The RiverThe age of councils
431

Council of Ephesus

Can Mary be called Mother of God? The council says yes, because her son is one person, and that person is God. The churches in the Persian Empire do not accept it and become the Church of the East.

Revealed / dogmatic Quotes checked
In brief

Nestorius, the new bishop of Constantinople, objected to calling Mary ‘Theotokos’, God-bearer. Cyril, bishop of Alexandria, wrote letters arguing that he was wrong, and Rome sided with Cyril.

In 431 a council met at Ephesus. Cyril opened it before the bishops from Antioch arrived and removed Nestorius in a single day; the Antiochenes held a rival council, and two years later the two sides agreed a formula of reunion. ‘Theotokos’ stood.

The churches in the Persian Empire did not accept the council and became the Church of the East.

Where we are

The situation

By the 400s, Christians had long called Mary Theotokos, Greek for ‘God-bearer’. It was in their prayers, and ordinary believers used it.

In 428 a monk from Antioch named Nestorius became of Constantinople, the emperor's capital. One of the priests he brought with him preached that no one should call Mary that, ‘for Mary was but a woman’. Nestorius backed him, and people in the pews were upset.

Cyril, bishop of Alexandria in Egypt, wrote letters arguing that Nestorius was wrong. There was rivalry underneath, too. Alexandria had been the second city of the Church, and in 381 a had ranked the new capital, Constantinople, above it.

Both men put their case to Celestine. Rome sided with Cyril.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A sermon in Constantinople started it

    Socrates records that a presbyter named Anastasius, brought from Antioch by Nestorius, preached that no one should call Mary Theotokos 'for Mary was but a woman', and that Nestorius backed him.

    “This Anastasius preaching one day in the church said, 'Let no one call Mary Theotocos: for Mary was but a woman; and it is impossible that God should be born of a woman.' These words created a great sensation, and troubled many both of the clergy and laity.”
  2. 02

    The people already believed the title

    Socrates adds that the congregation had 'heretofore been taught to acknowledge Christ as God' and not to separate his humanity from his divinity, which is why the sermon caused offence. The title was older than the dispute.

    “…they having been heretofore taught to acknowledge Christ as God, and by no means to separate his humanity from his divinity on account of the economy of incarnation.”
The problem

What was at stake

It sounds like an argument about Mary. It's really about Jesus.

If Jesus is one person, God the Son who became a man, then the baby Mary carried was God, and she can rightly be called the one who gave birth to God.

If he is two subjects loosely joined, a man in whom God lived, then she gave birth only to the man.

Nestorius worried the title made it sound as if God had a beginning. Cyril worried that Nestorius was splitting in two, a charge Nestorius always denied. The title about Mary was a test of who Jesus is.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Cyril's first anathema

    Cyril's third letter to Nestorius ends with twelve anathemas. The first states the whole issue: if Emmanuel is truly God, then the Virgin who bore the Word made flesh is Mother of God.

    “If anyone will not confess that the Emmanuel is very God, and that therefore the Holy Virgin is the Mother of God (Θεοτόκος), inasmuch as in the flesh she bore the Word of God made flesh [as it is written, The Word was made flesh] let him be anathema”
    Council of Ephesus · Cyril, Third Letter to Nestorius, anathema 1
  2. 02

    Nestorius's counter-anathema

    Nestorius answered with twelve of his own. His first shows what he feared: that 'God' would be said to have a mother in the sense of origin, rather than 'God with us' dwelling in an assumed humanity.

    “If anyone says that the Emmanuel is true God, and not rather God with us, that is, that he has united himself to a like nature with ours, which he assumed from the Virgin Mary, and dwelt in it; and if anyone calls Mary the mother of God…”
    Council of Ephesus · Nestorius, counter-anathema 1
  3. 03

    Cyril's teaching, in the letter the council approved

    The sentence the council made its own: because the holy Virgin bore, in the flesh, God united with flesh, she is called Mother of God.

    “And since the holy Virgin brought forth corporally God made one with flesh according to nature, for this reason we also call her Mother of God.”
    Council of Ephesus · Cyril, Second Letter to Nestorius
What happened

The event

Emperor Theodosius II called a council, a meeting of bishops, at Ephesus, in today's Turkey, for June 431.

Cyril arrived early. John, bishop of Antioch, and his bishops were late. Cyril waited about two weeks, then opened the council without them and removed Nestorius as bishop in a single day.

