The RiverRevolutions and missionsUnion
1724

Melkite Greek Catholic Church

The double election at Antioch

In 1724 rival parties in the Church of Antioch chose two patriarchs a week apart, one leaning to Rome and one to Constantinople. The see has had two lines ever since.

Byzantine tradition · a channel rejoining the main stream from the Eastern Orthodox

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

By the early 1700s the ancient Patriarchate of Antioch, whose Byzantine-rite Christians lived mostly in Syria and Lebanon, was split between a party leaning towards Rome, strong in Damascus, and a party looking to Constantinople. Catholic missionaries had worked in Syria for about a century.

When the patriarch died in 1724, the Damascus party elected the pro-Catholic Seraphim Tanas as Patriarch Cyril VI on 20 September. A week later the patriarch of Constantinople consecrated a rival, a Cypriot monk named Sylvester. Rome recognised Cyril in 1729.

Antioch has had a Melkite Greek Catholic patriarch and a Greek Orthodox one ever since.

Where we are

The situation

Antioch was one of the great Churches of the ancient world. By the 1700s its Byzantine-rite Christians, the Melkites, lived mostly in Syria and Lebanon, under the Ottoman Empire. Their head was the patriarch of Antioch.

They were divided. A party strong in Damascus leaned towards Rome; another looked to the patriarch of Constantinople.

Catholic missionaries had been working in Syria for about a century.

The problem

What was at stake

No one was arguing about the faith itself. The question was who would be patriarch, and whether the patriarchate would look to Rome or to Constantinople.

A vacancy would decide it. On 4 August 1724 Patriarch Athanasius III died.

What happened

The event

The Damascus party moved first. On 20 September 1724 they elected the pro-Catholic Seraphim Tanas as Patriarch Cyril VI.

A week later the patriarch of Constantinople consecrated a Cypriot monk, Sylvester, as patriarch of Antioch. Two patriarchs for one see, chosen seven days apart.

What came of it

The outcome

The two elections made the split formal. Rome took five years to recognise Cyril VI, in 1729.

Ever since, Antioch has had two lines: a Melkite Greek Catholic patriarch in full with Rome, sharing faith and with the , and a Greek patriarch who is not.

The Melkite Church today is spread across Lebanon, Syria, Israel, Palestine and the Americas. Its patriarch carries the titles of Antioch, Alexandria and Jerusalem.

The Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch takes part in the official Catholic–Orthodox dialogue. It sent a to pray the Nicene Creed with Pope Leo XIV at İznik, ancient Nicaea, in November 2025.

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    Antioch's Orthodox at İznik, 2025

    The Vatican's unity office listed the Churches present at the prayer for the 1,700th anniversary of Nicaea. The Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch, the other half of 1724, was among them.

    “Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch and All the East: His Eminence Basil, Metropolitan of Arcadia”
    Ecumenical prayer in Iznik to commemorate the First Council of Nicaea · Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, news of 1 December 2025, list of participants
Why it matters

For the trail

Melkite is the union with the least in it. Nobody at Antioch in 1724 was arguing about the Creed. Two parties in one Church elected two patriarchs, and each was recognised by a different centre.

It's the strongest case for the Orthodox reading that the unions split existing Churches rather than healing divided ones. The Orthodox call that method : bringing one part of a Church over to Rome on its own.

wrote that ‘carry a tragic wound’: they are kept from with the Orthodox, who share their heritage. What still keeps the two apart is mainly the pope's authority.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The dialogue's own account of how these Churches came to be

    Balamand §8 describes the class this belongs to: initiatives that restored communion with Rome and broke it with the Mother Churches of the East. The negotiated phrase about extraecclesial interests is a euphemism for state pressure.

    “These initiatives led to the union of certain communities with the See of Rome and brought with them, as a consequence, the breaking of communion with their Mother Churches of the East. This took place not without the interference of extraecclesial interests. In this way Oriental Catholic Churches came into being. And so a situation was created which has become a source of conflicts and of suffering in the first instance for the Orthodox but also for Catholics.”
  2. 02

    A pope on what these Churches carry

    John Paul II's word for the position of the Eastern Catholic Churches, in an apostolic letter addressed to the whole Church.

    “These Churches carry a tragic wound, for they are still kept from full communion with the Eastern Orthodox Churches despite sharing in the heritage of their fathers.”
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

Like every Eastern Catholic Church, it is ==equal in dignity to the Latin Church==, with its own liturgy and the right to govern itself (Orientalium Ecclesiarum 3, 5 and 6).

In 1993, at Balamand in Lebanon, Catholics and Orthodox agreed that unions like this one, bringing part of a Church over to Rome on its own, ==must not be used again==, and that the Eastern Catholic Churches that exist have every right to exist and to look after their people.

The Council also gave the Eastern Catholic Churches ‘a special duty of promoting the unity of all Christians, especially Eastern Christians’ (Orientalium Ecclesiarum 24).

