The Great Disappointment
On 22 October 1844 tens of thousands of Americans who followed the Baptist preacher William Miller waited for Christ to return. He did not come, and from the few who kept faith came the Seventh-day Adventists.
William Miller, a Baptist farmer and preacher in New York State, read the prophecy of Daniel 8:14 as a timetable and concluded that Christ would return around 1843. His followers, the Millerites, came from many Protestant churches.
When the spring of 1844 passed, one of their preachers, Samuel Snow, fixed the day at 22 October 1844, the Day of Atonement by one Jewish reckoning.
Shops closed, some farmers left crops in the fields, and believers gathered to wait. Christ did not come. ‘We wept, and wept, till the day dawn,’ wrote Hiram Edson, a farmer among them. Most Millerites gave up.
A small group decided the date had been right but the event wrong: Christ had entered the inner room of a sanctuary in heaven. They took up the Saturday Sabbath and the visions of a young believer, Ellen White, and in 1863 became the Seventh-day Adventist Church.
The situation
In the early 1800s the young United States was swept by revivals, later called the Second Great Awakening. Interest in the and in 's Second Coming ran high, and many preachers read the signs of the times.
William Miller was one voice among many. He had been a deist, someone who believes in a Creator but not in revelation, and an army captain in the War of 1812. After his conversion he studied the Bible for two years to answer his skeptical friends.
His method was his own: he read the numbers in Daniel and Revelation as a calendar. He was no outsider. His grandfather and his uncle were Baptist pastors, and in 1833 the Baptist church of Hampton and Whitehall licensed him to preach.
He did not set out to found a church. He told converts to stay in whatever church they belonged to, and most did.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Miller's conclusion, 1818
Miller told how two years of Bible study ended, in his Apology and Defence of 1845.
“I was thus brought, in 1818, at the close of my two years’ study of the Scriptures, to the solemn conclusion that in about twenty-five years from that time all the affairs of our present state would be wound up”
Sketches of the Christian Life and Public Labors of William Miller, gathered from his memoir by the late Sylvester Bliss, and from other sources · ch. II, quoting Miller's Apology and Defence (1845) - 02
A licensed Baptist preacher, 1833
In the autumn of 1833 his own congregation gave Miller a licence to preach. It opens like this.
“the Baptist church of Christ, in Hampton and Whitehall, do certify that Bro. William Miller is a member in regular standing in this church.”
Sketches of the Christian Life and Public Labors of William Miller, gathered from his memoir by the late Sylvester Bliss, and from other sources · ch. IV, the licence of the Baptist church of Hampton and Whitehall
What was at stake
Jesus had said of his return, ‘Of that day and hour knoweth no man’. Miller knew the objection. He answered that the same passage tells believers how to know when the end is near.
He took the 2,300 ‘days’ of Daniel 8:14 as years. He began them in 457 BC and ended them in 1843. The whole scheme rested on one man's reading of prophecy, with no teaching authority above it that his followers would accept.
When 1843 passed, the reckoning was moved. Samuel Snow fixed it to the Day of Atonement, the holiest day of the Jewish year, which by one reckoning fell on 22 October 1844.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The text Miller had to answer
Miller admitted that one saying of Jesus kept coming back to him while he worked.
“Sometimes, when at work, a text would arise like this: “Of that day and hour knoweth no man,” &c.; and how, then, could the Bible reveal the time of the advent?”
- 02
Miller's own window, published for 1843
Some followers found 'about the year 1843' too vague. As that year began, Miller published a synopsis of his views that ended with this article.
“I am fully convinced that some time between March 21, 1843, and March 21, 1844, according to the Jewish mode of computation of time, Christ will come, and bring all his saints with him”
Sketches of the Christian Life and Public Labors of William Miller, gathered from his memoir by the late Sylvester Bliss, and from other sources · ch. X, Synopsis of his Views, article 16 - 03
How a Catholic reference work told it in 1907
The Catholic Encyclopedia's 1907 article on the Adventists tells the move from 1843 to 1844 in one sentence.
“When the year 1843 had passed as any other, and the prediction had failed, Snow, one of his disciples, set himself to correct Miller's calculations, and in his turn announced the end of the world for 22 October, 1844.”
Adventists · Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Adventists', by Francis Havey
The event
Through October 1844 the movement grew quiet and intense. On 11 October Miller wrote that there was ‘no shouting’, only prayer and ‘a forsaking of the world’.
In the last ten days most believers stopped their ordinary business. Shops closed, some crops stood unharvested, and hundreds of pupils stayed away from school. Near Philadelphia about 150 people camped in a field on 21 October on the strength of one man's vision.
