The RiverRevolutions and missions
1652

George Fox preaches on Firbank Fell

George Fox, a weaver’s son who had left the parish churches behind, preaches for three hours from a rock on a hillside in Westmorland, in north-west England, to about a thousand people, and the Quaker movement gathers.

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

In the 1640s England fought a civil war. Bishops were abolished, the king was beheaded in 1649, and new groups sprang up everywhere. George Fox, a weaver's son from Leicestershire, left home at nineteen to search for God and found no minister who could help him.

He came to believe that Christ gives his light to every person and ‘was come to teach people himself’.

On Sunday 13 June 1652, at Firbank in Westmorland, Fox sat on a rock beside a chapel and spoke for about three hours to what was judged ‘above a thousand people’. The congregation's own preachers joined him.

Within two years about sixty travelling preachers had gone out from the north, and the Quakers, the Religious Society of Friends, had begun.

Where we are

The situation

In the 1640s England tore itself apart in a civil war between King Charles I and Parliament. Parliament won. In 1646 it abolished in the Church of England, and in 1649 it beheaded the king.

With the old church order broken, new groups sprang up everywhere: Presbyterians, Independents, Baptists and others with no name. The parish pulpits were held by ministers of several kinds. These were the ‘priests’ Fox would preach against.

Beyond them were people who had given up on every church. Some were called Seekers. The Quaker scholar Rufus Jones writes: ‘They held that there was no true Church, and that there had been none since the days of the .’

They met without ministers. As William Penn described them, they waited together in silence until something rose in one of them that seemed to come from God.

Go further· 4 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The voice in 1647

    Fox had tried the parish ministers and the dissenting preachers and found none who could help him. Then, he wrote, he heard this.

    “When all my hopes in them and in all men were gone, so that I had nothing outwardly to help me, nor could I tell what to do; then, O! then I heard a voice which said, “There is one, even Christ Jesus, that can speak to thy condition;” and when I heard it, my heart did leap for joy.”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. I (1624–1647)
  2. 02

    The Seekers, as Penn remembered them

    William Penn’s preface to the Journal describes the people Fox found. Friends’ unprogrammed meetings still worship in this silent, waiting way.

    “These people were called Seekers by some, and the Family of Love by others; because, as they came to the knowledge of one another, they sometimes met together, not formally to pray or preach, at appointed times or places, in their own wills, as in times past they were accustomed to do; but waited together in silence, and as anything rose in any one of their minds that they thought savoured of a divine spring, so they sometimes spoke.”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · William Penn, Preface to the Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1
  3. 03

    Pendle Hill, earlier that year

    Fox climbed the hill in Lancashire alone and afterwards drank from a spring on its side, still called George Fox’s Well when the 1901 edition was printed.

    “When I was come to the top, I saw the sea bordering upon Lancashire. From the top of this hill the Lord let me see in what places he had a great people to be gathered.”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. V (1652)
  4. 04

    Bishops abolished, 1646

    A modern survey of the Civil War dates the end of bishops in the Church of England under Parliament.

    “During the height of Puritan power under the Commonwealth and the Protectorate, episcopacy was formally abolished in the Church of England on 9 October 1646.”
    English Civil War · English Civil War (tertiary), Religion
The problem

What was at stake

Fox had been where the Seekers were. He had tried the parish ministers and the dissenting preachers and found no help. Then, he wrote, he heard a voice: ‘There is one, even Jesus, that can speak to thy condition’.

The Seekers were waiting for the Spirit of the apostles to return. Fox told them it had. Christ, he said, had come to teach his people himself, by his light in each person's conscience. So no church, clergy or outward rite need stand between them and God.

At Firbank he told the crowd that the steeple-house, his word for a church building, ‘and the ground whereon it stood, were no more holy than that mountain’.

For a Catholic this is the crux. The Church holds that Christ's Church did not vanish after the apostles but ‘subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of ’ (Lumen Gentium 8). The Seekers and Fox began from the opposite premise.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Why the Seekers kept no sacraments

    The Quaker scholar Rufus Jones explains the Seekers’ reasoning. It is the reasoning Friends inherited.

    “They did not celebrate any sacraments, for they held that there was nobody in the world who possessed an anointing clearly, certainly and infallibly enough to perform such rites.”
    George Fox: An Autobiography · George Fox: An Autobiography, ed. Rufus M. Jones (1903), Introduction
  2. 02

    The steeple-house and the mountain

    Fox preached outside on purpose, and said why to the people watching from the chapel.