John arrived a few days later. He and his supporters, a little more than thirty bishops by the council's count and about 43 by their own, held their own meeting and removed Cyril instead.

The emperor, unsure whom to back, held Cyril and Nestorius under guard for a time.

Pope Celestine's representatives arrived in July and confirmed Cyril's council.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Rome had already ruled

    Cyril's third letter says he writes together with the synod held at Rome under Celestine, and warns Nestorius to recant 'according to the limits defined' by Celestine. Rome's judgment preceded the council.

    “Behold, therefore, how we, together with the holy synod which met in great Rome, presided over by the most holy and most reverend brother and fellow-minister, Celestine the Bishop, also testify by this third letter to you, and counsel you to abstain from these mischievous and distorted dogmas.”
    Council of Ephesus · Cyril, Third Letter to Nestorius
  2. 02

    The sentence, 'with many tears'

    The council's deposition of Nestorius cites both the canons and Celestine's letter as compelling it.

    “Compelled thereto by the canons and by the letter of our most holy father and fellow-servant Cœlestine, the Roman bishop, we have come, with many tears, to this sorrowful sentence against him, namely, that our Lord Jesus Christ, whom he has blasphemed, decrees by the holy Synod that Nestorius be excluded from the episcopal dignity, and from all priestly communion.”
    Council of Ephesus · Sentence against Nestorius
  3. 03

    Thirty bishops walked out under John of Antioch

    The council's own report to the emperors lists the bishops who 'withdrew from among us' under John of Antioch, including Theodoret of Cyrus, and held a rival synod.

    “When we had assembled, according to the religious decree of the Emperors, in the Metropolis of Ephesus, certain persons, a little more than thirty in number, withdrew from among us, having for the leader of their schism John, Bishop of Antioch.”
    Council of Ephesus · Report of the Council to the Emperors
What came of it

The outcome

In 433 Cyril and John of Antioch made peace. They signed a shared statement, the Formula of Reunion: Jesus is one person, fully God and fully man, and Mary is Theotokos.

Nestorius never got his post back. He died in exile in Egypt around 450.

The churches of the Persian Empire, east of Rome's border, learned their theology from the Antioch side and never accepted the council's verdict. They went their own way as the , the first channel on the River.

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    Rome's legates confirmed Cyril's council

    At the second session the papal legates, two bishops and the presbyter Philip, arrived and joined the assembly Cyril had opened without the Antiochenes.

    “The most pious and God-beloved bishops, Arcadius and Projectus, as also the most beloved-of-God Philip, a presbyter and legate of the Apostolic See, then entered.”
    Council of Ephesus · Acts, Session II
Why it matters

For the trail

This was the first split among Christians that still lasts today, and it started with a word about Mary that was really about Jesus.

It's also a reminder that councils are human events. Bishops rushed, quarrelled and played politics, and the Church still holds that what Ephesus taught is true. Both things can be said at once.

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    A title about Mary that is really about Christ

    Every note above turns on the same point: Theotokos says nothing about Mary's nature and everything about her Son's. The Mary chapter starts from here.

    “…for this reason we also call her Mother of God.”
    Council of Ephesus · Cyril, Second Letter to Nestorius
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Church counts Ephesus as the third ecumenical council and holds its teaching that Mary is truly Mother of God, because her son is one divine person (CCC 495).

In plain terms

Think of it like this

The title on a birth certificate tells you who the child is, not what the mother is made of.

Calling Mary the Mother of God sounds like a statement about Mary and is in fact a statement about her son. If the one she carried is God the Word made flesh, the title follows. If it does not follow, then the child in the manger was someone other than God, which is exactly what the council thought was at stake.

Read the text
“And since the holy Virgin brought forth corporally God made one with flesh according to nature, for this reason we also call her Mother of God.”
Other readings

Where people disagree

Even at the time, the way Cyril ran the council was criticised. Opening without the bishops of Antioch broke the normal procedure, and the council's own report to the emperors reads like a defence of it.

The Church of the East has never accepted Ephesus. But in 1994 and the head of the Assyrian Church of the East signed a joint statement confessing the same faith in Christ. They said the old divisions were ‘due in large part to misunderstandings’.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A procedure even the winners had to defend

    The council's report to the emperors is itself a justification: it explains why Cyril opened proceedings with Antioch absent. The Church of the East never accepted the outcome; in 1994 Rome and the Assyrian Church declared the old dispute largely one of words.