Tuesday 22 October passed like any other day. Two days later the Millerite preacher Josiah Litch wrote to Miller: ‘the Lord has not come yet.’
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Eleven days before
Miller described the mood among believers in a letter of 11 October 1844.
“There is a forsaking of the world, an unconcern for the wants of life, a general searching of heart, confession of sin, and a deep feeling in prayer for Christ to come.”
Sketches of the Christian Life and Public Labors of William Miller, gathered from his memoir by the late Sylvester Bliss, and from other sources · ch. XVI, letter of 11 October 1844 - 02
The day after the day
Josiah Litch, one of the movement's leading preachers, wrote to Miller on 24 October 1844.
“It is a cloudy and dark day here—the sheep [Advent believers] are scattered—and the Lord has not come yet.”
Hiram Edson: Disappointed Millerite – Part 1 · Reactions to the Great Disappointment, quoting Litch to Miller, 24 October 1844 - 03
Miller, in November
Miller's first letter after the day, to Joshua Himes from Low Hampton, 10 November 1844.
“Yes, and although I have been twice disappointed, I am not yet cast down or discouraged.”
Sketches of the Christian Life and Public Labors of William Miller, gathered from his memoir by the late Sylvester Bliss, and from other sources · ch. XVI, letter of 10 November 1844
The outcome
The movement broke apart. By the Catholic Encyclopedia's count in 1907, Miller's followers had become six separate bodies. The largest, the Seventh-day Adventists, then had 76,102 members. Today it counts more than 24 million.
They came from the smallest circle of 1844. Edson and another believer, O. R. L. Crosier, taught that on 22 October Christ had entered the Most Holy Place of a sanctuary in .
Rachel Oaks brought the Saturday Sabbath from the Seventh Day Baptists, a small Baptist church that keeps Saturday as the Sabbath.
Ellen White's visions held the group together. They took their name in 1860 and organised in 1863. Over the next century, after a long argument, they came to confess the .
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The cornfield, 23 October 1844
Edson's own account of the moment, as the Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists quotes it.
“Heaven seemed open to my view, and I saw distinctly and clearly that instead of our High Priest coming out of the most holy place of the heavenly sanctuary to this earth on [October 22, 1844]…He, for the first time, entered on that day into the second apartment of that sanctuary.”
Edson, Hiram (1806–1882) · Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists, 'Edson, Hiram (1806–1882)', by Brian E. Strayer - 02
The Sabbath came from Seventh Day Baptists
The church's own encyclopedia opens its article on Rachel Oaks Preston with this sentence.
“Rachel Oaks Preston was a Seventh Day Baptist who introduced the seventh-day Sabbath to Advent believers, initiating a growing Sabbatarian Adventist movement.”
Preston, Rachel Harris Oaks (1809–1868) · Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists, 'Preston, Rachel Harris Oaks (1809–1868)', by Denis Kaiser - 03
Founders who rejected the Trinity
Merlin Burt, director of the Center for Adventist Research, sets out where two founders stood.
“Two of the principal founders of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, Joseph Bates and James White, like Himes, had been members of the Christian Connexion and rejected the doctrine of the Trinity.”
The Trinity in Seventh-day Adventist History · Ministry, February 2009, 'Up to 1890: Antitrinitarian period'
For the trail
The Adventist channel did not leave Rome directly. It left Baptist and Methodist churches, and the Christian Connexion, a movement much like Barton Stone's Christians. All were the fruit of earlier breaks, and this one came over a date that failed.
The Catholic case is that Scripture needs a living interpreter. The teaches that the task of authentically interpreting the word of God ‘has been entrusted exclusively to the living teaching office of the Church’ (Dei Verbum 10).
Catholic history has had its own preachers who were sure the end was near, so this is not a failing of others alone. But the Church’s teaching office has never fixed a day, and teaches that no one can.
Yet much was kept: Scripture, , the hope of Christ's return and, in time, the Trinity. Adventists are also known worldwide for their schools, hospitals and care for health.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
What Adventists teach about 1844
The 1844 date lives on in the church's Fundamental Beliefs.
“In 1844, at the end of the prophetic period of 2300 days, He entered the second and last phase of His atoning ministry, which was typified by the work of the high priest in the most holy place of the earthly sanctuary.”
Seventh-day Adventist Church Manual · Fundamental Beliefs 24, Christ's Ministry in the Heavenly Sanctuary - 02
Sunday in the second century
Against the Adventist Sabbath stands the witness of the early Church. Justin Martyr, writing around AD 155, described the Christian Sunday assembly.
“But Sunday is the day on which we all hold our common assembly, because it is the first day on which God, having wrought a change in the darkness and matter, made the world; and Jesus Christ our Saviour on the same day rose from the dead.”