    “I was moved to open to the people, that the steeple-house, and the ground whereon it stood, were no more holy than that mountain”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. V (1652), Firbank chapel
  3. 03

    What the Catholic Church holds instead

    The Second Vatican Council answers the Seekers’ premise directly, while granting that much that is good lies outside the Church’s visible structure.

    “This Church constituted and organized in the world as a society, subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the Bishops in communion with him”
What happened

The event

On Sunday 13 June 1652 Fox came to Firbank chapel in Westmorland. A congregation that had left the parish churches met there under its own preachers, Francis Howgill and John Audland. They preached that morning, and the chapel was too full to enter.

While the others went to dinner, Fox drank from a brook and sat down on a rock beside the chapel. In the afternoon, in his own words, ‘It was judged there were above a thousand people’. He spoke for about three hours.

He pointed them to the Spirit of God in themselves and told them the churches had fallen away since the apostles' days. Old people watched from the chapel windows, thinking it strange to see a man preach on a hill.

All the congregation's teachers, Fox wrote, were convinced. ‘Convinced’ is the Quaker word for coming to the faith.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Howgill hears Fox at Sedbergh

    In the week before Firbank, Fox preached in a churchyard near Sedbergh during a hiring fair. When a captain told him to go into the church, Howgill, a stranger to him, rose to defend him.

    “Then said Francis Howgill of me, “This man speaks with authority, and not as the scribes.””
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. V (1652)
  2. 02

    The old people at the windows

    Not everyone came out onto the fell.

    “Now there were many old people, who went into the chapel and looked out at the windows, thinking it a strange thing to see a man preach on a hill, and not in their church, as they called it”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. V (1652), Firbank chapel
  3. 03

    Margaret Fell in her pew

    Later that year Fox spoke in the church at Ulverston. Margaret Fell, whose husband was away on circuit as a judge, remembered what it did to her.

    “So I sat down in my pew again, and cried bitterly: and I cried in my spirit, to the Lord, “We are all thieves; we are all thieves; we have taken the Scriptures in words, and know nothing of them in ourselves.””
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 2 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 2, Margaret Fell’s testimony
What came of it

The outcome

The 1911 Britannica judged that these separatists of Westmorland, centred on nearby Preston Patrick, became the nucleus of the Quaker church. Fox went on to Swarthmoor Hall, where Margaret Fell, the wife of a judge, was convinced, and her house became the movement's centre.

Howgill and Audland became travelling preachers. By 1654 about sixty were at work across England. Friends met in silence, kept no clergy, and refused oaths and the outward signs of rank.

The cost came quickly. Howgill was sentenced to prison for life for refusing to swear an oath, and died a prisoner in 1668. Friends would be jailed by the thousand until 1689, when the law finally tolerated them.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The nucleus

    The 1911 Britannica says that people in Westmorland and north Lancashire who had already left the national worship heard Fox in 1652. It goes on:

    “it was this community (if it can be so called) at Preston Patrick which formed the nucleus of the Quaker church”
    Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Friends, Society of', Period 1647–1689
  2. 02

    Thirty preachers, then sixty

    The Dictionary of National Biography counts the travelling preachers who went out from Swarthmoor.

    “Her husband's residence, Swarthmoor Hall, Lancashire, became the headquarters of the movement, the travelling preachers, of whom Fox had thirty in 1653, sixty in the following year”
    Dictionary of National Biography · Dictionary of National Biography, 'Fox, George (1624–1691)'
  3. 03

    Howgill’s sentence

    Francis Howgill, who had preached at Firbank that morning, was sent to Appleby jail for refusing to swear. The sentence read:

    “You are put out of the king’s protection and the benefit of the law: your lands are confiscated to the king during your life, and your goods and chattels for ever; and you to be a prisoner during your life.”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, footnote 16
Why it matters

For the trail

Here the Quaker channel leaves the River, and it leaves further than any channel before it. Luther, Calvin, the Anglicans and the Baptists all kept with water and the Lord's Supper, however they understood them.

Friends gave up both as outward rites, with creeds and an ministry. They hold that the true baptism and supper are inward, in the Spirit. The Catholic Church counts with other Christians from baptism, so this break reaches deeper than a quarrel over authority.

Firbank also began a witness the Church itself now teaches: freedom of conscience for everyone (Dignitatis Humanae 2), and honour for those who renounce violence (Gaudium et Spes 78). Friends were saying both three centuries earlier.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Barclay on baptism, 1676

    Robert Barclay’s Apology is the Friends’ classic statement of faith. Its twelfth proposition sets out why they do not baptise with water.

