the extensive use of symbolism, sacramental ideas have continued to exercise a profound influence and it is therefore being inconsistent with itself in its unqualified opposition to the use of the sacraments in its worship.”
    Sacraments and Symbols in the Salvation Army · Lawson, Sacraments and Symbols, Abstract
  3. 03

    The Catholic answer

    The Catechism answers Booth's first reason without denying it: God is free, but the Church is bound to what the Lord commanded.

    “The Church does not know of any means other than Baptism that assures entry into eternal beatitude; this is why she takes care not to neglect the mission she has received from the Lord to see that all who can be baptized are "reborn of water and the Spirit." God has bound salvation to the sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments.”
  4. 04

    Catholic clergy and Protestant clergy

    In December 1896 Gladstone asked Booth whether Catholic countries had opposed the Army. Booth said priests guarded their people closely, but some had warmly supported his social work.

    “And I could hardly say, either on the Continent or elsewhere, that we had suffered more actual opposition from the Catholic than we had done from the Protestant Clergy.”
    The Life of General William Booth, the Founder of the Salvation Army, vol. II · Chapter XVII, Interview with W. E. Gladstone, p. 215
  5. 05

    Judging and being judged

    The Army's handbook admits a fault on its own side, and names the hurt on the other: some Salvationists have felt 'judged as inferior' by churches that cannot accept their stance on the sacraments.

    “Salvationists have sometimes been tempted to judge other denominations harshly in the light of our own standards”
    The Salvation Army Handbook of Doctrine · The Church: study notes, F3, Salvationists and other denominations, p. 273

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next