The First Apology · First Apology 67 - 03
The baptism the Church recognises
The Church's rule for judging baptism in other communities covers immersion, the Adventist practice.
“Baptism by immersion, or by pouring, together with the Trinitarian formula is, of itself, valid.”
Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism · Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993), §95a
What the Church says
The Church does not hold today’s Adventists guilty of the break: those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).
Their baptism, by immersion in the name of the Trinity, is valid (Ecumenical Directory 95), and it truly joins them to Christ, though the Church holds that these communities lack the sacrament of Orders, the ordination of bishops and priests (UR 22).
On the date, the Catechism teaches that Christ’s coming has been close at hand since the Ascension, though ‘it is not for you to know times or seasons which the Father has fixed by his own authority’ (CCC 673).
Adventists jailed for working on Sunday, and Vladimir Shelkov, leader of a Soviet Adventist group, who died in a labour camp in 1980, suffered what the Church now condemns: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).
==Here Adventists and the Council stand together.== The Adventist liberty association calls religious freedom ‘a basic right for every human being’.
“Our fondest hopes and expectations were blasted, and such a spirit of weeping came over us as I never experienced before. It seemed that the loss of all earthly friends could have been no comparison. We wept, and wept, till the day dawn.”
Edson went on: 'My advent experience has been the richest and brightest of all my christian [sic] experience. If this had proved a failure, what was the rest of my christian [sic] experience worth?' He was a Methodist steward and farmer at Port Gibson, New York. The next morning, crossing a cornfield, he came to the view on which the Seventh-day Adventists were built.
Where people disagree
Adventists answer that the date was right and only the event was misunderstood. In 1844, their Fundamental Beliefs say, Christ ‘entered the second and last phase of His atoning ministry’. Critics, Catholic and , see a failed prediction explained after the fact.
Smaller points are argued too. Miller's biographer called the stories of Millerites in ascension robes false, yet the writer Lydia Maria Child saw shops in New York advertising muslin for them.
The sharpest dispute is over Rome. Ellen White called the papacy the beast of Revelation 13 and said it was unchanged. She also wrote that there are ‘real Christians in the Roman Catholic ’.
The Church answers with Dignitatis Humanae, which in 1965 declared that no one may be forced in religion.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
Ascension robes: denied
Sylvester Bliss, Miller's biographer, insisted that the famous stories were false.
“All reports respecting the preparation of ascension robes, &c., and which are still by many believed, were demonstrated over and over again to be false and scandalous.”
Sketches of the Christian Life and Public Labors of William Miller, gathered from his memoir by the late Sylvester Bliss, and from other sources · ch. XVI, quoting Bliss, Memoirs of William Miller (1853) - 02
Ascension robes: advertised
Yet in New York that October a well-known writer saw muslin for them advertised in the shops, as Strayer notes.
“In New York City, Lydia Maria Child, at the time America’s most famous female writer, passed shops in the Bowery advertising “MUSLIN FOR ASCENSION ROBES!””
Hiram Edson: Disappointed Millerite – Part 1 · Opening section, citing Lydia Maria Child, Letters from New York, letter of 21 October 1844 - 03
Ellen White on Catholics
The same book that names the papacy the beast also says this.
“It is true that there are real Christians in the Roman Catholic communion. Thousands in that church are serving God according to the best light they have.”
The Great Controversy Between Christ and Satan: The Conflict of the Ages in the Christian Dispensation · The Great Controversy (1911 edition), ch. 35, Aims of the Papacy - 04
A Catholic reply to the papal-Antichrist reading
The reading of the pope as Antichrist was an old Protestant one. The Catholic Encyclopedia sums up John Henry Newman's reply to it in several points, among them this.
“If the Pope be Antichrist, those who receive and follow him cannot be men like St. Charles Borromeo, or Fénelon, or St. Bernard, or St. Francis de Sales.”
Antichrist · Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Antichrist', by Anthony Maas, summarising Newman
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- James White (editor), drawing on Sylvester Bliss, Memoirs of William Miller (1853), and Miller's own writings · 1875 · Battle Creek: Steam Press of the Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association; Project Gutenberg eBook #73721
- Brian E. Strayer · n.d. (online) · Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists (General Conference of Seventh-day Adventists)
- Merlin D. Burt · 2009-02 · Ministry (General Conference Ministerial Association)
- Ellen G. White · 1911 (first published 1888) · Washington, D.C.: Review & Herald Publishing Association; Project Gutenberg eBook #25833
- Francis Havey · 1907 · Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1 (New York: Robert Appleton Company), via New Advent