    “which is not the putting away the Filth of the Flesh, but the Answer of a good Conscience before God, by the Resurrection of Jesus Christ”
    An Apology for the True Christian Divinity · Barclay, Apology (8th ed., Birmingham, 1765), Proposition XII
  2. 02

    The Church’s starting point

    The Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity’s 2020 guide for bishops explains why baptism decides so much.

    “All ecumenism is baptismal ecumenism. ... they recognise a much more profound relationship with baptised Christians from other Christian communities who are their brothers and sisters in Christ”
    The Bishop and Christian Unity: An Ecumenical Vademecum · The Bishop and Christian Unity: An Ecumenical Vademecum (2020), §25
  3. 03

    The Peace Testimony, January 1661

    After an armed rising by another sect, Friends gave Charles II this declaration. It is still their testimony.

    “All bloody principles and practices, as to our own particulars, we utterly deny; with all outward wars and strife, and fightings with outward weapons, for any end, or under any pretence whatsoever; this is our testimony to the whole world.”
    The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, 1660: A Declaration from the harmless and innocent people of God, called Quakers
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Catholic Church honours the Friends’ faith in Christ, and does not hold today’s Friends responsible for the break: those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). There is no formal Catholic–Quaker dialogue, so its view follows from its general teaching.

That teaching counts the shared bond between Christians from baptism with water in the name of the Trinity (UR 22; Ecumenical Directory 93).

A baptised Friend shares that bond. A Friend who has never been baptised is not yet inside it, in the Church’s eyes, though their love for Christ is real, and the Church also teaches that God himself is not bound by the sacraments (CCC 1257).

The Church judges the persecution of Friends by one rule: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That condemns the jails of Puritans and Anglicans, the Puritan gallows in Boston, and the Inquisition’s cells at Malta and Rome.

On peace, the Council praises ‘those who renounce the use of violence in the vindication of their rights’ and asks the law to provide for conscientious objectors (Gaudium et Spes 78–79). It stops short of the Friends’ full peace testimony: governments keep ‘the right to legitimate defense’.

Read the text
“It was judged there were above a thousand people; amongst whom I declared God’s everlasting truth and word of life freely and largely, for about the space of three hours, directing all to the Spirit of God in themselves, that they might be turned from darkness to the light, and believe in it, that they might become the children of it”
The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 (Friends' Tract Association edition, 1901) · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. V (1652), Firbank chapel

Fox goes on to say he showed ‘the state of the apostacy since the apostles’ days’, and that the priests ‘have put them into chapter and verse, to make a trade of holy men’s words’. By the Dictionary of National Biography’s account, Fox dictated the Journal to scribes, and a committee under Penn revised it for printing in 1694, three years after his death.

Other readings

Where people disagree

Catholics and Friends read that afternoon differently. The 1909 Catholic Encyclopedia judged that Fox, finding no help in any church, ‘was thrown back upon himself and forced to accept his own imaginings as "revelations"’. It asked how the inward light differs ‘from the light of the individual reason’.

Friends answer that the light is Christ's, not their own. As the 1911 Britannica puts it, they hold that ‘the same Spirit who gave forth the Scriptures still guides men to a right understanding of them’.

The same Catholic article grants that Fox did not mean to start a new sect. He did not mean to found a church, and he founded one.

In the Catholic reading, a gathering without the apostles' successors or the cannot be the Church restored, whatever its holiness. Friends have argued among themselves too, over how far the light within can stand apart from the Christ of history.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A Catholic verdict of 1909

    James Loughlin’s article in the Catholic Encyclopedia is hostile. Its central charge is that Fox made his own reading the measure of everything.

    “Founding his opinions on isolated texts, he gradually evolved a system at variance with every existing form of Christianity.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Society of Friends (Quakers)'
  2. 02

    The same article’s concession

    Loughlin also grants what Friends themselves say about Fox’s intentions.

    “It was not his intention to increase the religious confusion of the time by the addition of a new sect.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Society of Friends (Quakers)'
  3. 03

    Christ within and the Christ of history

    Friends have argued among themselves over where the inward light leads. The 1911 Britannica describes the teaching of Elias Hicks, which split American Friends in 1827 and 1828.

    “he laid stress on “Christ within” in such a way as practically to take little account of the person and work of the “outward,” i.e. the historic Christ.”
    Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Friends, Society of', From 1835

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next