Read the text
“After the death of Patriarch Athanasius III Debbas on August 4, 1724, the Damascene party elected the pro-Catholic Seraphim Tanas as Patriarch Cyril VI on September 20. A week later, Patriarch Jeremiah III of Constantinople ordained a Cypriot monk named Sylvester as Athanasius’ designated successor who was supported by Aleppo, as Patriarch of Antioch. The election of two rival patriarchs formalized the schism between the two parties. Only in 1729 did Pope Benedict XIII recognize, as patriarch of Antioch, Cyril VI, who, moreover, received the pallium in 1744.”
Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Melkite Greek Catholic Church'

The entry's own word for what the double election produced is schism, not reunion.

Other readings

Where people disagree

Whether this counts as a union at all. No group crossed from one Church to another in September 1724; a party already inside the patriarchate won an election and was later recognised by Rome.

Greek Orthodox accounts treat Cyril VI's election as invalid and Sylvester's as the true . Melkite Catholics see their line as the ancient see continuing in communion with Rome.

The River draws 1724 because that's when the two lines began, not to settle which one is the true one.

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Claims behind this footprint

What this rests on

Each claim says one thing, shows the words it rests on, and says how far it has been checked. Long passages are folded; open them to read the whole text.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

After the death of Patriarch Athanasius III of Antioch in August 1724, the pro-Catholic party in Damascus elected Cyril VI on 20 September 1724 while Constantinople ordained Sylvester for Aleppo; the rival elections formalised the split, and Benedict XIII recognised Cyril VI as patriarch in 1729. This is the origin of the Melkite Greek Catholic Church.

Rests on
  • entry 'Melkite Greek Catholic Church'
    “After the death of Patriarch Athanasius III Debbas on August 4, 1724, the Damascene party elected the pro-Catholic Seraphim Tanas as Patriarch Cyril VI on September 20. A week later, Patriarch Jeremiah III of Constantinople ordained a Cypriot monk …”
    Read the full passage
    “After the death of Patriarch Athanasius III Debbas on August 4, 1724, the Damascene party elected the pro-Catholic Seraphim Tanas as Patriarch Cyril VI on September 20. A week later, Patriarch Jeremiah III of Constantinople ordained a Cypriot monk named Sylvester as Athanasius’ designated successor who was supported by Aleppo, as Patriarch of Antioch. The election of two rival patriarchs formalized the schism between the two parties. Only in 1729 did Pope Benedict XIII recognize, as patriarch of Antioch, Cyril VI, who, moreover, received the pallium in 1744.”
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

In almost every case only a part of an Eastern Church entered communion with Rome, so that the union created a new division rather than ending an existing one. The Catholic encyclopaedia of the Christian East states this as a characteristic of the unions as a class, and says that the creation of new divisions by the conclusion of most unions suggests that great mistakes have often been made.

Rests on
  • entry 'Eastern Catholic Churches'
    “Characteristic for agreeing to join the Catholic Church was 1) that – almost always – only a part of the Churches of a certain tradition accepted to do so; 2) that in the various periods of history in which this took place the ecclesiological …”
    Read the full passage
    “Characteristic for agreeing to join the Catholic Church was 1) that – almost always – only a part of the Churches of a certain tradition accepted to do so; 2) that in the various periods of history in which this took place the ecclesiological assessment of what constitutes a ‘union’ is different so that, e.g., Catholics set as a pre-condition for the union the correction of all the errors with which they reproached the other side.”
  • entry 'Eastern Catholic Churches'
    “That criticism has accompanied the emergence of certain ECC is understandable, for the great variety in the conditions under which unions came about shows that it was always difficult for the Churches in question to find the right process for the …”
    Read the full passage
    “That criticism has accompanied the emergence of certain ECC is understandable, for the great variety in the conditions under which unions came about shows that it was always difficult for the Churches in question to find the right process for the removal of divisions; moreover, the creation of new divisions by the conclusion of most unions suggests that great mistakes have often been made. Yet, it would be an injustice if criticism should be the cause of forgetting that those responsible for the processes were always inspired by the desire to comply with Christ’s command to be united with one another.”
  • Balamand Document §8
    “These initiatives led to the union of certain communities with the See of Rome and brought with them, as a consequence, the breaking of communion with their Mother Churches of the East. This took place not without the interference of extraecclesial …”
    Read the full passage
    “These initiatives led to the union of certain communities with the See of Rome and brought with them, as a consequence, the breaking of communion with their Mother Churches of the East. This took place not without the interference of extraecclesial interests. In this way Oriental Catholic Churches came into being. And so a situation was created which has become a source of conflicts and of suffering in the first instance for the Orthodox but also for Catholics.”
Limits
  • The same reference work's next sentence, quoted here, insists that those responsible were inspired by the desire for unity. The claim is about outcomes, not about motives, and the source's defence of the motives is carried with it rather than dropped.
  • 'Almost always' is the source's qualifier and is kept. The Maronite and Italo-Albanian cases are not unions at all and are excluded from the pattern on the River.
  • Balamand's phrase 'the interference of extraecclesial interests' was negotiated and is deliberately vague about who pressured whom. The English text is a same-day working translation of a French original.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

Go deeper
Questions people ask next