    “…certain persons, a little more than thirty in number, withdrew from among us, having for the leader of their schism John, Bishop of Antioch.”
    Council of Ephesus · Report of the Council to the Emperors
  2. 02

    1994: 'due in large part to misunderstandings'

    Fifteen centuries later John Paul II and the Catholicos-Patriarch of the Assyrian Church of the East confessed the same Christology in one text and said the old anathemas rested largely on misunderstanding, while admitting that unity has not yet been reached.

    “Therefore our Lord Jesus Christ is true God and true man, perfect in his divinity and perfect in his humanity, consubstantial with the Father and consubstantial with us in all things but sin. … The controversies of the past led to anathemas, bearing on persons and on formulas. The Lord's Spirit permits us to understand better today that the divisions brought about in this way were due in large part to misunderstandings.”

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Claims behind this footprint

What this rests on

Each claim says one thing, shows the words it rests on, and says how far it has been checked. Long passages are folded; open them to read the whole text.

01RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The Council of Ephesus (431) approved Cyril's teaching that the Virgin is rightly called Mother of God because she bore the Word made flesh, and deposed Nestorius.

Rests on
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Since 1973 the Catholic Church has signed common Christological declarations with the Coptic Orthodox Church (Paul VI and Shenouda III, 1973), the Assyrian Church of the East (John Paul II and Mar Dinkha IV, 1994) and the Armenian Apostolic Church (John Paul II and Karekin I, 1996). Each confesses Christ as perfect God and perfect man, each traces the old divisions largely to misunderstanding and differences of language, and each says that full communion has not yet been restored.

Rests on
  • Joint Declaration of Paul VI and Shenouda III, 10 May 1973
    “We confess that our Lord and God and Saviour and King of us all, Jesus Christ, is perfect God with respect to His divinity, perfect man with respect to His humanity. … In fact, since the year 451 A. D., theological differences, nourished and widened …”
    Read the full passage
    “We confess that our Lord and God and Saviour and King of us all, Jesus Christ, is perfect God with respect to His divinity, perfect man with respect to His humanity. … In fact, since the year 451 A. D., theological differences, nourished and widened by non-theological factors, have sprung up. These differences cannot be ignored. In spite of them, however, we are rediscovering ourselves as Churches with a common inheritance and are reaching out with determination and confidence in the Lord to achieve the fullness and perfection of that which is His gift.”
  • Common Christological Declaration of John Paul II and Mar Dinkha IV, 11 November 1994
    “Therefore our Lord Jesus Christ is true God and true man, perfect in his divinity and perfect in his humanity, consubstantial with the Father and consubstantial with us in all things but sin. … The controversies of the past led to anathemas, bearing …”
    Read the full passage
    “Therefore our Lord Jesus Christ is true God and true man, perfect in his divinity and perfect in his humanity, consubstantial with the Father and consubstantial with us in all things but sin. … The controversies of the past led to anathemas, bearing on persons and on formulas. The Lord’s Spirit permits us to understand better today that the divisions brought about in this way were due in large part to misunderstandings. … Since this unanimity for which we aim has not yet been attained, we cannot unfortunately celebrate together the Eucharist which is the sign of the ecclesial communion already fully restored.”
  • Common Declaration of John Paul II and Karekin I, 13 December 1996
    “Perfect God as to His divinity, perfect man as to His humanity, His divinity is united to His humanity in the Person of the Only-begotten Son of God, in a union which is real, perfect, without confusion, without alteration, without division, without …”
    Read the full passage
    “Perfect God as to His divinity, perfect man as to His humanity, His divinity is united to His humanity in the Person of the Only-begotten Son of God, in a union which is real, perfect, without confusion, without alteration, without division, without any form of separation. … Linguistic, cultural and political factors have immensely contributed towards the theological divergences that have found expression in their terminology of formulating their doctrines. … The communion already existing between the two Churches and the hope for and commitment to recovery of full communion between them should become factors of motivation for further contact, more regular and substantial dialogue, leading to a greater degree of mutual understanding and recovery of the communality of their faith and service.”
Limits
  • Only the Catholic-hosted texts are cited. How the Coptic, Assyrian and Armenian Churches themselves read these declarations must come from their own sources (BRD rule 7).
  • The vatican.va page title spells the Armenian Catholicos 'Karekim I Sarkissian'; the body of the declaration and the signature use 'Karekin I'.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

Go deeper
Questions people ask next